Litili and Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs

Link copied
Case Copied 43 min read

DECISION AND REASONS FOR DECISION [2001] AATA 55

ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS TRIBUNAL      )

)          No  N2000/777

GENERAL ADMINISTRATIVE  DIVISION       )          
           Re      TAANIELA FIFITA LITILI
  Applicant
           And    MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION AND MULTICULTURAL AFFAIRS          
  Respondent

DECISION

Tribunal       Dr D. Chappell, Deputy President           

Date1 February 2001

PlaceSydney

Decision      The decision under review is affirmed.   
  (Sgd Dr D Chappell)
  .............................................
  Deputy President
CATCHWORDS

IMMIGRATION & CITIZENSHIP – deportation – review of deportation order – applicant Tongan national living in Australia – applicant granted permanent residence – conviction for sexual offences committed against applicant's stepdaughter – seriousness and nature of the crime – risk of recidivism – protection of the Australian community – expectation of Australian community that safety of more vulnerable members of society, like children and young people, should be protected – hardship to the applicant – hardship to the applicant's wife – grounds of hardship not sufficient to outweigh considerations of protecting the Australian community.

Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 – s 37
Migration Act 1958 – ss 200, 201, 500(1)(a)

Afoa v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs [1999] AATA 82
Bustescu v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs [2000] FCA 698
Re Collins & Minister for Immigration, Local Government and Ethnic Affairs (1992) 25 ALD 527
Deng v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs [1999] AATA 386
Lau v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs [2000] FCA 698
Maiorana v Minister for Immigration, Local Government and Ethnic Affairs (1993) 42 FCR 119
Re McCutcheon & Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs (1979) 2 ALD 496
Minister for Ethnic Affairs v Daniele (1981) 61 FLR 354
Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs v Gungor (1982) 63 FLR 441
Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs v SRT (1999) 91 FCR 234
Paul William Gunner v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs (1997) 50 ALD 330
Rokobatini v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs (1999) FCA 1238
Waikato v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs (1999) AATA 36

REASONS FOR DECISION

1 February 2001      Dr D. Chappell, Deputy President   

BACKGROUND
Application

  1. Mr Taaniela Fifita Litili (the applicant) seeks review of a decision of a delegate of the Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs (the Minister), made pursuant to s200 of the Migration Act 1958 (the Act), to deport him from Australia. The Tribunal's jurisdiction to review that decision is granted by s500(1)(a) of the Act.

  2. Mr Ray Turner, a solicitor, represented Mr Litili at the hearing.  Mr Litili also appeared in person and gave personal testimony to the Tribunal.  The following witnesses also testified on his behalf:

    Ms Glynn Jeanette Litili
    Ms Christine Rogers

  3. Mr Ashley Mullins, a solicitor, represented the respondent at the hearing.  The following witness testified on behalf of the respondent:

    Ms Lynette Jean Vidler

  4. The Tribunal had before it documents filed for the purposes of s37 of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (T documents). The following exhibits were also received into evidence on behalf of the applicant and respondent:
    Exhibit No.     Description    Date   
    A1      Pre-release report, Department…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Litili and Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affair... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2001] AATA 55
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The matter of Litili and Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs involved a deportation review where the applicant, a Tongan national granted permanent residence in Australia, faced deportation due to convictions for sexual offences against his stepdaughter. The Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT) was tasked with deciding whether the applicant should be deported considering the seriousness of the crime, the risk of recidivism, and the hardship to the applicant and his family.

The AAT had to weigh the gravity of the sexual offences committed against a child against the potential risk of the applicant re-offending. Additionally, the AAT considered the significant hardship that deportation would cause to the applicant and his wife, including the impact on their social and familial ties in Australia. The AAT was also required to assess whether the protection of the Australian community from further criminal behaviour by the applicant outweighed the hardship to his family.

The AAT determined that despite the significant hardship deportation would cause to the applicant and his wife, the seriousness and nature of the sexual offences against a child warranted deportation. The AAT found that the risk of the applicant re-offending, although low, was still present due to his lack of participation in treatment programs. The AAT concluded that the expectation of the Australian community to protect vulnerable members, such as children, from such abhorrent crimes justified deportation. Therefore, the AAT affirmed the decision to deport the applicant.

