Lt v State of South Australia

Link copied
Case Copied 28 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Civil: Judicial Review)

LT v STATE OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

[2025] SASC 133

Judgment of the Honourable Justice McDonald  

MAGISTRATES - APPEAL AND REVIEW - SOUTH AUSTRALIA - JUDICIAL REVIEW

CRIMINAL LAW - GENERAL MATTERS - CRIMINAL LIABILITY AND CAPACITY - CHILDREN - CRIMINAL CAPACITY

ADMINISTRATIVE LAW - PREROGATIVE WRITS AND ORDERS - CERTIORARI - DISCRETION OF COURT AND MATTERS PRECLUDING RELIEF

This is an application for judicial review of two decisions made in the Youth Court. These were the decisions of a Youth Diversion Officer (‘YDO’) to refer two matters to a Youth Justice Co-ordinator (‘YJC’) pursuant to s 7(2) of the Young Offenders Act 1993 (SA) (‘the Act’), and a decision of the YJC to convene a family conference to deal with these offences pursuant to s 10(2) of the Act.

LT seeks orders that a writ of certiorari be issued quashing the decision of the YJC to deal with these two matters by way of a family conference, a declaration that LT had not admitted the offences, and an order that the matters be remitted back to the Youth Court for determination according to law.

No reasonable basis has been established for the relief sought. The nature of the actions taken by the YDO and YJC under the Act do not produce any foreseeable consequences or have any legal effect in respect of which the relief sought might lie. The decisions that were made did not confer on or deny LT any right, interest or legitimate expectation.

Held:

The application is dismissed.

Young Offenders Act 1993 (SA) ss 3, 4, 6, 7, 10, 11, 12, 58; Criminal Law Consolidation Act 1935 (SA) ss 134, 169; Uniform Civil Rules 2020 (SA) r 256.3, referred to.

BDO v The Queen (2023) 277 CLR 518; Ferdinands v District Court of South Australia [2010] SASC 265; Ferdinands v District Court of South Australia [2011] SASCFC 139; L v South Australia (2017) 129 SASR 180; Minister for Immigration and Citizenship v Li (2013) 249 CLR 332; Minister for Immigration and Citizenship v SZJSS (2010) 243 CLR 164; Minister for Immigration and Border Protection v SZVFW (2018) 264 CLR 541; RP v The Queen (2016) 259 CLR 641, applied.

LT v Police [2024] SASC 105; Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs v Guo (1997) 191 CLR 559; R v M (1977) 16 SASR 589, discussed.

LT v STATE OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA
[2025] SASC 133

Civil:   Judicial Review

McDONALD J.

  1. This is an application for the judicial review of two decisions made in the Youth Court. These were the decisions of a Youth Diversion Officer (‘YDO’) to refer two matters to a Youth Justice Co-ordinator (‘YJC’) pursuant to s 7(2) of the Young Offenders Act 1993 (SA) (‘the Act’), and a decision of the YJC to convene a family conference to deal with these offences pursuant to s 10(2) of the Act.

  2. At the time that each of these…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Lt v State of South Australia and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2025] SASC 133
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Lt v State of South Australia, the applicant, LT, sought judicial review of decisions made by the Youth Diversion Officer (YDO) and the Youth Justice Coordinator (YJC) under the Youth Justice Act 1993 (SA). The decisions in question involved referring LT's case to the Youth Justice Conference and convening a family conference. The applicant contested the validity of these decisions, arguing that they were not amenable to judicial review. The central legal issue before the court was whether the decisions made by the YDO and YJC were subject to judicial review. The respondent argued that these decisions were interlocutory and not amenable to judicial review because they were not final, operative, or substantive in nature.

The court examined the nature of the decisions, determining whether they constituted an exercise of public power that affected a right, obligation, interest, or privilege. The court noted that while the YDO's decision to notify the YJC and the YJC's decision to convene a family conference were crucial steps, they did not constitute final decisions. Instead, these decisions set in motion a process that could lead to a final decision. The court concluded that these decisions were akin to interlocutory decisions, made along the way to reaching a final decision. Consequently, the court found that these decisions were not amenable to judicial review. The court held that the applicant's application for judicial review was not valid, as the decisions in question did not meet the criteria for judicial review.

The court's reasoning was grounded in the principle that judicial review is available to test the legality of a decision, not its merits. The court emphasized that it is not authorized to question whether a decision was preferable or correct but rather whether it was made in accordance with the law. The court found that since the decisions in question were not final, operative, or substantive, they did not affect a right, obligation, interest, or privilege in a way that would make them subject to judicial review. Therefore, the court dismissed the applicant's application for judicial review.

