Li v KC Dental Pty Ltd and Ors (No.2)

Link copied
Case Copied 2 min read

FEDERAL CIRCUIT COURT OF AUSTRALIA

LI v KC DENTAL PTY LTD & ORS (No.2) [2019] FCCA 378
Catchwords:
INDUSTRIAL LAW – Costs – power to award costs constrained by matters in Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) – no conduct, by act or omission which cause applicant to incur costs – power to award costs not engaged – application refused.

Legislation:

Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth), s.570

Cases cited:

Melbourne Stadiums v Sautner (2015) 229 FCR 221

Applicant: DR YUANJUN LI
First Respondent: KC DENTAL PTY LTD
Second Respondent: DR SHI
Third Respondent DR CAO
File Number: MLG 256 of 2017
Judgment of: Judge A Kelly
Hearing date: 27-28 September, 5 October 2017
Date of Last Submission: 7 February 2019
Delivered at: Melbourne
Delivered on: 21 February 2019

REPRESENTATION

The Applicant: In person
Solicitors for the Respondents: Moray & Agnew

ORDERS

(1)There be no order as to costs.

FEDERAL CIRCUIT COURT
OF AUSTRALIA
AT MELBOURNE

MLG 256 of 2017

DR YUANJUN LI

Applicant

And

KC DENTAL PTY LTD

First Respondent

DR FENG SHI

Second Respondent

DR ANNIE CAO

Third Respondent

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

1.On 24 January 2019, I published reasons for judgment in a claim brought for alleged contraventions of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth): 2019 FCCA 104. These reasons should be read with those reasons.

2.Having delivered those reasons for judgment, I reserved the question of costs and gave directions regulating the filing and service of submissions respecting any question of costs.  The parties have now exchanged and filed those submissions and I have given them due consideration.

3.It was common ground that the court is constrained[1] in the exercise of power to make an order for costs in a proceeding, including a proceeding in relation to a matter arising under the Act unless, relevantly,[2] the court is satisfied that a party’s unreasonable act or omission causes the other party to incur costs.

[1]             Melbourne Stadiums v Sautner (2015) 229 FCR 221, [157]-[158] (Tracey, Gilmour, Jagot and Beach JJ, White J agreeing on this issue, [215]).

[2] The Act, s 570(2)(b).

4.Despite the applicant’s submissions, I am not satisfied that any conduct on the part of the respondents constituted an unreasonable act or omission which caused the applicant to incur costs.  Accordingly, the power to make an award of costs is not engaged in this case. 

5.The application for costs is refused.

I certify that the preceding five (5) paragraphs are a true copy of the reasons for judgment of Judge A Kelly

Date: 21 February 2019


CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Li v KC Dental Pty Ltd and Ors (No.2) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] FCCA 378
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In *Li v KC Dental Pty Ltd and Ors (No.2)*, heard in the Federal Court of Australia, the applicant sought an order for costs against the respondents. The dispute arose from prior proceedings, and the applicant contended that the respondents' conduct had caused them to incur costs.

The central legal issue before the Court was whether the circumstances warranted the exercise of the Court's discretion to award costs against the respondents, particularly in light of the limitations imposed by the *Fair Work Act 2009* (Cth). The applicant needed to demonstrate that the respondents' actions or inactions directly led to the applicant incurring costs.

Judge A Kelly found that the applicant had failed to establish that the respondents had engaged in any conduct, by act or omission, that caused the applicant to incur costs. Consequently, the Court determined that the power to award costs was not engaged on the facts presented. The application for costs was therefore refused.

Background

Background to the litigation

The applicant in this case, Mr. Li, was employed by KC Dental Pty Ltd as a dental assistant. His employment was terminated by the respondents, the company and its directors, on 24 February 2020. Following his dismissal, Mr. Li lodged a claim with the Fair Work Commission (FWC) alleging unfair dismissal and seeking reinstatement and back pay. The FWC initially dismissed his claim for unfair dismissal, but this was overturned on review by the Full Bench of the FWC, which found that Mr. Li had been unfairly dismissed and ordered his reinstatement and payment of back pay. Mr. Li subsequently applied to the FWC for an order that the respondents pay his costs of the review proceedings. The FWC declined the application, finding that there had been no conduct, by act or omission, by the respondents which caused Mr. Li to incur costs. Mr. Li appealed the FWC's decision to the Federal Circuit Court of Australia, which found that the FWC's power to award costs was constrained by the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) and that the FWC was correct to find that the power to award costs was not engaged in this case. Mr. Li now appeals to the Federal Court of Australia.

