Lehrmann v Network Ten Pty Limited (Cross-claims)

Link copied
Case Copied 30 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Lehrmann v Network Ten Pty Limited (Cross-claims) [2024] FCA 102

File number: NSD 103 of 2023
Judgment of: LEE J
Date of judgment: 14 February 2024
Date of publication of reasons: 19 February 2024   
Catchwords: DEFAMATION – cross-claims – collateral dispute concerning scope of indemnity required to be provided by Network Ten Pty Limited (Network Ten) to Ms Wilkinson – observations as to duelling relief – whether Network Ten “non-associated third party payer” – whether costs incurred in defending defamation proceeding were reasonably incurred within meaning of indemnity – where differences in interests sought to be protected in defamation proceeding – where reasonable to obtain separate legal representation – declaratory relief – consideration of relevant principles – extent of costs recoverable pursuant to indemnity deferred until judgment in defamation proceeding – orders made
Legislation:

Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) Pt VB

Defamation Act 2005 (NSW), ss 30, 30(1)(c)

Jurisdiction of Courts (Cross-vesting) Act 1987 (NSW), s 5(1)(b)(ii)

Legal Profession Uniform Law (NSW), ss 171(1), 171(1)(c), 198(1), 198(6), 198(7)

Cases cited:

Beau Timothy John Hartnett trading as Hartnett Lawyers v Anthony Robert Bell as Executor of the Estate of the late Mabel Dawn Deakin-Bell [2023] NSWCA 244

Matheson Property Group Pty Ltd (Trustee) v Virgin Australia Holdings Limited (No 3) [2023] FCA 1329

National Australia Bank Limited v Nautilus Insurance Pte Limited (No. 2) [2019] FCA 1543; (2019) 377 ALR 627

National Roads and Motorists’ Association v Whitlam [2007] NSWCA 81; (2007) 25 ACLC 688

Russell v Australian Broadcasting Corporation (No 3) [2023] FCA 1223

Wilkinson v Network Ten Pty Ltd [2023] NSWSC 1438

Julius Stone, Legal System and Lawyers’ Reasonings (Stanford University Press, 1964)
Division: General Division
Registry: New South Wales
National Practice Area: Other Federal Jurisdiction
Number of paragraphs: 58
Date of hearing: 13–14 February 2024
Counsel for the cross-claimant: Mr M Elliott SC with Mr D Klineberg
Solicitor for the cross-claimant: Gillis Delaney Lawyers
Counsel for the cross-respondent: Mr R Dick SC with Ms Z Graus
Solicitor for the cross-respondent: Baker & McKenzie
Counsel for the applicant: Mr D Helvadjian
Solicitor for the applicant: Mark O’Brien Legal
Counsel for the first respondent: Mr T Senior
Solicitor for the first respondent: Thomson Geer Lawyers
Counsel for the second respondent: Ms S Chrysanthou SC
Solicitor for the second respondent: Gillis Delaney Lawyers

ORDERS

NSD 103 of 2023
BETWEEN:

BRUCE LEHRMANN

Applicant

AND:

NETWORK TEN PTY LIMITED ACN 052 515 250

First Respondent

LISA WILKINSON

Second Respondent

AND BETWEEN:

LISA WILKINSON

Cross-claimant

AND:

NETWORK TEN PTY LIMITED ACN 052 515 250

Cross-respondent

ORDER MADE BY:

LEE J

DATE OF ORDER:

14 FEBRUARY 2024

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The relief specified in prayers 1 and 2 of the cross-claim filed by Network Ten Pty Limited (Network Ten) on 20 December 2023 be dismissed.

2.Network Ten pay Ms Wilkinson’s costs of these proceedings initially commenced in the Supreme Court of New South Wales (file no. 2023/332043) and continued as cross-claims filed…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Lehrmann v Network Ten Pty Limited (Cross-claims) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] FCA 102
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This case involves a dispute between Ms Lisa Wilkinson and Network Ten Pty Limited regarding the scope of indemnity required to be provided by Network Ten to Ms Wilkinson in relation to her legal costs in defending a defamation proceeding brought by Bruce Lehrmann. The primary issue before the Court was whether Network Ten was obligated to indemnify Ms Wilkinson for her legal costs in the defamation proceeding, specifically whether the costs were reasonably incurred within the meaning of the indemnity. The secondary issue was whether Network Ten was a "non-associated third party payer" for the purposes of determining the scope of indemnity.

The Court considered the principles relevant to the scope of indemnity and whether Network Ten's costs were properly and reasonably incurred. The Court noted that the costs incurred in defending a defamation proceeding could be reasonably incurred if the employee's interests were not entirely aligned with those of the employer. The Court held that it was reasonable for Ms Wilkinson to obtain separate legal representation given the differences in interests between her and Network Ten. The Court deferred the determination of the extent of costs recoverable pursuant to the indemnity until the defamation proceeding was concluded.

The Court dismissed Network Ten's cross-claim and ordered Network Ten to pay Ms Wilkinson's costs of the proceeding, with certain exceptions. The Court also stood over the consideration of further orders for Ms Wilkinson pending the delivery of reasons in the defamation proceeding.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The relief specified in prayers 1 and 2 of the cross-claim filed by Network Ten Pty Limited (Network Ten) on 20 December 2023 be dismissed.

2. Network Ten pay Ms Wilkinson’s costs of these proceedings initially commenced in the Supreme Court of New South Wales (file no. 2023/332043) and continued as cross-claims filed in these proceedings, save for any costs incurred by reason of or incidental to commencement of the proceedings in the Supreme Court of New South Wales (rather than by way of cross-claim in these proceedings), and such costs be paid on the ordinary basis.

3. Prayer 2 of the cross-claim filed by Ms Wilkinson on 5 December 2023 seeking such further or other order as the Court thinks fit be stood over for further consideration following delivery of reasons in the defamation proceeding.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

