Kumar v Minister for Immigration and Anor

Link copied
Case Copied 17 min read

FEDERAL CIRCUIT COURT OF AUSTRALIA

KUMAR v MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION & ANOR [2020] FCCA 1377
Catchwords:
MIGRATION – Extension of Time Application – insufficient explanation – lack of merit – extension of time refused.

Legislation:

Migration Act 1958 (Cth), s.477

Federal Circuit Court Rules 2001 (Cth), r.7.01, pt.3 div.1 sch.1

Cases cited:

Gupta v Minister for Immigration [2016] FCA 1004
Kumar v Minister for Immigration [2014] FCCA 2589
MZABP v Minister for Immigration & Border Protection [2015] FCA 1391
MZXHY v Minister for Immigration [2007] FCA 622
MZZIV v Minister for Immigration & Border Protection [2013] FCA 1203
SZJMG v Minister for Immigration [2008] FCA 1145
SZTES v Minister for Immigration & Border Protection [2015] FCA 719
SZTRY v Minister for Immigration & Border Protection [2015] FCAFC 86

Applicant: SHAM KUMAR
First Respondent: MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION, CITIZENSHIP, MIGRANT SERVICES AND MULTICULTURAL AFFAIRS
Second Respondent: ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS TRIBUNAL
File Number: MLG 1938 of 2016
Judgment of: Judge C. E. Kirton QC
Hearing date: 22 November 2018
Date of Last Submission: 22 November 2018
Delivered at: Melbourne
Delivered on: 3 June 2020

REPRESENTATION

Applicant: In person with the assistance of an interpreter
Solicitors for the Respondents: Australian Government Solicitor
Second Respondent: Submitting appearance, save as to costs

ORDERS

  1. Pursuant to r.7.01 of the Federal Circuit Court Rules 2001 (Cth), the name of the First Respondent be amended to “Minister for Immigration, Citizenship, Migrant Services and Multicultural Affairs”.

  2. The application for an extension of time pursuant to s.477(2) of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth) be dismissed.

  3. The Applicant pay the First Respondent’s costs fixed in the sum of $6,000.

FEDERAL CIRCUIT COURT
OF AUSTRALIA
AT MELBOURNE

MLG 1938 of 2016

SHAM KUMAR

Applicant

And

MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION, CITIZENSHIP, MIGRANT SERVICES AND MULTICULTURAL AFFAIRS

First Respondent

ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS TRIBUNAL

Second Respondent

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

Introduction

  1. By application filed in this Court on 9 September 2016 (Substantive Application), the Applicant seeks judicial review of a decision of the Second Respondent (Tribunal) made on 11 July 2016 (Tribunal’s Decision).  The Tribunal’s Decision affirmed a decision of a delegate (Delegate) of the First Respondent (Minister) to refuse to grant the Applicant a subclass 801 Partner (Residence) (Class BS) visa (Visa).

  2. In the Substantive Application, the Applicant seeks an extension of time (Extension of Time Application) pursuant to s.477(2) of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth) (Act) to pursue the Substantive Application.

  3. The Applicant was unrepresented before this Court and appeared with the assistance of an interpreter in the English and Punjabi languages.

Background

  1. The Court had before it a Court Book numbering 156 pages.  The Court has reviewed the material contained in the Court Book in detail.

  2. The Court notes that the Minister’s written submissions filed on 28 April 2017 (Minister’s Submissions) at [2] to [9] accurately summarise the factual history of this matter.  With some minor alterations, the Court adopts those submissions, as its own.  They provide,…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Kumar v Minister for Immigration and Anor and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2020] FCCA 1377
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The applicant, Mr. Kumar, sought judicial review of a decision by the Migration Review Tribunal (MRT) which affirmed the refusal of his Subclass 801 visa. The MRT had previously found that it lacked jurisdiction to review the refusal of his Subclass 820 visa due to a late application. Following a re-notification of the Subclass 801 refusal by the Department, the applicant lodged a new application for review with the MRT. The MRT heard evidence from the applicant and his friend, Ms. Devi, and ultimately affirmed the decision to refuse the Subclass 801 visa.

