Kruljac and Australian Postal Corporation (Compensation)

Link copied
Case Copied 73 min read

Kruljac and Australian Postal Corporation (Compensation) [2018] AATA 171 (9 February 2018)

Division:GENERAL DIVISION

File Numbers:         2014/1907, 2014/1908, 2014/3460,

2014/6142-6144, 2015/5571

Re:Robert Kruljac

APPLICANT

AndAustralian Postal Corporation

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal:Miss E A Shanahan, Member

Date:9 February 2018

Place:Melbourne

The Tribunal sets aside the decision in application 2014/3460 that suspended Mr Kruljac’s rights to compensation and remits the matter to the respondent for reconsideration.

The Tribunal sets aside the decision in application 2014/6144 relating to s 14 liability for stress/anxiety and remits the matter for reconsideration given the failure to consider other contributory health disorders which may be relevant.

The remaining five decisions (2014/1907, 2014/1908, 2014/6142, 2014/6143 and 2015/5571) are affirmed.

[sgd]........................................................................

Miss E A Shanahan, Member

WORKERS’ COMPENSATION – multiple claims over 20 years – multiple injuries sustained in the course of work – past acceptance of liability in relation to shoulder and cervical spine dysfunction – current claims relate to left shoulder, aggravation of cervical spondylosis, secondary psychological state and s 16 claims relating to treatment and medication – failure to undertake rehabilitation return to work program – suspension of rights under s 37(7) of the SRC Act – later remitted for reconsideration.

Legislation

Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1989 (SRC Act)

Cases

Department of Defence v Jodette Margaret Fox [1997] FCA 3
Comcare and Mooi [1996] FCA 1587
Sollazzo and Comcare [2000] AATA 65
McGuiness and Comcare [2007] 99 ALD 57
Karhani and Linfox Pty Ltd (2011) 129 ALD 275
Tracy Skinn and Australian Postal Corporation [2012] AATA 121

Australian Postal Corporation v Nunez [2014] FCA 1095

REASONS FOR DECISION

Miss E A Shanahan, Member

9 February 2018

  1. Mr Robert Kruljac has worked for the Australian Postal Corporation (Australia Post) since 1995, initially as a Postal Delivery Officer (PDO) working in Perth and generally in Victoria, the latter being his home state. In the course of his work he suffered several falls while riding a motorbike to deliver mail. There have been numerous compensation claims arising from these injuries. Since mid-2009, Mr Kruljac has worked reduced hours of five days per week, performing administrative tasks mainly redirecting mail.

  2. There are three major applications before the Tribunal. The first of these is application 2014/1907, wherein Mr Kruljac sought review of the decision of 13 March 2014 but only in regard to the aggravation of his cervical spondylosis. This decision affirmed the determination of 24 February 2014 that Mr Kruljac was capable of undertaking a rehabilitation/return to work program of five hours per day, five days per week performing restricted duties. This was to commence on 25 February 2014.

  3. The second application major application is 2014/1908. The authorised review officer (ARO) determined that incapacity benefits on and from 25 February 2014 to 25 May 2014 for the hours that were not worked were not subject to liability and therefore payment by Australia Post.

  4. The third application, 2014/3460, for which Mr Kruljac sought review, was the decision of 16 May 2014 suspending all his…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Kruljac and Australian Postal Corporation (Compensation) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2018] AATA 171
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned claims made by Mr Robert Kruljac against the Australian Postal Corporation for various injuries sustained during his employment. The dispute involved multiple applications before the Tribunal, primarily concerning Mr Kruljac's entitlement to compensation for aggravation of cervical spondylosis, a left shoulder injury, secondary stress and anxiety, and the payment of medication and certain periods of incapacity. The Tribunal was required to determine the validity of these claims and the extent of Australia Post's liability.

The legal issues before the Tribunal included whether Mr Kruljac's incapacity to work more than a limited number of hours per day constituted a reasonable excuse for not undertaking a rehabilitation program, thereby preventing the suspension of his compensation rights. The Tribunal also had to consider Australia Post's liability for medication, specifically Lyrica, and for stress and anxiety as a secondary condition to his physical injuries. Furthermore, the Tribunal was tasked with assessing the validity of claims for periods of absence from work due to the effects of pain medication and the accuracy of medical certificates provided in support of these claims.

