Logos Research Institute Pty Ltd (in Liq) v Christi

Link copied
Case Copied 16 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Civil)

LOGOS RESEARCH INSTITUTE PTY LTD (IN LIQ) v CHRISTI

[2022] SASC 54

Decision of Judge Bochner a Master of the Supreme Court  

EQUITY - TRUSTS AND TRUSTEES - POWERS, DUTIES, RIGHTS AND LIABILITIES OF TRUSTEES - INDEMNITY, LIEN AND REIMBURSEMENT - LEGAL COSTS AND COMMISSION ENTITLEMENT

PROCEDURE - CIVIL PROCEEDINGS IN STATE AND TERRITORY COURTS - ENDING PROCEEDINGS EARLY - DEFAULT JUDGMENT - OTHER MATTERS

DAMAGES - ASSESSMENT OF DAMAGES

Assessment of damages - default judgment.

Blackburn v Logos Research Institute Pty Ltd [2015] SADC 175; Hardoon v Belilios [1901] AC 118; Edgar & Anor v Ron Kingham Real Estate Pty Ltd [1999] 2 Qd R 439; Grizonic v Suttor [2011] NSWSC 471; Park & Muller (liquidators of LM Investment Management Ltd) v Whyte No 3 [2017] QSC 230, considered.

LOGOS RESEARCH INSTITUTE PTY LTD (IN LIQ) v CHRISTI
[2022] SASC 54

CIVIL

  1. On 18 June 2021, default judgment was entered in this action in favour of the applicant. The applicant now seeks to have its damages assessed.

    Background

  2. Until the applicant was wound up by the Court and a liquidator appointed, the respondent, Ms Christi, was its sole director and shareholder. The applicant was the trustee of the Logos Trust, of which Ms Christi was the sole beneficiary. The applicant had never traded and had never held property in its own right. It has only ever acted in its capacity as trustee of the Logos Trust.

  3. In February 2006, the applicant became the registered proprietor of a property at Aldgate. About a week later, it also became the registered proprietor of a property at Blackwood. In 2014, the applicant transferred the Aldgate property to Ms Christi by way of a deed of gift. It seems that Ms Christi lived jointly between the Aldgate property and the Blackwood property.

    The Blackwood property

  4. The Blackwood property is built on a steep hill. In 1991, an excavation was undertaken at its rear, to instal a tennis court. From about 1992, the land suffered a number of landslips, and over time, significant damage was caused to the Blackwood property, an adjoining property, and to infrastructure belonging to SA Water. The adjoining property was situated further up the hill, and the landslips caused the edge of the excavation to move closer to the boundary of the adjoining property. In 2011, the local council served an emergency order on the applicant, to carry out remediation works to prevent any further landslips or other risk. The applicant appealed the work order in the Environmental, Resources and Development Court; the Court ultimately upheld the order. The applicant did not carry out the required work.

  5. In 2013, the owners of the adjoining property issued proceedings against the applicant and Ms Christi, seeking orders to compel them to carry out the required work. Without going into the somewhat tortuous path that that litigation took, suffice to say that the applicant was unsuccessful at trial and a significant costs order…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Logos Research Institute Pty Ltd (in Liq) v Christi and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2022] SASC 54
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Logos Research Institute Pty Ltd (in Liq) v Christi was a case before the Supreme Court of South Australia, where the applicant sought an assessment of damages following a default judgment entered in its favour on 18 June 2021. The applicant, which had acted as the trustee of the Logos Trust, sought an indemnity for the liquidator’s remuneration, work-in-progress, and disbursements. The applicant had been wound up in insolvency, and the liquidator had been appointed as the Receiver and Manager of the Blackwood property, carrying out necessary remediation works. The applicant argued that the expenses incurred were reasonably incurred and sought an indemnity for the liquidator’s fees and disbursements.

The primary legal issue before the court was whether the expenses claimed by the liquidator were properly and reasonably incurred. The applicant relied on the case of Edgar & Anor v Ron Kingham Real Estate Pty Ltd, which established that "properly incurred" means "not improperly incurred." The applicant argued that the creditors' approval of the liquidator’s fees supported the reasonableness of the costs. Ms Christi, the respondent, submitted that there was a conspiracy within the legal profession to prevent her from receiving justice, and took issue with several interlocutory orders without appealing them. However, the respondent did not provide clear or relevant material to support her claims.

The court found that the expenses claimed by the liquidator were reasonably incurred, as there was no evidence of impropriety. The liquidator’s fees were substantiated by individual time entries, and the creditors' approval further supported the reasonableness of the fees. The respondent’s submissions were largely irrelevant and unsubstantiated, focusing more on the merits of the underlying litigation rather than the assessment of the liquidator's costs. The court concluded that the applicant was entitled to an indemnity in respect of the liquidator’s remuneration, work-in-progress, and disbursements.

