Lester Land Holdings Pty Ltd v The Development Assessment Commission (No 2)

Link copied
Case Copied 19 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Civil: Application for Judicial Review)

LESTER LAND HOLDINGS PTY LTD & ORS v THE DEVELOPMENT ASSESSMENT COMMISSION & ANOR (No 2)

[2020] SASC 214

Judgment of The Honourable Justice Parker

3 November 2020

ADMINISTRATIVE LAW - JUDICIAL REVIEW - PROCEDURE AND EVIDENCE - COSTS

PROCEDURE - CIVIL PROCEEDINGS IN STATE AND TERRITORY COURTS - COSTS

PROCEDURE - CIVIL PROCEEDINGS IN STATE AND TERRITORY COURTS - COSTS - GENERAL RULE: COSTS FOLLOW EVENT - PARTIAL SUCCESS

Application for costs.

The applicant succeeded in an application for judicial review of a decision made by the first respondent on 21 January 2016 to grant development plan consent in favour of the second respondent for the proposed development of land located at the south-east corner of the junction of North Terrace and West Terrace. The applicants were granted an order in the nature of certiorari quashing the decision of the first respondent.

At trial, the applicants challenged the decision of the first respondent to grant development plan consent on five grounds. Ultimately, the applicants only succeeded on one of those grounds.

The applicants seek an order that they be awarded their costs in accordance with the ordinary principle that costs follow the event. An order for costs is opposed by the respondents. The first and second respondents both submit that each party should bear their own costs. Further, in the event that an order for costs is made, the first respondent submits that it should not bear the costs of the other parties.

Held, per Parker J:

1.  The applicants were successful in having the decision of the first respondent quashed, however they failed on several significant matters. It is appropriate to depart to some extent from the general rule that costs follow the event by ordering that the second respondent pay 60 percent of the costs of the first, second and third applicants on a party/party basis.

2.  No order for costs is made against the first respondent on the basis that it did not add in any significant way to the costs incurred by the other parties and did not become an adversary in the proceedings. The first respondent’s role in the proceedings was restricted to providing assistance to the Court on matters of law, fact and administrative procedure.

Development Regulations 2008 (SA), referred to.
A, DC v Prince Alfred College Inc (No 2) [2016] SASCFC 27, applied.
Fernando v Medical Complaints Tribunal (2007) 16 Tas R 237; R (Davies) v Birmingham Deputy Coroner [2004] 3 All ER 543; Southern Cross Pipelines Australia Pty Ltd v Kenneth Comninos Michael Western Australian Independent Gas Pipelines Access Regulator [2002] WASC 316, discussed.
McFadzean v CFMEU (2007) 20 VR 250; Playford Vineyard Pty Ltd v Wishford Nominees Pty Ltd (No 4) [2020] SASC 204; R v Australian Broadcasting Tribunal; Ex parte Hardiman (1980) 144 CLR 13, considered.

LESTER LAND HOLDINGS PTY LTD & ORS v THE DEVELOPMENT ASSESSMENT COMMISSION & ANOR (No 2)
[2020] SASC…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Lester Land Holdings Pty Ltd v The Development Assessment Co... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2020] SASC 214
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Lester Land Holdings Pty Ltd v The Development Assessment Commission (No 2) involves a dispute over the allocation of costs in a judicial review proceeding. The applicants, Lester Land Holdings, sought judicial review of a decision made by the Development Assessment Commission (DAC), the second respondent in this case. The primary focus of the case was on the principles governing the award of costs in cases where a successful party has not prevailed on all issues. The applicants argued for a deviation from the general rule that costs follow the event, while the DAC contended that there were no special circumstances justifying a deviation from this principle.

The court was required to decide whether the general rule that costs follow the event should be modified in light of the applicants' partial success in the judicial review proceedings. The DAC argued that the applicants should bear the costs of the issues on which they failed, while the applicants sought a more equitable distribution of costs. The court had to balance the principles of cost allocation against the need to discourage parties from bringing claims of doubtful merit and to ensure the efficient resolution of litigation.

The court, in applying the well-established principles governing the award of costs, recognised that while the general rule is that costs follow the event, there are circumstances where the court may exercise its discretion to modify this rule. The court referred to the principles articulated in A, DC v Prince Alfred College Inc (No 2) and Playford Vineyard Pty Ltd v Wishford Nominees Pty Ltd (No 4), which emphasise that the interests of justice sometimes require a reduction in the costs that would otherwise be awarded to a successful party when that party has failed on particular disputed questions of fact or law. The court acknowledged that the legal profession has a duty to advise on the relative merits of the possible claims and defences and on the cost and time implications of pursuing those claims. The court concluded that the applicants should bear the costs of the issues on which they failed, given the lack of special circumstances justifying a deviation from the general rule.

