SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA
(Appeal to a Single Judge)
LAURO v MINTER ELLISON (A FIRM) (No 2)
[2025] SASC 90
Decision of the Honourable Justice B Doyle
3 June 2025
PROCEDURE - CIVIL PROCEEDINGS IN STATE AND TERRITORY COURTS - MOTIONS, INTERLOCUTORY APPLICATIONS AND OTHER PRE-TRIAL MATTERS
The appellant appeals against a decision by an Auxiliary Associate Justice to decline to recuse herself from the conduct of the appellant’s application for a taxation of costs as between solicitor and client.
By interlocutory application filed on 9 May 2025, the appellant’s litigation guardian seeks an order pursuant to r 23.4(4) of the Uniform Civil Rules 2020 (SA) (‘UCRs’) requiring disclosure of the names and addresses of the partners of the partnerships ‘associated with these proceedings and the proceedings at first instance’ as at 31 May 2001, 18 May 2022, 11 March 2025 and as at dates associated with the departure of a number of partners.
Held, dismissing the application:
1. the respondent’s response to the appellant’s request pursuant to r 23.4(1) of the UCRs has not been shown to be non-compliant;
2. there is therefore no basis for the Court to make an order pursuant to r 23.4(4) of the UCRs;
3. even treating the application as one that might have been made pursuant to r 23.4(3) of the UCRs, there are not proper grounds in the interests of justice to make the orders sought in the appellate proceeding.
Supreme Court Civil Rules 2006 (SA) r 86; Uniform Civil Rules 2020 (SA) rr 23.1, 23.2, 23.4, referred to.
Lauro v Minter Ellison (A Firm) [2025] SASC 77, discussed.
LAURO v MINTER ELLISON (A FIRM) (No 2)
[2025] SASC 90
Single judge appeal – civil
B DOYLE J: As explained in my reasons for declining to recuse myself from hearing the appeal in this matter, the underlying proceeding involves an application by the appellant for a taxation of costs as between solicitor and client.[1]
[1] Lauro v Minter Ellison (A Firm) [2025] SASC 77 at [1], [49].
By interlocutory application filed on 9 May 2025, the appellant seeks an order that the respondent ‘disclose the name and address of each person who is or was a partner of the MinterEllison partnerships associated with these proceedings and the proceedings at first instance’.
The appellant’s litigation guardian, Mr Lauro, has affirmed an affidavit in support of that application, in which he deposes that he wrote to the respondent in these terms:
My request to Minter Ellison to “confirm if and when Grant Mitchell, Gary Coppola and Adam Bannister and any other NT/SA [read, SA/NT] partners stopped being employed and/or associated with Minter Ellison” has been ignored.
Consequently, TAKE NOTICE that, pursuant to Rule 23.4(1) of the Uniform Civil Rules 2020 (SA), you are required to disclose the name and address of each person who was a member of the partnership comprising Minter Ellison / Minter Ellison Group / Minter Ellison Legal Group (as appears on the relevant retainer), and similar information for…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Lauro v Minter Ellison (A Firm) (No 2) and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2025] SASC 90
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court examined whether the respondent had adequately responded to Mr Lauro's requests for disclosure of partnership details on certain dates, particularly focusing on whether the respondent had named distinct partnerships as required. The court also considered whether it had the discretion to order further disclosure under rule 23.4(3) even if there had been non-compliance with rule 23.4(2). The respondent argued that it had provided sufficient information, while Mr Lauro contended that the response was inadequate and that additional disclosure was necessary. The court found that the respondent's response was adequate, as the difference in format did not materially affect the information provided. Furthermore, the court held that there was no proper ground in the interests of justice to order further disclosure, even under its own motion.
Ultimately, the Supreme Court dismissed Mr Lauro's interlocutory application. The court concluded that it was not satisfied that the respondent had failed to comply with rule 23.4(2) and, accordingly, could not exercise the discretionary power under rule 23.4(4). Additionally, the court did not find sufficient grounds in the interests of justice to order the disclosure sought under rule 23.4(3). The court reserved the question of costs until the hearing of the appeal, scheduled for 27 June 2025.
Background
Background to the litigation
The case subsequently moved to appellate proceedings in 2025, where Mr Lauro again sought further disclosure of partnership details from Minter Ellison. He argued that the response provided in the initial proceeding was insufficient and that he was entitled to more specific information. He also raised the issue that the CourtsSA portal allegedly did not allow for the entry of multiple Australian Business Numbers (ABNs) for a single party name, complicating the process of identifying the correct partnership. Despite these arguments, the court found that Minter Ellison had provided adequate responses to the requests for partnership details as per the rules. The court also noted that Mr Lauro had not distinctly named a different partnership as a respondent in the proceeding, further complicating his claims.
