Lieschke and Telstra Corporation Ltd (Compensation)

Link copied
Case Copied 31 min read

Lieschke and Telstra Corporation Ltd (Compensation) [2024] AATA 3434 (26 September 2024)

Division:GENERAL DIVISION

File Number(s):2017/0096, 2019/3287      

Re:Lieschke,  Christopher

APPLICANT

Telstra Corporation LtdAnd  

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal:Senior Member Hon J Rau SC

Date:26 September 2024

Place:Adelaide

ORDERS FOR APPLICATION 2017/0096:

  1. Pursuant to s 43(1)(c) of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth) (AAT Act), the decision of the Respondent of 7 October 2016 is set aside.

  2. Pursuant to s 43(1)(c)(ii) of the AAT Act, the matter is remitted to the Respondent with the following directions:

    (a)On the following dates, the Applicant was entitled to an increase in his normal weekly earnings (NWE) by the following percentages under ss 8 and 19 of the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (Cth) (SRC Act):

    (i)1 October 2010: 2.4%

    (ii)1 October 2011: 3.5%

    (b)On 1 December 2011, the Applicant was entitled to a further increase in the NWE payable to him under ss 8 and 19 of the SRC Act because:

    (i)when the Applicant suffered his relevant injury on 15 October 2009, he was a member of the same class (Class) of employees as the employees identified as E2, E3, E5, E6 and E7 at [68(a)] of the Tribunal’s reasons of 23 February 2024 (Reasons).

    (ii)on 1 December 2011, the Respondent began to transition to a changed digital support operating model (2011 Changes) resulting in new shift work responsibilities being assumed by all members of the Class (except the Applicant).

    (iii)due to the 2011 Changes, all members of the Class (except the Applicant) were required to perform a higher proportion of work on dates (or at times) to which overtime or other penalty rates applied.

    (iv)this resulted in all members of the Class (except for the Applicant) receiving an increase in the minimum amount per week payable to them under the industrial instruments that set their remuneration.

    (v)that increase in the amount payable to the members of the Class (except for the Applicant) constituted an increase by a ‘relevant percentage’ for the purposes of s 8(9A) of the SRC Act.

    (vi)the Applicant was therefore entitled to an increase in his NWE, pursuant to ss 8(9)-(9A) of the SRC Act, by 15.12% on 1 December 2011, which is the same percentage as that received by the member of the Class who received the lowest or least amount of increase on 1 December 2011, namely, employee E5.

    (c)On the following dates, the Applicant was entitled to further increases in his NWE by the following percentages pursuant to ss 8 and 19 of the SRC Act:

    (i)1 October 2012: 2%

    (ii)1 October 2013: 3%

    (iii)1 October 2014: 2%

    (iv)1 July 2015: 2.6%

    ORDERS FOR APPLICATION 2019/3287:

  3. Pursuant to s 43(1)(c) of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth) (AAT Act), the decision of the Respondent of 12 April 2019 is set aside.

  4. In substitution for that decision, and pursuant to s 43(1)(c)(i) of the AAT Act, the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Lieschke and Telstra Corporation Ltd (Compensation) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] AATA 3434
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an application by Mr Lieschke against Telstra Corporation Ltd regarding compensation entitlements under the *Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988* (Cth). The dispute arose from the calculation of Mr Lieschke's normal weekly earnings (NWE) following a workplace injury in 2009, and involved a complex history of determinations and reviews. The case was heard by Senior Member Hon J Rau SC of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal.

The primary legal issue before the Tribunal was to determine the correct calculation of Mr Lieschke's entitlements under section 19 of the *Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988*, which required a review of Telstra's entire decision-making process concerning his NWE. A significant aspect of this involved determining the continuing application and effect of an Australian Workplace Agreement (AWA) signed by Mr Lieschke in 2006, particularly in light of the *Fair Work (Transitional Provisions and Consequential Amendments) Act 2009* (Cth) and the subsequent introduction of an Enterprise Agreement by Telstra.

The Tribunal considered the provisions of the *Fair Work (Transitional Provisions and Consequential Amendments) Act 2009*, specifically Schedule 3, which preserved the operation of AWAs as "agreement-based transitional instruments". The Tribunal noted that Item 3 of Part 2 of Schedule 3 stipulated that such instruments continued to cover the same employees and employers as they would have if the *Workplace Relations Act 1996* (Cth) had remained in force. Furthermore, Item 18 of Part 3 addressed the conditional termination of individual agreement-based transitional instruments, such as AWAs, upon the making and commencement of an enterprise agreement, provided specific requirements for written agreement and notification were met. The Tribunal indicated that it would invite further submissions on the appropriate form of final orders.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

