Lilley v The State of Western Australia

Link copied
Case Copied 55 min read

JURISDICTION     :   SUPREME COURT OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA

TITLE OF COURT :   THE COURT OF APPEAL (WA)

CITATION:   LILLEY -v- THE STATE OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA [2019] WASCA 164

CORAM:   BUSS P

MAZZA JA

BEECH JA

HEARD:   10 APRIL 2019

DELIVERED          :   22 OCTOBER 2019

FILE NO/S:   CACR 47 of 2018

BETWEEN:   JEMMA VICTORIA LILLEY

Appellant

AND

THE STATE OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA

Respondent

ON APPEAL FROM:

Jurisdiction              :   SUPREME COURT OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA

Coram:   HALL J

File Number             :   INS 333 of 2016


Catchwords:

Criminal law - Appeal against conviction - Appellant and co-accused convicted after a joint trial of murder - Cut-throat defences - Propensity evidence - State adduced propensity evidence in its case against the appellant - Whether propensity evidence correctly admitted - Co‑accused adduced evidence in her defence which tended to prove that the appellant had a propensity to commit murder - Whether evidence correctly admitted - Whether the trial judge should have ordered that the appellant be discharged from the joint trial and tried separately

Legislation:

Criminal Code (WA), s 279
Criminal Procedure Act 2004 (WA), s 133, sch 1 cl 9(2)
Evidence Act 1906 (WA), s 31A, s 32

Result:

Appellant's application in the appeal dated 20 September 2018 dismissed
Leave to appeal refused
Appeal dismissed

Category:    B

Representation:

Counsel:

Appellant : Mr S B Watters
Respondent : Ms A L Forrester SC & Mr R G Wilson

Solicitors:

Appellant : Chambers Legal
Respondent : Director of Public Prosecutions (WA)

Case(s) referred to in decision(s):

Ali v The Queen [2005] HCA 8; (2005) 79 ALJR 662

APC v The State of Western Australia [2012] WASCA 159; (2012) 224 A Crim R 59

Castle v The Queen [2016] HCA 46; (2016) 259 CLR 449

La Bianca v The State of Western Australia [2019] WASCA 105

Liyanage v The State of Western Australia [2017] WASCA 112; (2017) 51 WAR 359

Mahmood v The State of Western Australia [2009] WASCA 220

Mansfield v The State of Western Australia [2017] WASCA 178; (2017) 52 WAR 233

McPhillamy v The Queen [2018] HCA 52; (2018) 92 ALJR 1045

RMD v The State of Western Australia [2017] WASCA 70; (2017) 266 A Crim R 67

Russell v The State of Western Australia [2011] WASCA 246; (2011) 214 A Crim R 326

The State of Western Australia v Bowen [2006] WASCA 133; (2006) 32 WAR 81

The State of Western Australia v Jackson [2019] WASCA 118

The State of Western Australia v Micalizzi [2010] WASCA 147

TABLE OF CONTENTS

Overview of the critical issue at the trial

Overview of the State's case at the trial

The appellant's formal admissions at the trial

Overview of the appellant's case at the trial

Overview of Ms Lenon's case at the trial

The grounds of appeal

Ground 1:  the pre-trial ruling of Jenkins J in relation to the propensity evidence

Ground 1:  the appellant's submissions

Ground 1:  its merits

Ground 2:  the appellant's submissions

Ground 2:  its merits

Ground…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Lilley v The State of Western Australia and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] WASCA 164
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The appellant, along with a co-accused, was convicted of murder following a joint trial. The appellant appealed against his conviction, arguing that the trial judge had erred in admitting certain propensity evidence. The appeal was heard in the Court of Appeal of Western Australia, the highest court in the state.

The key legal issues before the court were whether the propensity evidence was correctly admitted, both in the prosecution's case and in the defence of the co-accused, and whether the trial judge should have ordered that the appellant be discharged from the joint trial and tried separately. Propensity evidence is defined in the Evidence Act as evidence of a person's conduct or tendency to act in a particular way. The court had to consider whether the evidence had significant probative value and whether its probative value outweighed the risk of unfair prejudice.

The court held that the trial judge had correctly admitted the evidence. The court considered that the evidence had significant probative value, particularly in light of the defences of the appellant and his co-accused. The court found that the evidence was relevant to the assessment of the probability of the existence of a fact in issue, namely the appellant's propensity to commit murder. The court also held that the trial judge was not required to order that the appellant be discharged from the joint trial and tried separately.

The appeal was dismissed.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Section 31A of the Evidence Act provides:31A. Propensity and relationship evidence(1)In this section -propensity evidence means -(a)similar fact evidence or other evidence of the conduct of the accused person; or(b)evidence of the character or reputation of the accused person or of a tendency that the accused person has or had;relationship evidence means evidence of the attitude or conduct of the accused person towards another person, or a class of persons, over a period of time.(2)Propensity evidence or relationship evidence is admissible in proceedings for an offence if the court considers -(a)that the evidence would, either by itself or having regard to other evidence adduced or to be adduced, have significant probative value; and(b)that the probative value of the evidence compared to the degree of risk of an unfair trial, is such that fair‑minded people would think that the public interest in adducing all relevant evidence of guilt must have priority over the risk of an unfair trial.(3)In considering the probative value of evidence for the purposes of subsection (2) it is not open to the court to have regard to the possibility that the evidence may be the result of collusion, concoction or suggestion. The principles relevant to whether propensity evidence has significant probative value, within the meaning of s 31A of the Evidence Act, were summarised in RMD v The State of Western Australia as follows:[3][3] RMD v The State of Western Australia [2017] WASCA 70; (2017) 266 A Crim R 67 [185] (Beech JA). See also RMD [50] - [52] (Buss P); La Bianca v The State of Western Australia [2019] WASCA 105 [24] ‑ [26] (Buss P & Mazza JA), [144] (Mitchell JA).(1)In assessing whether evidence has significant probative value, the evidence is to be taken at its highest from the perspective of the prosecution. (2)In determining whether propensity evidence would have significant probative value, the propensity evidence is not to be viewed in isolation. Section 31A(2)(a) expressly requires that attention be directed to whether, having regard to other evidence adduced or to be adduced, the propensity evidence would have significant probative value.(3)Evidence has 'probative value' if the evidence could rationally affect, directly or indirectly, the assessment of [the] probability of the existence of a fact in issue.(4)The test in s 31A(2)(a) will be satisfied if the court considers (that is, thinks) that the propensity evidence 'would' (as distinct from could), either by itself or having regard to other evidence adduced or to be adduced, rationally affect, to a significant extent, the assessment of the probability of the existence of a fact in issue.(5)The adjective 'significant' in the phrase 'significant probative value' in s 31A(2)(a) connotes important or of consequence.(6)If propensity evidence has probative value, then whether the probative value is 'significant' will depend upon the nature of the fact in issue to which it is relevant, and the significance or importance which the propensity evidence, either by itself or having regard to other evidence adduced or to be adduced, has in proving that fact.(7)The high level of generality of an alleged propensity can affect the extent of the probative force of the propensity evidence. The more specific the alleged similarity the more likely it is that the propensity evidence will have significant probative value.(8)The nature and extent of any similarity between the conduct the subject of the propensity evidence and the conduct the subject of the charged act(s) is relevant to whether the evidence has significant probative value. (footnotes omitted)

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established