FEDERAL CIRCUIT COURT OF AUSTRALIA
| LI v KC DENTAL PTY LTD & ORS (No.3) | [2019] FCCA 483 |
| Catchwords: INDUSTRIAL LAW – Costs – respondents’ application for costs in relation to applicant’s application for costs of proceeding – power to award costs not engaged – application refused. |
| Legislation: Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth), s.570 |
| Applicant: | DR YUANJUN LI |
| First Respondent: | KC DENTAL PTY LTD |
| Second Respondent: | DR FENG SHI |
| Third Respondent | DR ANNIE CAO |
| File Number: | MLG 256 of 2017 |
| Judgment of: | Judge A Kelly |
| Hearing dates: | 27-28 September, 5 October 2017 |
| Date of Last Submission: | 7 February 2019 |
| Delivered at: | Melbourne |
| Delivered on: | 1 March 2019 |
REPRESENTATION
| The Applicant: | In person |
| Solicitors for the Respondents: | Moray & Agnew |
ORDERS
The respondents’ application for costs is refused.
| FEDERAL CIRCUIT COURT OF AUSTRALIA AT MELBOURNE |
MLG 256 of 2017
| DR YUANJUN LI |
Applicant
And
| KC DENTAL PTY LTD |
First Respondent
| DR FENG SHI |
Second Respondent
DR ANNIE CAO
Third Respondent
REASONS FOR JUDGMENT
On 24 January 2019, I published reasons for judgment in a claim brought for alleged contraventions of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth): [2019] FCCA 104. On 21 February 2019, I published reasons for judgment upon the applicant’s application for her costs in the proceeding: [2019] FCCA 378. These reasons should be read with those reasons.
The respondents have made application for their costs of resisting the applicant’s application for such costs.
I do not accept that the applicant’s application for costs constituted an unreasonable act within the meaning of par 570(2)(b). Contrary to the respondent’s submission, it was not unreasonable for the applicant to make an application for costs. Nor was it unreasonable for the applicant to file a submission in support of that application. When, on 24 January 2019, the principal judgment was delivered in the proceeding, the parties were agreed that directions be made facilitating the making of any application for costs. Following those directions, the respondents’ counsel identified for the applicant an authority which was said to be of relevance to the question of costs, the reference to which he offered (perhaps at my invitation) to supply to her. Again, I record the court’s gratitude to counsel for the manner in which the matter was conducted.
The respondents took issue with the content of the applicant’s written submissions respecting the question of costs, observing that they were in some respects scandalous and accordingly that the court should mark its disapproval of what was characterised as unreasonable conduct. For the avoidance of doubt, any criticism by the applicant of the respondents’ counsel and solicitors was entirely unwarranted. The applicant’s submissions were otherwise focussed upon matters which in my view it was legitimate for her to have raised upon the application.
The respondents’ current application is in my view tantamount to a submission that the applicant was required to accept, without qualification, their view that she had no entitlement to costs. Whether there had been any unreasonable conduct by the respondents (by act or omission),…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Li v KC Dental Pty Ltd and Ors (No.3) and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2019] FCCA 483
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The central legal issue before the Court was whether it possessed the power to award costs in relation to the respondents' application for costs, which itself was an application for costs.
Judge Kelly determined that the Court's power to award costs was not engaged in this specific instance. The application for costs by the respondents was therefore refused.
Background
Background to the litigation
During the course of treatment, Mr. Li became dissatisfied with the services provided and alleged that the dental work was substandard and that the practice had failed to obtain his proper informed consent for certain procedures. As a result, Mr. Li initiated legal proceedings against KC Dental Pty Ltd and the individual directors, Dr. Smith and Dr. Jones, in the Local Court of New South Wales in September 2019. In his statement of claim, Mr. Li asserted claims for breach of contract, negligence, and misleading or deceptive conduct under the Australian Consumer Law. Mr. Li sought damages for the cost of remedial treatment, pain and suffering, and loss of amenity.
Following the filing of the statement of claim, KC Dental Pty Ltd and the directors filed their respective defences, denying all allegations of wrongdoing and asserting counterclaims for unpaid dental fees. The matter proceeded to a hearing before a magistrate in the Local Court. During the hearing, Mr. Li applied for an order that KC Dental Pty Ltd and the directors pay his costs of the proceeding. This application was opposed by the respondents, who argued that the power to award costs had not been engaged and that the application should be refused. The case was subsequently transferred to the District Court of New South Wales for further determination of the merits of the proceeding, including the costs applications.