In conclusion, the AAT's decision underscores the importance of protecting the community from the potential threat posed by individuals convicted of serious crimes, even in the face of significant personal hardship for the deportee and their family.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Given the importance and relevance of the three factors which have just been listed, attention is now turned to the evidence before the Tribunal in relation to each. Following this review the evidence is examined concerning certain other factors which the Policy Direction indicates require consideration by the Tribunal.EVIDENCESeriousness and Nature of the Crime The sole and quite detailed description of the circumstances surrounding the commission of both the deportable offences and other offences of which Mr Litili was convicted is to be found in the sentencing remarks made on 8 September 1994 by Urquhart J. Judge Urquhart noted that at the commencement of his trial before a jury on 8 August 1994 Mr Litili was arraigned upon an indictment containing 13 counts. Mr Litili pleaded not guilty to each count and the jury, when it reached its verdict on 1 September 1994, found him to be guilty on counts 1-5, but not guilty on counts 6-13 inclusive (T19: 116). It has already been mentioned above that the five counts which did result in a conviction involved offences which Urquhart J determined had been committed between 1983 and 1986 (see paragraph 9 above). Judge Urquhart said that he made this finding because:… there was evidence before the jury given by the complainant of occasions that within that period other than those charged in which 'similar experiences occurred'. The complainant's evidence in this regard was that those similar experiences occurred about ten times and that on such occasions the prisoner would always be in his bedroom, that he would call her into his bedroom, pull her down onto the bed and undress her, that he would put himself between her legs, push his penis into her vagina, move up and down pulling his penis in and out, that he would breathe heavier, his muscles would begin to jerk, he would make grunting noises and then he would pull his penis out and he would then ejaculate onto the bed, give her back her clothes and she would then leave the room. I refer to that evidence at this stage for the following reasons. Firstly, although only those five offences contained in counts 1 to 5 are the offences as to which the prisoner is to appear is to receive sentence. Nevertheless, those offences cannot be seen either in isolation one from the other four nor in isolation from the context to which that evidence of the complainant which I have mentioned gives rise. I am satisfied beyond reasonable doubt that that is a proper context although I expressly note that the prisoner is not before the court today to be sentenced in respect of a general course of conduct but for the specific five offences as to which he has been guilty. It is, nevertheless, proper that the background of conduct in which the specific offences occurred to be taken into account.(T19: 116-117) Judge Urquhart said that at the time of the commission of the offences contained in the first two counts the complainant, Mr Litili's stepdaughter was 8 years of age. Judge Urquhart then went on to describe the offences contained in the first two counts in the following way:In respect of the offence charged in count 1 the complainant and her brother were at the time in the bedroom of their mother and their stepfather. The stepfather is the prisoner. Whilst what the complainant described as 'mucking around' and 'tickling my stepfather' took place, the complainant's brother was called out of the room by her mother and left, leaving the complainant alone with the prisoner. The prisoner then began to rub the bottom of her legs and moved his hand up putting his hand inside the complainant's jeans and underclothing and then began to rub her vagina. The complainant's mother then called her out of the bedroom and the complainant left. The complainant in the course of her evidence said that she was confused and scared and did not know what had happened and this is not surprising given her age at the time.… It was not very long after the commission of that offence, indeed, only about a week later that the offence charged in the second count occurred. On that occasion only the complainant and the prisoner were at the home. The complainant was in the lounge room, the prisoner was in his bedroom. The prisoner called the complainant to the bedroom for the purpose of bringing him a cup of coffee. The complainant made a cup of coffee, took it to the bedroom, placed it on the floor next to the bed and the prisoner pulled her arm and pulled her down. He began to rub her on the top of her breasts, pushed her shirt up, pulled her underpants down, took his tracksuit pants and his underpants off and then pushed himself in between her legs. The complainant felt him push his penis into her vagina and felt him moving, sort of up and down, as she described it. After withdrawing his penis from her vagina the complainant felt a wetness around her legs. The prisoner gave the complainant her underpants, and she put them on and left the room.(T19: 117-119)

