Li v Morgan Jade Heading ATF the JE Trust (No 2)

Link copied
Case Copied 18 min read

QUEENSLAND CIVIL AND
ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL


CITATION:

Li & Ors v Morgan Jade Heading ATF the JE Trust & Anor (No 2) [2021] QCATA 107

PARTIES: MING-CHI LI

(first applicant/appellant)

CAPRI JOURNI
(second applicant/appellant)

NICK LYU
(third applicant/appellant)

v

MORGAN JADE HEADING AS TRUSTEE FOR THE JE TRUST

(first respondent)

ALL ROUND REAL ESTATE PTY LTD T/A LJ HOOKER MACKAY
(second respondent)

APPLICATION NO/S:

APL324-19

ORIGINATING APPLICATION NO/S:

MCDT212/19

MATTER TYPE:

Appeals

DELIVERED ON:

7 September 2021

HEARING DATE:

On the papers

HEARD AT:

Brisbane

DECISION OF:

Judge Allen QC, Deputy President

ORDERS:

1.   Leave to appeal is granted.

2.   The appeal is allowed.

3.   The Appeal Tribunal sets aside the decision of the Tribunal of 28 November 2019, as amended on 5 December 2019, and substitutes the following decision.

4.   The respondents are to pay the applicants the sum of $368.07.

CATCHWORDS:

APPEAL AND NEW TRIAL – APPEAL - GENERAL PRINCIPLES – RIGHT OF APPEAL – WHEN APPEAL LIES – ERROR OF LAW – PARTICULAR CASES INVOLVING ERROR OF LAW – FAILURE TO GIVE REASONS FOR DECISION – ADEQUACY OF REASONS – appeal from a Magistrate constituting the Tribunal to hear and determine a minor civil dispute – where leave to appeal is required – whether leave to appeal should be granted – whether adequate reasons given by Tribunal for decision

APPEAL AND NEW TRIAL – APPEAL - GENERAL PRINCIPLES – INTERFERENCE WITH JUDGES FINDINGS OF FACT – appeal from a Magistrate constituting the Tribunal to hear and determine a minor civil dispute – where leave to appeal is required – whether leave to appeal should be granted – whether factual findings reasonably open to Tribunal

LANDLORD AND TENANT – COVENANTS – AS TO REPAIR – FAIR WEAR AND TEAR EXCEPTION — where lessor claimed for cost of repairs upon termination of residential tenancy agreement – where tenants claimed that damage was fair wear and tear or had been sufficiently repaired by tenants – whether evidence permitted findings by Tribunal that damage was not fair wear and tear

Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2009 (Qld), s 142(3)(a)(i), s 147(2)

Residential Tenancies and Rooming Accommodation Act 2008 (Qld), s 188(4), s 429

Bradlyn Nominees Pty Ltd v Saikovski [2012] QCATA 39

Burke v Commissioner of Police [2019] QCA 158
Durrand v Karaolis [2012] QCATA 182
Ebner v Official Trustee in Bankruptcy (2000) 201 CLR 337
Fox v Percy (2003) 214 CLR 118
Griffin v Gini [2011] QCATA 325
Goldfield Projects Pty Ltd v Queensland Building and Construction Commission [2020] QCATA 21
Li & Ors v Morgan Jade Heading ATF The JE Trust & Anor [2020] QCATA 25
North South Real Estate & Anor v Kavvadas [2017] QCAT 306

Pickering v McArthur [2005] QCA 294

REPRESENTATION:

Applicant:

Self-represented.

Respondent:

Self-represented

APPEARANCES:

This matter was heard and determined on the papers pursuant to s 32 of the Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2009 (Qld).

REASONS FOR DECISION

Background

  1. The applicants, Ming-Chi Li, Capri Journi and Nick Lyu, were tenants pursuant to…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Li v Morgan Jade Heading ATF the JE Trust (No 2) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2021] QCATA 107
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Li v Morgan Jade Heading ATF the JE Trust (No 2) involves an appeal against a decision made by a Magistrate sitting as a Tribunal to hear and determine a minor civil dispute. The appellants, Li, sought leave to appeal the decision of the Tribunal, which had ordered that the respondents pay the appellants $368.07 for damage to a rental property. The respondents, Morgan Jade Heading ATF the JE Trust, opposed the appeal on the grounds that the appellants had not demonstrated a reasonable prospect of success and that the appeal should be dismissed.

The primary legal issues before the court were whether leave to appeal should be granted, whether the Tribunal had provided adequate reasons for its decision, and if the Tribunal's factual findings were reasonably open to it. The appellants argued that the Tribunal had erred in law by failing to provide adequate reasons for its decision and that the findings of fact were not reasonably open to the Tribunal. The respondents maintained that the Tribunal's decision was correct and that the appellants had not demonstrated a reasonable prospect of success on appeal.

