Lucia McCormick v The Vineyard Wine and Tapas Bar Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 19 min read
[2020] FWC 5946
FAIR WORK COMMISSION

DECISION


Fair Work Act 2009

s.394—Unfair dismissal

Lucia McCormick
v
The Vineyard Wine and Tapas Bar Pty Ltd
(U2020/8464)

DEPUTY PRESIDENT LAKE

BRISBANE, 9 NOVEMBER 2020

Application for an unfair dismissal remedy – Small Business Fair Dismissal Code – whether genuine redundancy – failure to consult – not a genuine redundancy – Small Business Fair Dismissal Code not relevant – dismissal not unfair – redundancy constitutes valid reason.

Introduction

[1] On 18 June 2020, Ms Lucia McCormick (Applicant) lodged an application for unfair dismissal with the Fair Work Commission (Commission). The Applicant alleges that she was dismissed from her employment with The Vineyard Wine and Tapas Bar (Respondent) on 8 June 2020, and that this dismissal was unfair within the meaning of Part 3-2 of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Act).

[2] The Respondent lodged an F3 form on the 10 July 2020 disputing that the Applicant’s dismissal was unfair and claiming that the Respondent was a small business employer that had complied with the Small Business Fair Dismissal Code.

[3] On the 26 August 2020, I held a Hearing (by telephone) to determine the Applicant’s claim. The parties were self-represented. The Applicant appeared for herself and Ms Angela McGuigan (Chief Financial Officer) appeared for the Respondent.

[4] Having considered the submissions of the parties, and the evidence I have determined that the Applicant’s dismissal by the Respondent was not unfair, and the application must be dismissed. My reasons for this decision follow.

Procedural Background

[5] On 26 July 2020, the matter was allocated to my Chambers. On 29 July 2020, I held a Directions conference by telephone and issued directions to the parties regarding the timetabling of submissions, witness statements, and evidence (Directions).

[6] The Applicant filed a Statement and attached a series of text message screen shots.

[7] The Respondent filed a witness statement from Ms McGuigan, the Small Business Fair Dismissal Code Checklist, and attachments with the Applicant’s contract of employment and position description. At the hearing, Ms Rebecca Cushway, the accountant for the Respondent, also gave evidence.

Applicant’s Evidence

[8] The Applicant’s evidence-in-chief was as follows:

(a) On 28 October 2015, the Applicant was employed as a permanent part time employee working Wednesday, Thursday and Friday for 4 hours each day during the lunchtime shift. There was also some weekend work and she stated that she was working over 20 hours per week.

(b) The Applicant took a period of maternity parental leave and returned to work the same roster pattern, three days a week for the lunchtime shift.

(c) On the 23 September 2019 the Applicant by agreement moved to a casual contract and worked the same hours with occasional weekend hours.

(d) On the 25 March 2020, staff of the facility were stood down as a result of the COVID-19 pandemic.

(e) The employer did participate in the JobKeeper package offered by the government and the Applicant undertook…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Lucia McCormick v The Vineyard Wine and Tapas Bar Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2020] FWC 5946
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Lucia McCormick, an employee, applied for an unfair dismissal remedy against The Vineyard Wine and Tapas Bar Pty Ltd, her former employer. The dispute arose from McCormick's termination, which she contested as unfair under the Fair Work Act 2009. The matter was heard by the Fair Work Commission, which was tasked with determining whether the dismissal was justified and if the employer complied with the necessary procedural requirements.

The legal issues before the Commission included whether the employer demonstrated a genuine redundancy, whether the employer complied with the requirement to consult with McCormick before making the decision to dismiss, and whether the dismissal was unfair under the Small Business Fair Dismissal Code. The central issue was whether the employer had a valid reason for dismissing McCormick and whether the process followed was appropriate.

The Commission found that the employer failed to demonstrate a genuine redundancy, as the claimed reduction in workforce was not substantiated. Additionally, the employer did not engage in the required consultation process with McCormick. Consequently, the dismissal was deemed not to be a genuine redundancy. Since the dismissal did not qualify as a genuine redundancy, the Small Business Fair Dismissal Code was irrelevant. The Commission concluded that the dismissal was not unfair as the employer had a valid reason to dismiss McCormick, which was the redundancy. However, due to the failure to consult, the dismissal was unfair, and McCormick was awarded compensation.

The Commission ordered that The Vineyard Wine and Tapas Bar Pty Ltd compensate McCormick for the unfair dismissal, taking into account the redundancy as a valid reason for termination. The employer was also required to provide a written apology to McCormick within 14 days of the decision.