Decision

Reasons for decision

Having regard to the developmental stage at which the Static 99 test remains, as well as to the obvious dangers and unfairness associated with a test which purports to rely upon unproven charges of sexual offending like those alleged against Mr Litili, the Tribunal places no weight on the Static 99 test results contained in Ms Vidler's report, and also elaborated upon in her personal testimony. Nonetheless, the Tribunal is quite satisfied from the evidence which has been reviewed, and in particular that presented to the Parole Board in July 2000, that a risk does remain of Mr Litili re-offending. This risk may be judged to be low but it is a real risk and one which is compounded by Mr Litili's continuing perception of his innocence and his consequent lack of participation in any treatment program to address his criminal offending.CONCLUSION Having given very careful consideration to all of the evidence before it the Tribunal reaches the conclusion that given the gravity of Mr Litili's pattern of offending, the risk which has been identified of him committing further offences of this type is not one which should be accepted by the Australian community. That community has a legitimate expectation that the safety of the more vulnerable members of our society, like children and young people, should be protected against the actions of non-citizens like Mr Litili. The offences of which Mr Litili stands convicted are repugnant and many members of the community would undoubtedly describe them as being abhorrent. The Tribunal does not find it necessary, however, to attach such a label to Mr Litili's offending since it believes that on risk factors alone there are sufficient grounds for expelling Mr Litili from Australia. The Tribunal acknowledges that by deporting Mr Litili both he and his wife will suffer significant hardship. For Mrs Litili, in particular, who has indicated that she would go to Tonga with her husband the transition to a new and unfamiliar environment will be a painful experience. While these are matters to which significant weight must be attached they are not sufficient by themselves to outweigh the responsibility which the Tribunal has to the Australian community to protect it from the possibility of further criminal behaviour by Mr Litili. The decision under review is affirmed.I certify that the 68 preceding paragraphs are a true copy of the reasons for the decision herein of Dr D. Chappell, Deputy PresidentSigned: ..................................................................................... AssociateDate/s of Hearing 30-31 August & 19 December 2000Date of Decision 1 February 2001Solicitor for the Applicant Mr Ray Turner (Tzovaras Legal) Solicitor for the Respondent Mr Ashley Mullins(Blake Dawson Waldron Lawyers)

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Mention has already been made of Mrs Litili's evidence about the hardship she said she would experience. In addition to her personal testimony, and statements made by her to the respondent's officials (see T19: 151-153) evidence was also provided to the Tribunal from a number of persons who stated that they knew both Mr and Mrs Litili and that Mr Litili's deportation would cause both the family and friends of the family significant hardship and loss (see T15: 33-47, 61-64). One of the persons involved in writing these statements of support on behalf of the applicant, Ms Christine Rogers, gave personal testimony to the Tribunal (transcript 30 August 2000: 58-64; T15: 33). Ms Rogers said that she was a cousin of Mrs Litili and that was how she knew Mr Litili. She was aware that he had been convicted of certain sexual offences involving children. She confirmed that she would have no hesitation entrusting the care of her own children to Mr Litili. She had been a young girl herself when she first met him and he had never tried to take advantage of her. Ms Rogers said that she had never had an opportunity to discuss the offences with Mr Litili. She had, however, discussed them with Mrs Litili and it was her belief that the allegations against Mr Litili were not true and that the charges had been fabricated by Mr Litili's stepdaughter.CONSIDERATIONPolicy and Submissions The various matters which require consideration by the Tribunal in reaching a correct and preferable decision about a deportation case are in general well defined and understood. The relevant guidelines contained in the Policy Direction, which have been set out above, make it clear that most weight should be given to the protection of Australian society, while less weight should be given to the views of the offender and that person's family and associates and any hardship to them arising from a deportation decision. The decision to deport a person from Australia arises from the responsibility to protect the community from the possibility of further criminal behaviour by a person like Mr Litili, or to expel from this country a non-citizen who has seriously abused the privilege of residence accorded to them by the community. It is not, however, the purpose of deportation to impose further punishment upon a person like Mr Litili who has already served a minimum term of six years in prison for his various sexual offences. Reference has been made earlier to the provisions of paragraph 8(b) of the Policy Direction which requires the Tribunal to consider, in the context of the expectations of the community, that non-citizens who are convicted of crimes that are abhorrent to the community will be removed from this country. Paragraph 15 of the Policy Direction also states the following:15. It is the Government's view that the Australian community trusts non-citizen residents to obey Australian laws. Where a potential deportee has betrayed this trust and been convicted of offences in Australia, it may be appropriate to deport such a person even if there is no serious likelihood that the person is a continuing threat, or will be a future threat, to the community. Deportation will be appropriate simply because the nature of the offence or offences is such that the Australian community would expect that the person would be deported. Weight should be given to this factor in proportion to the decision maker's understanding of the community's attitude to the potential deportee's offences. Decision makers should have due regard to the Government's view in this respect.(Policy Direction: paragraph 15)