After publication of these reasons, I will give the parties time to consider their position. I will then convene a directions hearing, to hear their submissions concerning the appropriate next steps, or if appropriate, what the final orders should be.BACKGROUND FACTS The Applicant is 45 years of age. This case has a long and complex history. There have been previous AAT decisions involving Mr Lieschke and Telstra, regarding matters arising under the Act.[3] [3] Re Lieschke and Telstra Corp Ltd (2016) AATA 361; Re Lieschke and Telstra Corp Ltd (2018) AATA 3787; Re Lieschke and Telstra Corp Ltd (2021) AATA 4462. On 18 September 2006, Mr Lieschke signed an AWA covering his employment with Telstra (“the AWA”). This had a start date of 3 October 2006. This was expressed to operate for a period of 5 years from its lodgement with the Australian Industrial Relations Commission, which occurred on 6 October 2006.[4] [4] Exhibit 11, Australian Workplace Agreement (AWA) signed on 18.09.2006. There is no evidence to suggest that Mr Lieschke ever took any steps to terminate the operation of the AWA. On 15 October 2009 (“the date of injury”), he suffered a brain haemorrhage. By letter dated 28 January 2010 (“the 2010 determination”), Telstra accepted liability to pay compensation for a “subarachnoid haemorrhage due to a ruptured left middle cerebral aneurysm and a fractured left ankle” (“the Injury”). Telstra determined that as at the date of injury, the Applicant’s NWE was $1,083.65.[5] [5] Exhibit 5, T-Documents for Application 2017/0096 (2017 application), 12. On 3 March 2011, Mr Lieschke received a salary increase. This increased his NWE from $1,239.11 to $1268.85.[6][6] Exhibit 6, T-Document for Application 2019/3287 (2019 application), 7. Mr Lieschke says he attended a meeting in 2011 where he voted for the Telstra Enterprise Agreement 2012-2015 (“the EA”). It seems that he is mistaken in dating this recollection. Telstra says, and the evidence suggests, that this vote took place in September-October 2012. The EA began operating on 17 December 2012.[7][7] Exhibit 12, Telstra Enterprise Agreement 2012-2015 (2012 EA), 2. On 16 July 2013, Telstra varied the 2010 determination as follows (“the 2013 determination”):“I have decided to vary the determination dated 28 January 2010 to find under section 8 of the SRC Act that your normal weekly earnings:a) As at 15 October 2009 are $971.27;b) As at 22 July 2010 are $1,071.31;c) As at 3 March 2011 are $1,097.02;d) As at 1 October 2011 are $1,135.42;e) As at 1 October 2012 are $1,158.13; andf) As at 1 July 2013 are $1,187.08.”[8][8] Exhibit 5, 14. On 9 August 2013, Mr Lieschke lodged an application for review in the AAT, of the 2013 determination. This application concerned the correct calculation of his NWE.[9] [9] Ibid 21-35. On 19 February 2015, Mr Lieschke retired from his employment with the Respondent on medical grounds. On 30 May 2016, DP Bean made the following orders (“the 2016 AAT decision”):“The Tribunal:1)Sets aside the reviewable decision of the respondent dated 16 July 2013;2)In substitution for that decision determines that Mr Lieschke's NWE amount, pursuant to s 8 of the SRC Act, as at 15 October 2009, was $1,239.11;3)Remits to the respondent the determination of Mr Lieschke's subsequent NWE amounts, by reference to the Tribunal's Reasons for Decision and on the basis that during the relevant period, Mr Lieschke was paid 100.71% of his 'at risk' remuneration amount;4)Reserves liberty to apply within 14 days in relation to the costs of the proceedings; and5)Orders that in the absence of any such application, the respondent is to pay the costs of the proceedings incurred by Mr Lieschke pursuant to subs 67(8) of the SRC Act.”[10][10] Ibid 34-35.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

On 12 April 2019, the Telstra review officer revoked the 2019 determination and substituted a different decision (“the 2019 decision”).[15] [15] Ibid 7-10. On 11 June 2019, Mr Lieschke lodged an application with the AAT seeking a review of the 2019 decision. On 1 May 2019, spreadsheet C was provided to Mr Lieschke and the Tribunal. This indicated overpayment to Mr Lieschke in the sum of $19,290.64. On 1 December 2021, DP Britten-Jones set aside the 2016 decision and substituted a different NWE as at 15 October 2009 and 23 December 2015 (“AAT 2021”).[16][16] Re Lieschke and Telstra Corp Ltd (2021) AATA 4462. On 18 January 2022, Mr Lieschke appealed against AAT 2021. On 15 May 2023, The Federal Court made orders by consent setting aside the decision in AAT 2021 and remitting it back to the Tribunal.CONSIDERATION The issues before the Tribunal are the correct calculation of Mr Lieschke’s entitlements pursuant to s 19 of the SRC Act. This extends to reviewing the “entire reviewable decision of (Telstra)”.[17] This has several components which are discussed below. As previously mentioned, at this stage the Tribunal is not entering into the exercise of calculating actual pay rate adjustments, but dealing with the higher-level legal issues which must first be resolved to enable such calculations to be made.[17] Crick v Comcare (2020) AATA 4483 para 171 (Mc Dermott DP). There have been numerous adjustments to Mr Lieschke’s payments over the years. Each incremental increase is calculated by making an adjustment to the then existing pay rate. It follows that an error anywhere in this connected chain will require an adjustment to all succeeding calculations.The AWA/ EA issue As previously observed, the AWA applied to Mr Lieschke from 6 October 2006. Item 2 of Part 2 of Schedule 3 to the Fair Work (Transitional Provisions and Consequential Amendments) Act 2009 (“FWTP Act”) provides that the AWA was a “WR Act instrument”.[18] This preserved its ongoing operation, notwithstanding the repeal of the Workplace Relations Act 1996 (Cth) (“WR Act”):[18] Fair Work (Transitional Provisions and Consequential Amendments) Act 2009 (Cth) sch 3 item 2(5). Item 2(5) of Part 2 of Schedule 3 to the FWTP Act states that: “Transitional instruments are classified as follows: … (d) agreement-based transitional instruments of the following kinds are individual agreement-based transitional instruments: … (iii) AWAs Item 3 of Part 2 of Schedule 3 to the FWTP Act further relevantly provides that:"A transitional instrument covers the same employees, employers and any other persons that it would have covered (however described in the instrument or WR Act) if the WR Act had continued in operation. Note 1: The expression covers is used to indicate the range of employees, employers etc. to whom the instrument potentially applies (see subitem (2)). The employees, employers etc. who are within this range will depend on terms of the instrument, and on any relevant provisions of the WR Act. … (2) A transitional instrument applies to the same employees, employers and any other persons the instrument covers as would, if the WR Act had continued in operation, have been: (a) required by the WR Act to comply with terms of the instrument; or (b) entitled under the WR Act to enforce terms of the instrument. Note: The expression applies is used to indicate the range of employees … who are required to comply with, or can enforce, the terms of a transitional instrument