The primary legal issue before the court was whether the MRT had erred in affirming the refusal of the Subclass 801 visa. Specifically, the court considered whether the MRT had correctly applied the relevant criteria for the Subclass 801 visa, particularly the requirement that the applicant must be the holder of a Subclass 820 visa. The court also examined the applicant's evidence and the Tribunal's findings regarding his failure to demonstrate he held or had ever held a Subclass 820 visa.

The court found that the MRT had correctly identified that an essential criterion for the grant of a Subclass 801 visa is that the applicant must be the holder of a Subclass 820 visa. The Tribunal's findings, supported by the evidence presented, were that the applicant had not provided any proof that he held or had ever held a Subclass 820 visa. Consequently, the applicant failed to satisfy this essential requirement. The court noted that the applicant's evidence and submissions predominantly concerned the Subclass 820 decision, and he was unable to recall whether he held a Subclass 820 visa when questioned by the Tribunal.

The application for judicial review was dismissed.

Background

Background to the litigation

Mr Kumar is a citizen of India who sought a Subclass 801 visa, a provisional visa that requires the applicant to hold a Subclass 820 visa. The Subclass 820 visa refusal notice was issued on 24 February 2014. Mr Kumar applied for review of this decision with the Migration Review Tribunal (MRT), but the application was dismissed for being lodged beyond the 21-day statutory period. Mr Kumar subsequently applied for judicial review of the MRT decision, which was dismissed on 10 November 2014.

On 19 January 2016, the Minister’s Department notified Mr Kumar of an error in the Subclass 801 Decision and informed him that a new decision record would be provided. On 8 March 2016, Mr Kumar received re-notification of the refusal of his Subclass 801 visa. He then applied to the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT) for review of the Subclass 801 Decision on 24 March 2016. On 8 April 2016, Mr Kumar notified the AAT that he would be represented by Viva Immigration. On 29 June 2016, Mr Kumar appeared before the AAT, providing evidence, arguments, and copies of the Subclass 820 and Subclass 801 decision records. The AAT also heard oral evidence from Ms Sila Devi, a friend of Mr Kumar, and the Applicant was assisted by an interpreter in English and Punjabi.

The AAT affirmed the Subclass 801 Decision on 11 July 2016. It found that an essential requirement for a Subclass 801 visa is that the applicant is the holder of a Subclass 820 visa, which Mr Kumar did not satisfy. The AAT noted that Mr Kumar provided evidence predominantly concerning the Subclass 820 Decision and did not provide evidence that he held or had ever held a Subclass 820 visa. The AAT’s decision affirmed the Subclass 801 refusal, finding that Mr Kumar had not met the essential criteria for the visa.

