Lewis v Holder & Ors No. Scciv-03-445

Link copied
Case Copied 39 min read

LEWIS v HOLDER
[2003] SASC 266

Magistrates Appeal

  1. Gray J     This is a Crown appeal against the dismissal of a complaint by a magistrate.

    The Magistrate’s Court Proceedings

    The Complaint

  2. Dennis Mark Holder, Karen Louise Pty Ltd and Karen Louise Holder were charged with offences contrary to provisions of the Fisheries Act 1982 (SA). The defendants were represented by the same counsel. All pleaded not guilty.

    The complaint against Mr Holder was as follows:  

    Between 15 September 2001 and 16 September 2001 inclusive at Blanche Harbour-Douglas Bank Aquatic Reserve in the waters of the State of South Australia, the first defendant engaged in a fishing activity in an aquatic reserve, which activity was not a permitted activity.

    Contrary to section 48G(1)(b) of the Fisheries Act, 1982.

    Particulars

    1.1At all material times, the first defendant was a registered master by endorsement on the Blue Crab Fishery Licence No K06.

    1.2The boat ‘Peter Crombie’ was a registered boat by endorsement on the said licence.

    1.3The first defendant, while on the boat ‘Peter Crombie’, used crab pots to take 200kg of Blue Crab (Portunus pelagicus) in an aquatic reserve namely Blanche Harbour-Douglas Bank Aquatic Reserve.

    1.4The first defendant was not the holder of a permit issued pursuant to section 48G of the Fisheries Act, 1982.

    1.5The taking of Blue Crab using crab pots is not a permitted fishing activity within the Blanche Harbour-Douglas Bank Aquatic reserve, as described in the Schedule to the Fisheries (Aquatic Reserves) Regulations, 1989.

    ANDthe complainant further alleges tht the wholesale value of the fish at the time at which they were taken was $1200.

    Section 48G provides:

    (1) Except as provided by the regulations or pursuant to a permit under this section, a person must not—

    ...     

    (b) engage in any fishing activity in an aquatic reserve ...

  3. The complaint against Karen Louise Pty Ltd was as follows:

    Between 15 September 2001 and 16 September 2001 inclusive at Blanche Harbour-Douglas Bank Aquatic Reserve in the waters of the State of South Australia, the second defendant was the registered owner of the boat ‘Peter Crombie’, as holder of Blue Crab Fishery Licence No K06, on which the first defendant was registered by endorsement as master, which boat was used in the commission of an offence against the Fisheries Act, 1982, when the first defendant used the boat to engage in a fishing activity in an aquatic reserve, which activity was not a permitted activity.

    Contrary to section 48G(1)(b) and sections 69(3) and 69(4)(a) of the Fisheries Act, 1982.

    Particulars

    2.1At all material times, the second defendant was a body corporate and the holder of Blue Crab Fishery Licence No K06.

    2.2The first defendant was a registered master by endorsement on the said licence.

    2.3The boat ‘Peter Crombie’ was a registered boat by endorsement on the said licence.

    2.4Between 15 September 2001 and 16 September 2001, the first defendant, while on the boat ‘Peter Crombie’, used crab pots to take 200kg of Blue Crab (

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Lewis v Holder & Ors No. Scciv-03-445 and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2003] SASC 266
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Lewis v Holder & Ors No. Scciv-03-445, the appeal involved the defendants, Dennis Mark Holder, Karen Louise Holder Pty Ltd, and Karen Louise Holder, who were charged with fishing in an aquatic reserve, contrary to section 48G(1) of the Fisheries Act, 1984. The Crown sought to adduce further evidence in support of the appeal, which the defendants opposed. The appeal raised issues concerning the admissibility of the evidence and the magistrate's handling of the case. The key legal issues were whether the magistrate had erred in excluding the record of interview and whether the caution given to the defendant was adequate.

The court found that the magistrate had failed to have proper regard to all of the evidence. The defendant was aware of the specific nature of the offences under enquiry and that he was being investigated about illegal fishing. He was aware of the time, place, and circumstances of the alleged conduct and was expecting the investigators to arrive. The magistrate was in error in concluding that the defendant had no idea whatsoever that he was facing potential charges under the Fisheries legislation. Such a finding was not supported by the evidence. The court concluded that the caution that was given was adequate, and no unfairness to the defendant arose. The magistrate erred in excluding the record of interview, which was admissible. The Crown's proposed further evidence should be received, and any other legitimate complaints regarding the admissibility of the interview or specific parts of the interview could be addressed on the further hearing. The charge against the defendant should not have been dismissed, and the defendants had a case to answer.

