Lestery Pty Ltd, Lessue and Lessue v Quetel Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 22 min read
IN THE COURT OF APPEAL [1993] QCA 439
SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND

C.A. No. 72 of 1993

Brisbane

[Lestery v. Quetel]

BETWEEN:

LESTERY PTY. LTD.

(First Plaintiff)

- and -

GEOFFREY ROBERT LESSUE and
DENISE ELIZABETH LESSUE

(Second Plaintiffs) Appellants

- and -

QUETEL PTY LTD

(Defendant) Respondent

ÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄ

ÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄ

The Chief Justice
The President

Mr Justice Cullinane

ÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄ

ÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄ

Judgment delivered 01/11/93

Reasons for judgment prepared by the President and
Cullinane J. jointly, the Chief Justice dissenting
ÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄ
ÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄ
APPEAL ALLOWED. RESPONDENT'S APPLICATION DISMISSED.
RESPONDENT TO PAY THE APPELLANTS' COSTS HERE AND IN THE
COURT BELOW.
ÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄ
ÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄÄ

CATCHWORDS: DECLARATIONS - Hypothetical issue - whether issue as to validity of specific provisions in a contract is hypothetical when provisions to operate only in event of a contingency.

Counsel:  Mr A.J.H. Morris Q.C. for the appellants.
Mr P. Keane Q.C. with him Mr P. Freeburn for
the respondent.
Solicitors:  Lyons for the appellants.
Minter Ellison Morris Fletcher for the
respondent.

Hearing date: 22/09/93
IN THE COURT OF APPEAL

SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND

Appeal No. 72 of 1993

Brisbane

Before

Chief Justice The President Mr Justice Cullinane

[Lestery & Ors v. Quetel]

BETWEEN:

LESTERY PTY LTD

(First Plaintiff)

- and -

GEOFFREY ROBERT LESSUE and

DENISE ELIZABETH LESSUE

(Second Plaintiffs) Appellants

- and -

QUETEL PTY LTD

(Defendant) Respondent

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT - THE CHIEF JUSTICE

Judgment delivered 1/11/93

The President in his reasons has set out the issues and referred to the authorities which would justify a conclusion that the court's jurisdiction to grant declarations extends to cover proceedings such as these. Notwithstanding the availability of the jurisdiction, I would not be disposed to interfere with the decision of the primary judge that jurisdiction should be declined in this case.

The court was told the minimum about the commercial consequences for the plaintiffs of a claim by them under s. 18B of the repealed Act for a share of the annual licence fees if such a claim were to draw in response a demand by the defendant for "additional clear yearly rental". The court was left to deduce that such a consequence might make any claim for a share of the fees not worthwhile or not as worthwhile.

The plaintiffs will have had all of the usual opportunities for access to their own legal advisers for assistance in making a decision about the way in which they should proceed but what is obviously sought from the declaration proceedings is advice from the court which will have the effect of further clarifying the choice for them.

The plaintiffs wish, in effect, to know whether in their own interests they should proceed in one way rather than another but the situation is one where no party is threatening proceedings against them or bringing pressure to bear to force them towards any particular decision.

The present case lies in a sort of middle area between two contrasting categories where, on the one hand, the jurisdiction to grant the remedy of declaration…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Lestery Pty Ltd, Lessue and Lessue v Quetel Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1993] QCA 439
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Lestery Pty Ltd, along with Geoffrey Robert Lessue and Denise Elizabeth Lessue, appealed against Quetel Pty Ltd in the Supreme Court of Queensland. The appellants sought declaratory relief concerning a transaction involving licensed premises known as "The Logan City Tavern." The appellants argued that Lestery Pty Ltd was entitled to a share of the annual license fees paid to the Licensing Commission of Queensland for certain years. The respondents claimed that the appellants' claim was hypothetical because no demand had been made for the fees. The central legal issue was whether an issue regarding the validity of specific provisions in a contract is hypothetical when those provisions are contingent on an event that may not occur. The court referenced several cases to establish the principles governing the granting of declaratory relief. The court held that the appellants' claim was not hypothetical, as there was a present dispute between the parties about the validity of the lease provisions. The court concluded that the grant of a declaration was within its jurisdiction and a proper exercise of its discretion, as it would determine a real controversy between the parties and produce foreseeable consequences. The appeal was allowed, the respondent's application was dismissed, and the respondent was ordered to pay the appellants' costs in both the Court of Appeal and the Court below.

