Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
For the following reasons, the Tribunal has concluded that the decision to cancel the applicant’s visa should be affirmed. CONSIDERATION OF CLAIMS AND EVIDENCE Section 109(1) of the Act allows the Minister to cancel a visa if the visa holder has failed to comply with ss.101, 102, 103, 104, 105 or 107(2) of the Act. Broadly speaking, these sections require non-citizens to provide correct information in their visa applications and passenger cards, not to provide bogus documents and to notify the Department of any incorrect information of which they become aware and of any relevant changes in circumstances. The exercise of the cancellation power under s.109 of the Act is conditional on the Minister issuing a valid notice to the visa holder under s.107 of the Act, providing particulars of the alleged non-compliance. Where a notice is issued that does not comply with the requirements in s.107, the power to cancel the visa does not arise. Extracts of the Act relevant to this case are attached to this decision. In the present matter, the Tribunal is satisfied that the delegate had reached the necessary state of mind to engage s.107 and that the notice issued under s.107 complied with the statutory requirements.Was there non-compliance as described in the s.107 notice? The issue before the Tribunal is whether there was non-compliance in the way described in the s.107 notice, being the manner particularised in the notice, and if so, whether the visa should be cancelled. The non-compliance identified and particularised in the s.107 notice was non-compliance with s.103 in the following respects:Particulars of grounds for cancellationOn 20 March 2014 you lodged an application for an EN 186 visa (Employer Nomination Scheme).A copy of an employment contract dated 01 January 2014 between Shanshan Lu and Oak Financial Partners was provided to the Department in support of the ENS application. The signature block of this contract states the signature was from Cameron Vallve, Managing Director Valkyrie Private Wealth Management Pty Ltd t/a Oak Financial Partners. The contract is also signed by Shanshan Lu agreeing to the terms and conditions.On 08 August 2014 your EN 186 Employer Nominated Scheme visa was granted by the Department on the basis of the sponsorship provided by Valkyrie Private Wealth Management Pty Ltd t/a Oak Financial Partners.Since the grant of the EN 186 visa the Department has become aware of the following contrary information:A letter was received by the Department from Mr Cameron Vallve, Managing Director, Oak Financial Partners dated 09 September 2014. A copy of an employment contract was submitted with the letter. The letter stated in part:The employment contract he gave me which appears to be from our company (using our logo) has a signature next to my name which is definitely not my signature, eg. Someone else has signed this without my knowledge or consent.The employment contract (2 pages) is completely different from any contract our business has ever used. It's also written in broken English in parts (eg. 'you self' and 'you' instead of 'your' throughout), and has clearly been written by someone other than me or my HR Manager who has excellent grammar. Our employment contracts are typically 20+ pages long and don't look anything like this.The address (4/224 Upper Heidelberg Rd) and phone number on the Approval letter from the Dep 't of Immigration were once the correct details of our businesses, but these are now old and have not been used for over 4 years.Nobody has ever been employed at either of our businesses on an Immigration Visa at any point in time, and I am certain of this as I am the founder of both companies.Although the signature on the contract purports to be Mr Vallve's signature, Mr Vallve has stated to the Department that the contract was signed by someone other than him and without his knowledge or consent.
Decision
Reasons for decision
The Nationality Law of the People’s Republic of China 1980 allows foreign nationals to restore or acquire Chinese citizenship provided certain criteria are met. The law indicates that an Australian citizen child with Chinese citizen parents may acquire Chinese citizenship provided they do not retain foreign nationality (Article 8) and is willing to abide by China's Constitution and laws (Article 7).