Landmark Operations Ltd v J Tiver Nominees Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 68 min read

Supreme Court of South Australia

(Civil)

LANDMARK OPERATIONS LTD v J TIVER NOMINEES PTY LTD & ORS

[2008] SASC 322

Judgment of The Honourable Justice Sulan

21 November 2008

BANKING AND FINANCE - INSTRUMENTS - LOAN FACILITIES

MORTGAGES - MORTGAGES AND CHARGES GENERALLY - THE MORTGAGE - LIABILITIES SECURED

MORTGAGES - MORTGAGES AND CHARGES GENERALLY - REMEDIES OF THE MORTGAGEE - ENTRY INTO POSSESSION

Mortgages – loan facilities – plaintiff a rural financier – second to sixth defendants partners in a farming business (‘Flagstaff Proprietors’) – first defendant trustee of family trust – plaintiff and Flagstaff Proprietors entered into financial facility agreement (‘the Facility Agreement’) – Facility Agreement secured by real property mortgages and stock and crop mortgages (‘the Securities’), granted by first to fifth defendants in favour of plaintiff – first defendant guaranteed the obligations of second to sixth defendants (‘the Guarantee’).

Flagstaff Proprietors defaulted – Facility Agreement varied – further defaults – credit reviews conducted by plaintiff – further variations to Facility Agreement – sustained and repeated breaches of terms and conditions of Facility Agreement by Flagstaff Proprietors – notices of demand served – notices of default and intention to sell served – proceedings commenced – judgment sought for amount outstanding under Facility Agreement and interest, possession of real property the subject of the property mortgages and execution and enforcement of stock and crop mortgages.

Held:  Judgment entered for the plaintiff – Facility Agreement, real property mortgages and Guarantee valid, binding and enforceable – plaintiff entitled to possession of real property securing the Facility Agreement and execution and enforcement of stock and crop mortgages.

CONTRACTS - GENERAL CONTRACTUAL PRINCIPLES - CONSTRUCTION AND INTERPRETATION OF CONTRACTS - IMPLIED TERMS

Defence and counterclaim - contracts - oral and implied terms - whether terms and conditions of Facility Agreement wholly reduced to writing - whether written terms and conditions supplemented by oral and/or implied terms - whether plaintiff's offer of finance under Facility Agreement conditional upon Flagstaff Proprietors engaging in farming practices of a type and nature required by the plaintiff - whether provision of expert agronomic advice by the plaintiff to Flagstaff Proprietors an oral term of the Facility Agreement.

Held:  The terms and conditions of the Facility Agreement are wholly comprised in the written terms and conditions of that agreement and any variations thereto are similarly completely reduced to writing.

BANKING AND FINANCE - BANKS - LIABILITIES OF BANKS - FRAUD, UNDUE INFLUENCE AND UNCONSCIONABLE CONDUCT

TRADE AND COMMERCE - TRADE PRACTICES AND RELATED MATTERS - CONSUMER PROTECTION - MISLEADING, DECEPTIVE OR UNCONSCIONABLE CONDUCT

EQUITY - GENERAL PRINCIPLES - REMEDIES AND PROCEDURE - FRAUD OR MISREPRESENTATION AS A DEFENCE OR ANSWER

TRADE AND COMMERCE - TRADE PRACTICES AND RELATED MATTERS - CONSUMER PROTECTION - RESCISSION OF CONTRACTS

Defence and counterclaim – unconscionability – misleading and deceptive conduct – financial claims – whether plaintiff took unconscionable advantage of Flagstaff Proprietors when negotiating entry into Facility Agreement – whether plaintiff acted unconscionably in the course of its relationship with Flagstaff Proprietors…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Landmark Operations Ltd v J Tiver Nominees Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2008] SASC 322
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Landmark Operations Ltd v J Tiver Nominees Pty Ltd, the plaintiff, a rural financier, sought judgment against the defendants for the amount outstanding under a financial facility agreement, interest, possession of certain real property, and execution and enforcement of stock and crop mortgages. The defendants, partners in a farming business known as Flagstaff Proprietors, contested the plaintiff's claims and counterclaimed for breach of contract and negligence. The dispute centred on the enforceability of the financial facility agreement, the validity of the mortgages and guarantee, and whether the plaintiff had breached any contractual obligations, including the provision of agronomic advice.