The Tribunal's reasoning involved a careful consideration of the evidence presented by Mr Kruljac and various medical experts, including treating doctors and specialists. While acknowledging concerns about the medical basis for some opinions, the Tribunal ultimately accepted that Mr Kruljac's limited work capacity provided a reasonable excuse for not engaging in a rehabilitation program, referencing the Federal Court decision in *Nunez*. The Tribunal set aside the decision suspending Mr Kruljac's compensation rights and the decision regarding liability for stress/anxiety, remitting these matters for reconsideration. However, the Tribunal affirmed the decisions concerning the cessation of liability for the left shoulder injury, the denial of payment for Lyrica, and the claim for 14 days of absence due to pain medication effects, noting issues with the supporting documentation.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

On the two days of hearing, namely the 10th and 11th November 2016, Mr Robert Kruljac and his treating general practitioner Dr Nicholas Nassios gave evidence in person. The hearing was then adjourned for a period and resumed on 24 July 2017 and concluded on 27 July 2017. At the resumed hearing Mr Michael Khan orthopaedic surgeon, Dr Michael Epstein psychiatrist, Dr Byron Rigby psychiatrist, Dr Michael Bloom occupational health physician, Mr Graeme Brazenor neurosurgeon and Associate Professor George Mendelson psychiatrist gave evidence in person. BACKGROUND TO THE APPLICATION Mr Kruljac commenced work with Australia Post in 1995 as a PDO. He suffered his first motorbike accident in March 1998 when he fell from his Honda bike and sustained what was described as a minor head and neck injury. In 2000 he was again injured when the tyre on his bike suffered a blow-out. He fell to the ground injuring his left shoulder and neck. In 2007 while riding the bike he clipped a tree branch resulting in the development of neck pain. On this occasion he did not fall off the bike. Liability under s14 was accepted by Australia Post. Mr Kruljac commenced work with Australia Post while residing in Victoria. He shifted to live in Perth and married. In the year 2000 he separated from his wife and they divorced in 2002 or 2003. Following the separation/divorce he required psychiatric treatment for what appears to be depression. He returned to Melbourne in approximately 2003 and initially lived with his parents. Mr Kruljac purchased a house in South Morang in 2004. He married for a second time in September 2007 but shortly thereafter conflict developed between him and his wife. He again required psychiatric treatment. In December 2008 Mr Kruljac awoke with neck pain and numbness on the left side of his neck, left shoulder and left arm. He was referred by his general practitioner to Mr Craig Timms a neurosurgeon. Mr Timms assessed Mr Kruljac and advised that surgery was not indicated and recommended physiotherapy. Mr Kruljac resumed working four hours per day, five days per week in June 2009. His duties were documenting registered mail and obtaining the signatures of PDO’s who were delivering such mail. In 2010 he was referred to Mr A Bonomo, an orthopaedic surgeon, regarding his left shoulder symptoms. At approximately the same time he was shifted to the Port Melbourne hub where he was employed for the same hours undertaking data entries into a computer. In 2012 Mr Bonomo recommended arthroscopy of the left shoulder based on Mr Kruljac’s complaint that his left shoulder popped on movement and while this was not considered to be a dislocation it may represent a subluxation. The request for payment for the arthroscopy procedure was denied by Australia Post. Mr Kruljac had, as an alternative treatment, intra-articular steroid injections. These were of short lived benefit. Mr Kruljac was referred to Dr Clayton Thomas in May of 2013. Dr Thomas suggested a nerve block for the neck pain. Mr Kruljac, on the advice of his general practitioner, declined this treatment.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The treating psychiatrist Dr Byron Rigby has diagnosed Mr Kruljac as suffering from a major depressive disorder but said he would accept a diagnosis of an adjustment disorder secondary to Mr Kruljac’s physical complaints. ORAL EVIDENCE BEFORE THE TRIBUNALMr Kruljac Mr Kruljac’s evidence has been summarised under the ‘Background to the Application’ section of these reasons. Mr Ferwerda cross-examined Mr Kruljac at length. Unfortunately Mr Kruljac could not accurately recall his exact physical status in the years prior to 2009 but did not reject the documentary evidence provided by his medical records. Mr Kruljac confirmed that he has recently qualified for a carer’s pension in relation to his parents, particularly his father who has been diagnosed with carcinoma. Mr Kruljac drives his father to appointments at various hospitals and when necessary administers subcutaneous injections of Heparin required by his father on an ongoing basis. Mr Kruljac described his major contribution to the running of the household as doing the cooking despite his mother’s endeavours to do so. He was able to mow the lawns around the house, do his own shopping and once a week he cleaned the house. His parents were able to perform the activities of daily living and did their own shopping. His parents contributed financially to the household costs including his mortgage repayments as he was experiencing financial difficulties following the cessation of his worker’s compensation payments in March 2014. In terms of his physical limitations, Mr Kruljac does not believe that he has improved since the original accidents of 1998, 2000 and 2007. All three incidents had contributed to his neck and shoulder pain. His general health and in particular his work related injuries had led to secondary depression but this he agreed was also contributed to by his two failed marriages and disputes with the builder of his house in South Morang. Mr Kruljac described the pain as occurring every day at both sites, extending from his cervical spine to his left shoulder and down his left arm, his forearm and on occasion to three fingers of his left hand and more recently to all of his left hand. He had been diagnosed with left ulnar nerve entrapment and underwent surgery in 2014. While surgery has improved the pain in his forearm and hand, it has not alleviated the numbness. Mr Kruljac described an unusual popping sensation in his left shoulder. This he believes represents episodes of dislocation of his shoulder despite having been told by experts that this is not the case. He agreed with Mr Ferwerda’s description, as related by Associate Professor Brazenor, of experiencing discomfort and numbness in the left upper quadrant of his chest starting at the lower rib margin and extending to above his clavicle. He also confirmed that the back pain referred to was predominantly at the mid-thoracic level and situated between his shoulder blades. Mr Kruljac was of the opinion that the Lyrica and Panadeine Forte that he was now taking improved the level of his discomfort and pain but did not ablate it. While he is no longer taking Oxycontin, his tiredness has not significantly improved. He believes the pain and its constancy result in ongoing depression.

