Louis v State of Tasmania

Link copied
Case Copied 32 min read

[2001] TASSC 154

CITATION:                 Louis v State of Tasmania [2001] TASSC 154

PARTIES:  LOUIS, Graham James
  v
  STATE OF TASMANIA

TITLE OF COURT:  SUPREME COURT OF TASMANIA (FULL COURT)
JURISDICTION:  APPELLATE
FILE NO/S:  FCA 16/1997
DELIVERED ON:  21 December 2001
DELIVERED AT:  Hobart
HEARING DATES:  23 - 25 May 2001
JUDGMENT OF:  Cox CJ, Slicer, Evans JJ

CATCHWORDS:

REPRESENTATION:

Counsel:
             Appellant:  In person
             Respondent:  L J Neasey
Solicitors:
             Appellant:  In person
             Respondent:  Director of Public Prosecutions

Judgment Number:  [2001] TASSC 154
Number of Paragraphs:  61

Serial No 154/2001
File No FCA 16/1997

GRAHAM JAMES LOUIS v THE STATE OF TASMANIA

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT  FULL COURT

COX CJ
SLICER J
EVANS J
21 December 2001

Order of the Court

Appeal dismissed

Serial No 154/2001
File No FCA 16/1997

GRAHAM JAMES LOUIS v THE STATE OF TASMANIA

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT  FULL COURT

COX CJ
21 December 2001

  1. I agree with the reasons for judgment prepared by Slicer J which I have had the advantage of perusing.  The appeal should be dismissed.

    File No FCA 16/1997

GRAHAM JAMES LOUIS v THE STATE OF TASMANIA

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT  SLICER J
  21 December 2001

  1. This is an appeal against the dismissal of an action brought by Rosalina Melina Louis, Graham James Louis and Rachael Rose Louis.  As the sole appellant is the second plaintiff, it is convenient to continue to use the designation "plaintiffs" when referring to them other than by name.  The first and second plaintiffs are husband and wife, while the third plaintiff is their daughter.  They lived with other members of their family at Cornwall during January 1992.

  1. During the course of the afternoon of 9 January 1992, the young son in the family discharged an air rifle, an act which caused a neighbour, Mr Stefanescu, to make a complaint to police.  Later in the day two police officers, Const Skeggs and Const Casboult, went to the family home to attend to the complaint.  The ensuing events resulted in media publicity, a summary prosecution and dismissal, a civil action against the officers (later amended so as to be against the State of Tasmania), a trial lasting eight days, and this appeal comprising some 37 grounds.  Because of what had occurred at the home the officers (on their version) arrested Mr Louis on the grounds that he had committed the offence of threatening police and subsequently arrested and charged Mrs Louis with the offences of refusal to give her name and address, and damage to Mr Stefanescu, events occurring after the arrival of the police.

  1. Following a hearing on 9 July 1992, the complaints were dismissed by a magistrate sitting as a Court of Petty Sessions.  One of the many issues at the hearing was whether Mr Louis had been arrested for obstruction of police rather than threatening.  The issue was real in that, in their evidence, the police officers had contradicted an entry in the police brief which stated the charge to be that of obstruction.  Police officers had gone to…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Louis v State of Tasmania and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2001] TASSC 154
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Louis v State of Tasmania [2001] TASSC 154 involved an appeal against the dismissal of a civil action brought by Rosalina Melina Louis, Graham James Louis, and Rachael Rose Louis against the State of Tasmania. The plaintiffs alleged that police officers had trespassed, committed battery, false imprisonment, and malicious prosecution. The appeal was heard by the Supreme Court of Tasmania (Full Court) and the grounds for appeal were numerous and complex, encompassing issues of procedural validity, bias, credibility, and factual findings. The court found that many of the grounds for appeal were without merit, particularly those that were either procedural in nature or amounted to disagreement with the trial judge's assessment of the evidence. The court upheld the trial judge's findings on the basis that they were supported by the evidence and the trial judge had correctly applied the law. The appeal was ultimately dismissed.

Background

Background to the litigation

On the afternoon of 9 January 1992, a young boy in the Louis family discharged an air rifle, leading to a neighbour making a complaint to the police. Two police officers, Const Skeggs and Const Casboult, subsequently went to the Louis family home to address the complaint. This visit resulted in significant events, including the arrest of Graham James Louis and Rachael Rose Louis, leading to a media report, a summary prosecution, and a subsequent civil action against the officers and the State of Tasmania. The original complaint was dismissed by a magistrate, but the Louis family proceeded to file a civil action alleging trespass, battery, false imprisonment, and malicious prosecution, among other claims. The case was amended to include Rachael and Rosalina Melina Louis, Graham's wife and daughter respectively. After a lengthy trial, the court dismissed the plaintiffs' action, leading to the present appeal. The appeal comprises 37 grounds, many of which challenge the trial judge's findings of fact and credibility assessments. The central issue revolves around the legality of the police officers' entry into the Louis home and their subsequent conduct. The plaintiffs argue that the officers trespassed and unlawfully arrested Graham, while the officers claim they acted lawfully and were threatened by Graham. The trial judge found in favour of the officers, leading to the plaintiffs' dissatisfaction and subsequent appeal.

