Lenthall v Westpac Life Insurance Services Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 43 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Lenthall v Westpac Life Insurance Services Limited [2018] FCA 1422

File number: NSD 1812 of 2017
Judge: LEE J
Date of judgment: 18 September 2018
Catchwords: REPRESENTATIVE PROCEEDINGS – representative proceeding under Part IVA of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) – open class – application for common fund order – applicable principles – whether appropriate to make common fund order – desirability for amount to be paid to a funder increases as the risk undertaken by the funder increases and that any percentage commission payable to a funder be struck by reference to net resolution sum
Legislation:

Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) Pt IVA, s 33C

FCR 9.12(2)

Cases cited:

Australian Executor Trustee Ltd v Provident Capital Ltd [2018] FCA 439

Blairgowrie Trading Ltd v Allco Finance Group (recs & mgrs apptd) (in liq) [2015] FCA 811; (2015) 325 ALR 539 Caason Investments Pty Limited v Cao (No 2) [2018] FCA 527

Hodges v Sandhurst Trustees Limited [2018] FCA 1346

Impiombato v BHP Billiton Limited [2018] FCA 1272

McKay Super Solutions Pty Ltd (Trustee) v Bellamy’s Australia Ltd [2017] FCA 947

Modtech Engineering Pty Ltd v GPT Management Holdings Ltd [2013] FCA 626

Money Max Int Pty Ltd (Trustee) v QBE Insurance Group Limited [2016] FCAFC 148; (2016) 245 FCR 191

Pearson v State of Queensland [2017] FCA 1096

Perera v GetSwift Limited [2018] FCA 732; (2018) 127 ACSR 1

Wileypark Pty Ltd v AMP Limited [2018] FCAFC 143

Legg, M, “A Critical Assessment of the Shareholder Class Action Settlements - The Allco Class Action” (2018) 46 Australian Business Law Review 46

Date of hearing: 25, 26 June 2018
Registry: New South Wales
Division: General Division
National Practice Area: Commercial and Corporations
Sub-area: Commercial Contracts, Banking, Finance and Insurance
Number of paragraphs: 65
Counsel for the Applicants: Mr A S Martin with Mr T L Bagley
Solicitor for the Applicants: Shine Lawyers
Counsel for the Respondents: Mr A Leopold SC with Mr S Free
Solicitor for the Respondents: Allens
Counsel for the Intervener: Mr N Hutley SC with Ms S Tame
Solicitor for the Intervener: Robert & Partners Lawyers

ORDERS

NSD 1812 of 2017
BETWEEN:

GREGORY JOHN LENTHALL

First Applicant

SHARMILA LENTHALL

Second Applicant

SHANE THOMAS LYE

Third Applicant

KYLIE LEE LYE

Fourth Applicant

AND:

WESTPAC BANKING CORPORATION ABN 33 007 457 141

First Respondent

WESTPAC LIFE INSURANCE SERVICES LIMITED ABN 31 003 149 157

Second Respondent

JUDGE:

LEE J

DATE OF ORDER:

18 SEPTEMBER 2018

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.Subject to order 2, the parties provide to the Associate to Justice Lee an agreed minute of order or, failing agreement, each party’s proposed minute of order, reflecting these reasons by 4pm on 25 September 2018.

2.In the event that the funder, JustKapital Litigation Pty Limited, is not prepared to provide undertakings to fund this proceeding on the basis of the common fund order that the Court has indicated that it is prepared to make, then the applicants…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Lenthall v Westpac Life Insurance Services Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2018] FCA 1422
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Lenthall and others sought to bring a class action on behalf of a large number of consumers against Westpac Life Insurance Services Limited, alleging breaches of consumer law. The case was before the Federal Court, where the applicants sought a common fund order to facilitate the funding of the class action. The primary legal issue was whether it was appropriate to make the proposed common fund order, which would determine the funding terms for the litigation. The court had to consider the principles governing common fund orders, the reasonableness of the proposed funding rate, and the potential impact on the group members’ ability to have their claims advanced.

The court found that the proposed common fund order was reasonable and in the best interests of the group members. The funding rate, calculated as the lesser of three times the total spend on legal costs and disbursements and adverse costs orders, or 25% of the gross recovery in any resolution, was considered fair and consistent with the policy objectives of Part IVA of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976. The court also noted that the funder, JustKapital Litigation Pty Limited (JKL), was likely to meet its obligations and that there were no conflicts of interest. The solicitors had acted responsibly in selecting the funder, and without litigation funding, the proceeding would likely not advance to resolution. The court concluded that making the proposed order was appropriate to ensure justice was done in the proceeding.

The court made two orders to facilitate the agreement on the terms of the common fund order. First, the parties were to provide an agreed minute of order or, failing agreement, each party’s proposed minute of order, reflecting the court’s reasons by a specified date. Second, if the funder, JKL, was not prepared to provide undertakings to fund the proceeding on the basis of the common fund order that the court had indicated it was prepared to make, then the applicants were to inform the Associate to Justice Lee, and the proceeding would be listed for a case management hearing.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Subject to order 2, the parties provide to the Associate to Justice Lee an agreed minute of order or, failing agreement, each party’s proposed minute of order, reflecting these reasons by 4pm on 25 September 2018.

2. In the event that the funder, JustKapital Litigation Pty Limited, is not prepared to provide undertakings to fund this proceeding on the basis of the common fund order that the Court has indicated that it is prepared to make, then the applicants are to inform the Associate to Justice Lee of this eventuality by 4pm on 21 September 2018, and the proceeding will thereafter be listed for a case management hearing.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The common fund order now sought proposed a funding rate of the lesser of three times the total spend on legal costs and disbursements and adverse costs orders, or 25% of the gross recovery in any resolution. C The Evidence & Relevant Findings Ms Jan Saddler and Ms Vicky Antzoulatos, solicitors for the applicants from Shine Lawyers, gave evidence. The evidence given by the solicitors establishes that: (a)JKL was selected as the appropriate litigation funder after negotiation of the funding commission (although only one other funder had been approached other than JKL, and these other discussions never reached a stage of negotiating terms or percentages);(b)despite the lack of detailed discussion with any other funder, there are no other funders who have shown any interest in funding a similar class action;(c)Shine has not approached alternative funders for the purposes of putting forward a more favourable common fund proposal (the reason being that Ms Antzoulatos considered to do so would expose the applicants to liability for breach of the JKL funding agreement);(d)total legal costs disclosed in the retainer agreement are between $6.5 million to $9 million;(e)JKL has already spent $1.2 million on legal costs; and(f)there are many group members (perhaps in excess of 80,000 although it is difficult to be precise). Ms Saddler also gave evidence that the group members each have, on average, a claim in the order of $2,000 to $15,000. This range is plainly “rubbery” and I think it is fair to say, on the present state of the evidence, the actual quantum of the amount in issue is very difficult to estimate with any degree of precision. Additionally, further evidence was filed, apparently in response to the possibility I raised (on 29 May 2018) that if the Court made a common fund order other than as proposed by the applicants, it would then be a matter for JKL to decide if it wants to continue to fund the proceeding and, if it does not, the matter would be stayed to allow the applicants the opportunity to find another funder. In response to this, Ms Antzoulatos deposed that if the Court set its own funding terms, then JKL may elect not to fund the proceeding and Shine may terminate their retainers with the applicants. In these circumstances, if a new litigation funder was not found by the applicants, there was a potential for a permanent stay of the proceeding. There is no real reason to doubt this evidence, although I consider it to be of marginal relevance. If I am not satisfied it is appropriate to make the proposed common fund order, then the appropriate exercise of discretion would be to refuse the amended application or suggest the basis upon which I would be prepared to approve such an order. In the circumstances of this case, I intend to place little weight on this evidence because the Court’s task is to form a view on whether the proposal currently put forward is one which is in the interests of group members, without the distraction of any minatory suggestion that the funding would be, or may be, withdrawn if the Court declines to make the precise order JKL seeks.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Moreover I am satisfied: first, that JKL will likely meet its obligations; secondly, as noted above, that the funding rate (if calculated by reference to net recoveries) is reasonable in all the circumstances and it is not evident another funder would propose more favourable terms; thirdly, no conflict issues arise; fourthly, that the solicitors have acted responsibly in the selection of the funder notwithstanding the only detailed discussion as to terms was with JKL; fifthly, the common fund order now proposed is put forward by the applicants and their solicitors conscious to their duties to group members; sixthly, that the legal costs are likely to be very considerable and without litigation funding it is likely that the proceeding would not advance to resolution at a mediation or on the merits; and seventhly, that the making of the proposed order, and thus allowing an open class, is consistent with the policy objectives of Part IVA.G Conclusion & Orders In the circumstances, in accordance with s 33ZF of the Act, the making of a common fund order in the terms I have proposed is appropriate to ensure that justice is done in this proceeding. Without an appropriate common fund order being made, a particular injustice would result, being the likely inability, absent funding, of the group members to have their claims advanced in this class action. In reaching this view I have not only had regard to the likely deductions from any resolution sum but further, as a matter of principle, it seems to me that a commission rate which is struck by reference to the lesser of a multiple of costs or net recoveries is a preferable form of a common fund order. This is not only because a percentage struck by reference to net recoveries allows for more ready comparison with earlier common fund orders, but it is more appropriate as reflecting the reality that what is fair, reasonable and in the interests of group members is an evaluation conducted by reference to what those group members actually receive in the hand following determination or settlement of their claims. Given the order being sought allows for a further proposed deduction being made from any resolution sum (the “uplift”), depending upon whether the outcome of the proceeding is successful, the focus on net recoveries is even more appropriate. I am cognisant of the fact that the amended application sought a common fund order on the basis of a percentage amount struck by reference to gross recoveries. As the applicants have anticipated, as has now become common, the form of order will record the giving of an undertaking by JKL to perform the funding terms. Obviously enough, it is entirely a matter for JKL as to whether it is prepared to provide the undertaking required. In these circumstances, I will allow a period to ascertain whether agreement to be reached between the parties on orders reflecting my reasons and for undertakings to be given. To guard against the possibility that JKL is not prepared to give an undertaking in the terms proposed, I will also make an order that the solicitors for the applicants inform my Associate if an undertaking is not forthcoming.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.