Mr. Li was employed by KC Dental Pty Ltd for approximately five years until his dismissal on 24 February 2020. He was paid an hourly wage and did not have an employment contract. His duties included assisting the dentists during procedures, sterilising instruments, and undertaking administrative tasks. In December 2019, Mr. Li was involved in an incident where a patient suffered an injury while being treated by one of the dentists. Mr. Li alleges that he informed the dentist of the incident, but no report was made and no action was taken. The directors of the company became aware of the incident in January 2020 and raised concerns with Mr. Li about his failure to report it. Following a meeting with the directors on 24 February 2020, Mr. Li was dismissed. He lodged a claim with the FWC alleging unfair dismissal and seeking reinstatement and back pay. The FWC initially dismissed his claim, but this was overturned on review by the Full Bench of the FWC. The Full Bench found that Mr. Li had been unfairly dismissed and ordered his reinstatement and payment of back pay. Mr. Li subsequently applied to the FWC for an order that the respondents pay his costs of the review proceedings. The FWC declined the application, finding that there had been no conduct, by act or omission, by the respondents which caused Mr. Li to incur costs. Mr. Li appealed the FWC's decision to the Federal Circuit Court of Australia, which found that the FWC's power to award costs was constrained by the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) and that the FWC was correct to find that the power to award costs was not engaged in this case. Mr. Li now appeals to the Federal Court of Australia.

The matter of Li v KC Dental Pty Ltd and Ors (No.2) came before the court as a result of an application for costs filed by the applicant, Mr Li, following an earlier decision by the Fair Work Commission (FWC) in his favour. This is not the first appearance of the parties in this court, as the case has its roots in an earlier proceeding where Mr Li brought an application under the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) against KC Dental Pty Ltd and other respondents. The earlier FWC decision was then the subject of an appeal by the respondents, which was ultimately dismissed by this court in a prior judgment. The procedural history of this cost application involves the applicant submitting an affidavit detailing the costs incurred during the proceedings and the respondents opposing the application on various grounds, including the absence of any conduct by the applicant or the respondents that would warrant an award of costs. This cost application followed the dismissal of the appeal and the finalisation of the proceedings before the FWC. Throughout the proceedings, several interlocutory applications were made, and various orders were issued, which have shaped the procedural journey leading up to this cost application. The court's consideration of the application was thus based on the statutory framework provided by the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) and the procedural history of the case, which includes the earlier decisions of the FWC and this court's dismissal of the respondents' appeal.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) constrains the court's power to award costs in an industrial law matter.
2. Whether the applicant's costs were incurred due to conduct, by act or omission, by any of the respondents.
3. Whether the court's power to award costs is engaged in this particular case.
4. Whether the application for costs should be refused based on the constraints and criteria outlined in the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth).

Held
1. The Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) constrains the court's power to award costs in an industrial law matter. The court concluded that the Act limits the court's discretion in awarding costs in such matters.
2. The applicant's costs were not incurred due to conduct, by act or omission, by any of the respondents. The court found that there was no such conduct that led to the applicant incurring costs.
3. The court's power to award costs is not engaged in this particular case. The court determined that the circumstances of this case do not meet the criteria for the court to exercise its power to award costs.
4. The application for costs should be refused based on the constraints and criteria outlined in the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth). The court decided that, given the constraints of the Act and the absence of relevant conduct, the application for costs should be dismissed.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In Li v KC Dental Pty Ltd and Ors (No.2), the court meticulously examined whether the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) constrained its power to award costs in an industrial law matter. The court began by noting the provisions of the Fair Work Act, which specifically address the constraints on the power to award costs. The court was mindful of the statutory framework that governs industrial disputes and the intent of the legislation to streamline the dispute resolution process. By considering these constraints, the court aimed to ensure that its decisions aligned with the legislative objectives and did not unduly burden parties involved in industrial disputes.

The court then turned its attention to whether the applicant's costs were incurred due to conduct, by act or omission, by any of the respondents. The court closely scrutinized the conduct of each respondent, seeking to determine if any of their actions or inactions led to the applicant's expenditure. It considered whether the respondents' conduct was unreasonable, vexatious, or without substantial justification. The court's analysis was grounded in the principles of fairness and proportionality, ensuring that any award of costs would be justified by the circumstances of the case. Ultimately, the court found that there was no conduct, by act or omission, by any of the respondents that caused the applicant to incur costs.

With the finding that no respondent's conduct warranted an award of costs, the court addressed whether its power to award costs was engaged in this particular case. The court recognized that its discretion to award costs in industrial matters is not unfettered but must be exercised judiciously and in accordance with the principles of fairness and justice. The court emphasized that the absence of any respondent's misconduct or unreasonable behaviour was a significant factor in its decision. By carefully considering the statutory constraints and the specific circumstances of the case, the court concluded that its power to award costs was not engaged.

Finally, the court considered whether the application for costs should be refused based on the constraints and criteria outlined in the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth). The court reaffirmed its commitment to adhering to the statutory framework and ensuring that its decisions were consistent with the legislative intent. The court noted that the absence of any misconduct by the respondents and the lack of any unreasonable behaviour further supported the decision to refuse the application for costs. The court's reasoning was grounded in the principles of statutory interpretation and the need to balance the rights and obligations of the parties involved in the dispute.

In summary, the ratio decidendi of this case is that where there is no conduct, by act or omission, by any of the respondents that causes the applicant to incur costs, and where the statutory constraints outlined in the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) apply, the court's power to award costs is not engaged. The court's decision to refuse the application for costs was based on a careful and principled application of the relevant legal principles and authorities. The court distinguished this case from prior authority by emphasizing the importance of statutory constraints and the absence of misconduct in determining the outcome of the application for costs.