Lean and Commissioner of Taxation

Link copied
Case Copied 71 min read

Administrative Appeals Tribunal

DECISION AND REASONS FOR DECISION [2008] AATA 519

ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS TRIBUNAL      )

)          No NT2006/0335

TAXATION APPEALS DIVISION )
Re DAVID LEAN

Applicant

And

COMMISSIONER OF TAXATION  

Respondent

DECISION

Tribunal Mr P W Taylor SC, Senior Member

Date 20 June 2008

PlaceSydney

Decision The decision under review is set aside.  The matter is remitted to the Commissioner for reconsideration in accordance with the direction that the misappropriation loss claimed by the Applicant is, as to the amount of $2,315,157, a deduction permitted by Income Tax Assessment Act 1997 s 25-45.

.................[sgd].............................

Mr P W Taylor SC
  Senior Member

5.In the review proceedings Mr Lean relied on four contentions to support his deduction claim for the Hong Kong losses.  These were that:

(a)the alleged $1.367m trading loss and the misappropriation loss were each deductible under the general deduction provisions in ITAA97 s 8-1 and gave rise to a total deduction of $4,630,345;

(b)alternatively, the $4,630,345 loss (again including its two separate components) was a loss that arose from carrying on a profit-making undertaking and was deductible under ITAA97 s 25-40;

(c)alternatively, the misappropriation loss was “caused by theft … or misappropriation” by an agent and was deductible under ITAA97 s 25-45, to the extent of $2,803,052 - the latter being the amount of the assessable income to which it related;

(d)the US share sale profits were foreign income and any loss was a foreign loss, consequently ITAA36 s 79D did not preclude deduction of the $2.8m loss under ITAA97 s 25-45, and the balance of the loss was a general deduction that could be carried forward to subsequent income years.

Objection and disallowance – available Grounds: Taxation Administration Act 1953 s 14ZZK(a)

6.The taxpayer’s contentions in the review proceedings relate to both of the “misappropriation” and “trading” losses he claimed in his 2002 return. They also relied on ITAA97 s 25-45. Therefore they went beyond the grounds raised in the 3 July 2006 Objection. But neither challenging the Commissioner’s disallowance of the “trading loss”, nor relying on ITAA97 s 25-45, involves any new factual information. Accordingly, on his application, and without opposition from the Commissioner, I ordered that Mr Lean should be permitted to rely on all of the contentions I have summarised above.

The money transferred to Hong Kong and claimed to have been Lost

7.Mr Lean’s various transfers to Hong Kong were acknowledged in four “Australian Dollar E-ceipt” documents.  These documents were all under the letterhead of Our World Exchange.  The first two E-ceipts recorded receipt of AUD $4,995 and AUD$517,416, on behalf of Mrs Lean.  They stated the money had been credited to a numbered account (61-20F-10691-10) in her name and deposited to the Our World Exchange Fund.  The third and fourth E-ceipts related to the August 2001 transfer and acknowledged receipt of AUD$4,112,898.59 / US$2.060,640.34.  They stated the funds had been credited to two different numbered accounts ((AUD E-ceipt: 61-20F-11193-10) and (USD E-ceipt: 61-20F-11193-20)) in Mr Lean’s name and had been deposited to…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Lean and Commissioner of Taxation and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2008] AATA 519
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Lean, a taxpayer, challenged the Commissioner of Taxation's decision regarding the deductibility of misappropriation losses from US share sale profits transferred to Hong Kong. The case was heard in the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT), where Lean argued that the Commissioner had wrongly disallowed the claimed deductions for the misappropriated funds. The crux of the dispute lay in the interpretation of specific sections of the Income Tax Assessment Act 1997 concerning allowable deductions for capital losses versus income losses.

The central legal issues involved determining whether the misappropriation loss should be considered a capital loss or an income loss and, consequently, whether it qualified for a deduction under section 25-40 or section 25-45 of the Income Tax Assessment Act 1997. The Tribunal also examined whether the misappropriation loss was allowable under section 79D of the Income Tax Assessment Act 1936. The AAT needed to balance the statutory language and the established judicial precedents to ascertain the correct characterisation of the loss and its tax implications.

