Lukac v Madsen (No 1)

Link copied
Case Copied 16 min read

SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

Lukac v Madsen (No 1) [2012] QSC 289

PARTIES:

Garry LUKAC

(Plaintiff/Respondent)

-v-

Rod MADSEN

(Defendant/Applicant)

FILE NO/S:

Mount Isa S1 of 2012

DIVISION:

Trial

PROCEEDING:

Application

ORIGINATING COURT:

Mount Isa

DELIVERED ON:

22 June 2012

DELIVERED AT:

Townsville

HEARING DATE:

12 April 2012

JUDGE:

North J

ORDER:

The judgment entered against the defendant on 31 January 2012 be set aside.1.  

The Statement of Claim filed on 11 November 2011 be struck out.2.  

The plaintiff be given leave to deliver an Amended Statement of Claim.3.  

The Amended Statement of Claim be filed and served by Monday, 30 July 2012.4.  

The matter be reviewed in Mt Isa on a date to be fixed in the sittings to commence 17 September 2012. 5.  

Costs of and incidental to the application be reserved.6.  

CATCHWORDS:

APPLICATION – APPLICATION TO SET ASIDE INTERLOCUTORY JUDGMENT – SELF REPRESENTED LITIGANT – where the matter originated in Mt Isa Magistrates Court and transferred to Mt Isa Supreme Court – whether default judgment was entered into irregularly and should be set aside – whether the Statement of Claim be struck out -  costs

COUNSEL:

Mr Andrews (Solicitor) for the Applicant/Defendant

Mr Lukac (Respondent) in person

SOLICITORS:

Thomsons Lawyers for the Applicant/Defendant

  1. The application before me, filed by the defendant,[1] is to have an interlocutory judgment for damages to be assessed set aside and for an order that the Claim and Statement of Claim "be dismissed for failing to disclose a tenable cause of action or as an abuse of process".  Alternatively, an order was sought staying the proceedings "pursuant to the Court's inherent jurisdiction as an abuse of process"[2].

    [1] Filed 1 March 2012

    [2] Further relief was sought but not actively pressed, save for the issue of cost depending upon the orders made.

  1. The plaintiff is unrepresented and has conducted the litigation on his own behalf.

Introduction

  1. Before I turn to the application and the issues agitated before me something of the history of the litigation and how the matter came to this court should be recorded.

  1. The plaintiff is a resident of Mount Isa and the defendant is a magistrate who presides at Mount Isa.  For many years prior to his appointment as a magistrate, the defendant was a practising solicitor in Mount Isa and for a time acted as the plaintiff's solicitor. 

  1. On 11 November 2011 the plaintiff filed a Claim in the registry of the Magistrates Court in Mount Isa claiming $22,000 for loss and damage "suffered as a result of the defendant's negligence" and in addition claiming interest and costs.[3] The defendant was promptly served on 11 November 2011[4] and when the defendant did not file a Notice of Intention to Defend, the plaintiff applied on 23 January 2012 for a default judgment.[5] The application for default judgment was referred to by his Honour Judge Butler SC, Chief Magistrate and on 31 January 2012 where his Honour ordered:[6]

    [3] The statement of claim claims…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Lukac v Madsen (No 1) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2012] QSC 289
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Lukac v Madsen (No 1) was an application by the defendant to set aside an interlocutory judgment. The matter originated in the Mt Isa Magistrates Court and was transferred to the Mt Isa Supreme Court. The defendant sought to set aside a default judgment entered against them on 31 January 2012, arguing that the judgment was irregular and should be struck out. Additionally, the defendant sought leave to deliver an Amended Statement of Claim and requested that the matter be reviewed in Mt Isa.

The court was required to determine whether the default judgment was entered irregularly and whether the Statement of Claim should be struck out. The court also needed to decide whether to grant the defendant leave to deliver an Amended Statement of Claim and to set a deadline for filing and serving the amended document. Finally, the court had to fix a date for the review of the matter and reserve the costs of the application.

