Lion-Beer, Spirits & Wine Pty Ltd v Michael Harvey

Link copied
Case Copied 25 min read

TRADE MARKS ACT 1995



DECISION OF A DELEGATE OF THE REGISTRAR OF TRADE MARKS WITH REASONS

Re:Opposition by Lion-Beer Wine and Spirits Pty Limited to registration of trade mark application 1312966(32) - TOSSERS EXTRA DRY - filed in the name of Michael Harvey.

Delegate: Alison Windsor
Representation: Opponent – Ed Heerey of Counsel instructed by Sarah Murray of King & Wood Mallesons
Applicant – Susan Gatford of Counsel instructed by Noelene Treloar of McPherson+Kelley Lawyers
Decision: 2013 ATMO 06
Section 52 opposition: grounds under ss 44, 60 and 42(b) pursued – no grounds established – application to proceed to registration.

Background

  1. The matter for determination in this instance is an opposition by Lion-Beer Wine & Spirits Pty Limited (formerly known as Lion Nathan Australia Pty Limited) (‘the Opponent’) to registration of trade mark application 1312966 filed in the name of Michael Harvey (‘the Applicant’).  The application was filed on 3 August 2009 for the following goods in class 32 of the Nice Classification:

    Alcohol free beer; alcoholic beers; beer; beer wort; bitter beer; black beer; dark beer; de-alcoholised beer; extracts of hops for making beer; fruit beers; ginger beer; malt beer; malt-containing beverages (beers); malt-containing beverages (non-alcoholic, except beers); non-alcoholic beers; pilsner beer; root beer; ale; fruit ale; ginger ale; lager; stout; aerated beverages (non-alcoholic); alcohol free beverages; beverages containing not more than 1.15% (by volume) of alcohol; edible essences for making beverages; electrolyte replacement beverages for general and sports purposes; essences for making beverages; fruit syrup (beverages or for making beverages); grain based non-alcoholic beverages; hop concentrates for use in the preparation of beverages; hop essences for use in the preparation of beverages; hop extracts for use in the preparation of beverages; low alcohol beverages containing not more than 1.15% (by volume) of alcohol; malt based preparations for making beverages; mineral water (beverages); non-alcoholic barley based beverages; non-alcoholic beverages; spring water (beverages), other than for medical purposes; tonic water (non-medicated beverages); waters (beverages); alcohol free cider; cider (non-alcoholic); none of the foregoing being fruit or vegetable juices (‘the Goods’).

  2. The trade mark applied for is the words ‘Tossers Extra Dry’ (‘the Trade Mark’) in plain upper and lower case as shown here. 

  3. It was examined as required by section 31 of the Trade Marks Act 1995 (‘the Act’) and after some minor amendments to the goods specification to overcome a ground for rejection raised under the provisions of section 44,[1] it was accepted for possible registration.  It was advertised as such in the Australian Official Journal of Trade Marks on 3 December 2009.

    [1] The relevant earlier dated trade mark is 973939 for the trade mark TOSSERS SALAD BAR which is registered for a range of goods and services in classes 29 and 43.

  4. On 2 March 2010 the Opponent filed a Notice of Opposition (‘the Notice’) which listed nine grounds of opposition.  The grounds are those relevant to sections 42, 43, 44, 58, 59. 60, 62(a), 62(b) and 62A. 

  5. Evidence in support, in answer and in reply as…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Lion-Beer, Spirits & Wine Pty Ltd v Michael Harvey and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2013] ATMO 6
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This decision concerns an opposition by Lion-Beer, Spirits & Wine Pty Ltd (the Opponent) to an application by Michael Harvey (the Applicant) for the trade mark TOOHEYS EXTRA DRY. The Opponent pursued grounds of opposition under sections 42, 44, and 60 of the relevant legislation, with the onus on the Opponent to establish at least one ground on the balance of probabilities as at the filing date of the Applicant's trade mark application, 3 August 2009.