The final orders of the court were that the applicants bear the costs of the issues on which they failed, reflecting the principle that costs ordinarily follow the event unless special circumstances justify a different order. The court did not find any special circumstances in this case that would warrant a deviation from the general rule.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The second respondent submits that there was no basis to relieve DAC from the obligation to make an equal contribution to any costs awarded to the applicants should its primary submissions not be accepted.Consideration The Full Court in A, DC v Prince Alfred College Inc (No 2) provided a comprehensive statement of the principles governing the award of costs in cases where a successful party has failed on some issues:[7] [7] [2016] SASCFC 27 at [5]-[13]. These principles were recently applied by Stanley J in Playford Vineyard Pty Ltd v Wishford Nominees Pty Ltd (No 4) [2020] SASC 204.[5]The principles governing the exercise of the costs discretion are well established. The Court exercises a judicial discretion with respect to costs in which the general rule is that costs ordinarily follow the event unless there are special circumstances justifying another order. In more recent times, courts more readily modify the general rule recognising that the interests of justice sometimes require a reduction in the costs that would otherwise have been awarded to a successful party when that party has failed on particular disputed questions of fact or law. In Ruddock v Vardalis (No 2), Black CJ and French J summarised the principles as follows: Within the general discretion of the courts to award costs it is accepted by decisions in both Australian and English jurisdictions that:•Ordinarily costs follow the event and a successful litigant receives costs in the absence of special circumstances justifying some other order.•Where a litigant has succeeded only upon a portion of the claim, the circumstances may make it reasonable that the litigant bear the expense of litigating that portion upon which he or she has failed.•A successful party who has failed on certain issues may not only be deprived of the costs of those issues but may be ordered as well to pay the other parties' costs of them. In this sense “issue” does not mean a precise issue in the technical pleading sense but any disputed question of fact or law.[6]The modification of the ordinary rule to reflect the way in which particular issues in the litigation are determined is a response to those ‘cases in which issues are raised which unduly extend the time and expense of litigation’. [7]In Victoria and Master Builders Association of Victoria Ormiston JA explained that in an era of high cost litigation it had become necessary to more often allocate costs according to success on particular issue[s] because ‘regrettably there are many cases in which issues are raised which unduly extend the time and expense of litigation’. Those observations were echoed in Mickelberg v Western Australia by Newens J who referred also to ‘the burdens imposed on the public resources of the Court’ by parties pursuing claims on which they are ultimately not successful.[8]Just as parties must make a cost benefit and risk analysis decision on whether to bring an action at all, so too must decisions be made about which claims to include within an action. Parties should not be encouraged to add to a claim which has sufficient prospects, in itself, to justify the bringing of an action other claims, of doubtful merit, on the assumption that the costs of pursuing the latter claims will be recovered because of success on the good claim. [9]In adversarial litigation the parties and their legal advisors carry the primary responsibility for ensuring the cost-effectiveness of litigation because they have a particular knowledge and understanding of the controversy, and the available evidence, which the court cannot know because of legal professional privilege.[10]It is therefore the responsibility of the legal profession to actively consider the affect of adding doubtful claims, or mounting defences to good claims without any foundation for doing so, on the efficient resolution of the proceedings. In accordance with that duty legal practitioners must give advice on the relative merits of the possible claims and defences and on the cost and time implications of pursuing those claims so that the litigant is in a position to give informed instructions on how to conduct the proceedings.[11]The authorities to which we have referred make it clear that the rule does not only apply to a ‘precise issue in the technical pleading sense’ but extends to any substantial disputed question of fact or law. There is of course a limit to the dissection of an action which is practicably possible.[12]On the other hand, the court should not be overly parsimonious in the award of costs to a plaintiff who has won a judgment against a wrongdoer who has denied liability on all of the grounds of the plaintiff’s claim. [13]There can be no precision in the balancing of the tension between the ordinary rule and its qualification. Much will depend on the extent to which the costs of the litigation of the separate issues can easily be separated out and on the reasonableness of the forensic decision of the successful party to pursue, not only the claims on which he or she succeeded, but also those claims on which he or she failed.(Citations omitted)