Kuan Han Pty Ltd v Oceanview Group Holdings Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 40 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Kuan Han Pty Ltd v Oceanview Group Holdings Pty Ltd [2003] FCA 1063

PRACTICE & PROCEDURE – mareva injunction claimed against third party – ancillary disclosure orders additionally sought – consideration of principles.

Conveyancing Act 1919 (NSW), s 37A
Corporations Act 2001 (Cth), Part 5.7
Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth), ss 51A, 52, 53A
Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth), s 23

Bax Global (Australia) Pty Ltd v Evans & Ors (1999) 47 NSWLR 538
Cardile & Ors v LED Builders Pty Ltd (1999) 198 CLR 380
Patterson v BTR Engineering (Aust) Limited (1989) 18 NSWLR 319

Patrick Stevedores Operations No 2 Pty Ltd v Maritime Union of Australia (1998) 195 CLR 1

A & Anor v C & Ors [1981] QB 956
Reid v Howard (1995) 184 CLR 1
Jackson v Sterling Industries Ltd (1987) 162 CLR 612
CSR Ltd v Cigna Insurance Australia Ltd (1997) 189 CLR 345
Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Top Snack Foods Pty Ltd & Ors [1997] 380 FCA
Southern Equities Corp Ltd (In Liq.) v Bond & Ors (No. 4) [2000] SASC 538

KUAN HAN PTY LIMITED v OCEANVIEW GROUP HOLDINGS PTY LTD

N 1016 OF 2002

CONTI J
12 SEPTEMBER 2003
SYDNEY


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY

N 1016 OF 2002

BETWEEN:

KUAN HAN PTY LIMITED
APPLICANT

AND:

OCEANVIEW GROUP HOLDINGS PTY LTD
RESPONDENT

OCEANVIEW GROUP HOLDINGS PTY LTD
CROSS CLAIMANT

KUAN HAN PTY LIMITED
CROSS RESPONDENT

JUDGE:

CONTI J

DATE OF ORDER:

12 SEPTEMBER 2003

WHERE MADE:

SYDNEY

THE COURT ORDERS THAT upon the applicant having given to the Court the usual undertaking as to damages and a further undertaking to commence proceedings under s 37A of the Conveyancing Act 1919 (NSW):

1. Samuel Issa, by himself, his servants or agents, be restrained until further order of this Court from disposing of, encumbering, otherwise dealing with in any way or lodging for registration any dealing affecting the registration of the property referred to as Folio Identifier Lot 67 of DP 6770;

2.The applicant be permitted to make use of the documents produced by the respondent in these proceedings, under compulsion of law, in proceedings to be commenced in the Supreme Court of New South Wales;

3.Subject to any proper claim of privilege at an appropriate time, and until further order of this Court, the respondent within 7 days of the making of this order file at Court in a sealed envelope marked ‘Only to be opened at a direction of a Judge’ an affidavit or affidavits setting out with particularity:

(a)all current assets and liabilities of the respondent and the approximate value of those assets and liabilities; and

(b)in respect of the funds the subject of the cheques received by or on behalf of the respondent on each of the settlements referred to in the schedule hereto:

(i)the account details of each account in to which the respondent deposited the funds; and

(ii)how and when the respondent dealt with…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Kuan Han Pty Ltd v Oceanview Group Holdings Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2003] FCA 1063
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of Kuan Han Pty Ltd v Oceanview Group Holdings Pty Ltd, the applicant, Kuan Han Pty Ltd, sought relief against the respondent, Oceanview Group Holdings Pty Ltd, due to alleged misrepresentations made during the sale of commercial property. The property, located at 32-36 Princess Street, Brighton-Le-Sands, was sold at auction for $5.91 million. Kuan Han claimed that it was misled regarding the annual outgoings, which were represented as $55,000 per year, while the actual outgoings were significantly higher. Kuan Han sought rescission of the sale contract or compensation for the difference in value. The court was also asked to consider an injunction against a third party, Samuel Issa, who had acquired property from the respondent under suspicious circumstances.