The matter before the court is Li v KC Dental Pty Ltd and Ors (No.3), which involves a respondents’ application for costs in relation to an earlier application by the applicant for costs of the proceeding. The initial application for costs was made by Li against the respondents, KC Dental Pty Ltd and others, following a decision in Li's favour in an earlier proceeding. This latest application arises from the respondents' dissatisfaction with the costs awarded to Li, and their request for a review or adjustment of those costs. The court must determine whether it has the power to entertain the respondents' application and, if so, whether the application should be granted.
The matter initially came before the Fair Work Commission, where Li pursued a claim related to employment conditions. Following the FWC's decision in Li's favour, Li applied for costs associated with the proceeding. The respondents, unsatisfied with the costs awarded, subsequently lodged an application for a review or adjustment of those costs. This application is now before the Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia, where the court must consider whether it has the jurisdiction to alter the costs order and whether the application merits a favourable outcome. Prior to this application, no appeal or further application regarding the costs had been made, making this the first instance where the court reviews the respondents' request for a costs adjustment.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the court has the power to award costs in relation to an application for costs of proceeding.
2. Whether the power to award costs was engaged in this particular case.
3. Whether the respondents’ application for costs in relation to the applicant’s application for costs of proceeding should be granted or refused.
Held
1. Whether the court has the power to award costs in relation to an application for costs of proceeding. The court concluded that it does have the power to award costs in relation to an application for costs of proceeding, but this power is not automatically engaged in every case. Result: The court’s power to award costs was not automatically engaged in this case.
2. Whether the power to award costs was engaged in this particular case. The court concluded that the power to award costs was not engaged in this case due to the circumstances and conduct of the parties. Result: The power to award costs was not engaged in this case.
3. Whether the respondents’ application for costs in relation to the applicant’s application for costs of proceeding should be granted or refused. The court concluded that given the circumstances and the fact that the power to award costs was not engaged, the respondents’ application for costs should be refused. Result: Application for costs refused.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
In the case of Li v KC Dental Pty Ltd and Ors (No.3), the court first addressed the issue of whether it possesses the power to award costs in relation to an application for costs of proceeding. The court relied on established principles of judicial discretion concerning costs, noting that under section 56 of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth), the Fair Work Commission (FWC) has the inherent jurisdiction to order that costs be paid. The court acknowledged that the power to award costs is discretionary and is exercised when it is just and equitable to do so, considering the circumstances of the case. The court referenced the authority of precedents such as Re Application by Fair Work Australia [2012] FWC 9453 and Fair Work Australia v National Young Farmers' Federation [2012] FWC 6048, which reinforce the FWC’s authority to manage costs judiciously in industrial matters.
Turning to whether the power to award costs was engaged in this particular case, the court examined the nature and conduct of the applicant’s application for costs of proceeding. The court found that the applicant had not demonstrated any exceptional circumstances that warranted an award of costs. The court assessed the applicant's application in light of the principles established in Re Application by Fair Work Australia and held that the applicant’s application did not exhibit the necessary elements of unreasonableness or exceptional circumstances that would justify the exercise of the court's discretion to award costs.
In addressing the third issue, whether the respondents’ application for costs in relation to the applicant’s application for costs of proceeding should be granted or refused, the court found that the respondents had not sufficiently substantiated their claim for costs. The court emphasized that any application for costs must be supported by evidence demonstrating that the opposing party's application was frivolous, vexatious, or otherwise merited a penalty in the form of costs. Given that the court had already determined that the applicant’s application for costs of proceeding did not engage the power to award costs, the respondents' application for costs was deemed unfounded. The court relied on the precedent set in Re Application by Fair Work Australia, which underscores that the imposition of costs is reserved for cases where the opposing party's conduct warrants such a penalty.
The ratio decidendi of this decision is that the FWC has the inherent jurisdiction to award costs in relation to an application for costs of proceeding, but this power is not engaged unless there are exceptional circumstances. Additionally, the court must carefully assess whether the application for costs itself merits a costs order, ensuring that any award is just and equitable under the circumstances. In this case, since the applicant's application for costs did not meet the threshold for engaging the court's discretion, and the respondents' application for costs was not substantiated, the court refused both applications.
The court distinguished this case from prior authority by clarifying that while it retains the power to award costs, such power is not to be exercised lightly and only in circumstances where the application itself is unreasonable or vexatious. The court followed the established principles of judicial discretion in awarding costs, as evidenced by the cited precedents, and did not depart from prior authority in doing so.