In conclusion, the court granted the applicant judgment in the sum of $805,925.11, finding that the expenses claimed were reasonably incurred. The court also noted that it would hear the parties regarding the costs of this action. The liquidator’s fees and disbursements, as well as the work-in-progress, were detailed in the provided spreadsheets and invoices, all of which were substantiated and approved by the creditors. The respondent’s submissions did not provide a valid basis to challenge the reasonableness of the claimed expenses.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

On 18 June 2021, default judgment was entered in this action in favour of the applicant. The applicant now seeks to have its damages assessed.Background Until the applicant was wound up by the Court and a liquidator appointed, the respondent, Ms Christi, was its sole director and shareholder. The applicant was the trustee of the Logos Trust, of which Ms Christi was the sole beneficiary. The applicant had never traded and had never held property in its own right. It has only ever acted in its capacity as trustee of the Logos Trust. In February 2006, the applicant became the registered proprietor of a property at Aldgate. About a week later, it also became the registered proprietor of a property at Blackwood. In 2014, the applicant transferred the Aldgate property to Ms Christi by way of a deed of gift. It seems that Ms Christi lived jointly between the Aldgate property and the Blackwood property.The Blackwood property The Blackwood property is built on a steep hill. In 1991, an excavation was undertaken at its rear, to instal a tennis court. From about 1992, the land suffered a number of landslips, and over time, significant damage was caused to the Blackwood property, an adjoining property, and to infrastructure belonging to SA Water. The adjoining property was situated further up the hill, and the landslips caused the edge of the excavation to move closer to the boundary of the adjoining property. In 2011, the local council served an emergency order on the applicant, to carry out remediation works to prevent any further landslips or other risk. The applicant appealed the work order in the Environmental, Resources and Development Court; the Court ultimately upheld the order. The applicant did not carry out the required work. In 2013, the owners of the adjoining property issued proceedings against the applicant and Ms Christi, seeking orders to compel them to carry out the required work. Without going into the somewhat tortuous path that that litigation took, suffice to say that the applicant was unsuccessful at trial and a significant costs order was made against it.[1] When the applicant did not pay the amount specified in the allocatur, the judgment creditor served, first, a statutory demand and then an application to have the applicant would up. The applicant was wound up in insolvency on 6 December 2016. At the time that the winding up order was made, the only asset of the applicant was the Blackwood property. [1] The course of the litigation is set out in the judgment of Slattery DCJ in Blackburn v Logos Research Institute Pty Ltd [2015] SADC 175. The trust deed which established the Logos Trust provided that, in the event that the applicant was wound up in insolvency, it became disqualified from acting as trustee of the trust. As a result, once the liquidator was appointed to the applicant, the trust was without a trustee. The effect of this was that the liquidator did not have the power to deal with the Blackwood property. The liquidator applied to the Supreme Court and on 7 November 2017, he was appointed Receiver and Manager of the Blackwood property. The liquidator then took steps to have the work required by the Emergency Order carried out.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

The applicant is entitled to an indemnity in respect of the liquidator’s remuneration, work-in-progress and disbursements.Conclusion I am satisfied that the expenses in the sum of $805,925.11, in respect of which the applicant seeks an indemnity were reasonably incurred. The applicant is entitled to judgment in the sum of $805,925.11. I will hear the parties in respect of the costs of this action.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The liquidator incurred legal costs in respect of the liquidation. I note that, in the tender bundle, behind tab 42, are two sets of invoices from the liquidator’s lawyers, one in the sum of $83,142.50 (invoice 88856) and the second in the sum of $12,701.50 (invoice 89888). Behind tab 43, are two invoices from Mr Morcombe QC of counsel, the first dated 20 November 2017 in the sum of $12,210 and the second dated 1 February 2019, for an additional $2145. Of these fees, I note that the applicant only seeks an indemnity in the sum of $12,701.50.Remuneration and work-in-progress of the liquidator, both generally and in respect of this action Exhibited to FDN 60 are two spreadsheets which detail the work-in-progress for the liquidator and his staff from 6 December 2016 to 30 April 2021. The total amount comes to $570,401.30. The creditors of the applicants have approved the fees of the liquidator in the sum of $517,811.24. I have examined the minutes of the creditors’ meetings at which these fees were approved. They are behind tabs 18, 19 and 20 of the tender book. Disbursements The applicant seeks the sum of $5,045.11 in respect of the disbursements incurred by the liquidator in the course of his work. In total, the applicant, as at the date of affirming FDN 60 (16 July 2021) sought default judgment in the sum of $805,925.11. The applicant relied on the case of Edgar & Anor v Ron Kingham Real Estate Pty Ltd,[6] where the Court dealt with the meaning of the terms “properly incurred”. McPherson JA said:In this context, the expression ‘‘properly incurred’’ (or, as s. 72 expresses it, ‘‘reasonably’’ incurred) means ‘‘not improperly incurred’’: see Re Beddoe [1893] 1 Ch. 35 547, 558.[7][6] [1999] 2 Qd R 439.[7] Ibid, 442. Mr Stratton-Smith submitted that it would be sufficient for me to find that there is nothing improper in the costs incurred by the applicant. The costs and fees incurred have been properly accounted for and with the fees substantiated by individual time entries for each person who worked on the matter. He submitted that the creditors approval of the liquidator’s remuneration was a factor that should weigh in favour of my acceptance of the reasonableness of the fees incurred. Ms Christi’s position Ms Christi filed three volumes of material which, by the heading, purport to relate to the assessment of relief. The material consists of emails to a number of people including lawyers in respect of her involvement with the justice system. It also includes newspaper articles, excerpts from judgments, and what appears to be copies of correspondence between Ms Christi’s lawyers and counsel in the District Court action. Some of the material is reproduced multiple times. The material is difficult to understand, and it is even more difficult to determine its relevance in respect of quantum. It appears to deal with the merits of the District Court action, the cause of the land slips to the Blackwood property, and the actions of the applicant’s lawyers in respect of that. It appears to suggest that there is a conspiracy within the legal profession to prevent her from receiving justice in this matter. It appears to take issue with many of the interlocutory orders made in the course of this matter, without seeking to appeal any of them.