Lastra Pena (Migration)

Link copied
Case Copied 13 min read

Lastra Pena (Migration) [2024] AATA 2257 (22 April 2024)

DECISION RECORD

DIVISION:Migration & Refugee Division

REVIEW APPLICANT:  Mr Juan Felix Lastra Pena

VISA APPLICANTS:  Ms Rosse Mary Jarro Cuyo
Mr Limbert Zamudio Jarro
Mr Pedro Martin Zamudio Jarro

REPRESENTATIVE:  Mr Surendra Man Shrestha, migration agent, Australian Immigration & Citizenship Centre

CASE NUMBER:  2309455

HOME AFFAIRS REFERENCE(S):          BCC2017/2267796

MEMBER:Michael Ison

DATE:22 April 2024

PLACE OF DECISION:  Melbourne

DECISION:The Tribunal remits the applications for a Prospective Marriage (Temporary) (Class TO) visa for reconsideration, with the direction that the first named visa applicant meets the following criteria for a Subclass 300 (Prospective Marriage) visa:

·cl 300.214 of Schedule 2 to the Regulations.

Statement made on 22 April 2024 at 12:33pm

CATCHWORDS
MIGRATION – Prospective Marriage (Temporary) (Class TO) visa – subclass 300 – parties met in person in Chile – decision under review remitted

LEGISLATION
Migration Act 1958, s 65
Migration Regulations 1994, Schedule 2, cl 300.214

STATEMENT OF DECISION AND REASONS

APPLICATION FOR REVIEW

  1. This is an application for review of decisions made by a delegate of the Minister for Home Affairs to refuse to grant the visa applicants Prospective Marriage (Temporary) (Class TO) visas under s 65 of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth) (the Act).

    Background

  2. The primary visa applicant is Ms Rosse Mary Jarro Cuyo who is 51 years-old and is a national of Bolivia. Ms Jarro Cuyo is referred to as the visa applicant or first named visa applicant in these reasons for decision as the context requires.

  3. The review applicant is Mr Juan Felix Lastra Pena who is 74-years-old, was born in Chile and is a national of Australia, having acquired Australian citizenship on 18 November 1987 by conferral. Mr Lastra Pena is referred to as the review applicant in these reasons for decision.  

  4. On 7 January 2011 the visa applicant applied for her Prospective Marriage (Class TO) (Subclass 300) visa as the prospective spouse of her sponsor for that visa, the review applicant. Mr Limbert Zamudio Jarro and Mr Pedro Martin Zamudio Jarro were also included in that Prospective Marriage visa application as members of the family unit of the visa applicant, being her sons from a previous de facto relationship. At the time of this decision Mr Limbert Zamudio Jarro is aged 30 and Mr Pedro Zamudio Jarro is aged 23 and both are nationals of Bolivia.

  5. Mr Limbert Zamudio Jarro and Mr Pedro Zamudio Jarro are referred to as the second named and third named visa applicant’s respectively or collectively as the secondary visa applicants in these reasons for decision.

  6. The visa applicant’s first application for the Subclass 300 visa was refused by a delegate of the Minister on 28 February 2011. The review applicant did not apply for review by the Tribunal of that visa refusal.   

  7. On 27 June 2017 the visa applicant applied a second time for a Prospective Marriage (Class TO) (Subclass 300) visa as the prospective spouse of her sponsor, the review applicant. The visa application was…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Lastra Pena (Migration) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] AATA 2257
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an application for review of decisions made by a delegate of the Minister for Home Affairs to refuse Prospective Marriage (Temporary) (Class TO) visas (subclass 300) to Ms Rosse Mary Jarro Cuyo, a Bolivian national, and her sons, Mr Limbert Zamudio Jarro and Mr Pedro Zamudio Jarro. The sponsor for the visa was Mr Juan Felix Lastra Pena, an Australian citizen. The review applicant, Mr Lastra Pena, appealed to the Federal Circuit Court of Australia after the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT) initially found it lacked jurisdiction to review the delegate's decision. The Federal Circuit Court quashed the AAT's decision and remitted the application back to the AAT for reconsideration.

The primary legal issue before the AAT was whether the visa applicant and the review applicant had met in person since turning 18 and were known to each other personally, as required by clause 300.214 of Schedule 2 to the Migration Regulations 1994 (Cth). The delegate had refused the visas on the basis that the applicants had not provided sufficient evidence to satisfy this criterion. The AAT was tasked with reviewing this refusal.