The court was required to determine whether the Opponent had established any of the pursued grounds of opposition. Specifically, the court considered the Opponent's reliance on its prior Australian trade mark registration for TOOHEYS EXTRA DRY, which covered goods in classes 9, 25, 28, 32, and 41. The Opponent argued that its registered goods in class 32, which included beers and other beverages, were the same as or similar to the goods specified in the Applicant's application. The central issue was therefore the similarity of the trade marks and whether the Applicant's use of the TOOHEYS EXTRA DRY mark would be likely to deceive or cause confusion, or otherwise be contrary to the Trade Practices Act or Fair Trading Act.

The Hearing Officer found that the Opponent possessed a reputation in its TOOHEYS trade mark. However, the Hearing Officer concluded that it was unlikely that the Applicant's use of the TOOHEYS EXTRA DRY trade mark would deceive or cause confusion, nor was there any indication that the Applicant sought to profit from the Opponent's reputation. Consequently, the Hearing Officer found that the Opponent had not established the section 42(b) ground of opposition, nor any other pursued ground.

The application for the trade mark TOOHEYS EXTRA DRY was permitted to proceed to registration. The Opponent was ordered to pay the Applicant's costs, to be assessed according to the official scale.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

I note here that the hearing canvassed two oppositions – the one which I have described thus far as well as the opposition by Mr Harvey to the Opponent’s application 1248610 for the trade mark EXTRA DRY. While much of the evidence for both oppositions is the same, because the matters to be considered in each opposition are quite different, I have chosen to deal with them in two separate decisions which will issue simultaneously. Evidence provided The evidence filed and served for the opposition consists of the following Statutory Declarations:Evidence in support Sarah Margaret Elliot Murray, made 20 May 2010 with Exhibits SMEM-1 to SMEM-5. (‘Murray 1’). Four of these Exhibits contain copies of Statutory Declarations filed in support of other applications which are owned by companies related to the Opponent. The declarations and their exhibits are as follows: SMEM-2 – Josh Gaudry, made 15 December 2009, with Exhibits JG-1 to JG-13 and JG-16 SMEM-3 – Andrew Charles Disley, made 22 April 2010 with Exhibit AD-1 SMEM-4 - Derek George Orford, made 23 October 2009 (‘Orford 1’) SMEM-5 – Margaret Zabel , made 8 January 2009 with Exhibits MZ-1 to MZ-50. Exhibits MZ-21, 24, 31 and 40 have been removed from the declaration and are not relied upon. Evidence in Answer Denis Coldebella, made 17 March 2011 Michael Harvey, made 20 April 2011 with Exhibits MH-1 to MH-8 Warren Goodwin Chandler, made 27 April 2011 with Exhibits WGC-1 to WGC-3 Evidence in Reply Derek George Orford, made 24 August 2011 (‘Orford 2’)Opponent’s further evidence Sarah Margaret Elliot Murray made 16 July 2012 with Exhibit SMEM-1 (‘Murray 2’), which consists of the following Statutory Declaration:o Ashleigh David John Bellotti, made 16 April 2012Applicant’s response to further evidence Michael Harvey, made 17 September 2012 with Exhibits MH 1 to MH 4 (‘Harvey 3’). Exhibit MH 1 consists of the following Statutory Declaration:o Adam Barkley, made 17 September 2012Grounds pursued and onus While the Notice nominated nine grounds of opposition, at the hearing only the grounds under sections 42, 44 and 60 were pursued. I regard the remainder of the grounds set out in the Notice as having been abandoned. The onus is on the Opponent to establish at least one of the grounds it has pursued, on the balance of probabilities.[3] The date at which the ground of opposition must be established is the date of filing of the Opposed trade mark (‘the relevant date’), in this case 3 August 2009.[4] [3] See, for example, Pfizer Products Inc v Karam [2006] FCA 1663; 237 ALR 787; (2006) 70 IPR 599; [2006] AIPC 92-146 per Gyles J at [6] to [26]; Chocolaterie Guylian N.V. v Registrar of Trade Marks [2009] FCA 891; (2009) 82 IPR 13; [2009] AIPC 92-355 per Sundberg J at [22] to [26]; NV Sumatra Tobacco Trading Company v British American Tobacco Services Limited [2011] FCA 1051; (2011) 283 ALR 743 per Greenwood J at [16] to [32]; and Fry Consulting Pty Ltd v Sports Warehouse Inc (No 2) (2012) 94 IPR 551 per Dodds-Streeton J at [13].[4] Southern Cross Refrigerating v Toowoomba Foundry Pty Ltd (1953) 91 CLR 592 at 595.Discussion and Reasons