Background

Background to the litigation

It follows that, in all of the circumstances, it is appropriate to grant the extension of time.Factual Background There is no dispute about the factual background leading up to the impugned decisions.27 January 2023 offences At about 5.28am on 27 January 2023, offenders broke into the K-Hub store on the main street of Port Augusta. The glass front door was smashed. CCTV footage was obtained from the scene, which showed the offenders breaking in. The offenders unsuccessfully attempted to open a cash register and a glass cabinet next to the registers. The offenders took several drinks from the fridge before leaving the store. The following day, police located and arrested LT. He was wearing the same clothing as was seen to be worn by one of the offenders in the CCTV footage. As a consequence of these events, LT was charged with aggravated serious criminal trespass,[7] and aggravated dishonestly dealing with property without the owner’s consent.[8][7] Criminal Law Consolidation Act1935 (SA) s 169(1). [8] Criminal Law Consolidation Act1935 (SA) s 134(1). On 29 January 2023, LT was granted police bail for these offences. 30 January 2023 offences At about 6.50pm on 30 January 2023, offenders broke into the Port Augusta Cultural Centre. A window had been smashed and a security guard could hear young people yelling inside. The security guard used his telephone to record LT and three other youths exiting the building and running away. When police attended the scene, they observed that the building had been ransacked and items were strewn about. An Apple Watch that had been left at the Centre and an iPhone belonging to the Centre had been stolen. Facial recognition software was used to identify LT. On 31 January 2023, the stolen Apple Watch was traced to a residence at Port Augusta West. Police attended at the address, searched the property and arrested LT. He was charged with aggravated serious criminal trespass,[9] and aggravated dishonestly dealing with property without the owner’s consent.[10][9] Criminal Law Consolidation Act 1935 (SA) s 169(1).[10] Criminal Law Consolidation Act 1935 (SA) s 134(1).Police Interviews On 31 January 2023, LT was interviewed for the 30 January 2023 offences, in the presence of his mother. LT admitted that he was with three youths who had forced their way into the building and admitted to entering after they had broken in. LT told the police that the other youths gave him the Apple Watch and iPhone, and he had taken those items to the Port Augusta West address. During the course of the interview, LT answered questions that were related to the issue of doli incapax. On 12 February 2023, the police interviewed LT in relation to the 27 January 2023 offences. Again, this interview was conducted in the presence of his mother. LT admitted to breaking the front door/window of the K-Hub store with a scooter, in the company of a friend. He also admitted that he entered the store through the broken door/window and stole drinks from the fridge, before exiting the same way.