This case concerns the procedural history of Kumar v Minister for Immigration and Anor, a matter that has traversed multiple tribunals and courts in Australia. Initially, the Applicant, Mr Kumar, filed an application for review with the Migration Review Tribunal (MRT) concerning a refusal of a Subclass 820 visa. However, the MRT found that it did not have jurisdiction to review the Subclass 820 Decision as the application was filed more than 21 days after the deemed service. Mr Kumar subsequently applied for judicial review of the MRT Decision, which was dismissed by the Federal Circuit Court of Australia on 10 November 2014. Following this, the Minister's Department notified Mr Kumar of an error in relation to the Subclass 801 Decision and provided a new decision record. On 8 March 2016, Mr Kumar received re-notification and reasons for the refusal of the Subclass 801 Visa. On 24 March 2016, Mr Kumar applied to the Tribunal for review of the Subclass 801 Decision, which was heard on 29 June 2016. During the hearing, the Applicant presented evidence and arguments, with an interpreter assisting in English and Punjabi. Ultimately, on 11 July 2016, the Tribunal affirmed the Subclass 801 Decision to refuse the Visa.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The Tribunal expressed concern throughout the hearing that much of the evidence that was provided by the Applicant indicated that he was confused, and that he was providing evidence surrounding the Subclass 820 Decision. The Tribunal explained and confirmed with the Applicant on several occasions that it is the Subclass 801 Decision under review, and not the Subclass 820 Decision[20]. At [11], [20] and [22], for example, the Tribunal stated the following to clarify which decision was under review:11.The Tribunal told Mr Kumar that on the application for review form which he submitted to the Tribunal he had sought review of a Subclass 820 visa refusal. The Tribunal sought clarification from Mr Kumar whether it was his intention that the Tribunal review the Subclass 820 or the Subclass 801 refusal. Mr Kumar told the Tribunal his intent is to have the Subclass 801 reviewed. As a result the Tribunal will review the Subclass 801 refusal.[…]20.He did not have any proof that he held or holds a Subclass 820 visa. When Macrina Celeste, his sponsor, went to the Philippines he gave her approximately $5,000. When she returned she had the letter from Immigration and after he gave her some money she gave him the letter. The Tribunal clarified that Mr Kumar was talking about the Subclass 820 refusal notification and he responded in the affirmative. Mr Kumar told the Tribunal the parties fought and Ms Celeste left the home and the parties have not lived together since 2013.[20] See CB 154, at [11], [20] and [22] for example.[…]Ms Devi’s evidence 22.Mr Kumar is a good guy. She has known him since the time he married his sponsor. The letter sent to him by the Department to inform him of the Subclass 820 visa he did not receive in time. He was told that if he went to the Department he would be provided additional time to respond. The Tribunal told Ms Devi that this information referred to the refusal of the Subclass 820 visa and this Tribunal review was for the Subclass 801 visa. As it is an essential criteria for the grant of the Visa that “the applicant is the holder of a Subclass 820 visa”, and this criteria had not been met, the Tribunal affirmed the decision of the Delegate not to grant the Applicant the Visa[21]. At [23]-[26], the Tribunal stated:23.Mr Kumar did not provide any evidence that he held a Subclass 820 visa and there is no other material before the Tribunal which indicates he holds a Subclass 820 visa. At the time of this decision Mr Kumar has not provided any evidence to the Tribunal that he is the holder of a Subclass 820 visa.24.The question in this case is whether Mr Kumar meets the requirements for a Subclass 801 visa.25.The criteria for a Subclass 801 visa are attached to this decision. An essential requirement for a Subclass 801 visa is that “the applicant is the holder of a Subclass 820 visa”.26.The evidence before the Tribunal is that Mr Kumar is not the holder of a Subclass 820 visa therefore it follows that he cannot be granted a Subclass 801 visa.[21] CB 155, at [25]-[26].

Decision

Reasons for decision

On 24 February 2014, the MRT found it did not have jurisdiction to review the Subclass 820 Decision, as the review application had been filed more than 21 days from the day of deemed service[3] (MRT Decision). The Applicant then applied for judicial review of the MRT Decision, which was dismissed on 10 November 2014 by this Court[4].[3] CB 129 -130.[4] Kumar v Minister for Immigration [2014] FCCA 2589. On 19 January 2016, the Minister’s Department (Department) wrote to the Applicant to notify him of an error in relation to the Subclass 801 Decision and that a new decision record would be provided[5].[5] CB 131-132. On 8 March 2016, the Department wrote to the Applicant providing re‑notification and reasons for the refusal of the Subclass 801 Visa (Re-notification Notice)[6]. [6] CB 133-136. On 24 March 2016, the Applicant applied to the Tribunal for review of the Subclass 801 Decision[7].[7] CB 137-138. On 8 April 2016, the Applicant notified the Tribunal that he would be represented by Viva Immigration[8].[8] CB 141-142. On 29 June 2016, the Applicant appeared at the Tribunal. The Applicant gave evidence, presented arguments and provided the Tribunal with a copy of the decision record for the Subclass 820 Decision and the Subclass 801 Decision. The Tribunal also heard oral evidence from Ms Sila Devi, the Applicant’s friend. The Applicant was assisted by an interpreter in the English and Punjabi languages[9].[9] CB 148-150; 153, at [10]. On 11 July 2016, the Tribunal affirmed the Subclass 801 Decision to refuse the Visa. The Tribunal’s Decision appears at pages 153 to 155 of the Court Book. The Minister’s Submissions at [11] to [15] accurately summarise the Tribunal’s Decision. The Court adopts the summary provided in those submissions, with amendments, as its own. The Tribunal first set out the relevant background[10] and outlined the relevant law[11]. The Tribunal then confirmed that the Applicant was seeking review of the Subclass 801 Decision, and not the Subclass 820 Decision[12].[10] CB 153, at [5]-[10].[11] CB 153, at [1]-[3].[12] CB 154, at [11]. The Tribunal accurately identified that an essential requirement for the granting of the Visa is that the Applicant “is the holder of a Subclass 820 visa”[13]. The Tribunal found that there was no evidence that the Applicant holds, or has ever held, a subclass 820 visa, and therefore failed to satisfy the requirement[14]. At [12], the Tribunal stated:The Tribunal told Mr Kumar that an essential requirement for a Subclass 801 visa is that the visa applicant is the holder of a Subclass 820 visa. The Tribunal asked Mr Kumar if he held or had ever held a Subclass 820 visa. Mr Kumar told the Tribunal that he could not remember.[13] CB 155, at [25].[14] CB 155, at [23]. The Applicant gave evidence predominantly regarding the Subclass 820 Decision[15]. The Applicant also gave evidence in respect to the delay in filing his application with the Tribunal for the review of the Subclass 820 Decision, and confirmed that that was all he wished to say[16]. The Applicant did not provide evidence that he holds or has ever held a subclass 820 visa[17].[15] CB 154, at [20].[16] CB 154, at [21].[17] CB 154, at [20].

