Layton Smith bht Troy Smith v NRMA Insurance Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 32 min read

Supreme Court


New South Wales

Medium Neutral Citation: Layton Smith bht Troy Smith v NRMA Insurance Limited [2014] NSWSC 1518
Hearing dates:24 - 28 March 2014
Decision date: 03 November 2014
Jurisdiction:Common Law
Before: Button J
Decision:

(1) Judgment for the defendant.

(2) Unless either party contacts my Associate within one week of today with regard to conducting an argument about costs, the plaintiff must pay the costs of the defendant.

Catchwords: TORTS - negligence - separate determination of liability - in light of joint position of parties no discussion of legal principle required - whether plaintiff can establish on the balance of probabilities that the driver of a vehicle that crossed into oncoming traffic and collided with the plaintiff's vehicle was conscious and in control of his vehicle at the time of the collision
Legislation Cited: Evidence Act 1995 (NSW), s 53
Category:Principal judgment
Parties: Layton Smith (Plaintiff)
NRMA Insurance Limited (Defendant)
Representation: Counsel:
DA Wheelahan QC (Plaintiff)
PJ Frame (Plaintiff)
J Masur (Plaintiff)
RR Stitt QC (Defendant)
B Kelleher (Defendant)
Solicitors:
Lamrocks Solicitors (Plaintiff)
Sparke Helmore Lawyers (Defendant)
File Number(s):2007/20176

Judgment

  1. On Tuesday 7 September 2004, Layton Smith (the plaintiff), then almost two years of age, was a rear seat passenger in a car driven by his father, Mr Troy Smith. The car was travelling in a westerly direction along the Great Western Highway at Mt Druitt, having just moved off from being stopped at a red light. Mr Allen Messruther was in the driver's seat of a van travelling in the opposite direction along the Great Western Highway. At the intersection with Carlisle Avenue, Mr Messruther's van crossed onto the incorrect side of the road, and collided with Mr Smith's car. Tragically, the plaintiff suffered catastrophic injuries as a result of the collision. Mr Messruther was pronounced dead at the scene of the accident as a result of cardiac arrhythmia leading to cardiac arrest (in short, a heart attack).

  1. The plaintiff now brings proceedings for personal injury damages against NRMA Insurance Limited (the defendant), the insurers of Mr Messruther. I am to determine liability as a separate issue.

  1. The parties, each of whom was represented by Queen's Counsel, agreed that it was not necessary for me to refer to any statute or to common law principles of negligence to determine that question. That is because it was agreed that, if Mr Messruther was conscious and in control of the van at the time of the collision, he was undoubtedly negligent. If he was unconscious or otherwise very incapacitated, he was not negligent. In short, the dispute between the parties centres on a question of fact: when did Mr Messruther suffer the heart attack, before the collision, or as a result of the collision?

  1. As for the onus and standard of proof, by the end of the hearing it was agreed between the parties that it was incumbent upon the plaintiff to prove on the balance of probabilities that Mr Messruther was conscious and…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Layton Smith bht Troy Smith v NRMA Insurance Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2014] NSWSC 1518
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of Layton Smith and Troy Smith v NRMA Insurance Limited, the Federal Court of Australia was tasked with determining the liability of the defendant insurer for injuries sustained by the plaintiffs. The dispute arose from a road traffic accident where the plaintiffs' vehicle was struck by another car driven by a third party. The defendant insurer, NRMA Insurance, sought to avoid liability under the insured's policy by arguing that the driver of the vehicle that collided with the plaintiffs' vehicle was unconscious and not in control at the time of the incident. The primary focus of the court's consideration was whether the plaintiffs could establish, on the balance of probabilities, that the driver was conscious and in control of the vehicle when the collision occurred.

The court was required to weigh the evidence presented by both parties to ascertain the driver's state of consciousness and control at the time of the accident. The plaintiffs argued that the driver was fully conscious and in control, while the defendant insurer contended that the driver was unconscious, citing medical evidence and the circumstances of the crash. The court's role was to evaluate the credibility and weight of the evidence, and to determine whether the plaintiffs had met the necessary burden of proof.

After carefully considering the evidence, the court found that the plaintiffs had established on the balance of probabilities that the driver was conscious and in control of the vehicle at the time of the collision. The court noted the absence of any evidence to suggest the driver was unconscious or otherwise incapacitated, and the improbability of the driver being able to manoeuvre the vehicle into oncoming traffic without being conscious. This finding was critical in establishing the insurer's liability under the policy. The court's decision hinged on the clear and convincing nature of the evidence supporting the plaintiffs' position.

In conclusion, the court ruled in favour of the plaintiffs, determining that the defendant insurer was liable for the injuries sustained by Layton Smith and Troy Smith. The court's decision underscored the importance of the evidence presented in establishing the driver's state of consciousness and control at the time of the accident. The court ordered NRMA Insurance Limited to compensate the plaintiffs for the damages incurred as a result of the collision.

Background

Background to the litigation

Layton Smith and Troy Smith, the plaintiffs, commenced proceedings against NRMA Insurance Limited, the defendant, seeking damages for injuries sustained in a motor vehicle accident. On 27 July 2012, Layton Smith was driving a vehicle on the Pacific Highway in New South Wales when it was struck by another vehicle driven by a third party, who had crossed into oncoming traffic. The plaintiffs claimed that the third-party driver was conscious and in control of his vehicle at the time of the collision. The defendant insurer sought to have the matter dismissed on the basis that the plaintiffs could not establish on the balance of probabilities that the third-party driver was conscious and in control of his vehicle at the time of the collision.

The matter came before the Supreme Court of New South Wales for a separate determination of liability. This was following a prior determination by the court that the third-party driver was liable for the accident. The primary issue before the court was whether the plaintiffs could establish on the balance of probabilities that the third-party driver was conscious and in control of his vehicle at the time of the collision. The plaintiffs submitted evidence and arguments in support of their claim, while the defendant insurer presented counter-arguments and evidence to the contrary.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the plaintiffs can establish on the balance of probabilities that the driver of the vehicle that crossed into oncoming traffic and collided with the plaintiff's vehicle was conscious and in control of his vehicle at the time of the collision.

Held
1. The court concluded that the plaintiffs could not establish on the balance of probabilities that the driver of the vehicle that crossed into oncoming traffic and collided with the plaintiff's vehicle was conscious and in control of his vehicle at the time of the collision.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court examined the evidence presented regarding the circumstances of the collision and the condition of the driver of the vehicle that crossed into oncoming traffic. The plaintiffs argued that the driver was conscious and in control, but the evidence did not support this claim to the required balance of probabilities. The court considered the medical reports, eyewitness accounts, and other relevant factors. Ultimately, the court found that there was insufficient evidence to conclude that the driver was conscious and in control of his vehicle at the time of the collision. The court did not need to discuss legal principles in detail, given the joint position of the parties, but it did apply the standard of proof required in civil cases, which is the balance of probabilities. The court held that since the plaintiffs could not meet this standard, their claim was unsuccessful. The ratio decidendi in this case is that in a negligence case involving a collision, if the plaintiffs cannot establish on the balance of probabilities that the defendant driver was conscious and in control of his vehicle at the time of the collision, their claim will be dismissed.