This case concerns an appeal by Graham James Louis against the dismissal of a civil action he and his family brought against the State of Tasmania. The original action stemmed from an incident on 9 January 1992, when police officers visited the Louis family home in Cornwall following a complaint by a neighbour. The ensuing events led to a summary prosecution, a civil action, and ultimately this appeal. The matter came before the Supreme Court of Tasmania on appeal from a trial held in September 1996. The appeal was heard by the Full Court over three days from 23-25 May 2001, and judgment was delivered on 21 December 2001. The appeal was dismissed. The procedural history of the matter involved several key steps. Initially, Mr Louis and his family brought an action against the police officers involved in the incident. The claim was later amended to name the State of Tasmania as the defendant under the Crown Proceedings Act 1993. The case went to trial in September 1996, with a judgment handed down on 24 February 1997 dismissing the plaintiffs' claims. Mr Louis then appealed the trial judgment to the Full Court of the Supreme Court of Tasmania. The appeal was heard over three days in May 2001, with judgment delivered in December 2001. The Full Court dismissed the appeal. The appeal involved 37 grounds, which were grouped into categories such as validity of proceedings, Jones v Dunkel, fairness, burden of proof, competence and bias of the trial judge, findings of fact, and others. The Full Court found that most of the grounds of appeal were without merit and dismissed the appeal.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Was the legality of the proceedings properly addressed by the court, particularly regarding the validity of the second plaintiff instituting proceedings on behalf of the first and third plaintiffs?
2. Did the court err in its approach to the principles set out in Jones v Dunkel concerning the failure of the plaintiffs to call a particular witness?
3. Did the court err in its assessment of the credibility of the plaintiffs' witnesses, including Mrs Louis and Mr Louis?
4. Did the court err in its consideration of the police officers' entry into the plaintiffs' home, particularly whether they trespassed or effected forced entry?
5. Did the court err in its findings regarding the timing of the police officers' arrival at the neighbour's house?
6. Did the court err in its findings regarding the attempted use of handcuffs on the second plaintiff and the holding of a weapon by the police officers?
7. Did the court err in its findings regarding the reception of evidence of prior convictions held by the appellant?
8. Did the court err in its findings of fact concerning the plaintiffs' claims, including the alleged trespass, battery, and false imprisonment?
9. Did the court err in its handling of the police prosecution file and its potential relevance to the case?

Held
1. The court concluded that the second plaintiff's initiation of proceedings on behalf of the first and third plaintiffs was valid, dismissing the grounds related to the legality of the proceedings.
2. The court found no error in its approach to the principles set out in Jones v Dunkel regarding the plaintiffs' failure to call a particular witness.
3. The court upheld its assessment of the credibility of the plaintiffs' witnesses, including Mrs Louis and Mr Louis, rejecting the grounds that claimed errors in this assessment.
4. The court upheld its findings concerning the police officers' entry into the plaintiffs' home, dismissing claims that they trespassed or effected forced entry.
5. The court upheld its findings regarding the timing of the police officers' arrival at the neighbour's house, dismissing the claim of error in this regard.
6. The court upheld its findings regarding the attempted use of handcuffs on the second plaintiff and the holding of a weapon by the police officers, dismissing the claims of error.
7. The court upheld its findings regarding the reception of evidence of prior convictions held by the appellant, dismissing the related grounds of appeal.
8. The court upheld its findings of fact concerning the plaintiffs' claims, including the alleged trespass, battery, and false imprisonment, dismissing the grounds of error.
9. The court upheld its handling of the police prosecution file, dismissing the claims of error related to its potential relevance to the case.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court began by addressing the issue of the validity of the proceedings, specifically whether the second plaintiff, Graham James Louis, could institute proceedings on behalf of the first and third plaintiffs. The court found that the amendments to the pleadings were made to advance the plaintiffs' respective actions and that the grounds were self-defeating if upheld, as they would result in the dismissal of the actions without determination of the merits. The court dismissed these grounds.

The court then examined the issue of the court's approach to the principles set out in Jones v Dunkel concerning the failure of the plaintiffs to call a particular witness. The court found that the learned trial judge made no adverse inference concerning the failure to call the witness and that the comment made by the trial judge was in the context of the witness's evidence neither assisting nor harming the plaintiffs' cause. The court held that there was no merit in this point.

The court assessed the credibility of the plaintiffs' witnesses, including Mrs Louis and Mr Louis. The court found that the learned trial judge was entitled to reject portions of the evidence given by Mrs Louis and that his conclusion that she was being deliberately untruthful was permitted by the evidence. The court also found that the learned trial judge's assessment of Mr Louis's credibility was not an error in law and was permitted by the evidence.

The court considered the police officers' entry into the plaintiffs' home, particularly whether they trespassed or effected forced entry. The court found that the learned trial judge's conclusion that the police officers did not trespass was permitted by the evidence and that the conclusion was safely made and not subject to review.

The court examined the timing of the police officers' arrival at the neighbour's house and found that the learned trial judge did not make the finding complained of.

The court also assessed the attempted use of handcuffs on the second plaintiff and the holding of a weapon by the police officers. The court found that the learned trial judge's findings were permitted by the evidence.

Regarding the reception of evidence of prior convictions held by the appellant, the court found that there was no error in the reception of the evidence and that the learned trial judge found the evidence of prior offences to be of little relevance in the proceedings.

The court examined the findings of fact concerning the plaintiffs' claims, including the alleged trespass, battery, and false imprisonment. The court found that the learned trial judge's findings were permitted by the evidence and that the conclusion was safely made and not subject to review.

Finally, the court considered the handling of the police prosecution file and its potential relevance to the case. The court found that there was no substance in the plaintiffs' claims that the learned trial judge was wrong in not using the contents of the police prosecution file.

In summary, the ratio decidendi of this case is that the court found no merit in the majority of the grounds of appeal raised by the appellant and upheld the decision of the learned trial judge. The court found that the learned trial judge's conclusions were permitted by the evidence and that the findings of fact were safely made and not subject to review.