The court needed to determine whether there were grounds to grant relief based on the alleged misrepresentations and whether an injunction should be issued against Samuel Issa to prevent him from disposing of the property. The legal issues included whether Kuan Han had a sufficiently arguable case for misrepresentation under the Trade Practices Act 1974 and whether there were grounds to suspect fraudulent intent in the transfer of property from the respondent to Samuel Issa.

The court found that Kuan Han had presented a credible case of misrepresentation, as there was no evidence from the respondent to contradict the claims. Regarding the injunction against Samuel Issa, the court considered that the transfer of property at a significantly lower price than its fair market value, coupled with the close relationship between the respondent and Samuel Issa, suggested an intent to defraud creditors. Thus, the court deemed it appropriate to issue an injunction to prevent Samuel Issa from disposing of the property until further order.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

What follows is an outline of the material facts which give rise to the present controversy and my reasons for granting the above orders.Further detail of background to the interlocutory applications The substantive proceedings which I have already identified were commenced by statement of claim on 27 September 2002. The context is the purchase of a substantial commercial property at 32-36 Princess Street, Brighton-Le-Sands, New South Wales by the applicant from the respondent for a purchase price of 5.91 million dollars. Those commercial premises are currently occupied by Coles Supermarkets Australia Pty Ltd, which utilises the premises to carry on the business of a supermarket. Prior to the purchase of this commercial property, which occurred at public auction on 20 November 2001, the applicant contends that material misrepresentations, each in contravention of ss 51A, 52, 53A of the Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth) (‘the TP Act’), were made to it on behalf of the respondent in relation to the extent of outgoings payable in respect of the property. These representations were to the effect that the outgoings were $55,000 per year when in fact the true outgoings of the commercial premises at the time the representations were made were either $72,203.01, $112,044.97 or $112,045.41 per annum. The applicant maintains that it was induced to purchase the commercial property for the amount that it did in reliance upon the accuracy of the specified outgoings of $55,000 per year. The applicant apparently acquired its property for investment purposes, and not for occupation. The applicant contends that based on what are the true outgoings, the property is valued at between $4,700,000 and $5,700,000, that is between $200,000 and $1,200,000 less than the price paid by the applicant. The applicant claims, amongst other relief, for an order pursuant to s 87 of the TP Act for rescission of the contract of sale entered into between the applicant and respondent on 20 November 2001, or alternatively an order that the respondent compensate the applicant for the difference between the amount paid under the contract of sale and the true value in the light of the amount of the actual outgoings that prevailed at the time of the alleged representations. The applicant has placed a large body of evidence before the Court which indicates that the applicant has a sufficiently arguable case to the effect that the respondent has contravened ss 51A, 52 and 53A of the TP Act. The respondent did not in these interlocutory proceedings contend otherwise, nor has the respondent filed any evidence refuting the contentions advanced by the applicant in the principal proceedings in spite of the directions of the docket Judge to do so. On 7 July 2003, the applicant’s solicitor informed the respondent’s solicitor by way of letter that it had come to the applicant’s attention that between 17 April 2003 and 7 July 2003 the respondent had ceased to be the registered proprietor of two strata properties forming part of the residential tower of the development, namely Lot 7 on Strata Plan 62254 and Lot 10 on Strata Plan 62254. The applicant’s solicitor further stated that his enquiries to date confirmed that the respondent remained nevertheless the registered proprietor of the property comprised in certificate of title identifier comprising Lot 67 on Deposited Plan 6770, subject to a mortgage in favour of Westpac Banking Corporation. That property is located at 44 Princess Street, Brighton-Le-Sands, and features in these proceedings as the property sold to Samuel Issa allegedly in order to defraud the respondent’s creditors. Number 44 Princess Street is vacant land not falling within Strata Plan 62254. The applicant’s solicitor also conveyed his client’s concern about the way in which the respondent was dealing with its assets and in turn requested that the respondent’s solicitor provide him by no later than 5:00 pm on 14 July 2003 with following information concerning:‘a.the net proceeds of the sale of the two strata units being comprised in the certificate of title folio identifier Lot 7 of SP 62254 and Lot 10 of SP 62254;b.how [the respondent] dealt with the net proceeds and whether there (sic) are still part of the assets of [the respondent];c.why the properties were sold;d.the current estimated value of the property comprised in certificate of title folio identifier Lot 67 of DP 6770, and the current level of indebtedness of [the respondent] to Westpac secured by the mortgage on that property; ande.[the respondent’s] current asset and liability position and evidence to meet a judgement in these proceedings of an amount up to $500,000.’The applicant’s solicitor thereby put the respondent on notice that failing an adequate reply, the applicant would approach the Court for a mareva injunction and any further relief as it may be advised.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

