Australian Fitness Supplies Pty Ltd v Rasheed Rane

Link copied
Case Copied 16 min read

DESIGNS ACT 2003



DECISION OF A DELEGATE OF THE REGISTRAR OF DESIGNS WITH REASONS

Re:Design Registration No. 338172 in the name of Australian Fitness Supplies Pty Ltd

and

Request for revocation under section 51 by Rasheed Rane

Delegate: Debrett Lyons
Representation: Decision on the written record
Decision:

2013 ADO 6
Section 51 request: insufficient evidence that someone other than the registered owner is an entitled person. Declaration under s.52 refused.

Background

  1. On 27 July 2011 an application was made under the Designs Act 2003 (“the Act”) by IP Holdings Pty Limited to register a design in respect of a product entitled “Gym fitness equipment” (“the Design”).

  2. Daniel Alenaddaf was nominated as the designer. 

  3. The Design was registered on 19 August 2011 (“the Registration”).

  4. Ownership of the Registration was transferred to Australian Fitness Supplies Pty Ltd (“the Owner”) in consequence of a Deed of Assignment made on 14 July 2012.

  5. On 13 May 2013, Rasheed Rane (“the Requestor”) made a request for revocation (“the Request”) of the Registration under section 51 of the Act.

  6. The Request includes grounds for revocation which stated in redacted form:

Mr Daniel Alenaddaf is listed as the sole designer of the Design.  Ownership was transferred to Australian Fitness Supplies Pty Ltd (‘AFS’) by Deed of Assignment dated 14 July 2012.  Mr Alenaddaf is the Managing Director of AFS.

…
Annexed and marked Exhibit 2 is a printout from the website of Nantong Ruilin International Co Ltd of Nantong, Jiangsu, China (‘Nantong’) which shows the AF1001 TRANSFORMA. 

The AF1001 TRANSFORMA is imported into Australia from Nantong and retailed under the ‘MONSTER G6’ brand by AFS. 

The AF1001 TRANSFORMA is also imported into Australia from Nantong by Renouf Import Direct Pty Ltd, which trades as ‘Renouf Home Fitness’ of 72 Collingwood Street, Osbourne Park WA 6017.  Renouf Fitness retails the AF1001 TRANSFORMA under the brand name 360PT.

Annexed and marked Exhibit 3 is a printout from the website: The printout shows various depictions of the 360PT. 

A Youtube of a video made by Renouf Home Fitness which is entitled “360PT Multi-Functional Trainer - Weight Stacks - Smith Machine - Power Rack” can be accessed at

Annexed and marked Exhibit 4 is a printout of an email exchange on 21 January 2013 between Zaid of Southside Fitness and Carl of Natong.  Zaid stated:

“Also, Item AF1001, did your factory design this machine or is it Australia Fitness Supplies machine & design?”

Carl stated in reply:

“AF1001 is our factory design. Because we have a contract with AFS, so we couldn't sell to you.”

Annexed and marked Exhibit 5 is an email dated 1 March 2013 from Carl of Nantong, which states:

We know that you bought TRANSFORMA AF1001 – 10 pieces from Nantong Kylin last year. This item is our original design and we have three patents for it. Base on the contract between AFS & us, and you & AFS are in Australia, we couldn’t sell AF1001 to you now. Please understanding.

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Australian Fitness Supplies Pty Ltd v Rasheed Rane and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2013] ADO 6
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Australian Fitness Supplies Pty Ltd (AFS) is the registered owner of a design registered under the Designs Act 2003 (Cth). The design in question pertains to a product named "Gym fitness equipment." The design was initially registered in the name of IP Holdings Pty Limited, and later transferred to AFS via a Deed of Assignment dated 14 July 2012. Rasheed Rane (the Requestor) has requested the revocation of this design registration under section 51 of the Act, asserting that AFS is not the entitled person as per section 13 of the Act. The core of the Requestor's case is that AFS is merely a distributor of products bearing the Design and is not the designer or otherwise entitled to the Design.

The primary legal issue before the court was whether AFS was an entitled person under section 13 of the Act at the time of the design's registration. The Delegate had to determine if the Requestor provided sufficient evidence to demonstrate that someone other than AFS was an entitled person at the time the Design was first registered. The Delegate examined the provided evidence, which included various exhibits such as emails, patent applications, and website printouts, to assess the Requestor's claim.

The Delegate concluded that the evidence presented was insufficient to support the Requestor's claim. The Delegate found that the Requestor failed to establish a clear connection between the design in question and the Chinese patent and design applications provided as evidence. Furthermore, the Delegate noted that the email evidence was not contemporaneous and therefore unreliable. The Delegate also highlighted the lack of substantial similarity between the Chinese intellectual property and the registered design, rendering it irrelevant for the purposes of assessing entitlement. Consequently, the Delegate determined that the Requestor did not meet the required standard of proof on the balance of probabilities.

Based on the evidence and the applicable legal standards, the Delegate rejected the Requestor's application for revocation. The Delegate found that the Requestor had not established that someone other than AFS was an entitled person at the time the Design was first registered. Therefore, the registration remains valid, and the application for revocation under section 51 of the Act is unsuccessful.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established