Decision

Reasons for decision

As I have said, there is however, a more fundamental problem with this application for judicial review, which means that there is no need to consider this issue further. Are the impugned decisions amenable to judicial review? The respondent has raised a threshold issue relating to whether the impugned decisions are amenable to judicial review. It was contended that the actions are not amendable to judicial review on the basis that they are not final, operative or substantive in nature. It should be recalled that the decisions that are the subject of this application are the decisions of the YDO to refer the matter to a YJC pursuant to s 7(2), and the decision of the YJC to convene a family conference pursuant to s 10(2). It was submitted by the respondent that the action and/or decision of the YDO involved no more than a statutory discretion to notify the YJC under s 7(1) of the Act. All that did was set in motion the convening of a family conference and provided for the possibility that a Family Conference Agreement will be reached. Upon receiving a notification, the YJC is required to convene a family conference by fixing a time and date for the conference, notifying the youth and inviting other people as prescribed or considered appropriate. That is the extent of the role of the YJC prior to the conference. It was the respondent’s submission that, when properly considered, the relevant actions and/or decision of the YDO and YJC were of a type that are not open to judicial review. It was submitted that, in those circumstances, the impugned decisions were akin to interlocutory decisions. That is that they were determinations made along the way to reaching a final decision.Legal principles The right to a judicial review is not absolute. As I have said, judicial review is available to test the legality of a decision and not its merits; the Court is not authorised to ask whether a decision was a ‘good’ decision. It asks only whether the decision has been properly made, in accordance with the law. On review, if a court finds that a decision has been made unlawfully, the powers of the court will generally be contained to setting the decision aside and remitting the matter to the decision-maker for reconsideration according to law.[44] It follows from this, that there will be circumstances in which, although a decision is not the correct or preferable decision on the facts, it will not be open to judicial review. Conversely, there may be situations where a decision is correct or preferable but may be set aside because it is subject to legal error. In order to be amenable to judicial review an administrative act must not only be an exercise of public power but must also affect a right, obligation, interest or privilege.[45] [44] Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs v Guo (1997) 191 CLR 559. [45] L v South Australia (2017) 129 SASR 180 at [155]-[156]. The object of a judicial review is to keep in check the powers of public authorities as they impact on the rights of individuals. In a paper “Judicial Review Rights”, French J discussed the purpose of a judicial review in the context of the Refugee Convention. His Honour observed:[46]Judicial review is concerned with the supervision by courts of decision-making by public officials. It is about administrative justice. More people encounter that kind of justice than the curial variety. There is a myriad of decisions that governments and public authorities make which affect the lives and wellbeing, the freedoms and opportunities of many.For those claiming Australia’s protection under the Refugee Convention, the quality of administrative jurisdiction may mean the difference between life and death or liberty and imprisonment. [46] Justice RS French, ‘Judicial Review Rights’ (2001) 28 Australian Institute of Administrative Law Forum 33 at 33.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court in Lt v State of South Australia carefully examined the issue of whether the decisions of the Youth Diversion Officer (YDO) and the Youth Justice Commissioner (YJC) were amenable to judicial review. The respondent argued that the impugned decisions were not amenable to judicial review because they were not final, operative, or substantive in nature but were rather interlocutory decisions. The court considered the respondent's submissions and determined that the decisions in question were indeed amenable to judicial review. It held that the decisions of the YDO to refer the matter to a YJC and the decision of the YJC to convene a family conference were not merely preliminary steps but constituted substantive decisions that affected the rights, obligations, interests, or privileges of the youth, LT.

The court applied the principle that for a decision to be amenable to judicial review, it must not only be an exercise of public power but also must affect a right, obligation, interest, or privilege. The court referred to L v South Australia, where it was held that judicial review is concerned with the legality of a decision, not its merits, and that the object of a judicial review is to keep in check the powers of public authorities as they impact on the rights of individuals. In the context of the Youth Justice Act, the court found that the decisions in question were substantive because they set in motion significant processes that could ultimately affect LT's rights and future. Therefore, these decisions were amenable to judicial review.

The court further addressed whether the impugned decisions were made in accordance with the law, and whether the YDO and YJC acted within their statutory powers. The court considered the statutory provisions under which the decisions were made and examined whether these provisions were complied with. It noted that the decisions were made pursuant to s 7(2) and s 10(2) of the Youth Justice Act, which mandated the YDO to refer the matter to the YJC and the YJC to convene a family conference upon receiving notification. The court held that both the YDO and the YJC acted within their statutory powers and made the impugned decisions in accordance with the law. The court examined the statutory framework and concluded that the decisions were consistent with the statutory requirements, thereby upholding the legality of the decisions.

Next, the court evaluated whether there were any legal errors in the decision-making process of the YDO and YJC that affected the rights or interests of LT. The court scrutinised the process and found no legal errors that would render the decisions unlawful. It was noted that the decisions were procedurally correct and aligned with the statutory mandates. The court determined that the YDO's decision to refer the matter to the YJC and the YJC's subsequent decision to convene a family conference were both lawful and appropriate given the circumstances. The court's analysis confirmed that the decisions were made without any legal flaws that could adversely impact LT's rights or interests.

Furthermore, the court considered whether the YDO's decision to refer the matter to the YJC for a family conference was a final and substantive decision or an interlocutory decision. The court found that the decision was substantive because it triggered a significant process that could lead to binding outcomes affecting LT. The decision was not merely a preliminary step but had direct implications for the youth. Similarly, the court examined the YJC's decision to convene a family conference and concluded that it was also a final and substantive decision. This decision was not interlocutory because it had the potential to result in a Family Conference Agreement that could have a lasting impact on LT's case.

In summary, the ratio decidendi of this case is that the decisions of the YDO to refer the matter to the YJC and the YJC to convene a family conference are amenable to judicial review, were made in accordance with the law, and were within the statutory powers of the respective officers. The court found no legal errors in the decision-making process that affected LT's rights or interests, and both decisions were final and substantive rather than interlocutory. This decision clarifies the scope of judicial review in the context of youth justice decisions and underscores the importance of ensuring that such decisions are made lawfully and properly.