Leeward Management Pty Ltd v Noosa Shire Council

Link copied
Case Copied 63 min read

PLANNING & ENVIRONEMENT COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

Leeward Management Pty Ltd v Noosa Shire Council [2022] QPEC 58

PARTIES:

LEEWARD MANAGEMENT PTY LTD ATF LE TRUST TRADING AS PROJECT BA
ABN 12 119 712 501

(respondent/appellant)

v
NOOSA SHIRE COUNCIL

(applicant/respondent)

FILE NO/S:

25/2022

DIVISION:

Planning and Environment

PROCEEDING:

Application

ORIGINATING COURT:

Planning and Environment Court, Maroochydore

DELIVERED ON:

23 December 2022

DELIVERED AT:

Planning and Environment Court, Maroochydore

HEARING DATE:

8 June 2022

JUDGES:

Long SC DCJ

CATCHWORDS:

PLANNING AND ENVIRONMENT COURT – APPEAL – Application in pending proceedings – Where the Council applies for the appellant’s appeal to be struck out pursuant to rule 171(1)(a), (d), (e) and (2) of the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 1999 – Where the Council contends on three (3) bases that they relief sought in their application should be granted – Whether the appeal should be struck out on any of the grounds identified in the Council’s application

PLANNING AND ENVIRONMENT COURT – PROCEDURE – Application in pending proceedings – where the first basis for the relief sought in the Council’s application is that the development application was not properly made – Where, to be properly made, a development application must comply with section 51(1)-(3) PA – Where an assessment can be made against such development application by an assessment manager and, as the case may be, a referral agency –  Where an assessment manager is to decide the development application and comply with the referral agency’s response to them – Where the legislative scheme contemplates that a singularly proposed development application may comprise components susceptible to differing assessment and determination or that an application may be decided in part –  Where  the appellant contends that the Council is the assessment manager responsible for deciding parts of the development application relating to demolition and both the right and left hand side shed extension – Where the Council contend that the development could not commence without a building development approval of a private certifier – Whether the development application was properly made

PLANNING AND ENVIRONMENT COURT – PROCEDURE – Application in pending proceedings – where the second basis for the relief sought in the Council’s application is that there is no lawful decision for the appeal to be brought against - Where the Council contends that severable parts of the proposed development required separate submission to separately identified assessment managers in order to separately engage any referral agency response irrespective of s 54(3) PA – Where the Council contends there is no refusal or deemed refusal of the certain components of the development application by the relevant assessment manager because the appellant failed to pay the fee for the referral agency – Whether s 54(3) is engaged to abrogate the requirement of an additional fee – Whether s 60(4) of the PA is engaged and what impact such engagement has on the form of the decision of the Council

PLANNING AND ENVIRONMENT COURT – PROCEDURE – Application in pending proceedings – where the first…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Leeward Management Pty Ltd v Noosa Shire Council and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2022] QPEC 58
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In Leeward Management Pty Ltd v Noosa Shire Council, the Court was called upon to consider an application by Noosa Shire Council to have the appellant's appeal struck out. The Council argued that the appeal should be dismissed on three grounds: the development application was not properly made, there was no lawful decision to appeal against, and the appeal was brought out of time. The appellant, Leeward Management, contested these arguments, asserting that the application was properly made and that the appeal was timely. The Court had to determine whether the appeal should be struck out on any of the grounds presented by the Council.

The primary legal issue was whether the appellant's appeal was properly made and timely. The Court considered whether the development application complied with the necessary legislative requirements, particularly under section 51 of the Planning Act, and whether the appellant's failure to pay a fee for the referral agency constituted a failure to make a proper application. Additionally, the Court examined whether there was a lawful decision to appeal against and whether the appeal was filed within the statutory time limit. The Council argued that the development application was not properly made because it was not submitted to the appropriate assessment managers and because the appellant did not pay the necessary fee. They also contended that there was no lawful decision to appeal against due to the failure to pay the fee and that the appeal was out of time.

The Court found that the development application was properly made as it complied with the requirements of section 51 of the Planning Act. The Court determined that the failure to pay the fee for the referral agency did not invalidate the application. Regarding the lawful decision to appeal against, the Court held that the appellant's appeal was valid despite the non-payment of the fee. The Court also concluded that the appeal was not out of time, as the appellant had a reasonable prospect of the Court exercising its discretion to excuse non-compliance with the time limit under section 37 of the Planning and Environment Court Act 2016.

The Court dismissed the Council's application to strike out the appeal. The decision emphasised the importance of compliance with legislative requirements in development applications but acknowledged that the appellant's failure to pay the referral agency fee did not render the application invalid. The Court also highlighted the appellant's right to appeal within the statutory time frame and the potential for the Court to exercise its discretion to excuse non-compliance with time limits.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Before proceeding to identify and deal with the issues which appear to be at the heart of this application, some observations may be made as to matters which are distracting and able to be put aside:(a)first and as is apparent from what has been set out as to the circumstances of the making of the development application in issue and the exchanged correspondence, from the outset the parties have taken and acted upon diametrically opposed views as to whether or not there was any obligation upon the Council to make a decision in respect of the extensions aspect of the application. Accordingly, that issue and more particularly the application of s 51 of the PA as to whether or not there was a properly made application, enlivening such an obligation, is more fundamental than the application of the development assessment rules, which pursuant to s 51(2)(a) of the PA may provide for “when a development application may be taken to be properly made for s 51(5)”. Accordingly, the determination here as to whether or not there was, relevantly, a properly made application does not depend upon whether or not any “action notice” or “confirmation notice” was given; and(b)secondly, neither is it necessarily the case that the relief sought by the appellant is to be characterised as effectively as to unapplied for declaratory relief pursuant to s 11 of the Planning and Environment Court Act 2016 (as to “a matter done …. or that should have been done for …. the Planning Act”) or presenting the difficulties identified in Perivall Pty Ltd v Rockhampton Regional Council & Ors.[25] Rather, the question is as to whether the appeal is appropriately brought in respect of the refusal of part of the development application which was made, having regard to the effect of s 60(6) and the antecedent question as to whether there was a development application which engaged any obligation to make that decision. In that respect, it may also be noted that the powers of the Court in respect of any such valid appeal are in respect of the decision appealed against:[25][2018] QPEC 46 at [13]-[71].“47 Appeal decision(1)In deciding a Planning Act appeal, the P&E Court must decide to do 1 of the following (the appeal decision) for the decision appealed against— (a) confirm it; (b) change it; (c) set it aside and— (i)make a decision replacing it; or (ii)return the matter to the entity that made the decision appealed against with directions the P&E Court considers appropriate.”And further, that s 47(2) provides that the “appeal decision”:“may also include other orders, declarations or directions the P&E Court considers appropriate.”The essential issues Turning then to the essential issues, it is only necessary to deal with the respective contentions of the parties, as made in their final form and without reference to all of the significant complications of the shifts and adjustments which emerged in earlier written and oral submissions, including to also accommodate the consideration of s 60(4) of the PA, as the potential engagement of that provision emerged in those earlier submissions.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established