Throughout these proceedings, the court was tasked with determining whether Minter Ellison had complied with the relevant rules regarding disclosure and whether Mr Lauro's requests were properly made. The court examined the specific details provided in Mr Kearney's email and concluded that the response was sufficient despite minor discrepancies. Additionally, the court considered whether the requested disclosure of partnership details as at 31 May 2001 was necessary and whether it would be an appropriate exercise of discretion to order such disclosure. Ultimately, the court determined that there were no proper grounds in the interests of justice to make the orders sought by Mr Lauro.
The case of Lauro v Minter Ellison (A Firm) (No 2) has a procedural history that involves multiple stages and applications within the court system. Initially, the matter began with an originating application filed by Mr Lauro against Minter Ellison (A Firm), which was heard and decided in a prior proceeding. Following the initial decision, Mr Lauro appealed the outcome, leading to an appellate hearing before the current court. During the appellate process, Mr Lauro made an interlocutory application seeking specific disclosures related to the partnership details of Minter Ellison (A Firm) as at certain dates relevant to the case. This application was part of the broader appeal proceedings and was made under the relevant rules of court. The court was required to consider whether the respondent had complied with previous disclosure obligations and whether there were grounds to order further disclosure under the rules. The application was contested, and the court ultimately dismissed the interlocutory application, reserving the issue of costs for the hearing of the main appeal.
In examining the procedural history, it is evident that the case has progressed through various stages, including an initial application, an appeal, and now an interlocutory application in the appeal process. The court’s decisions at each stage have shaped the procedural path of the case, with key rulings pertaining to disclosure obligations and compliance with court rules. The current application before the court seeks to address perceived inadequacies in the disclosure of partnership details, a matter that has been central to the procedural disputes in this case. The court's decision to dismiss the interlocutory application highlights the procedural intricacies involved in managing such complex litigation, where compliance with disclosure requirements and the exercise of discretion under the rules play a significant role in determining the progression of the case.
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
Finally, there is r 23.4(4). It applies where there is demonstrated non-compliance with the earlier sub-rules or an order made pursuant to them. It confers a discretionary power to make such orders as the Court thinks fit.Consideration As earlier noted, Mr Lauro relies on r 23.4(4). In order to make an order under that sub-rule I would need to be satisfied of non-compliance with the earlier sub-rules. Having said that, if I am satisfied that there are good reasons in the interests of justice to make the orders sought by Mr Lauro, I could make orders under r 23.4(3) of my own motion. I commence by considering the application for disclosure of partnership details as at 18 May 2022 and 11 March 2025. These were the ‘relevant dates’ in respect of the originating application and the appeal respectively. Prima facie, Mr Lauro is entitled to details of the partners of the respondent partnership at those dates. The issue is whether he has already been given those details, as set out in the email from Mr Kearney and its attachments. Mr Lauro complains that that response is inadequate. He submits that his request pursuant to r 23.4(1) required disclosure of the partnership details of the respondent as described in his originating application. In that document, he named as the respondent: MINTER ELLISON (A FIRM) (ABN: 77478593704) Trading as MINTER ELLISON (ABN: 77478593704) Mr Kearney’s email provides the partnership details for the respondent ‘being MinterEllison (A Firm) (ABN 77478593704)’. The absence of a space is said to make the email non-responsive to the request. In my view, given the common ABN references, there is nothing of significance in that difference. It follows that I am not persuaded the respondent failed to comply with r 23.4(2), nor that there is a reason to make a further order requiring disclosure of partnership details pursuant to r 23.4(3) with reference to the two dates mentioned. Insofar as the appellant seeks disclosure with respect to what may be a different partnership, being a partnership associated with the ABN 91 556 716 819, I am not satisfied that r 23.4(2) required disclosure with respect to a partnership that has not distinctly been named in the proceeding. As earlier noted, Mr Lauro’s evidence is that the CourtsSA portal does not facilitate the entry of multiple ABNs for a party name. Be that as it may, it would appear that the appellant did not take the step of naming two different partnerships or firms as separate respondents. Next, I consider the request for disclosure of partnership details as at 31 May 2001. This is said to be the date of the retainer. I do not have any evidence of that fact, but for present purposes I will assume it to be correct. In the underlying taxation, a change in the composition (or even identity) of the partnership between 2001 and the institution of the originating application may be of some legal or forensic significance. Even if I assume that it is (and I have not heard detailed submissions that would allow me to make that conclusion at this stage), I am unable to see why it would be a proper exercise of discretion to make the order sought in the appellate proceeding.