Lawrence v Sambevski No. DCCIV-96-1427 Judgment No. D3548

Link copied
Case Copied 17 min read

Court

DISTRICT COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

Reasons of His Honour Judge Lunn

Hearing

17/12/96.

Catchwords

COSTS Cancellation fee for medical witness - relevant criteria for quantum - award of $600 upheld. MEDICAL PRACTITIONERS Claim against a defendant for $1,500 by surgeon on a quantum meruit for a cancelled attendance at Court - award of $600 upheld on a minor civil action review. PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE Minor civil action review - right to adduce fresh evidence on review - nature of review process considered - further evidence not allowed.

Representation

Applicant JULIE LAWRENCE:
Counsel: MR E REINBOTH - Solicitors: STANLEY &; PARTNERS

Respondent GORDANA SAMBEVSKI:
Counsel: MR A REDFORD - Solicitors: SCALES &; PARTNERS

DCCIV-96-1427

Judgment No. D3548

17 January 1997

On Appeal from MR K MILLARD SM

(Civil)

LAWRENCE v SAMBEVSKI

Civil

Judge Lunn

Minor civil action review

The plaintiff is a specialist surgeon who had treated the defendant. A prosecution against the defendant for making an alleged false claim to her employer about her injuries and disability was listed for trial in the Adelaide Magistrates Court on 2 November 1995. In August 1995 the solicitors for the defendant arranged with the plaintiff for her to attend at the Adelaide Magistrates Court at 11.30am on 2 November to give evidence for the defence. On 1 November the defendant's solicitors advised the plaintiff that her attendance on 2 November was not required and requested an account for a cancellation fee. The plaintiff sent an account for $1,500. She justified this on the grounds of an AMA recommended rate of $300 per hour and from her having cancelled a full morning's operating list from which she had expected to earn about $2,000. The defendant disputed the amount claimed. There had been no prior agreement about the rate at which any cancellation fee would be assessed. The plaintiff sued the defendant in a minor civil action in the Adelaide Magistrates Court (Civil) for the $1,500. A trial was held on 16 October 1996. The plaintiff did not attend, but her practice manager represented her. A number of documents were handed to the Magistrate on behalf of the plaintiff including an affidavit from her. No oral evidence was given, or sought to be given. The Magistrate decided the question on the contents of the documents handed up and everyone involved acquiesced in this course. On 30 October he delivered a reserved judgment in which he gave judgment for the plaintiff for $600 for the cancellation fee plus some costs. The plaintiff brought an application in this Court for a review of that decision contending that she should have been allowed the full $1,500 claimed. The defendant did not cross appeal. At the hearing before me the plaintiff did not pursue the first ground of review, "That the special Magistrate erred in accepting into evidence material presented by the defendant without giving the plaintiff an opportunity to read or consider the said documents."

Fresh evidence

At the commencement of the review hearing counsel for the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Lawrence v Sambevski No. DCCIV-96-1427 Judgment No. D3548 and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1997] SADC 3548
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The District Court of South Australia heard an appeal by Julie Lawrence, a specialist surgeon, against a decision by a Magistrate who had awarded her a cancellation fee of $600 instead of the $1,500 she had claimed from Gordana Sambevski, her former patient. The plaintiff had attended court on a quantum meruit for a cancelled appearance at the Adelaide Magistrates Court. The plaintiff justified the amount claimed on the basis of an AMA recommended rate of $300 per hour and from having cancelled a full morning's operating list from which she had expected to earn about $2,000. The defendant disputed the amount claimed. The plaintiff brought an application in the District Court for a review of that decision contending that she should have been allowed the full $1,500 claimed. The court had to determine whether the Magistrate had erred in accepting into evidence material presented by the defendant without giving the plaintiff an opportunity to read or consider the said documents and whether the plaintiff should have been allowed fresh evidence on the review. The court also had to determine the legal issues of whether the scope of any fresh evidence to be taken on a review could exceed that which the Magistrate was required to take on the trial of a minor civil action, and whether the amount of the cancellation fee was to be determined on a quantum meruit of what was reasonable in all of the relevant circumstances. The court held that the Magistrate was not obliged to ensure that all possible evidence was adduced on any issue to which he might ultimately have regard in the determination of the action, and the District Court was not obliged to hear all of the relevant evidence about all of the issues and make up its mind about them. The court also held that the amount of the cancellation fee was to be determined on a quantum meruit of what was reasonable in all of the relevant circumstances, and the assessment of a cancellation fee on a quantum meruit was no different in law from fixing a proper witness fee which would have been payable if the plaintiff had given evidence subject to any proper deductions for the actual use she could have made of the time set aside through not having to attend at Court. The court dismissed the review and ordered that the defendant have her costs of the review which it fixed at $200 plus a witness fee for herself of $22, but with liberty to the parties to apply within fourteen days to vary this order.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.