IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA)
1
NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY) No. G44 of
1978
GENERAL DIVISION
BETWEEN:
TRADE PRACTICES COMMISSION
Plarntiff
T .N .T. MANAGEMENT PTY. LIMITED
First Defendant
BRAMBLES HOLDINGS LIMITED
Second Defendant
MAYNE NICKLESS LIMITED
Third Defendant
YOUNGS TRANSPORT PTY. LIMITED
Fourth Defendant
ANSETT TRANSPORT INDUSTRIES
(OPERATIONS) PTY. LIMITED
Fifth Defendant
EXPRESS FREIGHT PTY. LIMITED
S i x t h
Defendant
ASSOCIATED STEAMSHIPS PTY.
LIMITED
Seventh Defendant
IPEC HOLDINGS LIMITED
Eighth Defendant
INTERSTATE PARCEL EXPRESS
CO.
PTY. LIMITED
Ninth Defendant
CORAM:
Bowen C . J .
20 October 1981.
- 2 -
REASONS FOR JUDGMENT
| BOWEN C . J . | On 31 August 1981 a notice | of | motion | was | f i l e d by |
| the | f irst , | f i f t h and | seventh defendants in proceedings | No. | G44 |
| of | 1978 | s e e k i n g | o r d e r s | p u r s u a n t | t o | s.157 | o f | t h e | T r a d e |
| P rac t i ces A c t 1974 | t h a t | the | Trade | Practices | Commission | ( t h e |
| Commission) | f u r n i s h | t r u e | c o p i e s | o f | c e r t a i n | documents. | The |
| documents | i n | ques t ion | were | l i s ted | under | headings | (ii) and |
| (iil) in | Exh ib i t | Y | t o | an | a f f ldav i t | o f | Wynn | P a t r i c i a | Hannon |
| sworn | on | 11 June 1981 and f i l e d i n the proceedings. |
When the matter first came before m e I was asked t o r u l e
| on those documents w l t h which Miss | Hannon | w a s assoc la ted . |
| Evidence | was | g iven d i r ec t ed t o p rov ing t ha t | she | was | an | o f f i c e r |
| of the Commission and t h a t she had | been | responsible | for |
| b r i n g l n g | the | p a r t i c u l a r | d o c u m e n t s | i n t o | e x i s t e n c e . | The |
| documents, | which | were | not | in | evidence, | w e r e handed | t o m e . | I |
| was | asked t o r u l e on | two | ques t ions : | f i r s t , | whether | the |
| documents | in quest ion | had | been | "prepared | by | an | officer | of | the |
| Commission", | and, | secondly, | whether | each | document | "tended | t o |
| establlsh | the | case" | of | any | of | the | three | defendants. | My |
| decislon | given | on | 9 | October | 1981 w a s t ha t | each | of | t h e |
| documents | i n quest ion had been prepared by | Miss | Hannon | who | w a s |
| an… |
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Trade Practices Commission v T.N.T. Management Pty Ltd and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [1981] FCA 222
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court found that the documents had indeed been prepared by officers of the TPC. However, the court held that none of the documents tended to establish the case of any of the defendants, except for a statement by Mr. W. Levitt, which contained both material supporting the plaintiff's case and material that might cut down the plaintiff's case. Because this statement tended to establish the defendants' case, the court ordered that the TPC must furnish a copy of it to each of the three defendants.
The Federal Court of Australia ordered that the Trade Practices Commission furnish a copy of the statement of Mr. W. Levitt to each of the three defendants.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi