Legal Services Commissioner v Conradie

Link copied
Case Copied 29 min read

QUEENSLAND CIVIL AND
ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL


CITATION:

Legal Services Commissioner v Conradie [2018] QCAT 170

PARTIES:

LEGAL SERVICES COMMISSIONER
(applicant)

v

ERICH HEIN CONRADIE

(respondent)

APPLICATION NO/S:

OCR064-16

MATTER TYPE:

Occupational regulation matters

DELIVERED ON:

12  June 2018

HEARING DATE:

26 February 2018

HEARD AT:

Brisbane

DECISION OF:

Hon Peter Lyons QC, Judicial Member

Assisted by:
Mr S Anderson
Mr K Revell

ORDERS:

1.   A local practising certificate is not to be granted to the respondent before 6 February 2019.

2.   When he next applies for a local practising certificate, the respondent is to submit with the application a report, from a psychiatrist or a psychologist, seen within 6 months prior to the application, dealing with the respondent’s mental health generally, and his management of it, particularly relating to depression.

3.   When the respondent applies for a local practising certificate after he has again been in practice for a period of twelve months, he is to submit with the application a report from a psychiatrist or a psychologist seen within 6 months prior to the application, dealing with the respondent’s mental health generally, and his management of it, particularly relating to depression.

4.   The respondent is to pay the applicant’s costs of and incidental to the application to be assessed on the standard basis.

CATCHWORDS:

PROFESSIONS AND TRADES – LAWYERS – COMPLAINTS AND DISCIPLINE – PROFESSIONAL MISCONDUCT AND UNSATISFACTORY PROFESSIONAL CONDUCT – GENERALLY – falsification of documents and transactions – trust money – solicitor’s costs – where four charges of respondent’s conduct relating to competence and diligence, billing, trust accounting and dishonesty  – whether professional misconduct or unsatisfactory professional conduct – whether fit and proper person

EVIDENCE – ADMISSIBILITY – OPINION EVIDENCE – EXPERT OPINION – QUALIFICATIONS OF WITNESS – where expert opinion from psychologist on respondent’s mental state – whether psychologist qualified to give evidence of a diagnosis of depression

Acts Interpretation Act 1954 (Qld), s 49A
Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2009 (Qld), s 9, s 10, s 28

Legal Profession Act 2007 (Qld), s 249, s 332, s, 418, s 419, s 456, s 462

Adamson v Queensland Law Society Inc [1990] 1 Qd R 498
Attorney-General v Legal Services Commissioner & Anor; Legal Services Commissioner v Shand [2018] QCA 66
Jensen v Legal Services Commissioner [2017] QCA 189
Legal Profession Complaints Committee v Love [2014] WASC 389
Legal Services Commissioner v Mugford [2016] QCAT 78
Legal Services Commissioner v Shand [2017] QCAT 159
R v Nguyen [2015] QCA 205

Watts v Legal Services Commissioner [2016] QCA 224

APPEARANCES & REPRESENTATION:

Applicant:

D A Holliday, instructed by the Legal Services Commission

Respondent:

A M Nelson, instructed by Slade Waterhouse Lawyers

REASONS FOR DECISION

  1. The applicant has brought proceedings seeking disciplinary orders pursuant to
    s 456 of the Legal Profession Act 2007 (Qld) (‘LP Act’), and an order for costs.

  2. The primary issue is whether the Tribunal should recommend the removal of the applicant’s name from the roll of legal practitioners on the ground that he is at…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Legal Services Commissioner v Conradie and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2018] QCAT 170
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Legal Services Commissioner v Conradie, the Legal Services Commissioner (the applicant) brought charges against Conradie, a legal practitioner, alleging that he engaged in unsatisfactory professional conduct or professional misconduct. The charges related to the respondent's competence and diligence in litigation, his failure to provide an itemised bill, improper handling of trust money, and dishonesty in creating false documents and misleading the Queensland Law Society. The Commissioner sought to have Conradie declared unfit to practise law.

The central legal issue was whether Conradie's conduct constituted professional misconduct or unsatisfactory professional conduct, warranting disciplinary action. Another significant issue was the admissibility of expert opinion evidence from a psychologist, Dr Gavan Palk, regarding Conradie's mental health at the time of the alleged misconduct. The Commissioner objected to the psychologist's evidence on the ground that he was not qualified to diagnose depression.

The court determined that Conradie's conduct in handling trust money improperly and creating false documents constituted professional misconduct. The court found that Conradie's actions were dishonest and demonstrated a lack of integrity, which are critical attributes of a legal practitioner. Regarding the expert evidence, the court held that Dr Palk was qualified to provide an opinion on Conradie's mental health, despite not being a medical practitioner, because the Tribunal was not bound by the rules of evidence and could assess the psychologist's qualifications on the facts presented. The court concluded that Conradie's conduct warranted a suspension of his practising certificate and set conditions for his future practice, including obtaining reports on his mental health from a qualified professional.

The court ordered that Conradie would not be granted a local practising certificate before 6 February 2019 and that he must submit mental health reports when applying for future practising certificates. Conradie was also ordered to pay the applicant's costs of the proceeding.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. A local practising certificate is not to be granted to the respondent before 6 February 2019.

2. When he next applies for a local practising certificate, the respondent is to submit with the application a report, from a psychiatrist or a psychologist, seen within 6 months prior to the application, dealing with the respondent’s mental health generally, and his management of it, particularly relating to depression.

3. When the respondent applies for a local practising certificate after he has again been in practice for a period of twelve months, he is to submit with the application a report from a psychiatrist or a psychologist seen within 6 months prior to the application, dealing with the respondent’s mental health generally, and his management of it, particularly relating to depression.

4. The respondent is to pay the applicant’s costs of and incidental to the application to be assessed on the standard basis.

Background

Background to the litigation

The applicant has formulated four charges, contending in respect of each that the respondent engaged in unsatisfactory professional conduct or professional misconduct. The first charge alleges that the respondent failed to act with competence and diligence in his conduct of litigation on behalf of Tenement Administrations Services Pty Ltd (‘TAS’) (‘the incompetence charge’). The second charge is that the respondent failed to provide an itemised bill when first requested to do so by his client (‘the itemised bill charge’). The third charge alleges that, on six occasions, the respondent improperly dealt with his client’s trust money for his own benefit, without the authority of the client (‘the trust account charge’). The fourth charge is that the respondent created false documents and otherwise dishonestly misled the Queensland Law Society (‘QLS’) (‘the dishonesty charge’). The charges may be better understood from a recitation of the facts, which are not in issue.Facts The respondent was admitted to practice as a legal practitioner in Queensland on 15 January 2008. At the times relevant to these charges, he carried on the legal practice, Conradie and Associates Solicitors, as a sole practitioner. In 2012, TAS was engaged in litigation which it had commenced in the Federal Court. On about 19 June 2012, Ms Jay Evans-Wheeler, the managing director of TAS, retained Mr Conradie to act for the company in that litigation. On 25 July 2012, Ms Evans-Wheeler paid $10,000 to the trust account of Mr Conradie’s law practice on account of costs and outlays for the proceeding. On 4 July 2012 the Federal Court made orders including an order that TAS respond to any request for particulars by 16 August 2012, and that it file a notice of discovery by 11 October 2012. TAS failed to comply with these orders. On 15 November 2012 the Deputy District Registrar of that Court (‘Deputy Registrar’) wrote to the respondent pointing out that his client had not taken any step since the order of July 2012. On 26 November 2012 the respondent advised the Deputy Registrar that he proposed to provide further and better particulars by 30 November 2012 and to file a list of documents by 2 December 2012. He did not do so. On 31 December 2012, the Deputy Registrar again wrote to the respondent about these matters, but the respondent did not reply. In January 2013 Ms Evans-Wheeler attended at the respondent’s office for 10 days to assist in the preparation of the notice of discovery and a list of documents to be provided by TAS. At a directions hearing on 6 February 2013, the respondent apologised for non-compliance with the Court’s orders and told the Court that he and his opponent had agreed on orders to be made that day. The orders were thus made by consent, although the respondent did not have his client’s instructions to consent to them. They included orders that by 12 February 2013, TAS would respond to the request for further and better particulars, serve a list of documents to be discovered and file and serve a notice of discovery, and, that if TAS failed to comply, the proceeding in the Federal Court would be dismissed with costs.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The respondent has obtained evidence from a psychologist, Dr Gavan Palk, in relation to his state of mind at the time of the conduct the subject of these charges. Ms Holliday of Counsel who appeared for the Commissioner took objection to some of this evidence. Although the objection was subsequently withdrawn, it is convenient to discuss it.Objection to Dr Palk’s evidence Dr Palk’s first report is dated 8 June 2014 but was probably written one year later, on 8 June 2015. It recorded that he administered what he described as self-report psychometric measures. One is the Depression Anxiety Stress Scale (‘DASS’); another is the Personality Assessment Screener (‘PAS’); and the third is the Personality Assessment Inventory (‘PAI’). Dr Palk recorded that the respondent’s scores on the DASS ‘indicate that he is currently experiencing excessive depression and anxiety as well as severe stress’. Dr Palk later recorded that there were indications that the respondent suffered from a long term depressive and anxiety disorder. Dr Palk said that the PAI had been extensively researched and found to be highly reliable in identifying clinical and mental health problems. The PAI results showed depression, anxiety and excessive consumption of alcohol. Dr Palk also applied a diagnostic approach known as the DSM-5 which he said has limitations but is accepted in the mental health field for formal diagnosis of mental health concerns. Matters reported by the respondent appear to share many of the DSM-5 features associated with alcohol abuse or substance dependence and a dysthymic disorder (mild chronic depression). Dr Palk later stated that the respondent’s scores on the DASS indicated that he was currently experiencing excessive depression and anxiety and severe stress. He needed ongoing medical and psychological treatment to assist him to cope appropriately with his depression and anxiety. Dr Palk saw the respondent again on 3 November 2016, resulting in a report dated 12 November 2016. He again provided a DSM-5 diagnosis. He reported that the previous depression, anxiety and excessive consumption of alcohol that were noted in June 2015 seemed to have been largely resolved. Ms Holliday objected in her written submissions to the evidence from Dr Palk to the extent that it purported to provide an opinion as to a diagnosis of mental illness, relying what was said in R v Nguyen.[1] In Legal Services Commissioner v Mugford, this Tribunal applied a statement from Nguyen to the effect that a psychologist (who is not a medical practitioner) does not have qualifications necessary to provide a diagnosis of depression.[2][1][2015] QCA 205, [34].[2][2016] QCAT 78, [55]-[56]. Since this Tribunal is not bound by the rules of evidence,[3] Ms Holliday orally sought a ruling that evidence from Dr Palk that the respondent suffered from a mental illness be given no weight, on the ground that Dr Palk was not qualified to express such an opinion. In a Court, factual controversies as to the qualifications of an expert are resolved on a voir dire hearing.[4] In the present case, the Tribunal heard evidence relevant to Dr Palk’s qualification to give the diagnosis of depression.[3]See s 28 of the Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2009 (Qld) (‘QCAT Act’).[4]See J.D. Heydon, Cross on Evidence (LexisNexis Butterworths, 11th ed, 2017), [29045]; cf. Fisher v Brown [1968] SASR 65, 72; TTS Pty Ltd v Griffiths (1991) 105 FLR 255, 263-6, referred to in Cross, [29060].

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.