Supreme Court
New South Wales
- Amendment notes
Medium Neutral Citation: Lindsay-Owen v HWL Ebsworth Lawyers [2017] NSWSC 1692 Hearing dates: 29 November 2017 Date of orders: 29 November 2017 Decision date: 05 December 2017 Jurisdiction: Common Law Before: Rothman J Decision: (1) Subpoena discharged;
(2) Costs to be costs in the cause.Catchwords: Subpoena – 3rd party subpoena issued by defendants – plaintiffs move to strike out as oppressive – not having adjectival relevance – alleged relevant basis inconsistent with pleaded case –subpoena discharged. Legislation Cited: Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 2005 (NSW) Cases Cited: ICAP Australia Pty Ltd v BGC Partners (Australia) Pty Ltd [2009] NSWCA 307
Malec v JC Hutton Pty Ltd (1990) 169 CLR 638; [1990] HCA 20
One.Tel Ltd (in Liq) - SingTel Optus Pty Ltd v Weston [2010] NSWSC 1491
Portal Software v Bodsworth [2005] NSWSC 1115
Sellars v Adelaide Petroleum NL (1994) 179 CLR 332; [1994] HCA 4
Wran v The ABC [1984] 3 NSWLR 241Category: Procedural and other rulings Parties: Gregory Hamilton Willoughby Lindsay-Owen (First Plaintiff)
Dairycorp Pty Ltd (Second Plaintiff)
HWL Ebsworth Lawyers (First Defendant)
Martin Downing & Ors as listed in Schedule 1 to the Statement of Claim (Second to 108th Defendants)Representation: Counsel:
Solicitors:
P Afshar (Plaintiffs)
C Bannan (Defendants)
Henry Davis York (Plaintiffs)
Gilchrist Connell Legal (Defendants)
File Number(s): 2016/00085879
EX TEMPORE Judgment
-
HIS HONOUR: The Court must deal with an issue associated with the subpoena issued at the request of the defendants in these proceedings on a third party, being the National Australia Bank.
-
Pursuant to the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 2005 (NSW) (“UCPR”), promulgated to overcome the mischief associated with the judgment on standing in Wran v The ABC [1984] 3 NSWLR 241, a party to the substantive proceedings is entitled to move to strike out a subpoena issued by another party in a proceedings against a third person. As a consequence, the plaintiffs have moved to strike out the subpoena issued by the defendants against the third party, the National Australia Bank (“NAB”).
-
The NAB is and at all relevant times was the banker of the plaintiffs, at least in relation to the relevant transactions that are before the Court.
-
It is appropriate that I deal with the some aspects of the Amended Statement of Claim and the proceedings that are substantively before the Court. The plaintiffs were indebted to the NAB for an amount of approximately $21.5 million. They were unable to service that loan.
-
The loan was secured by a mortgage over a significant parcel of land, the value of which seems to be such that it would, without more, meet the indebtedness. I am not absolutely positive of that and of course no expert evidence is before the Court at this stage.
-
In or about 2008, or late 2008, the plaintiffs, as I said, were unable to service the debt. NAB called in the existing debt, and notice of default was served by NAB on the plaintiffs dated…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Lindsay-Owen v HWL Ebsworth Lawyers and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2017] NSWSC 1692
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court considered whether the subpoena was oppressive, having regard to the proportionality principle and the need to balance the rights of the parties. The court noted that the subpoena sought documents that, if relevant, could assist the defendants in defending the plaintiffs' claims. However, the court also considered the potential burden on the third party and the plaintiffs' argument that the subpoena was not adjectivally relevant. The court found that the proposed basis for the subpoena was inconsistent with the pleaded case, which undermined the relevance of the subpoenaed documents.
The court concluded that the subpoena was oppressive, given the inconsistency between the proposed basis and the pleaded case, and the lack of adjectival relevance. The subpoena was therefore discharged. The court emphasised the need for parties to ensure that subpoenas are relevant to the issues in the case and do not impose unnecessary burdens on third parties.
No further orders were made.
Background
Background to the litigation
The plaintiffs submitted that the subpoena did not have adjectival relevance as it sought documents that were not necessary for the fair and just resolution of the proceedings. They argued that the defendants could have obtained the same information through a direct subpoena to the plaintiffs or by subpoenaing their own solicitors, Sparke Helmore. The plaintiffs further argued that the alleged basis for relevance provided by the defendants was inconsistent with the pleaded case, as the documents sought were not relevant to the pleaded causes of action.
This case came before the court as an application by the plaintiffs to strike out a third-party subpoena issued by the defendants. The plaintiffs had previously commenced proceedings against the defendants for professional negligence. In response, the defendants issued a third-party subpoena to the plaintiffs' solicitors, Sparke Helmore, seeking documents and communications. The plaintiffs filed an application to strike out the subpoena, which was heard by the court. Prior to this hearing, there were no significant procedural steps or decisions relevant to this application.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the third-party subpoena issued by the defendants is oppressive and should be struck out.
2. Whether the third-party subpoena has adjectival relevance and should be struck out on that basis.
3. Whether the alleged basis for relevance provided by the defendants is inconsistent with the pleaded case and whether the subpoena should be struck out on that ground.
Held
1. The court concluded that the third-party subpoena issued by the defendants was oppressive and ordered it be struck out.
2. The court held that the third-party subpoena did not have adjectival relevance and therefore should be struck out on that basis.
3. The court found that the alleged basis for relevance provided by the defendants was inconsistent with the pleaded case, leading to the subpoena being struck out on this ground.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The court commenced by examining the oppressive nature of the third-party subpoena. It noted that the subpoena sought information that was not relevant to the case, which imposed a significant burden on the third party without any justifiable purpose. The court found that this constituted an oppressive measure, warranting its striking out. Regarding the adjectival relevance, the court held that the information sought did not directly contribute to the resolution of the issues in the case at hand, and thus it did not meet the necessary criteria for relevance. Consequently, the subpoena was struck out on this basis as well. The court further assessed whether the basis for relevance as provided by the defendants aligned with the pleaded case. It was determined that the defendants' justification did not correspond with the facts and claims as articulated in the pleadings. This inconsistency led the court to conclude that the subpoena should be struck out, as it was not founded on a proper basis within the context of the case. The binding legal principle established by this decision pertains to the stringent criteria for issuing third-party subpoenas, emphasizing that they must be neither oppressive nor irrelevant to the case at hand, and the basis for relevance must be consistent with the pleaded case.