Lehtovaara V Commissioner of Patents

Link copied
Case Copied 33 min read

Re: IN THE MATTER of the Patents Act 1952
And: IN THE MATTER of a reference of a question of law by the Administrative
Appeals Tribunal; IN THE MATTER of an application for a patent in which the
applicant was RITVA MAIJA LEHTOVAARA (1981) 58 FLR 1
No. VG 99 of 1981 Patent
Patent - Administrative Law

COURT

IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA


VICTORIA DISTRICT REGISTRY
GENERAL DIVISION
Franki(1), Northrop(2) and Ellicott(2) JJ.
CATCHWORDS

Patent - Application for standard patent - extension of time for acceptance - decision of Commissioner of Patents - application lapsed - whether power to extend time.

Administrative Law - Administrative Appeals Tribunal - case stated - whether Commissioner of Patents has power to extend time for acceptance prescribed by s.54 under s.160.

Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 s.45 Patents Act 1952 ss.49, 53, 54, 141, 160

Patents - Application for standard patent - Extension of time for acceptance - Decision of Commissioner of Patents - Application lapsed - Whether power to extend time - Patents Act 1952 (Cth), ss. 49, 52, 53, 54, 141, 160.

Administrative Law - Administrative Appeals Tribunal - Case stated - Whether Commissioner of Patents has power to extend time for acceptance prescribed by s. 54 under s. 160 of Patents Act - Whether Tribunal has jurisdiction to consider whether lawful ground of objection has been removed in reviewing decision under s. 160 of Patents Act - Patents Act 1952 (Cth), ss. 49, 52, 53, 54, 141, 160 - Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth), s. 45.

HEADNOTE

Under s. 52 of the Patents Act if the Commissioner is satisfied there is no lawful ground of objection to an application for a standard patent and complete specification, or that such grounds have been removed, he shall accept the application and complete specification. By s. 53 if an application and complete specification is not accepted within the time provided by s. 54 it lapses. Section 54 (1) provides that the period within which an application and complete specification may be accepted is twelve months after the first report of the examiner is sent; and s. 54 (1B) enables the Commissioner to extend the period for acceptance whether or not it has already expired.

By s. 160 (1) the Commissioner shall grant an extension of time where, due to some error or omission in the Patent Office, an act or step is not taken in time; and under s. 160 (2) the Commissioner may extend time where, due to error or omission by the applicant or his attorney or due to circumstances beyond his control, a necessary act or step is not taken in time.

Held: Per Northrop and Ellicott JJ., Franki J. dissenting - (1) In considering whether s. 160 is to apply to the various provisions in the Patents Act fixing a time for doing an act or taking a step, the test is whether each such provision contains any clear indication that s. 160 should not apply.

Australian Paper…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Lehtovaara V Commissioner of Patents and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1981] FCA 248
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Lehtovaara V Commissioner of Patents, the applicant, Lehtovaara, sought an extension of time for acceptance of a patent application and complete specification. The dispute arose after the application lapsed due to the Commissioner of Patents' failure to accept it within the time stipulated by section 54 of the Patents Act. Lehtovaara argued that the Commissioner had the power to extend the time for acceptance under section 160 of the Act. The case was brought before the court to determine the Commissioner's authority to extend the acceptance period and whether the Tribunal could review the Commissioner's decision.

The court addressed several legal issues, primarily whether the Commissioner had the power to extend the time for acceptance in different circumstances, such as when the delay was due to errors or omissions by the applicant, the Commissioner, or an officer employed in the Patent Office. The court also examined whether the Tribunal had the authority to decide on the validity of objections to the patent application and whether the application lapsed if the Commissioner failed to accept it within the stipulated time.

The court found that the Commissioner indeed had the power to extend the time for acceptance under section 160 of the Act in cases of errors or omissions by the applicant, agent, attorney, or an officer in the Patent Office. However, the court determined that it was not appropriate to answer whether the Commissioner was bound to exercise this power if objections raised in an examiner's report were later withdrawn or not upheld. The court also confirmed that the Tribunal had the power to decide if certain matters constituted lawful grounds of objection to the patent application and whether any such grounds had been removed.

The case was remitted to the Administrative Appeals Tribunal for determination in accordance with the answers provided, and leave was granted to either party to move for an order for costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

The questions asked in the case stated are answered as follows:

1.

If an application for a patent and complete specification is not accepted within the time for acceptance provided by s.54 of the Act by reason of an error or omission on the part of the applicant or of his agent or attorney or circumstances beyond the control of the applicant within sub-section 160(2) of the Act, does the Commissioner of Patents have power under sub-section 160(2) of the Act to extend the time for acceptance as provided by s.54 of the Act?

Answer: Yes.

2.

If an application for a patent and complete specification is not accepted within the time for acceptance as provided by s.54 of the Act by reason of an error or omission on the part of an officer or person employed in the Patent Office within sub-section 160(1) of the Act, does the Commissioner of Patents have the power under sub-section 160(1) of the Act to extend the time for acceptance as provided by s.54 of the Act?

Answer: Yes.

3.

If yes to 2,

(a) If an examiner's adverse report communicates objections which are later withdrawn by the Commissioner or are not upheld as lawful objections, is the failure of the Commissioner to accept the application within the time for acceptance before such objections are so withdrawn or not upheld a failure to accept the application by reason of an error or omission on the part of an officer or person employed in the Patent Office within sub-section 160(1) of the Act?

(b) Is the Commissioner without more deemed to have extended the time for acceptance?

(c) If no to part (b), is the Commissioner then

(i) able, (ii) bound

to exercise the power to extend the said time for acceptance?

Answer: Not appropriate to answer.

4.

Has the Tribunal for the purposes of reviewing a decision of the Commissioner under s.160 of the Act the power to decide

(i) whether any matter or matters constitute a lawful ground of objection to an application for a patent and complete specification

and

(ii) whether any grounds of objection to an application and complete specification have been removed

within the meaning of s.52(1) of the Act?

Answer: Yes, if those issues properly arise.

5.

If an examiner's adverse report communicates objections which are later withdrawn by the Commissioner or are not upheld as lawful objections and if by reason only of such adverse report the Commissioner does not accept the application for a patent and complete specification within the time for acceptance as provided by s.54 of the Act -

(i) does the application lapse by operation of s.53 of the Act?

(ii) is the Commissioner under an obligation pursuant to s.52 of the Act to accept the application and complete specification notwithstanding that the time for acceptance as provided by s.54 of the Act has expired?

Answer: Not appropriate to answer.

Remit case to the Administrative Appeals Tribunal for determination in accordance with the answers given.

Leave granted to either party to move for an order for costs.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established