[4] When this was discussed with the applicant at the hearing, she stated that she does not want Liam to be a Chinese citizen and that she had made enquiries after the cancellation about foreigners in China and how he can stay with his parents but they did not give her explicit information about how he can be granted Chinese citizenship. The representative submitted that the applicant does not want to acquire Chinese citizenship for Liam and it would be difficult to relinquish Australian citizenship as it would not be in the child’s best interest. [4] Nationality Law of the People's Republic of China 1980 (China) effective as of 10 September 1980. >The Tribunal has considered the applicant’s response and submissions, and while it acknowledges that the applicant may not want her son to relinquish his Australian citizenship so as to acquire Chinese citizenship, the Tribunal considers that to be a matter for the applicant and Mr Li, and is satisfied that it is within their control as his parents to acquire Chinese citizenship for Liam should they wish to do so. The Tribunal is satisfied that the applicant and her two children can continue to live in China with the children’s father as a family as they have been doing since December 2016. If the applicant is not able extend Liam’s temporary residence visa or cannot obtain some form of ongoing residence visa for him to remain in China, Chinese law nevertheless provides an option for him to acquire Chinese citizenship which would enable him to remain in China indefinitely with his parents and brother. The Tribunal has had regard to the submission that the applicant is willing to seek, and is able to secure, employment in Australia and considers that if the applicant is able to secure genuine employment in future, it is open for her to apply for another employer sponsored permanent visa which she would be able to apply for from China. The applicant also gave evidence about the impact of the cancellation on her two children. The Tribunal has considered that evidence together with the written submissions provided by the representative under the heading Australia’s international obligations. The subsequent behaviour of the visa holder concerning his or her obligations under Subdivision C of Division 3 of Part 2 of the Act and any other instances of non-compliance by the visa holder known to the Minister. The Tribunal makes no adverse findings in respect of the applicant’s obligations under Subdivision C of Division 3 of Part 2 of the Act or any other instances of non-compliance. The Tribunal’s concern about the applicant’s conduct after travelling to Australia has been more appropriately considered under other considerations of the discretion. Any breaches of the law since the non-compliance and the seriousness of those breachesThere is no evidence before the Tribunal to suggest that the applicant has breached any law since the non-compliance. The time that has elapsed since the non-complianceThe non-compliance, being the provision of provision of a bogus document with the visa application, occurred on 20 March 2014. The time that has elapsed since the non-compliance is therefore just over 3 years. Any contribution made by the holder to the community.The applicant has not submitted, and there is no evidence before the Tribunal, regarding any contributions made by the applicant to the community. Other considerations Whilst the above factors must be considered, they do not represent an exhaustive statement of the circumstances that might properly be considered to be relevant in any given case: MIAC v Khadgi (2010) 190 FCR 248. The Tribunal may also have regard to lawful government policy. The relevant policy is set out in the Department’s Procedural Advice Manual) PAM3 ‘General visa cancellation powers’. This policy requires delegates to also have regard to matters such as whether the visa would have been granted if the correct information had been given, whether there are persons in Australia whose visa would, or may, be automatically cancelled under s.140 of the Act, and whether the visa cancellation may result in Australia breaching its international obligations.The representative made detailed submission addressing some of the above factors which the Tribunal has considered as follows. Consequential cancellation under s.140 of the ActIt was submitted that the cancellation of the applicant’s visa resulted in the consequential cancellation of the eldest son’s visa and that he has returned to China with his mother. The younger son, Liam, is an Australian citizen and he will not be affected by s.140 of the Act. There is no evidence before the Tribunal to suggest that any action will be taken to revoke Liam’s citizenship. Liam is currently residing in China with his parents and brother. Technically, Liam can reside in Australia and be cared for by either a guardian or possibly his grandparents should they wish to travel to Australia on their 163 visas. However, for reasons detailed further below, the Tribunal considers that it is in Liam’s best interest that he be cared for by both parents and that the family unit remain intact. All members of the family unit are currently living in China and have been there since December 2016 and the Tribunal is satisfied that the family can continue to live together in China. As discussed above, Liam can, if he is unable to secure a long term residence visa in China, acquire Chinese nationality. Separation of the family unit is therefore not a necessary consequence of the cancellation. Another circumstance which the Tribunal has considered which was noted by the delegate in the decision record is that the cancellation of the applicant’s visa will impact the partner visa application made by Mr Li. The Tribunal accepts that if the applicant’s visa is cancelled, Mr Li’s partner visa will not be granted. The Tribunal gives limited weight to