Danby Pty Ltd v Rib Loc Group Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 16 min read

In the Matter of the Patents Act 1952

‑ and ‑

In the Matter of Patent Application No. 558128 in the Name of DANBY PTY. LTD.

‑ and ‑

In the Matter of an Application by RIB LOC GROUP LIMITED for an Extension of Time under Section 160 to Lodge Notice of Opposition.

DECISION OF A SUPERVISING EXAMINER OF PATENTS:
Background
         Application No. 42585/85 was lodged on 16 May, 1985 by DANBY PTY. LTD. for a patent for an invention entitled "Method of Lining a Sewer Pipe".  The specification became Open to Public Inspection on 21 November, 1985, and two notices under sub‑section 57(1) were lodged on 9 May, 1986 and 1 September, 1986 by Johannes Carl Schmidt, a consultant to the firm Collison & Co.  A request for examination was lodged on 16 October, 1986, accompanied by a regulation 19(2) request for expedition of examination.  The application was advertised as accepted on 22 January, 1987 and was given the serial No. 558128.  The three‑month period allowed by ss.59(1) for lodging notice of opposition expired on 22 April, 1987, and on 1 July, 1987 Mr. Schmidt applied in his own name under paragraph (a) of ss.160(2) for an extension of time of three months to 22 July, 1987 in which to lodge the notice of opposition.  On 8 July, 1987 a notice was received from Grant Adams & Co., representing DANBY PTY. LTD., objecting to the granting of the

extension of time.  On 10 July, 1987 a substitute application for extension of time in the name of RIB LOC GROUP LIMITED was lodged by Collison & Co. and Grant Adams & Co. confirmed Danby's objection thereto by a notice lodged on 16 July, 1987.  A notice of opposition was lodged by Rib Loc also on 16 July, 1987.
         Evidence in support of the application for extension of time was lodged with the first application, the substitute application and on 24 July, 1987.  The matter came to a hearing in Canberra on 27 July, 1987 at which evidence in answer was presented by Grant Adams & Co.  Because there was a substantial amount of documentary evidence presented by each of the parties, and because it was presented only either at the hearing or three days beforehand, each party was given fourteen days from the date of the hearing in which to lodge submissions about the other party's late lodged documentation.  Mr. P. Kildea, patent attorney, appeared for Collison & Co. representing Rib Loc, and Mr. B. O'Donnell of Counsel appeared for Grant Adams & Co. representing Danby.  On 7 August, 1987 evidence in reply was lodged by Mr. Kildea on behalf of Rib Loc.
Evidence
         Evidence lodged in support of the application for extension of time comprises the following:

1.Two declarations dated 1 July, 1987 and 10 July, 1987 by Mr. Schmidt in which he indicated that his client had issued instructions to lodge a notice of opposition and that Mr. Schmidt "believed that a watch was being kept by…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Danby Pty Ltd v Rib Loc Group Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1987] APO 21
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of the Patents Act 1952 and Patent Application No. 558128 in the name of DANBY PTY LTD, and in the matter of an application by RIB LOC GROUP LIMITED for an extension of time under Section 160 to lodge a notice of opposition, the court was required to decide two primary legal issues. Firstly, whether there was sufficient evidence to establish that the failure to meet the time limit for lodging the notice of opposition was due to an error or omission by Rib Loc's agents or attorneys. Secondly, whether the Commissioner had the discretion to grant the extension of time under the circumstances presented. The court found that the evidence showed a breakdown in communications within Collison & Co., Rib Loc's legal representatives, and that the failure to instigate a proper watch on Danby's patent application constituted an error or omission. In exercising discretion, the court weighed the interests of the patent applicant, the prospective opponent, and the public, ultimately concluding that granting the extension served the public interest in valid patents and Rib Loc's interest in not being restricted by the patent outweighed the inconvenience to Danby.

The court allowed the extension of time to 22 July 1987 to validate the notice of opposition lodged by Rib Loc on 16 July 1987, thereby permitting Rib Loc to challenge the validity of Danby's patent. The decision was made considering the evidence presented, the criteria for granting an extension of time, and the respective interests of the parties involved. The court made no award of costs, taking into account the reasons for the decision and the inconvenience caused to Danby by the late application for the extension of time.