Decision

Reasons for decision

I have found that the Opponent has a reputation in its trade mark Tooheys, but I have also found that it is most unlikely that the Applicant’s use of the Trade Mark would deceive or cause confusion. As a result I find that there is nothing in the Trade Mark which directs people towards a wrong choice or causes them to believe that the Opponent is any way involved in the manufacture of the Applicant’s goods. Similarly, I can find nothing in the Applicant’s conduct which points to any attempt to profit from the Opponent’s reputation. I am satisfied that the Applicant’s use of the Trade Mark would not be contrary to either the TPA or the FTA. The Opponent has not established the section 42(b) ground of opposition.Decision The Opponent has not met the onus upon it to establish a ground of opposition. Application 1312966 may proceed to registration after one month from the date of this decision. If the Registrar has been served with a notice of appeal before that time, I direct that registration shall not occur until either the appeal is withdrawn or a court so orders. Costs The Applicant has requested its costs. It is usual for costs to follow the event, and I see no reason to depart from that principle here. I award costs, according to the official scale set out in Schedule 8 of the Trade Marks Regulations 1995, against the unsuccessful trade mark opponent, Lion-Beer Wine & Spirits Pty Limited.Alison WindsorHearing OfficerTrade Marks and Designs Hearings22 January 2013

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Opponent specified that it was relying on one of its own prior Australian trade mark registrations, details of which appear below:Registration number: 1169672Registration date: 2 April 2007Goods/Services: Class 9: Apparatus for recording, transmission or reproduction of sound or images; recording discs; computers; apparatus for data storage; hard drives; audio tapes, audio-video tapes, audio video cassettes, audio video discs; CD-ROMs; digital versatile discs; headphones; audio speakers; speakers for computers; personal stereo speaker apparatus; digital audio and video devices; audio cassette recorders and players, video cassette recorders and players, compact disc players, digital versatile disc recorders and players, digital audio tape recorders and players; radios; cameras; video cameras; bags and cases adapted or shaped to contain cameras and/or video cameras; mobile telephones; parts and accessories for mobile telephones; mobile telephone covers; mobile telephone cases; portable digital electronic devices and software related thereto; handheld digital electronic devices and software related thereto; MP3 players; hand held computers, personal digital assistants, electronic organizers, electronic notepads; magnetic data carriers; telephones, computer gaming machines, videophones; electronic handheld devices for the wireless receipt and/or transmission of data, particularly messages, and devices that enable the user to keep track of or manage personal information; bags and cases adapted or shaped to contain MP3 players, hand held computers, personal digital assistants, electronic organizers and electronic notepadsClass 25:Clothing, footwear and headgearClass 28:Games, playthings and sporting articles (not included in other classes) including, but not limited to; amusement machines, balls, bats, cricket apparatus, fishing tackle, fishing rods, footballs, golf gloves, golf clubs, paintball equipment, sailboards, scooters, skateboards, body boards, surf boards, surf skis, skiing apparatus, table tennis equipment and water-skisClass 32: Beers; mineral and aerated waters and other non-alcoholic drinks; fruit drinks and fruit juices; syrups and other preparations for making beveragesClass 41: Entertainment; sporting, recreational and cultural activities and events including organising and conducting of sporting events, competitions, musical and theatrical productionsTrade Mark: TOOHEYS EXTRA DRY The Opponent pointed out that the goods covered in its specified registration include all beers, all mineral and aerated waters and other non-alcoholic drinks. This, it said, encompasses all of the goods specified in Mr Harvey’s application. I note that the Opponent’s registered goods in class 32 also include syrups and other preparations for making beverages. I am satisfied that the Opponent’s registered goods in class 32 are the same as and similar to those which the Applicant is claiming. It is clear that the registration the Opponent has chosen to rely upon has an earlier priority date to that of the Trade Mark. The remaining matter for determination is the similarity of the trade marks.