this consideration as Mr Li is able to continue to reside in China, with the applicant and their children, where he is currently employed. Whether the visa cancellation may result in Australia breaching its international obligations? The representative made detailed submissions regarding Australia’s obligations under the Convention on the Rights of the Child (CRC). It was submitted that the cancellation will directly affect the applicant’s children, one of whom is an Australian citizen. It was submitted that the applicant’s older son is 6 years of age and has spent a better part of 3 years in Australia. It was submitted that the older son speaks and reads English, identifies as an Australian and is struggling to adjust in China and cannot read Mandarin. It was submitted that the cancellation should be set aside so that no further interruption occur s to his education and social development. The Tribunal has considered the above submissions. The Tribunal accepts, based on the school reports from Kent Rd Public School in Marsfield that Roy attended Kindergarten in the 2016 academic year. The Tribunal accepts that Roy lived in Australia for a period of 2 years and 2 months, between October 2014 and December 2016, with his mother and that during that time he learned to speak and read English and adjust to life in Australia. The Tribunal acknowledges that Roy may have experienced some adjustment difficulties upon returning to China, including with learning Mandarin, however, Roy is still very young and the Tribunal is satisfied that he will, after a period of adjustment, adapt to the study environment, language and lifestyle in China. Roy is a citizen of China and the Tribunal is satisfied that Roy will readjust to life and the language in China with the assistance of his parents who have lived the majority of their lives in China and are fluent in Mandarin. The representative also referred to Articles 18, 18(2), 24 and 26 of the CRC which primarily relate to the recognition that both parents have the primary responsibility for the children, the best interests of the child, assistance by States to parents in the development of institution and facilities and services for the care of the children, the right of the child to enjoy a high standard of health and access to health services, right to benefit from social security and other rights in accordance with national law. It was submitted that the Australian citizen child will be deprived of his rights afforded under the Australian law should his mother’s visa remain cancelled. It was submitted that the Australian citizen child is entitled to benefit from the rights afforded under Australian law and that it would be to his detriment to remain in China. It was submitted that he is not a citizen of China and will not be entitled to the same rights as citizens. It was submitted that the living and education standards in China are below that of the standards in Australia. It was submitted that China experiences dangerous level of air pollution which has adverse effects on health. The representative provided referenced to a number of articles regarding the high levels of air pollution in China and its effects on the health of the population. It was submitted that the applicant hopes to see her sons benefit from Australia’s culture, the quality of air, the quality of education, the quality of social support services and Australian quality of life. Reference was also made to Article 25 (2), of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights which provides that motherhood and childhood are entitled to special care and assistance, which is adopted by the CRC, and is a consideration in the Department’s policy. It was submitted that the welfare and rights of the children are of paramount importance. It was submitted that the Tribunal should consider the long-term effects that the visa cancellation may have on the children and on the benefits to them should they remain in Australia, where one of the children is a citizen. It was submitted that the cancellation is to the detriment of the applicant’s children who are innocent third parties.At the hearing the applicant also gave evidence that her children will be affected by environmental issues in China, including pollution and food safety issues. She stated that if her Australian citizen son grows up in China it will be difficult for him to merge into the Australian community later in life. She is concerned that he will be prevented from having a normal life and education in Australia which may later affect him. The Tribunal has also considered Australia’s obligations pursuant the Convention on the Rights of the Child (CRC) and acknowledges that in taking actions concerning children, the best interest of the child shall be a primary consideration. Given the relatively young age of the children, the Tribunal considers that it is in the best interest of Roy and Liam to be with their parents and for the family unit to remain intact. As discussed above, the Tribunal is satisfied that the family, who currently reside in China, can continue to live together in China. The Tribunal