Lindsay v Health Care Complaints Commission

Link copied
Case Copied 66 min read
CITATION:

Lindsay v Health Care Complaints Commission [2005] NSWCA 356

HEARING DATE(S):

6 September 2005

 
JUDGMENT DATE: 


8 November 2005

JUDGMENT OF:

Mason P at 1; Hodgson JA at 2; Hunt AJA at 4

DECISION:

1. The appeal is allowed in part; 2. The appeal against the Medical Tribunal’s decision refusing to grant a stay of proceedings is dismissed; 3. The appeal against the Tribunal’s decision upholding the complaints against the appellant in relation to his medical records concerning Patients A and B is dismissed; 4. The appeal against the Tribunal’s characterisation of the appellant’s failure to provide Patient A with a copy of his pathology results as unsatisfactory professional conduct is upheld, and the complaint against the appellant in relation to his conduct concerning Patient A is to that extent dismissed; 5. The Tribunal’s decision dismissing the complaint against the appellant in relation to his conduct otherwise than in relation to his medical records concerning Patient B is confirmed; 6. The appeal against the Tribunal’s finding that the appellant be severely reprimanded in relation to his medical records concerning Patients A and B is dismissed; 7. The following audit condition on the appellant’s registration as a medical practitioner is imposed pursuant to s 61(1)(c) of the Medical Practice Act 1992 in substitution for that imposed by the Tribunal:; Dr Lindsay is to continue to submit to a random audit of his medical records by the person or persons already nominated by the New South Wales Medical Board to monitor his compliance with Schedule 2 of the Medical Practice Regulation 2003 as required by the Board. Dr Lindsay is to continue to authorise the said person or persons to prepare for the Board a report of his/her findings. Dr Lindsay is to meet all costs associated with the audit programme; 8. The following supervision condition on the appellant’s registration as a medical practitioner is imposed pursuant to s 61(1)(c) in substitution for that imposed by the Tribunal:; Dr Lindsay is to accept supervision by the person already nominated by the Medical Board to provide support and to monitor Dr Lindsay’s keeping of medical records for his patients. The supervisor is to provide supervision to the third level nominated in the Board’s policy PCH 7.1 dated August 2002. The costs of such supervision and reporting to the Board at least annually is to be borne by Dr Lindsay. It is an element of this condition that Dr Lindsay cooperate fully with his supervisor; 9. The appeal against the costs order made by the Tribunal is upheld. The Commission is ordered to pay 75% of the appellant’s costs in the Tribunal, such costs to include all the costs thrown away as a result of the various amendments made to the complaints by the Commission; 10. The appellant is ordered to pay 60% of the Commission’s costs of the appeal.

CATCHWORDS:

Medical Tribunal - complaint of unsatisfactory professional conduct - material showing that conduct was part of a pattern and not isolated -…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Lindsay v Health Care Complaints Commission and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2005] NSWCA 356
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This case concerned an appeal by Dr Lindsay to the Supreme Court of New South Wales against decisions made by the Medical Tribunal. The dispute arose from complaints of unsatisfactory professional conduct made against Dr Lindsay by the Health Care Complaints Commission, relating to his professional conduct concerning several patients, particularly in relation to his medical records and the provision of pathology results. Dr Lindsay sought to challenge the Tribunal's findings, its characterisation of his conduct, and the orders made, as well as the Tribunal's refusal to stay proceedings.

The Supreme Court was required to determine several legal issues. These included whether the Medical Tribunal erred in law by considering conduct not the subject of a complaint when characterising Dr Lindsay's conduct as unsatisfactory professional conduct. The Court also had to consider the jurisdiction and approach of both the Tribunal and the Supreme Court in relation to staying proceedings before the Tribunal on the grounds of abuse of process. Furthermore, the Court needed to determine the appropriate orders to be made on appeal, including whether to uphold or overturn the Tribunal's findings and the nature of any conditions to be imposed on Dr Lindsay's registration.

The Court reasoned that while material showing a pattern of conduct could be relevant to the orders made by the Tribunal, it was an error of law for the Tribunal to take into account conduct not forming part of the complaint when characterising the conduct that was the subject of the complaint as unsatisfactory professional conduct. The Court affirmed that the Supreme Court had broad powers on appeal to make such order as it thought fit when an error of law was established, but cautioned against differing from a specialist tribunal on the characterisation of conduct without good reason. The Court dismissed the appeal against the refusal to stay proceedings, finding no abuse of process. However, it upheld the appeal in part concerning the characterisation of Dr Lindsay's failure to provide a patient with pathology results, finding this specific conduct was not unsatisfactory professional conduct. The Court also substituted new audit and supervision conditions for those imposed by the Tribunal and upheld the appeal against the costs order made by the Tribunal.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The appeal is allowed in part; 2. The appeal against the Medical Tribunal’s decision refusing to grant a stay of proceedings is dismissed; 3. The appeal against the Tribunal’s decision upholding the complaints against the appellant in relation to his medical records concerning Patients A and B is dismissed; 4. The appeal against the Tribunal’s characterisation of the appellant’s failure to provide Patient A with a copy of his pathology results as unsatisfactory professional conduct is upheld, and the complaint against the appellant in relation to his conduct concerning Patient A is to that extent dismissed; 5. The Tribunal’s decision dismissing the complaint against the appellant in relation to his conduct otherwise than in relation to his medical records concerning Patient B is confirmed; 6. The appeal against the Tribunal’s finding that the appellant be severely reprimanded in relation to his medical records concerning Patients A and B is dismissed; 7. The following audit condition on the appellant’s registration as a medical practitioner is imposed pursuant to s 61(1)(c) of the Medical Practice Act 1992 in substitution for that imposed by the Tribunal:; Dr Lindsay is to continue to submit to a random audit of his medical records by the person or persons already nominated by the New South Wales Medical Board to monitor his compliance with Schedule 2 of the Medical Practice Regulation 2003 as required by the Board. Dr Lindsay is to continue to authorise the said person or persons to prepare for the Board a report of his/her findings. Dr Lindsay is to meet all costs associated with the audit programme; 8. The following supervision condition on the appellant’s registration as a medical practitioner is imposed pursuant to s 61(1)(c) in substitution for that imposed by the Tribunal:; Dr Lindsay is to accept supervision by the person already nominated by the Medical Board to provide support and to monitor Dr Lindsay’s keeping of medical records for his patients. The supervisor is to provide supervision to the third level nominated in the Board’s policy PCH 7.1 dated August 2002. The costs of such supervision and reporting to the Board at least annually is to be borne by Dr Lindsay. It is an element of this condition that Dr Lindsay cooperate fully with his supervisor; 9. The appeal against the costs order made by the Tribunal is upheld. The Commission is ordered to pay 75% of the appellant’s costs in the Tribunal, such costs to include all the costs thrown away as a result of the various amendments made to the complaints by the Commission; 10. The appellant is ordered to pay 60% of the Commission’s costs of the appeal.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established