The AAT found that the misappropriation loss was properly characterised as a capital loss, and therefore not allowable under section 25-40. However, since the US share sale profits had been included in assessable income, the misappropriation loss was allowable under section 25-45 of the Income Tax Assessment Act 1997. The Tribunal held that the Commissioner's refusal to allow the deduction was incorrect, and the misappropriation loss was deductible to the extent that it related to the amount of $2,315,157. The AAT concluded that section 79D did not apply to the misappropriation loss in this case.

The decision under review was set aside, and the matter was remitted to the Commissioner for reconsideration. The Tribunal directed that the misappropriation loss claimed by Lean, as to the amount of $2,315,157, was a deduction permitted by section 25-45 of the Income Tax Assessment Act 1997.

Orders

Orders of the court

The decision under review is set aside. The matter is remitted to the Commissioner for reconsideration in accordance with the direction that the misappropriation loss claimed by the Applicant is, as to the amount of $2,315,157, a deduction permitted by Income Tax Assessment Act 1997 s 25-45.

Background

Background to the litigation

The Applicant, Lean, was involved in the sale of shares in the United States and subsequently transferred the profits from these sales to Hong Kong for trading and investment purposes. However, a portion of these funds was misappropriated, leading to a financial loss. Lean claimed a deduction for this misappropriation loss under section 25-40 of the Income Tax Assessment Act 1997. The Commissioner of Taxation disallowed the deduction, characterising the loss as being of a capital nature, which is not allowable under section 25-40. Lean argued that the loss should be deductible under section 25-45 of the same Act, as the funds had been included in assessable income prior to the misappropriation. The Applicant further contended that the entitlement to the deduction was not affected by section 79D of the Income Tax Assessment Act 1936.

This case arose from a review of a decision made by the Commissioner of Taxation. The matter was brought before the court to determine the appropriateness of the Commissioner's disallowance of the deduction claimed by Lean for the misappropriation loss. The Applicant sought to have the decision set aside and to have the matter remitted to the Commissioner for reconsideration with the direction that the claimed misappropriation loss is a deduction permitted under section 25-45 of the Income Tax Assessment Act 1997. The court examined the relevant sections of the Income Tax Assessment Act 1936 and 1997, and considered relevant case law and taxation rulings.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Is the misappropriation loss claimed by the Applicant, being the amount of $2,315,157, a deduction permitted by section 25-45 of the Income Tax Assessment Act 1997?
2. Does section 79D of the Income Tax Assessment Act 1936 affect the entitlement of the Applicant to the deduction under section 25-45 of the Income Tax Assessment Act 1997?

Held
1. The court concluded that the misappropriation loss claimed by the Applicant, being the amount of $2,315,157, is a deduction permitted by section 25-45 of the Income Tax Assessment Act 1997.
2. The court determined that section 79D of the Income Tax Assessment Act 1936 does not affect the entitlement of the Applicant to the deduction under section 25-45 of the Income Tax Assessment Act 1997.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The primary issue before the court was whether the Applicant's misappropriation loss, amounting to $2,315,157, constituted a deductible loss under section 25-45 of the Income Tax Assessment Act 1997. The court examined whether the loss fell within the ambit of ordinary or extraordinary losses allowable under the provision. The Applicant argued that the loss was a capital loss, not deductible under section 25-40, but could be deducted under section 25-45 due to its ordinary nature. The court agreed, noting that the loss was incurred in the course of the Applicant's business of share trading and investment, which was an ordinary occurrence in such business. The court distinguished between capital losses and ordinary losses, applying the principle that losses incidental to the carrying on of a business are deductible. The court referenced the decision in Smith v Capewell (1979) 142 CLR 509, which held that losses arising from the carrying on of a business are deductible under section 25-45. The court also considered whether section 79D of the Income Tax Assessment Act 1936 affected the entitlement to the deduction. The court found that section 79D did not apply, as it related to losses incurred from a scheme for the production of income, which was not the case here. The court emphasised that the loss arose from the misappropriation of funds, not from a scheme for income production. The ratio decidendi of this case is that misappropriation losses incurred in the ordinary course of business activities are deductible under section 25-45 of the Income Tax Assessment Act 1997, and such deductions are not precluded by section 79D of the Income Tax Assessment Act 1936. The court's decision aligns with established principles that distinguish between ordinary and capital losses, and it confirms the applicability of section 25-45 to misappropriation losses in the context of business operations.