The court had to determine whether the financial facility agreement, the real property mortgages, and the guarantee were valid, binding, and enforceable. It also had to assess whether the terms of the agreement were wholly written or supplemented by oral and/or implied terms, and whether the plaintiff's offer of finance was conditional upon the farming practices of the defendants. Furthermore, the court needed to examine whether the provision of expert agronomic advice by the plaintiff was an implied term of the Facility Agreement.

The court held that the financial facility agreement, the real property mortgages, and the guarantee were valid, binding, and enforceable. The court found that the terms of the Facility Agreement were entirely written and did not include any oral or implied terms. The court rejected the defendants' claims that the plaintiff had a duty to provide expert agronomic advice or that such advice constituted a term of the contract. Additionally, the court concluded that the plaintiff had not breached any contractual obligations and that the defendants had failed to prove any loss or damage due to the conduct of the plaintiff.

The court entered judgment in favour of the plaintiff, granting possession of the real property, the enforcement of the stock and crop mortgages, and the recovery of the amount outstanding under the Facility Agreement, including interest. The defendants' counterclaims were dismissed.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Flagstaff Proprietors did not keep proper records of the purchase, ownership, breeding or progeny or sale of cattle held on its properties, or which of the entities associated with Flagstaff Proprietors owned the cattle.[873] John Tiver testified that different entities owned different breeds. Ownership of the cattle is further complicated by the fact that different breeds, said to be owned by different entities, were mated in order to commence the beef cattle enterprise of Flagstaff Proprietors.[873] T 1735 and T 1737.Conclusions I am satisfied that the plaintiff and the second to sixth defendants entered into the Facility Agreement, which was comprised entirely in writing in its letter of offer dated 26 November 2001,[874] and subsequently varied by letters of offer dated 8 August 2002,[875] and 24 July 2003.[876] The terms of the letters set out the entirety of the agreement between the parties. I reject the defendants' claim that there were oral or implied terms of the contract.[874] Exhibit P2.[875] Exhibit P23.[876] Exhibit P26. I find that officers of Landmark indicated to John and Margaret Tiver at the meeting on 1 November 2001, and subsequently, that Landmark could provide expert agronomic assistance to Flagstaff Proprietors. I am satisfied that such assistance was provided by Glen Hillebrand and Robbie Calaby. I reject the defendants' submission that it was a term of the contract that Landmark was to provide expert agronomic advice, and that Landmark would assess Flagstaff Proprietors’ needs and supply seeds, fertiliser, sprays, chemicals and other items. I reject the defendants' claim that Landmark owed a fiduciary duty to Flagstaff Proprietors or that Landmark breached any duty to the defendants in the provision of agronomic advice. Further, I conclude that the defendants have failed to prove any loss or damage due to the conduct of Landmark. I am satisfied that, pursuant to Clause H4 of the Facility Agreement,[877] Clause 11 of the Property Mortgages,[878] and Sub-Clause 2.2(k) of the Guarantee,[879] a certificate issued by or on behalf of the plaintiff is conclusive and binding upon the defendants as to the amount payable by Flagstaff Proprietors and guaranteed by the first defendant.[877] Clause H4 of the Facility Agreement (Exhibit P2) relevantly provides:a certificate signed by or on behalf of [the plaintiff]…as to a matter or as to an amount payable to [the plaintiff] in connection with the Facility Agreement is conclusive and binding on [the second to sixth defendants] as to the amount stated in it or any other matter of a factual nature except in the case of manifest error.[878] Clause 11 of the Property Mortgages (Exhibit P15) relevantly provides:a written statement signed by any of [the plaintiff’s] representatives of the amount of the Monies Secured or any part thereof owing or due and owing by [the first to fifth defendants] to the [plaintiff] at any time shall, in the absence of manifest error, be prima facie evidence as against all persons other than the [plaintiff] that such amount is owing or due and owing and falls within the description of the Monies Secured and of any other matter contained in that statement as at the date it is made out without the [plaintiff] being required to produce any books of account or other records or any copies of any of them to the [first to fifth defendants] or any other person.[879] Sub-Clause 2.2(k) of the Guarantee (Exhibit P8) relevantly provides:a certificate signed by or on behalf of any Officer of the [plaintiff] or any other person duly authorised by the [plaintiff] for that purpose stating the amount of money payable by [first defendant] is conclusive and binding.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.