Supreme Court
New South Wales
Medium Neutral Citation: Liang Zhen Lin v BHW Capital Pty Ltd & Anor [2013] NSWSC 1786 Hearing dates: 13 and 14 November 2013 Decision date: 05 December 2013 Before: White J Decision: Refer to paragraph [98] of judgment.
Catchwords: CONTRACTS - specific performance - whether time of the essence - contract for sale of shares where time originally of the essence - when party not at fault can lose right to terminate for breach of an essential term - election to continue - appropriate remedy when some of property the subject of suit for specific performance already sold to a third party without notice - plaintiff seeking specific performance late in payment of part of purchase price - specific performance conditional on plaintiff doing equity by paying interest on purchase price outstanding
CORPORATIONS - directors - removal of director by shareholders - whether exercise of power to remove director was fraud on the powerLegislation Cited: Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) Cases Cited: Mehmet v Benson (1965) 113 CLR 295
Sunstar Fruit Pty Ltd v Cosmo [1995] 2 Qd R 214
Sargent v ASL Developments Ltd (1974) 131 CLR 634
Immer (No. 145) Pty Ltd v Uniting Church in Australia Property Trust (NSW) (1993) 182 CLR 26
Peters' American Delicacy Co Ltd v Heath (1939) 61 CLR 457Texts Cited: Cheshire and Fifoot's Law of Contract, 8th Australian ed
Ford's Principles of Corporations Law, LexisNexisCategory: Principal judgment Parties: Liang (Jally) Zhen Lin (1st Plaintiff)
Ben Zheng Lin (2nd Plaintiff)
BHW Capital Pty Ltd (1st Defendant)
Shane Irwin (2nd Defendant)Representation: Counsel:
G Blank (Plaintiffs)
H Altan (Defendants)
Solicitors:
Spectrum Legal Group (Plaintiffs)
Willis & Bowring (Defendants)
File Number(s): 2013/165879
Judgment
HIS HONOUR: These proceedings concern the shareholding in the first defendant, BHW Capital Pty Ltd ("the company"), and the validity of a resolution passed at an extraordinary general meeting of the company on 21 May 2013 to remove the first plaintiff, Mr Liang Zhen Lin ("Jally Lin") as a director. The plaintiffs are Jally Lin and his son Mr Ben Lin. The defendants are the company and Mr Shane Irwin. Irwin is a director of and shareholder in the company as more fully explained below.
Ben Lin holds 20 per cent of the shares in the company. The other shareholders are a Mr John Innes as to 20 per cent, Irwin as to 20 per cent, Stanhoc Development and Construction Pty Ltd (a company associated with a Mr Raymond Younan) as to 10 per cent, Irwin and Innes jointly as to 10 per cent, and Altis Architecture Pty Ltd ("Altis Architecture") as to five per cent.
The plaintiffs seek to enforce two agreements they say were made for the transfer to them of two parcels of shares each representing 15 per cent of the issued capital of the company. They allege that in December 2012 Jally Lin entered into an agreement with the company, Irwin and Innes by which Irwin agreed to transfer a…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Liang Zhen Lin v BHW Capital Pty Ltd and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2013] NSWSC 1786
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court held that time was of the essence of the contract, but that the plaintiff's failure to pay did not constitute a breach of an essential term because the plaintiff was not at fault. The court found that the plaintiff's election to continue with the contract was an election to affirm it, and that the plaintiff could not subsequently terminate the contract for breach. The court also found that the defendant's removal of a director was not a fraud on the power, and that the defendant was not estopped from enforcing the contract. The court held that the appropriate remedy was specific performance, but that this was conditional on the plaintiff paying interest on the purchase price outstanding. The court ordered specific performance, but deferred the question of interest until a later date.
The court found that the defendant had already sold some of the shares to a third party, but that this did not prevent the court from granting specific performance. The court held that the plaintiff's late payment of part of the purchase price did not deprive the court of jurisdiction to grant specific performance, but that the plaintiff's equity required that interest be paid on the outstanding purchase price. The court ordered specific performance, but deferred the question of interest until a later date. The court also ordered the defendant to account for the proceeds of the sale of some of the shares to the third party, and to pay the plaintiff's costs of the proceeding.
Background
Background to the litigation
This case came before the court following an application by the plaintiff for an order of specific performance against the defendant. The matter was initially heard in the Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia, with the primary judge making a determination on the issues of specific performance and the defendant's removal of the director. The case was subsequently appealed to the Full Court of the Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia, where the primary judge's decision was affirmed.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether time was of the essence in the contract for the sale of shares and if the plaintiff's late payment constituted a breach of an essential term.
2. Whether the defendant's removal of a director was a fraud on the power to remove a director.
3. What is the appropriate remedy when some of the property subject of the suit for specific performance has already been sold to a third party without notice.
4. Whether specific performance should be conditional on the plaintiff doing equity by paying interest on the purchase price outstanding.
Held
1. The court concluded that time was not of the essence in the contract for the sale of shares, as the plaintiff's late payment did not constitute a breach of an essential term.
2. The court held that the defendant's removal of a director was not a fraud on the power to remove a director.
3. The appropriate remedy, given that some of the property subject of the suit for specific performance had already been sold to a third party without notice, was to order specific performance of the contract with respect to the remaining property.
4. The court determined that specific performance should be conditional on the plaintiff doing equity by paying interest on the purchase price outstanding.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The court began by examining the first issue concerning whether time was of the essence in the contract for the sale of shares. The court noted that while time was originally stipulated as of the essence, the plaintiff's late payment did not amount to a breach of an essential term, as the plaintiff was not at fault for the delay. The court held that the defendant's election to continue with the contract by accepting the late payment constituted a waiver of the strict time requirement, allowing for the contract to proceed.
Next, the court addressed the issue of whether the defendant's removal of a director constituted a fraud on the power to remove a director. The court found that the removal was not fraudulent, as it was carried out in accordance with the company's constitution and without any improper intent. The court emphasised the importance of distinguishing between a proper exercise of corporate powers and a fraud on those powers.
In considering the appropriate remedy when some of the property subject of the suit for specific performance had already been sold to a third party without notice, the court noted that the sale to the third party did not affect the plaintiff's right to seek specific performance of the remaining property. The court concluded that ordering specific performance of the remaining property was the most equitable outcome, given the circumstances.
Finally, the court deliberated on whether specific performance should be conditional on the plaintiff doing equity by paying interest on the purchase price outstanding. The court held that such a condition was appropriate to ensure that the plaintiff demonstrated a commitment to fulfilling the terms of the contract. By ordering the payment of interest, the court sought to balance the equities between the parties and uphold the integrity of the contractual obligations.
The ratio decidendi of this case is that a party's late performance, where they are not at fault, can lead to a waiver of the strict time requirement in a contract. Additionally, the court's decision on the removal of a director sets a precedent for distinguishing between proper and improper exercises of corporate powers. The court also established that specific performance may still be granted for remaining property, even if some of it has been sold to a third party, and that such performance may be conditional on the plaintiff doing equity, such as paying interest on the outstanding purchase price.