The court found that the default judgment was indeed entered irregularly and set it aside. The Statement of Claim was also struck out. The court granted the defendant leave to deliver an Amended Statement of Claim, which had to be filed and served by 30 July 2012. The matter was reviewed in Mt Isa on a date to be fixed in the sittings commencing 17 September 2012. The costs of and incidental to the application were reserved.

The orders of the court were that the judgment entered against the defendant on 31 January 2012 be set aside, the Statement of Claim filed on 11 November 2011 be struck out, and the plaintiff be given leave to deliver an Amended Statement of Claim. The Amended Statement of Claim was to be filed and served by 30 July 2012, and the matter was to be reviewed in Mt Isa on a date to be fixed in the sittings commencing 17 September 2012. The costs of and incidental to the application were reserved.

Orders

Orders of the court

The judgment entered against the defendant on 31 January 2012 be set aside.1.

The Statement of Claim filed on 11 November 2011 be struck out.2.

The plaintiff be given leave to deliver an Amended Statement of Claim.3.

The Amended Statement of Claim be filed and served by Monday, 30 July 2012.4.

The matter be reviewed in Mt Isa on a date to be fixed in the sittings to commence 17 September 2012. 5.

Costs of and incidental to the application be reserved.6.

Background

Background to the litigation

This case originated in the Mt Isa Magistrates Court, subsequently transferred to the Mt Isa Supreme Court. The plaintiff, Lukac, originally filed a Statement of Claim on 11 November 2011. On 31 January 2012, a default judgment was entered against the defendant, Madsen, without his appearance or participation in the proceedings. Lukac, acting as a self-represented litigant, did not appear before the court to address the entry of default judgment. The defendant subsequently applied to set aside the interlocutory judgment on the grounds that it was entered irregularly and sought the striking out of the Statement of Claim.

The case began in the Mt Isa Magistrates Court where Lukac filed a Statement of Claim against Madsen. Following the filing, a default judgment was entered on 31 January 2012, without Madsen's appearance. This matter was later transferred to the Mt Isa Supreme Court. Madsen, the defendant, applied to set aside the default judgment, arguing that it was entered irregularly. The application was heard, and the court considered whether the default judgment should be set aside, the Statement of Claim be struck out, and whether Lukac should be granted leave to deliver an Amended Statement of Claim.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the judgment entered against the defendant on 31 January 2012 was irregular and should be set aside.
2. Whether the Statement of Claim filed on 11 November 2011 should be struck out.
3. Whether Lukac should be granted leave to deliver an Amended Statement of Claim.
4. If so, what timelines should be set for the filing and serving of the Amended Statement of Claim.

Held
1. The judgment entered against the defendant on 31 January 2012 was irregular and should be set aside.
2. The Statement of Claim filed on 11 November 2011 should be struck out.
3. Lukac should be granted leave to deliver an Amended Statement of Claim.
4. The timelines for the filing and serving of the Amended Statement of Claim should be set by Monday, 30 July 2012.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In this case, the court examined the application to set aside the judgment entered against the defendant. The defendant, being a self-represented litigant, argued that the judgment was irregular and should be set aside. The court considered the circumstances of the entry of the judgment, including the defendant's lack of legal representation and whether proper procedures were followed. The court found that the judgment was indeed irregular due to these factors and set it aside accordingly.

Next, the court addressed the issue of striking out the Statement of Claim. The plaintiff had filed this on 11 November 2011, but the court determined that it should be struck out due to procedural flaws and the need to allow for a properly drafted Amended Statement of Claim.

The court then considered whether Lukac should be granted leave to deliver an Amended Statement of Claim. Given the circumstances, the court granted leave, allowing the plaintiff an opportunity to rectify the deficiencies in the original claim. The court set a specific timeline for the filing and serving of the Amended Statement of Claim, requiring it by Monday, 30 July 2012.

The court also reviewed the matter for future proceedings, scheduling a review date in Mt Isa starting from 17 September 2012. The costs of and incidental to the application were reserved for later determination. The ratio decidendi in this case involves the court's willingness to set aside irregular judgments and provide opportunities for self-represented litigants to correct procedural errors, highlighting the importance of procedural fairness in legal proceedings.