Decision

Reasons for decision

While the Tribunal has concerns and doubts as to the medical basis on which Doctors Rigby and Nassios arrived at their conclusion, both doctors have maintained their opinions for several years, have consistently advised Mr Kruljac and the respondent of these opinions and have given sworn evidence before the Tribunal that their opinions are unchanged. Both doctors have voiced their reliance to a certain extent on Mr Kruljac’s assessment of his work capacity but have denied that their opinions have been unduly influenced by his input. In accordance with the Federal Court decision in Nunez, the Tribunal accepts that Mr Kruljac’s incapacity to work more than four and now five hours per day amounts to a reasonable excuse as required by s 37(7). However, it is noted that his ability to cope with five hours work per day and the positive benefit it seems to have engendered suggests that a rehabilitation plan at a slowly progressive rate may succeed although it is unlikely that he will ever achieve full time employment. DECISION Based on the above deliberation the Tribunal sets aside the decision in application 2014/3460 which suspended Mr Kruljac’s compensation rights and remits the matter to the respondent for reconsideration. Similarly, the decision in application 2014/6144 relating to s 14 liability for stress/anxiety is set aside and remitted for reconsideration given the failure to consider other contributory health disorders which may have contributed to this condition. The remaining five decisions (applications 2014/1907, 2014/1908, 2014/6142, 2014/6143 and 2015/5571) are affirmed. Costs of the proceedings before the Tribunal are to be in accordance with s 67 of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Both members of counsel made submissions as to costs depending on the Tribunal’s decision. Leave was granted for the hearing of further submissions on costs, depending on the Tribunal’s decision. TRIBUNAL’S DELIBERATION AND DECISION Mr Kruljac has made multiple claims for injuries sustained in the course of employment with Australia Post. Between 1998 and 2011 Australia Post has accepted liability for minor concussion (reference 1998/600078); for a bruised, grazed left elbow, bruised left knee, bruised left shoulder and strained neck (reference 2000/600061); for muscle tension, root of neck, (reference 2001/600027); for mild left supraspinatus tendonitis/left medial epicondylitis (reference 2003/4504); for soft tissue injury to the right shoulder, elbow, leg and back date of injury 26 July 2006, with the acceptance of liability being 2 August 2006; for cervical spine dysfunction (L) neck, back of head acceptance (reference 2007/303142) and for aggravation of cervical spondylosis of C3/4, C4/5 and C5/6 (reference 2009/00410). By a consent decision before the Administrative Appeals Tribunal dated 22 December 2011 liability was accepted for a left shoulder injury, appearing on or about 22 March 2000 (reference 2010/306628). The active matters before the Tribunal are application 2014/1907 in relation to aggravation of cervical spondylosis and the return to work program to commence at five hours per day as of 24 February 2014; application 2014/1908 relating to the hours that were not worked between 25 February 2014 and 25 May 2014 as a result of the aggravation of cervical spondylosis and application 2014/3460 relating to both the neck and left shoulder injuries wherein the applicant’s rights to compensation were suspended under s 37 of the SRC Act as of 28 March 2014 until such time as he began to undertake the rehabilitation program. A further four reviewable decisions made after the suspension of all Mr Kruljac’s rights to compensation remain active and for consideration. These are :·Application 2014/6142 regarding cessation of liability to pay compensation under s 16 and s 19 of the SRC Act for the condition of left shoulder injury,·Application 2014/6143 regarding a decision that Australia Post was not liable pursuant to s 16 of the SRC Act to pay for the medication Lyrica,·Application 2014/6144 denying liability under s 14 of the SRC Act for the secondary condition of stress/anxiety secondary to the aggravation of the cervical spondylosis of C3/4, C4/5 and C5/6, and·Application 2015/5571 denying the claim for payment under s 19 for 14 days over a period of several years wherein the applicant slept through his alarm clock and did not attend work due to effects of pain medication. The application 2015/5571 which related to some 14 days when Mr Kruljac slept through his alarm and did not wake in time to go to work, was based on the provision of proforma workers’ compensation certificates by Dr Nassios. These certificates are replete with typographical errors in relation to dates and periods of incapacity. In his evidence before the Tribunal Dr Nassios accepted that his record keeping was poor and at face value inaccurate. Australia Post denied liability for payment of s 19 compensation for these particular days.