CONTI J

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: CONTI J

Austin J in Bax Global (Australia) Pty Ltd v Evans & Ors (1999) 47 NSWLR 538 at 544-5, observed that ‘[w]ithout information about the nature and location of the defendant’s assets, the plaintiff may be unable to make the risk assessment which is necessary in order to give the undertaking as to damages, or if the undertaking is given, it may lead to an unexpected exposure’. The state of progress of the present interlocutory proceedings before me had sufficiently changed the dynamics of the litigation to warrant in my opinion the proposed Order 2(a) being revisited by me.Resolution of the issues arising for consideration In Cardile & Ors v LED Builders Pty Ltd (1999) 198 CLR 380 Gaudron, McHugh, Gummow and Callinan JJ observed (at 403) that the Court must exercise ‘a high degree of caution’ when invited to grant a mareva injunction and that such an injunction:(i)operates as a very tight negative pledge species of security over property, to which the contempt sanction is attached;(ii)does not deprive the party subject to its restraint either of title to or possession of the assets to which the order extends;(iii)does not improve the position of claimants in an insolvency of the judgment debtor; and(iv)operates in personam and not as an attachment. Following the High Court’s decision in Cardile v LED Builders, a mareva injunction may be appropriately made against a third party to the proceedings ‘assuming the existence of other relevant criteria and discretionary factors, in circumstances in which ... some process, ultimately enforceable by the courts, is or may be available to the judgment creditor as a consequence of a judgment against that actual or potential judgment debtor, pursuant to which, whether by appointment of a liquidator, trustee in bankruptcy, receiver or otherwise, the third party may be obliged to disgorge property or otherwise contribute to the funds or property of the judgment debtor to help satisfy the judgment against the judgment debtor’ (at 405-6 per Gaudron, McHugh, Gummow and Callinan JJ). The applicant contended that legal process is available to compel Samuel Issa to disgorge title to the 44 Princess Street property from s 37A of the Conveyancing Act which provides:‘37A Voluntary alienation to defraud creditors voidable(1)Save as provided in this section, every alienation of property, made whether before or after the commencement of the Conveyancing (Amendment) Act 1930, with intent to defraud creditors, shall be voidable at the instance of any person thereby prejudiced.(2)This section does not affect the law of bankruptcy for the time being in force.(3)This section does not extend to any estate or interest in property alienated to a purchaser in good faith not having, at the time of the alienation, notice of the intent to defraud creditors.’ The applicant’s principal complaint concerning the transfer of the 44 Princess Street property by the respondent to Samuel Issa is essentially that the transaction was made with the intent to defraud creditors. It was pointed out by the applicant that a relevant matter prima facie establishing that intent is that the consideration paid by Samuel Issa was approximately $39,000 less than the $399,000 purchase price paid by the respondent in 1995 which was of course $360,000 recorded in [14] above. The applicant sought to establish that the fair market value of the 44 Princess Street property was $600,000 at the time of transfer to Samuel Issa, and that I should take judicial notice of the circumstance that property prices in Sydney have not stagnated but have rather steadily increased over the material period of time. It was submitted that on no possible view could it be accepted that the 44 Princess Street property was transferred on commercial or arms length financial terms, and that the proximate relationship between the director of the respondent and the transferee of the property tended to fortify that conclusion. It was therefore submitted that there was an arguable case that there had occurred an alienation of the property made with the intent to defraud creditors and that on discretionary grounds, a mareva style injunction should issue against Samuel Issa having the effect of preventing him from disposing of the 44 Princess Street property until further order of this Court.