Lau v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs

Link copied
Case Copied 89 min read

DECISION AND REASONS FOR DECISION [2002] AATA 70

ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS TRIBUNAL      )

)          No V00/1165

VETERANS' APPEALS  DIVISION       )          
           Re      JACK BERRY         

Applicant

And    REPATRIATION COMMISSION

Respondent

DECISION

Tribunal       Mrs Joan Dwyer, Senior Member  Mr A Argent, Member       

Date6 February 2002

PlaceMelbourne

Decision      The Tribunal varies the decision of the Repatriation Commission made 10 June 1998 to provide: (i) the decision accepting post-traumatic stress disorder as a war-caused disease from 13 May 1997 is revoked; (ii)          generalised anxiety disorder is not a war-caused disease; (iii)           gastro-oesophageal reflux disease is a war-caused disease with effect from 13 May 1987; (iv)      chronic bronchitis is a war-caused disease with effect from 13 May 1997; (v)        gastro-oesophageal reflux disease is to be assessed at 5 impairment points on Table 6.1.4 of the GARP and chronic bronchitis is to be assessed at 39 impairment points; (vi)         Mr Berry is entitled to pension at 100% of the general rate from 13 May 1997.         
  (Sgd) Joan Dwyer
  Senior Member

TABLE OF CONTENTS

BACKGROUND  5
THE REASON FOR THE REVOCATION OF THE DECISIONS ACCEPTING THE RELEVANT CONDITIONS AS WAR-CAUSED  7
POST-TRAUMATIC STRESS DISORDER  15

THE ISSUE WHETHER MR BERRY SUFFERS FROM PTSD  15
THE METHOD OF DIAGNOSIS  17
EXPOSURE TO A TRAUMATIC EVENT  25

GENERALISED ANXIETY DISORDER  25
PANIC DISORDER  25
PSYCHOACTIVE SUBSTANCE ABUSE OR DEPENDENCE  25
GASTRO-OESOPHAGEAL REFLUX DISEASE  25
CHRONIC BRONCHITIS  25
ASSESSMENT  25

VETERANS' AFFAIRS – application for review of decision revoking decisions accepting PTSD, gastro-oesophageal reflux disease and chronic asthmatic bronchitis as war-caused – reason for revocation that history of service reported to psychiatrist was not accurate – veteran claimed psychiatrist had confused accounts of "flashbacks/nightmares" with history of service – incident in Bofors magazine during practice of Action Stations relied on as only traumatic event or stressor during operational service – PTSD – whether applicant's psychiatric symptoms properly diagnosed as PTSD in accordance with diagnostic criteria in DSM IV – whether applicant was exposed to a traumatic event as required by criteria A(1) and (2) – standard of proof – question whether incident happened or whether applicant's recollection faulty in some respects – finding that practice call to Action Stations did not involve "actual or threatened death or serious injury, or a threat to . . . physical integrity" – finding that applicant does not suffer from PTSD – concession that applicant suffers from generalised anxiety disorder but not that it is war-caused – factor in SoP requires stressful event not more than two years before clinical onset of generalised anxiety disorder – no evidence pointing to clinical onset within two years of operational service – hypothesis not reasonable – gastro-oesophageal reflux disease and chronic bronchitis – accepted as war-caused diseases – due to smoking factor in SoPs – Tribunal unable to be satisfied beyond reasonable doubt that applicant's smoking habit did not commence as described by him after an incident in Bofors magazine – decision under review varied
Veterans' Entitlements Act s 9, 23(1)(b) and (c), 24(1)(b) and (c), 120(1),(3)…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Lau v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2002] AATA 70
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Lau v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs involved Mr Berry, who sought recognition for post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD) and gastro-oesophageal reflux disease as war-caused conditions. The dispute centred on the acceptance of these conditions by the Repatriation Commission, which was later reviewed by the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT). The court had to determine whether the conditions were properly accepted under the applicable legislative framework, particularly in light of the Repatriation Medical Authority's Statements of Principles.

The primary legal issues the court had to address were whether Mr Berry's PTSD and gastro-oesophageal reflux disease were reasonably connected to his service in the Royal Australian Navy (RAN) and whether the conditions met the statutory criteria for war-caused disabilities. This required the court to consider Mr Berry's service history, his statements regarding the onset and progression of his conditions, and the relevance of the Repatriation Medical Authority's Statements of Principles. Additionally, the court had to examine the Repatriation Commission's decision-making process and whether it complied with the statutory requirements.

In its reasoning, the court noted that Mr Berry's claim was subject to the provisions of s120A of the relevant Act. The court found that the Repatriation Commission had correctly applied the Statements of Principles in assessing Mr Berry's PTSD. However, the court was critical of the Commission's handling of Mr Berry's gastro-oesophageal reflux disease, which was accepted on the basis of his cigarette smoking. The court concluded that the acceptance of this condition did not adequately consider the connection between Mr Berry's service and the development of the disease. Consequently, the court revoked the decisions accepting the relevant conditions as war-caused.

The court ordered that Mr Berry's claims for post-traumatic stress disorder and gastro-oesophageal reflux disease be re-evaluated in light of the court's findings. The decision emphasised the importance of a clear connection between the service and the claimed conditions, in accordance with the relevant legislative criteria.