The AAT considered evidence presented by the parties, including testimony from Mr Lastra Pena and his son, Mr Lastra Ochra. Mr Lastra Pena stated he first met the visa applicant online in 2009 and subsequently met her in person in Santiago, Chile, where he claims to have sponsored her travel and stayed for two months. Mr Lastra Ochra testified that he believed the relationship was genuine and that he had met the visa applicant during a trip to Bolivia. The AAT noted discrepancies in Mr Lastra Pena's recollection of dates but did not draw adverse inferences due to the age of the events and Mr Lastra Pena's age. The AAT concluded that the matter should be remitted for reconsideration, implying that the delegate's initial assessment of the evidence may have been flawed or incomplete.

The Federal Circuit Court, in its ex tempore decision, found that the AAT's previous decision was affected by an error, referencing the Federal Court's decision in *Sandor v MICMA* [2023] FCA 434. Although the Minister made a formal submission that *Sandor* was wrongly decided, the Court considered itself bound by that Federal Court decision. Consequently, the Court ordered that the AAT review the primary decision according to law.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

This is an application for review of decisions made by a delegate of the Minister for Home Affairs to refuse to grant the visa applicants Prospective Marriage (Temporary) (Class TO) visas under s 65 of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth) (the Act).Background The primary visa applicant is Ms Rosse Mary Jarro Cuyo who is 51 years-old and is a national of Bolivia. Ms Jarro Cuyo is referred to as the visa applicant or first named visa applicant in these reasons for decision as the context requires. The review applicant is Mr Juan Felix Lastra Pena who is 74-years-old, was born in Chile and is a national of Australia, having acquired Australian citizenship on 18 November 1987 by conferral. Mr Lastra Pena is referred to as the review applicant in these reasons for decision. On 7 January 2011 the visa applicant applied for her Prospective Marriage (Class TO) (Subclass 300) visa as the prospective spouse of her sponsor for that visa, the review applicant. Mr Limbert Zamudio Jarro and Mr Pedro Martin Zamudio Jarro were also included in that Prospective Marriage visa application as members of the family unit of the visa applicant, being her sons from a previous de facto relationship. At the time of this decision Mr Limbert Zamudio Jarro is aged 30 and Mr Pedro Zamudio Jarro is aged 23 and both are nationals of Bolivia. Mr Limbert Zamudio Jarro and Mr Pedro Zamudio Jarro are referred to as the second named and third named visa applicant’s respectively or collectively as the secondary visa applicants in these reasons for decision. The visa applicant’s first application for the Subclass 300 visa was refused by a delegate of the Minister on 28 February 2011. The review applicant did not apply for review by the Tribunal of that visa refusal. On 27 June 2017 the visa applicant applied a second time for a Prospective Marriage (Class TO) (Subclass 300) visa as the prospective spouse of her sponsor, the review applicant. The visa application was made on the grounds of the visa applicant’s intention to marry the review applicant. This was the visa application that included both of the visa applicant’s sons. The visa applicant and review applicant claim that they first met in person on 13 June 2013 in Santiago, Chile. They also claim to have committed to a shared life to the exclusion of all others on that date when they got engaged in a Church in Chile. However, at time of the visa application, the applicants did not provide a Notice of Intention to Marry to the delegate. On 23 January 2018 the delegate received a letter from a marriage celebrant dated 25 August 2017 stating that the marriage will take place on 7 April 2018 at 1 Tyree Avenue in Springvale, Victoria. The visa applicant has been in a de facto relationship once previously, from 21 January 1992 to 25 April 2003. The visa applicant’s sons were born during that relationship. The review applicant has been married once previously, from 17 December 1974 to 10 December 1987 and that marriage produced two children.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