accepts that the applicant wants her sons to benefit from Australia’s culture, the air quality, education, social support services and the Australian lifestyle and gives some weight to these factors in the applicant’s favour. The Tribunal accepts that the air quality in China is of concern however there is no probative evidence before the Tribunal to indicate that the children have any health complications or would be unable to live in China for that reason. The Tribunal is also not satisfied that the children will be deprived of an education, basic levels of healthcare or other social services in China. Though the Tribunal does acknowledge that if Liam’s parents decide not to acquire Chinese citizenship for him, he may not be entitled to the same rights afforded to Chinese citizens as submitted by the representative. The Tribunal accepts that the children are innocent third parties in that they have played no role in the breach, however, they are still very young, have spent limited time in Australia and will be able to adapt to life in China with the assistance of their parents. The Tribunal does not accept that it would be to the detriment of Liam or Roy if the children remained in China. The children continue to have the love, support and nurture of both of their parents whilst they are living in China. Their father is currently employed and can provide for them. The Tribunal has considered the applicant’s evidence and accepts that her visa cancellation may mean that Liam is unable to live and study in Australia while he is still young, however it does not accept that this will necessary mean that will be difficult for him to merge into the Australian community later in life. The Tribunal considers the applicant’s fears to be highly speculative as there is no way of predicting how Liam will integrate into the Australian community later in life should he wish to live in Australia. As found above, the Tribunal considers that the best interest of the children, which the Tribunal acknowledges is a primary consideration, is for the family unit to remain intact. The Tribunal has had regard to all of the evidence and submissions and is satisfied that the cancellation will not necessarily result in the children being separated from their parents. The Tribunal has considered the effects of the cancellation on the children but is not satisfied that they would amount to a breach of Australia’s obligations under CRC. Whether the visa would have been granted if the correct information had been given? The Tribunal is satisfied that the employer sponsored Subclass 186 visa would not have been granted had the delegate considering that visa application known that the applicant was not actually offered a position with the nominating employer Oak Financial Partners. Conclusions The Tribunal has considered all of the evidence before and has carefully weighed up all of the relevant circumstances in this case. The Tribunal gives weight to the fact that one of the applicant’s children is an Australian citizen. The Tribunal also gives some weight to the time the applicant and her children have spent in Australia. It also acknowledges, and gives weight to the applicant’s desire to live and raise her children in Australia where they can enjoy high quality of air, education and health services. Against these factors however is the fact that the applicant was granted a permanent sponsored employer visa partly on the basis of a bogus document, without which she would not have been entitled to the grant of the visa. While the Tribunal has accepted that the applicant did not herself procure the bogus document, the evidence strongly suggests that the applicant was aware that the employment arrangement with Oak Financial Partners was not genuine and had been contrived for the purposes of securing a migration outcome for her and her son. The Tribunal considers the breach in this case to be serious and significant, and one which seriously undermines the integrity of Australia’s immigration program. The Tribunal considers the factors in favour of cancelling the visa outweigh those against cancellation of the visa. The Tribunal has decided that there was non-compliance by the applicant in the way described in the notice given under s.107 of the Act. Further, having regard to all the relevant circumstances, as discussed above, the Tribunal concludes that the visa should be cancelled.DECISIONThe Tribunal affirms the decision to cancel the first named applicant’s Subclass 186 - Employer Nomination Scheme visa.The Tribunal has no jurisdiction with respect to the other applicant.R. SkarosMemberATTACHMENT – Relevant Extracts from the Migration Act 1958:5Interpretation(1)In this Act, unless the contrary intention appears:bogus document, in relation to a person, means a document that the Minister reasonably suspects is a document that:(a) purports to have been, but was not, issued in respect of the person; or(b) is counterfeit or has been altered by a person who does not have authority to do so; or(c) was obtained because of a false or misleading statement, whether or not made knowingly.97InterpretationIn this Subdivision:application form, in relation to a non‑citizen, means a form on which a non‑citizen applies for a visa, being a form that regulations made for the purposes of section 46 allow to be used for making the application.passenger card has the meaning given by subsection 506(2) and, for the purposes of section 115, includes any document provided for by regulations under paragraph 504(1)(c).Note:Bogus document is defined in subsection 5(1).98Completion of visa applicationA non‑citizen who does not fill in his or her application form or passenger card is taken to do so if he or she causes it to be filled in or if it is otherwise filled in on his or her behalf.99Information is answerAny information that a non‑citizen gives or provides, causes to be given or provided, or that is given or provided on his or her behalf, to the Minister, an officer, an authorised system, a person or the Tribunal, or the Immigration Assessment authority, reviewing a decision under this Act in relation to the non‑citizen’s application for a visa is taken for the purposes of section 100, paragraphs 101(b) and 102(b) and sections 104 and 105 to be an answer to a question in the non‑citizen’s application form, whether the information is given or provided orally or in writing and whether at an interview or otherwise.100Incorrect answersFor the purposes of this Subdivision, an answer to a question is incorrect even though the person who gave or provided the answer, or caused the answer to be given or provided, did not know that it was incorrect.103Bogus documents not to be given etc.A non‑citizen must not give, present, [produce]* or provide to an officer, an authorised system, the Minister, the Immigration Assessment Authority, or the Tribunal performing a function or purpose under this Act, a bogus document or cause such a document to be so given, presented, [produced]* or provided.* This wording applies to documents given, presented, produced or provided on or after 4 November 2014: Schedule 7 to Counter Terrorism Legislation Amendment (Foreign Fighters) Act 2014 (No.116, 2014).107Notice of incorrect applications(1)If the Minister considers that the holder of a visa who has been immigration cleared (whether or not because of that visa) did not comply with section 101, 102, 103, 104 or 105 or with subsection (2) in a response to a notice under this section, the Minister may give the holder a notice:(a) giving particulars of the possible non‑compliance; and(b) stating that, within a period stated in the notice as mentioned in subsection (1A), the holder may give the Minister a written response to the notice that:(i)if the holder disputes that there was non‑compliance:(A)shows that there was compliance; and(B)in case the Minister decides under section 108 that, in spite of the statement under sub‑subparagraph (A), there was non‑compliance—shows cause why the visa should not be cancelled; or(ii)if the holder accepts that there was non‑compliance:(A)give reasons for the non‑compliance; and(B)shows cause why the visa should not be cancelled; and(c) stating that the Minister will consider cancelling the visa:(i)if the holder gives the Minister oral or written notice, within the period stated as mentioned in subsection (1A), that he or she will not give a written response—when that notice is given; or(ii)if the holder gives the Minister a written response within that period—when the response is given; or(iii)otherwise—at the end of that period; and(d) setting out the effect of sections 108, 109, 111 and 112; and(e) informing the holder that the holder’s obligations under section 104 or 105 are not affected by the notice under this section; and(f) requiring the holder:(i)to tell the Minister the address at which the holder is living; and(ii)if the holder changes that address before the Minister notifies the holder of the Minister’s decision on whether there was non‑compliance by the holder—to tell the Minister the changed address.(1A)The period to be stated in the notice under subsection (1) must be:(a) in respect of the holder of a temporary visa—the period prescribed by the regulations or, if no period is prescribed, a reasonable period; or(b) otherwise—14 days.(1B)Regulations prescribing a period for the purposes of paragraph (1A)(a) may prescribe different periods and state when a particular period is to apply, which, without limiting the generality of the power, may be to:(a) visas of a stated class; or(b) visa holders in stated circumstances; or(c) visa holders in a stated class of people (who may be visa holders in a particular place); or(d) visa holders in a stated class of people (who may be visa holders in a particular place) in stated circumstances.(2)If the visa holder responds to the notice, he or she must do so without making any incorrect statement.