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

On 15 May 2023, The Federal Court made orders by consent setting aside the decision in AAT 2021 and remitting it back to the Tribunal.CONSIDERATION The issues before the Tribunal are the correct calculation of Mr Lieschke’s entitlements pursuant to s 19 of the SRC Act. This extends to reviewing the “entire reviewable decision of (Telstra)”.[17] This has several components which are discussed below. As previously mentioned, at this stage the Tribunal is not entering into the exercise of calculating actual pay rate adjustments, but dealing with the higher-level legal issues which must first be resolved to enable such calculations to be made.[17] Crick v Comcare (2020) AATA 4483 para 171 (Mc Dermott DP). There have been numerous adjustments to Mr Lieschke’s payments over the years. Each incremental increase is calculated by making an adjustment to the then existing pay rate. It follows that an error anywhere in this connected chain will require an adjustment to all succeeding calculations.The AWA/ EA issue As previously observed, the AWA applied to Mr Lieschke from 6 October 2006. Item 2 of Part 2 of Schedule 3 to the Fair Work (Transitional Provisions and Consequential Amendments) Act 2009 (“FWTP Act”) provides that the AWA was a “WR Act instrument”.[18] This preserved its ongoing operation, notwithstanding the repeal of the Workplace Relations Act 1996 (Cth) (“WR Act”):[18] Fair Work (Transitional Provisions and Consequential Amendments) Act 2009 (Cth) sch 3 item 2(5). Item 2(5) of Part 2 of Schedule 3 to the FWTP Act states that: “Transitional instruments are classified as follows: … (d) agreement-based transitional instruments of the following kinds are individual agreement-based transitional instruments: … (iii) AWAs Item 3 of Part 2 of Schedule 3 to the FWTP Act further relevantly provides that:"A transitional instrument covers the same employees, employers and any other persons that it would have covered (however described in the instrument or WR Act) if the WR Act had continued in operation. Note 1: The expression covers is used to indicate the range of employees, employers etc. to whom the instrument potentially applies (see subitem (2)). The employees, employers etc. who are within this range will depend on terms of the instrument, and on any relevant provisions of the WR Act. … (2) A transitional instrument applies to the same employees, employers and any other persons the instrument covers as would, if the WR Act had continued in operation, have been: (a) required by the WR Act to comply with terms of the instrument; or (b) entitled under the WR Act to enforce terms of the instrument. Note: The expression applies is used to indicate the range of employees … who are required to comply with, or can enforce, the terms of a transitional instrument Item 18 of Part 3 of Schedule 3 to the FWTP Act relevantly provides that: (1) This item provides for the making of an instrument (a conditional termination) that will have the effect of terminating an individual agreement-based transitional instrument if: (a) an enterprise agreement (the proposed enterprise agreement) is made that covers the employee and the employer; and (b) the proposed enterprise agreement comes into operation. (2) If the transitional instrument has not passed its nominal expiry date, the conditional termination must be a written agreement signed by the employer and the employee. The signatures must be witnessed. (3) If the transitional instrument has passed its nominal expiry date, the conditional termination must be in writing and signed either by the employee or the employer. The signature must be witnessed. … (6) The employer must give the employee a copy of the conditional termination if: (a) the conditional termination is an agreement signed by the employee and the employer in the circumstances covered by subitem (2); or (b) the conditional termination is signed by the employer in the circumstances covered by subitem (3). … (8) If the requirements of subitems (2) to (5) have been complied with in relation to the conditional termination, the transitional instrument terminates when the proposed enterprise agreement comes into operation.