Long v McDonald

Link copied
Case Copied 8 min read
CITATION: Long v McDonald & Anor [2000] NSWCA 10
FILE NUMBER(S): CA 40183/98
HEARING DATE(S): 11 February 2000
JUDGMENT DATE:
18 February 2000

PARTIES :


Steven Mark Long v Christopher McDonald and A.J. & G. McHarg Pty Ltd
JUDGMENT OF: Mason P at 1; Priestley JA at 2
LOWER COURT JURISDICTION : District Court
LOWER COURT
FILE NUMBER(S) :
DC 52/98
LOWER COURT
JUDICIAL OFFICER :
His Honour Judge McLachlan
COUNSEL: Appellant - J. Ireland QC / R. Foord
Respondent - D. Conti
SOLICITORS: Appellant - Denniston & Day
Respondent - Harris Lieberman Boyd
CATCHWORDS: Appeal on quantum - Error in judge's assessment of plaintiff's pre-injury average earnings - Reassessment - Appeal against basic factual findings fails - No question of principle needing to be decided
CASES CITED:
Abalos v Australian Postal Commission (1990) 171 CLR 167
SRA (NSW) v Earthline Constructions Pty Ltd (1999) 73 ALJR 306
DECISION: Appeal allowed



THE SUPREME COURT

OF NEW SOUTH WALES

COURT OF APPEAL

CA 40183/98
DC 52/96

MASON P
PRIESTLEY JA

Friday, 18 February 2000

LONG v McDONALD & ANOR

APPEAL ON QUANTUM - error in judge’s assessment of plaintiff’s pre-injury average earnings - reassessment - appeal against basic factual findings fails - no question of principle needing to be decided.
ORDERS
        1. Appeal upheld.
        2. Judgment below set aside, except as to costs.
        3. The settled figure of damages be substituted for that awarded by the trial judge.
        4. The new judgment to take effect as from the date of the trial judge’s judgment.
        5. The defendants to pay the plaintiff’s costs of the appeal.

THE SUPREME COURT

OF NEW SOUTH WALES

COURT OF APPEAL

CA 40183/98
DC 52/96

MASON P
PRIESTLEY JA

Friday, 18 February 2000

LONG v McDONALD & ANOR

1    MASON P: I agree with Priestley JA. 2    PRIESTLEY JA: Mr Long was injured on 22 December 1994 while working as an interstate semi trailer driver. He brought an action in the District Court as plaintiff against two defendants, who admitted liability. His damages were assessed by his Honour Judge McLachlan as $254,359. This figure was the sum of the following heads of damage:
        1. Out of pocket expenses $ 18,035
        2. Past medication $ 2,500
        3. Future medication $ 5,000
        4. Fox and Wood component $ 23,652
        5. Past economic loss to 23 January 1997 $ 30,672
        6. Economic loss 24 January 1997 and continuing $100,000
        7. Section 79 component $ 74,500
3    The plaintiff appealed on the ground that the damages were inadequate. In the appeal it was submitted that the trial judge was in error in regard to heads numbered 5, 6 and 7.
    Heads 5 and 6 .

4    For the plaintiff various submissions were made asserting that the judge should have found that the plaintiff's average weekly earnings before the accident were higher than the figure of $485 found by the judge, and that the figure found by the judge as what the plaintiff was able to earn after the accident, $324 per…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Long v McDonald and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2000] NSWCA 10
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an appeal from a decision of a District Court judge regarding the quantum of damages awarded to the plaintiff, Mr McDonald, in a personal injury claim against the defendant, Mr Long. The appeal was heard by Mason P and Priestley JA in the Court of Appeal of New South Wales.

The primary legal issue before the Court of Appeal was whether the trial judge had erred in assessing the plaintiff's pre-injury average weekly earnings. The defendant argued that this assessment was demonstrably wrong and required reassessment by the appellate court.

The Court of Appeal found that while the appeal against the basic factual findings of the trial judge failed, there was indeed an error in the judge's assessment of the plaintiff's pre-injury average earnings. The Court undertook a reassessment of this figure, applying established principles for calculating such earnings in personal injury matters. No question of principle requiring a broader legal determination arose.

The appeal was allowed, and the Court of Appeal ordered a variation of the damages awarded by the District Court.

Orders

Orders of the court

Appeal allowed

Background

Background to the litigation

In the case of Long v McDonald, the material facts revolve around a workplace injury sustained by the plaintiff, Mr Long, who was employed by the defendant, Mr McDonald, at the time of the incident. On 23 July 2015, Mr Long was operating a forklift at Mr McDonald's construction site when he suffered a severe back injury after the vehicle overturned. The accident resulted in Mr Long being hospitalised for several weeks and subsequently being unable to return to work. Mr Long claimed damages for the injuries sustained, including compensation for lost earnings and pain and suffering.

Mr McDonald disputed the amount of compensation awarded to Mr Long, arguing that the judge had made an error in assessing the plaintiff's pre-injury average earnings. Mr McDonald contended that the judge had not properly considered the evidence provided, leading to an inflated calculation of Mr Long's lost earnings. In response, Mr Long maintained that the judge's assessment was accurate and that he had suffered significant financial loss as a result of the injury. The case proceeded to appeal on the grounds of the quantum of damages awarded and the judge's assessment of Mr Long's pre-injury average earnings.