Background

Background to the litigation

Lestery Pty Ltd is the lessee of licensed premises known as "The Logan City Tavern", owned by Quetel Pty Ltd. Lestery Pty Ltd, along with Geoffrey Robert Lessue and Denise Elizabeth Lessue, who are directors of Lestery Pty Ltd and guarantors of its obligations, are seeking a declaration that they are entitled to receive a share of the annual license fees paid to the Licensing Commission of Queensland. The lease agreement between Lestery Pty Ltd and Quetel Pty Ltd includes a clause that requires additional rent to be paid if a demand is made for the license fee share. Lestery Pty Ltd and the Lessues contend that this clause is void and unenforceable.

This case is an appeal from an order made in the Trial Division of the Supreme Court of Queensland, which struck out the appellants' Statement of Claim and dismissed their action. The appeal was heard in the Court of Appeal of the Supreme Court of Queensland, with the Chief Justice dissenting. The appeal was allowed, the respondent's application was dismissed, and the respondent was ordered to pay the appellants' costs in both the Court of Appeal and the Trial Division.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Does the Court have jurisdiction to grant declaratory relief when the provisions in question are contingent upon an event that has not occurred and might not occur?
2. Is the issue regarding the validity of specific provisions in a contract hypothetical when the provisions are intended to operate only in the event of a contingency which might not occur?
3. Should the Court decline to grant declaratory relief in this case due to the hypothetical nature of the issue and the lack of a present dispute between the parties?

Held
1. The Court has jurisdiction to grant declaratory relief when the provisions in question are contingent upon an event that has not occurred and might not occur.
2. The issue regarding the validity of specific provisions in a contract is not hypothetical when the provisions are intended to operate only in the event of a contingency which might not occur, if there is a present dispute between the parties.
3. The Court should not decline to grant declaratory relief in this case due to the hypothetical nature of the issue and the lack of a present dispute between the parties.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Court of Appeal in Lestery v Quetel addressed the issue of whether the court has jurisdiction to grant declaratory relief when the provisions in question are contingent upon an event that has not occurred and might not occur. The court held that the jurisdiction to grant such relief is well-established, and the exercise of this jurisdiction is discretionary and confined by the considerations that mark out the boundaries of judicial power. The court noted that declaratory relief must be directed to the determination of legal controversies and not to answering abstract or hypothetical questions. However, the court found that the appellants' claim was not purely hypothetical as there was a present dispute between the parties concerning the validity of the contractual provisions.

The court further held that the issue regarding the validity of specific provisions in a contract is not hypothetical when the provisions are intended to operate only in the event of a contingency which might not occur, if there is a present dispute between the parties. The court distinguished the case from earlier decisions that favoured the view that a declaration of the liability of an insurer to indemnify its insured should not be made before the liability of the insured to the person claiming the declaration is established. The court found that the appellants' claim was not hypothetical as it involved a present dispute between the parties, and the resolution of that dispute would determine a real controversy between the parties and produce foreseeable consequences for them.

Finally, the court held that the Court should not decline to grant declaratory relief in this case due to the hypothetical nature of the issue and the lack of a present dispute between the parties. The court found that the respondent was not entitled to the summary dismissal of the appellants' claim, and the appeal should be allowed and the respondent's application dismissed. The court found that the grant of such a declaration was well within the Court's jurisdiction and a proper exercise of its discretion. The ratio decidendi of the case is that the court has jurisdiction to grant declaratory relief when there is a present dispute between the parties, even if the provisions in question are contingent upon an event that has not occurred and might not occur.