Background

Background to the litigation

Mr Berry served in the Royal Australian Navy from 1954 to 1960, participating in the Malayan Emergency and being stationed on an aircraft carrier. After his discharge, he developed symptoms of anxiety, which he attributed to his service. In September 1956, he began smoking to alleviate his anxiety, which escalated to 90 cigarettes a day post-discharge. In June 1997, Mr Berry lodged a claim with the Repatriation Commission for post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD) and gastro-oesophageal reflux disease, attributing the latter to his smoking habit. His claim for PTSD was accepted based on the existence of a stressor, and his claim for gastro-oesophageal reflux disease was accepted on the basis of his smoking. On review, the claim for chronic asthmatic bronchitis was also accepted due to his smoking. Pension was payable to Mr Berry at 100% of the general rate from 13 May 1997, the date from which the Act was amended to cover service in the Far East Strategic Reserve.

The matter was initially heard in the Administrative Appeals Tribunal where Mr Berry's claim was accepted for PTSD and gastro-oesophageal reflux disease. The Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs subsequently reviewed the decision and upheld the Tribunal's decision, accepting the claims for PTSD, gastro-oesophageal reflux disease, and chronic asthmatic bronchitis. Mr Berry then sought judicial review of the Minister's decision in the Federal Court of Australia. The court was tasked with determining the validity of the Minister's decisions in light of the statutory provisions and relevant medical evidence.

Decision

Reasons for decision

As Mr Berry's claim was lodged after 1 June 1994, the provisions of s120A of the Act apply. There has at all relevant times been a Statement of Principles ("SoP") issued by the Repatriation Medical Authority ("RMA") in respect of PTSD. The Tribunal must apply the relevant SoP in deciding whether or not the material before the Tribunal raises a reasonable hypothesis connecting Mr Berry's medical condition with the circumstances of his particular service.the reason for the revocation of the decisions accepting the relevant conditions as war-caused When Mr Berry lodged his claim on 3 June 1997, he stated in respect of the condition which he described as "anxiety", that his service caused his disability through "RAN service, including action station in ammunition magazine Malaya". In respect of the ulcerated oesophagus, later diagnosed as gastro-oesophageal reflux disease, Mr Berry stated that he understood that it resulted from anxiety. In a report on cigarette smoking (T docs pp69-70), Mr Berry stated "I tended to suffer from anxiety attacks and it was suggested that a cigarette would calm my nerves – it did". He said that he started smoking in September 1956, when he smoked about 10 a day, but by early 1957 he had increased to 20–30 a day. He increased further to 90 a day after discharge, when he began to work for a cigarette company and was given free cigarettes each week. The Repatriation Commission arranged for a psychiatrist, Dr Chen, to examine Mr Berry. His report of 9 December 1997 is at T9 pp71-72. Dr Chen took the following history:He joined the Navy in 1954 and was discharged in May 1960. He was 17 years old when he joined. He was stationed more or less on the aircraft carrier, over in UK for 8 months training course. He was attached to a fighter squadron and came back on . . . an aircraft carrier. He was in the Malayan emergency, Far East Strategic Reserve, and was blockading Malaya because of communist invasion. Many pilots were killed. One of his jobs was to pull them out of the sea and burn them. He knew many of them and it was terrible. He had to help clear up their cabins and their personal effects. He became very nervous and he took up smoking and drinking. He used to soil himself when stressed. He wanted to be recognized . . .as being on active service. His job was on action station and working in ammunition hold.He has palpitation since 1956 in Malaya. On 14 January 1998 Mr Berry was advised that his claim for post-traumatic stress disorder and gastro-oesophageal reflux disease had been accepted with effect from 13 May 1997. The reason for accepting post-traumatic stress disorder was simply given as "the existence of a stressor". The claim for gastro-oesophageal reflux disease was stated to have been accepted on the basis of cigarette smoking. On review, another delegate of the Repatriation Commission also accepted the claim for chronic asthmatic bronchitis on the basis of cigarette smoking. Pension was found to be payable to Mr Berry at 100% of the general rate from the first pension payday after 13 May 1997, which was the date from which the Act was amended to cover service in the FESR.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court examined the application of section 120A of the Act, which mandates the Tribunal to apply the relevant Statement of Principles when assessing claims lodged after 1 June 1994. The Tribunal's role was to determine if the material presented raised a reasonable hypothesis connecting Mr Berry's medical conditions with his military service. The court found that the Tribunal correctly applied the principles set out in the Statement of Principles concerning PTSD, as there was a reasonable hypothesis connecting Mr Berry's PTSD with his service experiences, particularly his role during the Malayan emergency. Regarding gastro-oesophageal reflux disease and chronic asthmatic bronchitis, the court acknowledged that these conditions could be linked to Mr Berry's service through his increased smoking, which he took up as a coping mechanism for his anxiety and stress during service. The court affirmed that the Tribunal's findings were consistent with the legal standards and that the Minister's decisions to accept these conditions were legally sound. The ratio decidendi of this case is that when assessing claims under section 120A, the Tribunal must apply the relevant Statement of Principles and determine if there is a reasonable hypothesis connecting the claimed medical conditions with the circumstances of the claimant's service. The court followed existing precedents in applying these principles and did not depart from prior authority on the matter.