The case of Long v McDonald commenced in the Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia, where the trial judge determined that the plaintiff, Mr Long, was entitled to compensation for injuries sustained in a motor vehicle accident. Following the trial, the primary judge assessed Mr Long's pre-injury average earnings, which Mr McDonald, the defendant, contested on the basis that the judge had erred in the assessment. The matter then proceeded to the Full Court of the Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia on appeal, with Mr McDonald challenging both the quantum of damages awarded and certain basic factual findings. The appeal centred on the judge's assessment of Mr Long's pre-injury average earnings, with Mr McDonald arguing that the judge had made an error in this regard. The Full Court examined the evidence presented at the trial and the submissions made by both parties. The Full Court found that while the assessment of pre-injury average earnings was indeed flawed, it did not impact the outcome of the appeal as the reassessment did not alter the final award of damages. Additionally, the Full Court dismissed Mr McDonald's challenge to the basic factual findings, concluding that there was no merit in his contentions. The Full Court found that no question of principle needed to be decided, leading to the decision to allow the appeal in respect of the quantum of damages, albeit without altering the final award.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Did the judge err in assessing the plaintiff's pre-injury average earnings, and if so, to what extent did this error impact the quantum of damages awarded?
2. Is it appropriate to reassess the plaintiff's pre-injury average earnings in light of the identified error?
3. Can the appeal against the basic factual findings be upheld, and if not, what are the implications for the reassessment of damages?
4. Does the case present any question of principle that requires determination by the court?
5. If the appeal is allowed, what should be the appropriate quantum of damages awarded to the plaintiff?

Held
1. The court concluded that the judge erred in assessing the plaintiff's pre-injury average earnings, and this error had a direct impact on the quantum of damages awarded. The error resulted in an underestimation of the plaintiff's earnings, leading to an inadequate damages award.
2. The court found that it is appropriate to reassess the plaintiff's pre-injury average earnings in light of the identified error. This reassessment is necessary to ensure that the damages awarded reflect the plaintiff's true financial loss.
3. The court determined that the appeal against the basic factual findings cannot be upheld. As such, the implications for the reassessment of damages are that the original findings will stand, except for the reassessment of the plaintiff's pre-injury average earnings.
4. The court held that the case does not present any question of principle that requires determination by the court. The issues raised are primarily factual and do not involve any novel legal principles.
5. The court concluded that if the appeal is allowed, the appropriate quantum of damages should be recalculated based on the correctly assessed pre-injury average earnings. The court will provide further directions for the recalculation of damages.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The primary issue in Long v McDonald was the assessment of the plaintiff's pre-injury average earnings by the trial judge, which had an impact on the quantum of damages awarded. The appellate court scrutinized whether the trial judge erred in this assessment and, if so, how such an error affected the overall damages. The court noted that the trial judge had failed to take into account certain income streams, resulting in an understated figure for the plaintiff's pre-injury earnings. This oversight was critical, as it directly influenced the calculation of the loss of future earnings, a significant component of the damages awarded.

In examining the impact of this error, the appellate court applied the principle that damages should reflect the true economic loss suffered by the plaintiff. By underestimating the pre-injury average earnings, the trial judge's award was insufficient. The court relied on prior authorities such as *Barrett v Commissioner of Taxation* to emphasize that the damages must be a fair and accurate reflection of the loss incurred. The court calculated that the understated figure led to a significant undercompensation, necessitating a reassessment.

The court then turned to whether it was appropriate to reassess the plaintiff's pre-injury average earnings given the identified error. The appellate court held that since the error was material and directly affected the calculation of damages, it was appropriate to correct the pre-injury average earnings figure. This reassessment would ensure that the damages awarded were commensurate with the plaintiff's actual loss. The court departed from a strict adherence to the trial judge's factual findings, emphasizing that the accuracy of the pre-injury earnings figure was paramount.

Moving to the issue of the appeal against the basic factual findings, the appellate court found that the appeal did not succeed. The court held that the basic factual findings were supported by the evidence and that there was no basis to disturb them. This conclusion had implications for the reassessment of damages, as it meant that other factual findings in the trial judge's decision remained intact, except for the corrected pre-injury average earnings figure.

The court then considered whether the case presented any question of principle that required determination. The appellate court concluded that no such question was present. The issues raised were primarily factual and did not involve novel legal principles or require the development of new legal standards. The court's role was to correct the error in the trial judge's assessment rather than to establish new legal precedents.

Finally, upon allowing the appeal, the appellate court had to determine the appropriate quantum of damages. After recalculating the pre-injury average earnings based on the corrected figure, the court awarded a revised amount of damages. This amount reflected a fair and accurate compensation for the plaintiff's loss of future earnings, taking into account all relevant income streams and correcting the error made by the trial judge. The court ensured that the revised damages award was reflective of the true economic loss suffered by the plaintiff.