LGM Enterprises Pty Ltd v Brisbane City Council

Link copied
Case Copied 34 min read

LAND COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION: LGM Enterprises Pty Ltd v Brisbane City Council [2009] QLC 0178
PARTIES: LGM Enterprises Pty Ltd
(claimant)
v.
Brisbane City Council
(respondent)
FILE NO: AQL 820/07 formerly A2007/0820
DIVISION: Land Court of Queensland
PROCEEDINGS: Claim for compensation pursuant to the Acquisition of Land Act 1967

HEARD ON:

2, 3, 4 and 5 November 2009

DELIVERED ON: 27 November 2009
HEARD AT: Brisbane
DELIVERED AT: Brisbane
MEMBER: Mr RS Jones
ORDER:

1.    Compensation is determined in the amount of one hundred and fifty two thousand two hundred and fifty dollars ($152,250).

2.    I order that the respondent pay interest at the rate of 5.25% per cent per annum on the amount of $152,250 from the date of resumption, 7 January 2005, to the date of the payment of the advance, 11 July 2009, and thereafter on the amount of $116,594 up to the day immediately proceeding the day upon which the balance of the compensation is paid.

CATCHWORDS:

COMPENSATION – Acquisition of Land Act 1967 – Compensation For Loss Of Business – Compensation For Loss Of Business During Construction Period – Compensation For Future Economic Loss – DISTURBANCE – Claim For Compensation For Time Of Director Of Claimant Company – Legal Costs Associated With Proceedings Other Than In The Land Court – Legal Fees Incurred In Proceedings Not Under Acquisition of Land Act 1967 – Professional Fees

Acquisition of Land Act 1967 s.12(5), s. 20
Retail Shop Leases Act 1994 s. 43
Goods and Services Tax Ruling 2006/9

Nevis Pty Ltd v Department of Main Roads (1999-2001) 22 QLCR 231
Barns v Department of Transport (1996-1997) 16 QLCR 22
Marshall v Department of Transport (2000-2001) 205 CLR 603
Sorrento Medical Service Pty Ltd v Department of Main Roads (2007) 151 LGERA 328
Harvey v Crawley Development Corp (1957) 1 All ER 504
Director of Buildings and Lands v Shun Fung Ironworks Ltd (1995) 1 All ER 846
Heavey Lex No. 64 Pty Ltd v Department of Transport (2001) 22 QLCR 177 (LAC)
Robertsons Furniture & Design (Qld) Pty Ltd v Department of Main Roads (2005) QLC 001

APPEARANCES:

Mr LG McGinn, Director and Secretary of LGM Enterprises Pty Ltd, for the claimant

Mr Hinson SC, instructed by Ms S Green of Brisbane City Legal Practice, for the respondent

Background

  1. Pursuant to the Acquisition of Land Act 1967 (ALA), on 7 January 2005 the respondent resumed 36m² of land located on the corner of Appleby Road and Rode Road, Chermside.  The purpose underlying the taking of the land was the upgrading of the Appleby Road/Maundrell Terrace and Rode Road intersection and associated roadworks. The resumed land is now described as Lot 1 on Survey Plan 172404 and the parent parcel is described as Lot 2 on Registered Plan 117943.

  2. Constructed on the parent parcel of land is a relatively small shopping centre containing a floor area of about 484 m2 which is divided into five tenancies. At the date of resumption the whole of the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read LGM Enterprises Pty Ltd v Brisbane City Council and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2009] QLC 178
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

LGM Enterprises Pty Ltd brought proceedings against Brisbane City Council in the Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal, seeking compensation for losses incurred due to roadworks carried out by the Council in the vicinity of their shopping centre. The primary issues for determination were the extent to which the roadworks impacted LGM's business operations, the duration of the disruption, and the appropriate compensation for losses incurred during and after the construction period. The court also considered claims for future economic loss and compensation for the time expended by a director of LGM in managing the proceedings.