For the following reasons, the Tribunal has concluded that the matter should be remitted for reconsideration.CONSIDERATION OF CLAIMS AND EVIDENCE The issue in the present case is whether the visa applicant and review applicant have met in person since they each turned 18 and are known to each other personally.Have the applicants met in person and are they known to each other personally? Clause 300.214 has two requirements. The first is that the parties have met in person. This first requirement reflects that the parties must have physically met each other – not merely by telephone, video call or through social media or written correspondence. The second is that the parties are known to each other personally. This second requirement reflects that a single or fleeting in-person meeting may not be sufficient because being known to each other imports at least the beginning of the development of some form of relationship. The parties did not provide relationship statements with the visa application, did not provide evidence of having met in person and did not provide evidence of communications between them. The Department wrote to the review applicant three times and granted the review applicant an extension of time to respond to the third letter but did not receive further information from the review applicant prior to making the decision to refuse the visa applications on 9 May 2018. During the Tribunal hearing Mr Lastra Ochra told the Tribunal that the application for the visa has been a drawn-out process during which his father, the review applicant, has suffered a lot. Mr Lastra Ochra’s evidence is he travelled through Bolivia for a week in 2018 and stayed one night with the visa applicant, met the second named visa applicant whilst the third named visa applicant was away at university. Mr Lastra Ochra told the Tribunal the visa applicant spoke very warmly about the review applicant when Mr Lastra Ochra was in Bolivia and he has spoken to her a number of times on the telephone throughout her relationship with his father. Mr Lastra Ochra told the Tribunal he believes the relationship between his father and the visa applicant is “100% genuine”. The review applicant told the Tribunal that he first met the visa applicant online on an internet website Latino-American Cupid in approximately 2011. With the subsequent evidence provided to the Tribunal it is clear they first met online in 2009 and that the review applicant is a not an accurate historian in this and other regards. However, given the Tribunal was discussing events with the review applicant that occurred 10 to 15 years ago and also given the review applicant’s age the Tribunal has not drawn any adverse inferences from the review applicant’s incorrect recollection of dates in this review. The review applicant’s evidence is that he and the visa applicant initially communicated through the website, then by telephone before meeting in person in Santiago, Chile where the review applicant has family. The review applicant told the Tribunal he paid for the travel of the visa applicant and her children and he stayed in Chile for two months, they stayed for approximately six weeks and they visited members of his large family including his grandparents in Rancagu for a week to 10 days, went to the beach often because there are no beaches in Bolivia and visited different cities and places in Chile. The review applicant told the Tribunal that during their stay in Rancagu one of the visa applicant’s sons broke his hand and had to go to hospital but because they were Bolivian and not Chilean citizens, the review applicant had to pay for the hospital expenses before the visa applicant’s son would be treated.

Decision

Reasons for decision

The visa applicant’s second application for the Subclass 300 Prospective Marriage visa was refused on 9 May 2018. It is the refusal to grant the applicants’ those Prospective Marriage visas that is the subject of this review. The primary decision of a delegate of the Minister The review applicant provided the Tribunal with a copy of the primary decision. The visa applicants applied for the visas on 27 June 2017. At the time the visa application was lodged, Class TO contained only one subclass: Subclass 300 (Prospective Marriage). The criteria for a Subclass 300 visa are set out in Part 300 of Schedule 2 to the Migration Regulations 1994 (Cth) (the Regulations). The primary criteria must be satisfied by at least one applicant. Other members of the family unit, if any, who are applicants for the visa need satisfy only the secondary criteria. Relevantly to this matter the primary criteria include cl 300.214 which provides:(1) The applicant and the prospective spouse have met in person since each of them turned 18.(2) The applicant and the prospective spouse are known to each other personally. The delegate refused to grant the visas on 9 May 2018 on the basis that the first named visa applicant did not satisfy cl 300.214 of Schedule 2 to the Regulations because the delegate found the applicants did not provide any evidence of the visa applicant having met the review applicant in person after they each turned 18 years of age.Review 1821080 before the Tribunal (differently constituted) The review applicant lodged the application for review of the primary decision with the Tribunal on 20 July 2018. The review applicant’s application was considered by the Tribunal, differently constituted, in Tribunal review 1821080. On 6 August 2018 the Tribunal decided in writing that it did not have jurisdiction in this matter as the application for review was not received by the Tribunal until 20 July 2018, when at the time an application for review had to be lodged with the Tribunal within 70 days of the applicant being notified of the Department’s refusal to grant the visas. The 70th day after the primary decision was 18 June 2018. Review by the Federal Circuit Court On 22 August 2018 the review applicant appealed to the Federal Circuit Court of Australia, as it then was, for judicial review of the Tribunal’s decision in Tribunal review 1821080. On 15 June 2023 the Federal Circuit Court quashed the Tribunal’s decision dated 6 August 2018 and remitted the review applicant’s application back to the Tribunal, with the consent of the Minister, with an order that the Tribunal review the primary decision according to law as follows:The Court (sic) made an ex tempore decision and did not provide written reasons. The Department advised that the Minister accepted that the Tribunal decision was affected by the same error found in Sandor v MICMA [2023] FCA 434 but made a formal submission that Sandor is wrong. The Court found it was bound to follow the Federal Court's decision in Sandor.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established