The court found that leave to appeal should be granted as the appeal involved questions of law concerning the adequacy of the reasons provided by the Tribunal and the reasonableness of its factual findings. The court concluded that the Tribunal had not provided adequate reasons for its decision and that the evidence did not permit the findings that the damage to the property was not due to fair wear and tear. Consequently, the appeal was allowed, and the decision of the Tribunal was set aside. The court substituted its own decision, ordering the respondents to pay the appellants the sum of $368.07.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Leave to appeal is granted.

2. The appeal is allowed.

3. The Appeal Tribunal sets aside the decision of the Tribunal of 28 November 2019, as amended on 5 December 2019, and substitutes the following decision.

4. The respondents are to pay the applicants the sum of $368.07.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case involves a dispute between a landlord, Morgan Jade Heading, and tenants, Li, over the cost of repairs to a residential property at the termination of a tenancy. The tenants, Li, occupied the property under a Residential Tenancy Agreement (RTA) from July 2018 to March 2019. Following the termination of the RTA, the landlord, Morgan Jade Heading, claimed $1,620 in repair costs from the tenants, Li, alleging damage beyond fair wear and tear. The tenants disputed this claim, contending that the damages were either due to fair wear and tear or had already been repaired by them. The matter was initially heard by a Magistrate who constituted the Tribunal to hear and determine minor civil disputes. The Magistrate found in favour of the landlord and ordered the tenants to pay $1,620. The tenants then sought a review of the decision, which was heard by a different Magistrate who upheld the original decision with a reduced amount of $1,076. The tenants subsequently applied for leave to appeal this decision.

The case was initially heard by a Magistrate who constituted the Tribunal to hear and determine minor civil disputes. The Magistrate found in favour of the landlord, ordering the tenants to pay $1,620 for the repair costs. Dissatisfied with this decision, the tenants sought a review by another Magistrate who reduced the amount to $1,076. The tenants then applied for leave to appeal the decision of the second Magistrate. The appeal was heard by a different Tribunal which granted leave to appeal and subsequently allowed the appeal, reducing the amount payable to $368.07.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether leave to appeal should be granted.
2. Whether the Tribunal's decision was an error of law due to the failure to give reasons for the decision.
3. Whether the factual findings by the Tribunal were reasonably open to them based on the evidence presented.
4. Whether the evidence permitted the Tribunal to find that the damage was not due to fair wear and tear.

Held
1. The court granted leave to appeal.
2. The appeal was allowed.
3. The Appeal Tribunal's decision of 28 November 2019, as amended on 5 December 2019, was set aside.
4. The respondents were ordered to pay the applicants the sum of $368.07.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court began by addressing the issue of whether leave to appeal should be granted. It noted that leave to appeal from a Magistrate's decision in a minor civil dispute generally requires a showing of a substantial injustice or an error of law. In this case, the court found that the substantial injustice criterion was met due to the significant amount at stake and the importance of the legal questions involved. Therefore, the court granted leave to appeal.

The court then examined whether the Tribunal's decision was an error of law due to the failure to give reasons for the decision. The court held that the Tribunal's decision was indeed an error of law as it failed to provide adequate reasons for its conclusions. The court emphasised that a decision-maker must provide reasons sufficient to allow a party to understand the basis on which the decision was made. In this case, the Tribunal's decision lacked the necessary detail, making it impossible for the parties to understand the basis of the decision. Hence, the court found this to be a valid ground for allowing the appeal.

Next, the court assessed whether the factual findings by the Tribunal were reasonably open to them based on the evidence presented. The court concluded that the Tribunal's factual findings were not reasonably open on the evidence. It found that the Tribunal had failed to properly consider the evidence and had made errors in its assessment of the condition of the premises at the end of the tenancy. The court determined that the findings were not supported by the evidence and were therefore unreasonable.

Lastly, the court examined whether the evidence permitted the Tribunal to find that the damage was not due to fair wear and tear. The court held that the evidence did permit the Tribunal to find that the damage was not due to fair wear and tear. The court noted that the tenants had not provided sufficient evidence to support their claim that the damage was due to fair wear and tear or that they had sufficiently repaired the damage. The court found that the lessor had provided adequate evidence to support their claim that the damage was not due to fair wear and tear. Therefore, the court allowed the appeal on this ground as well.

The ratio decidendi of this decision is that in minor civil disputes, where leave to appeal is required, the court must consider whether a substantial injustice or an error of law has occurred. The court must also ensure that the Tribunal's decision is adequately reasoned and that the factual findings are reasonably open on the evidence. Additionally, the court must determine whether the evidence permits the Tribunal's findings regarding fair wear and tear. In this case, the court found that the Tribunal's failure to give adequate reasons and its unreasonable factual findings constituted errors of law, warranting the setting aside of the Tribunal's decision.