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The Tribunal has no jurisdiction with respect to the other applicant.R. SkarosMemberATTACHMENT – Relevant Extracts from the Migration Act 1958:5Interpretation(1)In this Act, unless the contrary intention appears:bogus document, in relation to a person, means a document that the Minister reasonably suspects is a document that:(a) purports to have been, but was not, issued in respect of the person; or(b) is counterfeit or has been altered by a person who does not have authority to do so; or(c) was obtained because of a false or misleading statement, whether or not made knowingly.97InterpretationIn this Subdivision:application form, in relation to a non‑citizen, means a form on which a non‑citizen applies for a visa, being a form that regulations made for the purposes of section 46 allow to be used for making the application.passenger card has the meaning given by subsection 506(2) and, for the purposes of section 115, includes any document provided for by regulations under paragraph 504(1)(c).Note:Bogus document is defined in subsection 5(1).98Completion of visa applicationA non‑citizen who does not fill in his or her application form or passenger card is taken to do so if he or she causes it to be filled in or if it is otherwise filled in on his or her behalf.99Information is answerAny information that a non‑citizen gives or provides, causes to be given or provided, or that is given or provided on his or her behalf, to the Minister, an officer, an authorised system, a person or the Tribunal, or the Immigration Assessment authority, reviewing a decision under this Act in relation to the non‑citizen’s application for a visa is taken for the purposes of section 100, paragraphs 101(b) and 102(b) and sections 104 and 105 to be an answer to a question in the non‑citizen’s application form, whether the information is given or provided orally or in writing and whether at an interview or otherwise.100Incorrect answersFor the purposes of this Subdivision, an answer to a question is incorrect even though the person who gave or provided the answer, or caused the answer to be given or provided, did not know that it was incorrect.103Bogus documents not to be given etc.A non‑citizen must not give, present, [produce]* or provide to an officer, an authorised system, the Minister, the Immigration Assessment Authority, or the Tribunal performing a function or purpose under this Act, a bogus document or cause such a document to be so given, presented, [produced]* or provided.* This wording applies to documents given, presented, produced or provided on or after 4 November 2014: Schedule 7 to Counter Terrorism Legislation Amendment (Foreign Fighters) Act 2014 (No.116, 2014).107Notice of incorrect applications(1)If the Minister considers that the holder of a visa who has been immigration cleared (whether or not because of that visa) did not comply with section 101, 102, 103, 104 or 105 or with subsection (2) in a response to a notice under this section, the Minister may give the holder a notice:(a) giving particulars of the possible non‑compliance; and(b) stating that, within a period stated in the notice as mentioned in subsection (1A), the holder may give the Minister a written response to the notice that:(i)if the holder disputes that there was non‑compliance:(A)shows that there was compliance; and(B)in case the Minister decides under section 108 that, in spite of the statement under sub‑subparagraph (A), there was non‑compliance—shows cause why the visa should not be cancelled; or(ii)if the holder accepts that there was non‑compliance:(A)give reasons for the non‑compliance; and(B)shows cause why the visa should not be cancelled; and(c) stating that the Minister will consider cancelling the visa:(i)if the holder gives the Minister oral or written notice, within the period stated as mentioned in subsection (1A), that he or she will not give a written response—when that notice is given; or(ii)if the holder gives the Minister a written response within that period—when the response is given; or(iii)otherwise—at the end of that period; and(d) setting out the effect of sections 108, 109, 111 and 112; and(e) informing the holder that the holder’s obligations under section 104 or 105 are not affected by the notice under this section; and(f) requiring the holder:(i)to tell the Minister the address at which the holder is living; and(ii)if the holder changes that address before the Minister notifies the holder of the Minister’s decision on whether there was non‑compliance by the holder—to tell the Minister the changed address.(1A)The period to be stated in the notice under subsection (1) must be:(a) in respect of the holder of a temporary visa—the period prescribed by the regulations or, if no period is prescribed, a reasonable period; or(b) otherwise—14 days.(1B)Regulations prescribing a period for the purposes of paragraph (1A)(a) may prescribe different periods and state when a particular period is to apply, which, without limiting the generality of the power, may be to:(a) visas of a stated class; or(b) visa holders in stated circumstances; or(c) visa holders in a stated class of people (who may be visa holders in a particular place); or(d) visa holders in a stated class of people (who may be visa holders in a particular place) in stated circumstances.(2)If the visa holder responds to the notice, he or she must do so without making any incorrect statement.