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court in Kumar v Minister for Immigration and Anor addressed several key issues, starting with the Tribunal's jurisdiction to review the Subclass 801 Decision. The court found that the Tribunal did not have jurisdiction to review the Subclass 820 Decision, as the Applicant filed his review application more than 21 days from the day of deemed service, a timeframe dictated by relevant legislative provisions. The Applicant's confusion between the Subclass 801 and Subclass 820 decisions did not extend the Tribunal's jurisdiction retroactively, and the Tribunal was correct in limiting its review to the Subclass 801 Decision. The court upheld this finding, reinforcing the necessity of adhering to statutory timelines for judicial review applications.

Turning to the essential requirement for a Subclass 801 visa, the court examined whether the Applicant satisfied the criterion that he is the holder of a Subclass 820 visa. The Tribunal found that the Applicant did not provide any evidence that he holds, or has ever held, a Subclass 820 visa. This finding was pivotal, as the Tribunal concluded that the Applicant could not meet the essential requirement for the Subclass 801 visa without holding a Subclass 820 visa. The court agreed with the Tribunal's assessment, highlighting that the lack of evidence supporting the Applicant's claim to hold a Subclass 820 visa was a critical factor in affirming the refusal of the Subclass 801 visa.

The court further considered the Tribunal's finding that the Applicant did not provide evidence that he holds or has ever held a Subclass 820 visa. The Tribunal meticulously noted the Applicant's predominant focus on the Subclass 820 Decision during his testimony, and the absence of any evidence or acknowledgment from the Applicant that he holds a Subclass 820 visa. The court found no error in the Tribunal's conclusion, underscoring that the Applicant's failure to provide relevant evidence was a valid basis for the Tribunal's decision. The Applicant's testimony, which was largely incoherent and focused on the incorrect Subclass 820 Decision, did not support his claim to hold a Subclass 820 visa.

Lastly, the court reviewed the legality, correctness, and reasonableness of the Tribunal's decision to affirm the Subclass 801 Decision to refuse the visa. The Tribunal's decision was grounded in the Applicant's failure to meet the essential requirement of holding a Subclass 820 visa, a requirement clearly stated in the relevant legislation. The court found no legal errors in the Tribunal's reasoning, noting that the decision was based on the lack of evidence provided by the Applicant. The court upheld the Tribunal's decision, confirming that it was lawful, correct, and reasonable given the evidence and legal principles applied. The Tribunal's decision process was thorough, and its conclusion was well-supported by the evidence presented.

The ratio decidendi of this case is that a visa applicant must satisfy all essential requirements for the visa class in question, and the Tribunal's decision to affirm the refusal of a visa is upheld if the applicant fails to provide evidence of meeting these requirements. Additionally, the court confirmed that the Tribunal's jurisdiction is strictly bound by statutory timelines for review applications, and confusion between different visa decisions does not extend this jurisdiction.