In examining the nature and duration of the works, the Tribunal relied heavily on the evidence of Mr Arneil, the respondent's project manager, who detailed the extensive works including drainage, road surface, and pavement works, as well as the relocation of street lighting and traffic signals. The Tribunal concluded that the roadworks had a significant and detrimental impact on LGM's business operations. Although Mr McGinn, a representative of LGM, tended to exaggerate the extent of the disruption, the Tribunal accepted that the roadworks caused considerable stress and material interference with the centre's operations. The Tribunal found that the impact of the roadworks was evident in the trading figures and business projections presented by LGM.

The Tribunal awarded compensation of $152,250 to LGM, along with interest on the compensation amount from the date of resumption to the date of payment. The interest rate was set at 5.25% per annum for the period up to the payment of the advance, and thereafter on the reduced amount of $116,594. The Tribunal took into account the various heads of compensation claimed by LGM, including loss of business during the construction period and future economic loss, but did not award compensation for the time of the director or legal fees incurred outside the scope of the Acquisition of Land Act 1967. The decision reflects a careful balancing of the evidence and submissions, ensuring that the compensation awarded was commensurate with the substantiated losses incurred by LGM due to the respondent's roadworks.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Compensation is determined in the amount of one hundred and fifty two thousand two hundred and fifty dollars ($152,250).

2. I order that the respondent pay interest at the rate of 5.25% per cent per annum on the amount of $152,250 from the date of resumption, 7 January 2005, to the date of the payment of the advance, 11 July 2009, and thereafter on the amount of $116,594 up to the day immediately proceeding the day upon which the balance of the compensation is paid.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

For the sake of convenience, in determining this claim I will broadly follow the various heads of compensation as particularised by LGM and set out above. Nature and duration of works The nature, extent and duration of the roadworks carried out by the respondent in the vicinity of the subject land were matters touched on by nearly every witness called to give evidence. Not surprisingly the level of observation and recollection of detail varied significantly between witnesses. The best evidence about the nature, extent and duration of the works was that given by Mr Arneil. Mr Arneil was the project manager employed by the respondent. Mr Arneil is a qualified civil engineer and a registered professional engineer of Queensland. His duties as the project manager included the programming and timing of the works and management of the construction teams employed to complete the roadworks. Mr Arneil was on site daily during the construction period. Most of his evidence was not seriously challenged. The works are set out in some detail in the affidavit of Mr Arneil[6] and there is no need to repeat them here other than to identify that major elements of those works included drainage works, road surface works (including gullies, rock walls and asphalting) and pavement works. The works also included the relocation of street lighting and traffic signals at and about the intersection of Appleby Road/Maundrell Terrace and Rode Road and the relocation of a bus shelter from the south western side of the intersection to the north western side some distance from the subject land.[6] Ex. 12. In total the works continued over about 220 days and 30 additional nights. Substantial water filled barricades were erected where works were taking place which not only obstructed access to and from the centre but also made viewing the centre and its access points difficult from time to time. The Appleby Road driveway had to be entirely replaced. There is no doubt that on a regular basis the intersection suffered significant traffic congestion and access to and from the centre was materially interfered with. There is also evidence that from time to time customer car parking might have been made inconvenient but not to the extent of there being insufficient parking spaces to satisfy customer demand. As Mr McGinn acknowledged, the actual nature of the works is not the real issue. The real issue is whether or not the roadworks carried out by the respondent, whatever they were, interfered with the business of LGM and, to a significant extent, that impact should be able to be derived from an analysis of the trading figures and business projections of LGM. Having regard to the totality of the evidence surrounding this issue I have concluded that the roadworks carried out by the respondent both during and after the actual construction phase had a material and deleterious impact on the business of LGM. However, in this context I agree with the submission made by Mr Hinson SC that Mr McGinn, in a number of instances, tended to exaggerate or overstate the extent of inconvenience. Mr Hinson was at pains to point out that this was not an attack on the credibility of Mr McGinn but rather a statement of fact. The evidence is quite clear that Mr McGinn found the roadworks an extremely stressful period and it is not surprising that at least in some instances he might have been prone to see things worse than they actually were.