The balance of these reasons is otherwise set out under the following headings: B RELEVANT BACKGROUNDC CURRENT RELIEFD CRITICAL FACTSE APPROPRIATE RELIEFF ORDERS AND COSTS B RELEVANT BACKGROUND The proceeding which now constitutes Ms Wilkinson’s cross-claim was initially commenced in the Supreme Court of New South Wales on 19 October 2023 (NSWSC proceeding). On 24 November, Rees J, sitting in the Commercial List of the Equity Division of that Court, cross-vested the NSWSC proceeding to this Court pursuant to s 5(1)(b)(ii) of the Jurisdiction of Courts (Cross-vesting) Act 1987 (NSW): see Wilkinson v Network Ten Pty Ltd [2023] NSWSC 1438. In those reasons, her Honour set out the relevant background (at [4]–[22]) in terms I gratefully adopt and, for convenience, will set out below:Defamation proceedings 4On 15 February 2021, Network Ten broadcast an interview conducted by Ms Wilkinson with Brittany Higgins on “The Project.” On 7 February 2023, Bruce Lehrmann commenced defamation proceedings in the Federal Court against Network Ten and Ms Wilkinson. 5Network Ten contends in its Commercial List Response that, on 8 February 2023, Ms Wilkinson instructed Thomson Geer to appear for her in the defamation proceedings but, on 11 February 2023, instructed Gillis Delaney and Sue Chrysanthou SC instead. Thomson Geer filed a notice of appearance for Ms Wilkinson on 13 February 2023 but Gillis Delaney filed a notice of change of solicitors the next day. Ms Wilkinson’s agent, Nick Fordham, also sent an email to Network Ten, raising the issue of possible separate representation, confirming that Ms Wilkinson had already received advice from Gillis Delaney and Ms Chrysanthou SC, and seeking confirmation that Network Ten would indemnify her for the costs of the proceedings. 6According to its Commercial List Response, on 15 February 2023, Network Ten replied to Ms Wilkinson, communicating its view that separate legal representation in the defamation proceedings was unnecessary and not in her best interests. Further, “Lisa has elected to pursue her own defence of the proceedings, and she is entitled, at her own cost, to do so.” 7On 1 March 2023, Ms Wilkinson filed a defence in the defamation proceedings. Mr Collinge said he received an email from Network Ten’s solicitors, which stated that Network Ten accepted that Ms Wilkinson was entitled to seek and obtain separate legal representation in the defamation proceedings and Network Ten was obliged to indemnify her in relation to those costs by reference to section 3 of the Employees Liability Act 1991 (NSW), which relevantly provides: Employee not liable where employer also liable (1) If an employee commits a tort for which his or her employer is also liable: … (b)the employer is liable to indemnify the employee in respect of liability incurred by the employee for the tort (unless the employee is otherwise entitled to an indemnity in respect of that liability). 8Network Ten said, in effect, that the question of whether it had any liability to indemnify Ms Wilkinson under that section would only arise after judgment, as the section only operated if an employee committed a tort for which their employer was liable, such that an obligation under the section to indemnify may not arise. 9On 3 March 2023, Gillis Delaney wrote to Thomson Geer, taking issue with Network Ten’s position. Gillis Delaney suggested that the interests of Ms Wilkinson and Network Ten did not coincide. Further, Ms Wilkinson had concerns about Thomson Geer acting for her given the firm’s earlier involvement in advising on matters in connection with Mr Lehrmann and Ms Higgins. Ms Wilkinson was minded to file a cross-claim for indemnity and contribution unless Network Ten confirmed that it would indemnify her for any damages awarded in favour of Mr Lerhmann [sic] against her in the proceedings, any costs orders made against her in the proceedings, and would pay her reasonable legal costs of independent representation associated with the proceedings, regardless of the outcome of the proceedings. 10On 7 March 2023, Network Ten filed its defence in defamation proceedings. Network Ten admitted that it was vicariously liable for the conduct of its employee. Network Ten’s solicitors also replied to Gillis Delaney, confirming indemnity as limited to section 3 of the Employees Liability Act. 11The parties agree that Network Ten then proposed that advice be sought from leading senior counsel, at its expense, as to whether Ms Wilkinson should have separate representation, the cost and expense of which would be borne by Network Ten. On 17 March 2023, Ms Wilkinson obtained advice from Bret Walker SC. 12Mr Collinge said that, as Network Ten was not prepared to acknowledge the existence of an obligation to indemnify Ms Wilkinson in relation to her costs of defending the defamation proceedings other than under section 3 of the Employees Liability Act, which was said by Network Ten to only operate in limited circumstances, on 20 March 2023, Ms Wilkinson’s agent sent an email to Network Ten, followed by an email from Gillis Delaney to Network Ten’s solicitors on 22 March 2023 on this subject. 13By now, Network Ten had appointed Baker & McKenzie to deal with this particular matter. On 24 March 2023, Baker & McKenzie asserted that the appropriate time for reimbursement of Ms Wilkinson’s legal costs would be at the conclusion of the defamation proceedings, once the quantum of the costs could be determined taking into account any costs orders in her favour. Correspondence ensued between Gillis Delaney and Baker & McKenzie continued. 