The court set aside the order of the magistrate dismissing the complaint against the three defendants. The matter was remitted for further hearing, and the court ordered that the charge against the defendants should not have been dismissed. The defendants had a case to answer, and the matter would be heard again in court. The court's decision was based on the evidence presented and the legal issues raised in the case. The court found that the magistrate had not properly considered all of the evidence and had made an error in excluding the record of interview, which was admissible. The court's decision was based on the principle that the defendants had a right to a fair hearing, and the evidence presented should have been considered in determining the outcome of the case.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The appeal is authorised by section 42. This court has jurisdiction to hear and determine the appeal. Further Evidence Counsel for the Crown made an application to this Court to receive further evidence. It was not submitted that this evidence was strictly necessary, but out of an abundance of caution, the application was pressed. An affidavit in support of the application sworn by counsel for the crown at trial provided inter alia:I was instructed to prosecute Dennis Mark Holder (“the first defendant”), Karen Louise Holder Pty Ltd (“the second defendant”) and Karen Louise Holder (“the third defendant”). The defendants were charged with fishing in an aquatic reserve, contrary to section 48G(1) of the Fisheries Act, 1984. The defendants indicated that they would be pleading not guilty, and the matter was set down for trial on 10 March 2003.Exhibited to this affidavit and marked as indicated are the following documents:(a) Section 67 certificate indicating that the second defendant was the holder of a Blue Crab Fishery Licence, No K06 – “Exhibit FLL1”;(b) Copy of Blue Crab Fishery Licence No K06 – “Exhibit FLL2”;(c) Section 67 certificate indicating that the first defendant was a registered master by endorsement on licence K06 – “Exhibit FLL3”;(d) Company extract indicating that the third defendant was the sole director of the second defendant – “Exhibit FLL4”(e) Copy of the gazettal dated 27 July 1989 by which the Blanche Harbour – Douglas Bank Aquatic Reserve was proclaimed – “Exhibit FLL5”(f) Bundle of three section 67 certificates, one for each defendant, indicating that none of the defendants were the holder of a permit under section 48G – “Exhibit FLL6”The documents comprising Exhibits FLL1-5 were provided to the defence well in advance of the trial as documents upon which the prosecution would rely. The bundle of documents comprising Exhibit FLL6 was provided to the defence of the morning of the trial as further documents upon which the prosecution would rely.…After some discussion, [the magistrate] decided that a voir dire would be held. Prior to the commencement of the voir dire, [the magistrate] invited a brief opening from me to provide some background to the matter. During the course of my opening submissions, I attempted to tender a number of documents. [Defence counsel] objected to this course. Subsequently, [the magistrate] indicated that it was not the appropriate time to tender them, and that they could be dealt with after the voir dire. Had I been permitted to tender documents as part of my opening, I would have tendered the documents in Exhibits FLL1-6, as outlined in [the paragraph] above.Subsequently, [the magistrate] ruled that the interview was inadmissible. After that ruling, I tendered no further evidence as I thought it would be futile to continue with the case in the absence of the record of interview. At the time, I did not consider the potential significance of tendering the documents marked Exhibit FLL1-6 in relation to a possible appeal.

Decision

Reasons for decision

The magistrate failed to have proper regard to all of the evidence. Mr Holder was aware of the specific nature of the offences under enquiry and that he was being investigated about illegal fishing. He was aware of the time, the place and the circumstances of the alleged conduct. He was expecting the investigators to arrive. He had prepared himself to put his side of the story. He sought to demonstrate that he was fishing legally. The magistrate was in error in concluding that Mr Holder had no idea whatsoever that he was facing potential charges under the Fisheries legislation. Such a finding was not supported by the evidence. Conclusion In this case the caution that was given was adequate. No unfairness to Mr Holder arose. The magistrate erred in excluding the record of interview. The record of interview was admissible.[10] As earlier observed the further evidence proposed to be led by the Crown should be received.[10] Counsel for the defendants foreshadowed the possibility of other unspecified challenges to the admissibility of the interview or specific parts of the interview. If other legitimate complaints are identified the magistrate will be able to address these matters on the further hearing. Having regard to the contents of the record of interview Mr Holder had a case to answer. The charge against him should not have been dismissed. Karen Louise Pty Ltd and Ms Holder also had a case to answer. The order of the magistrate dismissing the complaint against the three defendants is set aside. The matter is remitted for further hearing.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.