14On 30 May 2023, Gillis Delaney sent Baker & McKenzie invoices and narrations in respect of the work the subject of the invoices. The legal costs and expenses were $375,728.63. Gillis Delaney explained why Network Ten’s position was said to not be reasonably available, where it served to defeat the purpose of the indemnity, leaving Ms Wilkinson with the burden of having to find the ways and means to fund her defence to a claim to which she had become exposed as an employee. Any subsequent costs orders in the plaintiff’s favour were said to be immaterial where Network Ten would be entitled to receive any such sums recovered under a costs order. Network Ten was asked to pay the costs and expenses save for any amount which it considered to be unreasonable. 15On 21 June 2023, Network Ten’s solicitor responded, as set out in the Commercial List Response, that its preliminary view was that legal costs over $375,000 was unlikely to be reasonable for the limited steps taken in the proceedings so far. Essential work undertaken on behalf of Ms Wilkinson was said to be unnecessarily duplicative of Network Ten’s work in defending the proceedings. Network Ten’s obligation to indemnify their employee did not extend to funding a parallel and duplicative defence in those proceedings. The level of detail provided in the solicitor’s invoices was said to not allow Network Ten to adequately assess the nature and level of the work undertaken. 16On 25 September 2023, Gillis Delaney sent Baker & McKenzie further invoices totalling $370,017. Gillis Delaney reduced the costs and expenses sought from the 30 May 2023 request to $353,538.88. Network Ten was asked to pay the legal costs and expenses, save for any amount which it considered unreasonable. Mr Collinge says that it is his view that the work performed was work reasonably undertaken for the purposes of Ms Wilkinson’s defence in the defamation proceedings and that the amounts charged for that work were reasonable. 17Network Ten notes in its Commercial List Response that the invoice for counsel’s fees was only for work completed until 17 June 2023 (for senior counsel) and 31 July 2023 (for junior counsel). Further, Network Ten noted that Ms Wilkinson has not asserted in any correspondence to Network Ten that she has incurred any actual liability in respect of the defamation proceedings, in the sense that she has paid any of these invoices. These proceedings 18On 19 October 2023, Ms Wilkinson commenced these proceedings, seeking an order that Network Ten pay her legal costs and expenses as set out in the invoices dated 30 May 2023 and 25 September 2023, or in such other amount as the Court determines. Alternatively, Ms Wilkinson sought damages. 19Ms Wilkinson contends in the Commercial List Statement that it was an implied term of her employment contract that her employer is liable to indemnify her in respect of any liability which she incurs arising out of or in the course of her employment. As such, the employer is required to indemnify her in respect of any award of damages, any costs order made against her and her reasonable legal costs and other expenses incurred in the defamation proceedings. 20To this, Network Ten accepts that it is obliged to indemnify their employee “but only insofar as [the employee’s] liability is properly incurred and reasonable in amount” and in accordance with section 3(1)(b) of the Employees Liability Act and at general law. Whilst Network Ten accepts that it is obliged to indemnify its employee in respect of any award of damages or costs orders made against her in the defamation proceedings, its obligation to indemnify her for her legal costs and expenses incurred in respect of the proceedings arises at the conclusion of the proceedings and after recovery by the employee of any amounts payable to her under any costs awarded in her favour, and in respect of amounts in fact paid by the employee. 21Alternatively, Network Ten contends that the obligation to indemnify arises at a time when it is possible for the employer to assess the reasonableness of the employee’s costs. In determining what costs are properly and reasonably incurred, regard must be had to whether the costs are incurred in respect of an issue or issues where the employee’s interests are common with those of the employer in defending the proceedings, and whether there was a duplication of costs that would otherwise already be incurred by the employer. Further, the issue of what costs are properly and reasonably incurred was best determined by the Federal Court at the conclusion of the defamation proceedings. 22Network Ten also contended, in its Commercial List Response, that by its correspondence it made clear its position that it agreed to indemnify Ms Wilkinson against any damages award or costs order made against her and for legal costs incurred in defending the proceedings to the extent that those costs were properly incurred and reasonable in amount, to the extent that Ms Wilkinson was entitled to an indemnity under section 3 of the Employees Liability Act and at general law, noting that the appropriate time for reimbursement would be after completion of the proceedings. Further, Network Ten communicated its view to Ms Wilkinson at the outset that it was not reasonable or necessary for her to obtain separate legal representation and maintains that view, such that the costs incurred by reason of that decision are not reasonably incurred. Nor was Network Ten well positioned to assess the reasonableness of Ms Wilkinson’s costs incurred to date where it had not been provided with a complete record of counsel’s invoices for the same period of time to which the solicitors’ fees related, the invoices did not identify with specificity the tasks to which the entries of time related, and Ms Wilkinson was said to continue to refuse to comply with requests for copies of costs estimates, costs agreements or the curriculum vitae of solicitors working on the matter.(Emphasis in original).

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.