Forrest and Repatriation Commission (Veterans' entitlements)

Link copied
Case Copied 56 min read

Forrest and Repatriation Commission (Veterans' entitlements) [2018] AATA 759 (4 April 2018)

Division:Veterans' Appeals Division

File Number:           2015/0300

Re:Thomas Forrest

APPLICANT

AndRepatriation Commission

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal:Miss E A Shanahan, Member

Date:4 April 2018

Place:Melbourne

The Tribunal affirms the decision under review.

.......[sgd].................................................................

Miss E A Shanahan, Member

VETERANS’ AFFAIRS – claim for increase in disability pension – dispute as to lifestyle rating – seeking extreme disablement adjustment – not eligible for special or intermediate rate – earlier hearing discontinued on the basis of an entry mistake in the current entitlements – reliance on transcript – issue as to whether incapacity related to accepted disabilities – decision affirmed

Legislation

Veterans’ Entitlement Act 1986 (Cth)

Secondary Material

Guide to the Assessment of Rates of Veterans’ Pension (No 2) 2016

Cases
Re Anderson and Repatriation Commission (1998) 53 ALD 467

Raisbeck v Repatriation Commission (1993) 31 ALD 704

REASONS FOR DECISION

Miss E A Shanahan, Member

4 April 2018

  1. On 26 May 2014 Mr Forrest lodged a claim in accordance with s 22 of the Veterans’ Entitlement Act 1986 (the VE Act) for an increase in his pension. At the time of his application he was 66 and had not worked since ceasing Reserve service in 2009. He is receiving a disability pension at 100 per cent of the General Rate. On 17 June 2014 a determination was made by the Repatriation Commission (the Commission), denying an increase in pension as Mr Forrest’s lifestyle rating in accordance with the Guide to the Assessment of Rates of Veterans’ Pension (No 2) 2016 (GARP) averaged 5. As the required lifestyle rating is an average of 6, he did not satisfy the requirements of s 22.

  2. The Veterans’ Review Board (the VRB) affirmed the decision on 21 October 2014. They determined that Mr Forrest had an impairment rating of 70 points and on their calculations an average lifestyle rating of 5 points. In their decision the VRB referred in particular to the large number of non accepted disabilities from which Mr Forrest suffered, the most relevant of which was peripheral neuropathy, first diagnosed in 2005. The VRB considered the peripheral neuropathy to have a considerable impact on Mr Forrest’s health and lifestyle.

  3. At the hearing of this matter on 23 October 2017 Mr Forrest was represented by Ms Fiona Spencer of counsel, instructed by Ms Sophia McMahon, trainee solicitor of Williams Winter. Mr Ken Rudge, solicitor with the Department of Veterans’ Affairs (DVA), appeared for the Commission. This matter had been part heard on 23 and 24 March 2017. The s 37 documents (the Tribunal documents filed pursuant to s 37 of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975) had been found to contain an error in relation to Mr Forrest’s accepted entitlements for his war-caused medical conditions.

  4. The then presiding Member ordered that the hearing be discontinued and the matter be reheard by a differently constituted Tribunal. Mr Forrest and his wife Rae Forrest and his treating physician Dr Kemp had…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Forrest and Repatriation Commission (Veterans' entitlements) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2018] AATA 759
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an appeal by Mr Forrest against a decision of the Repatriation Commission regarding his veteran's entitlements. The central dispute revolved around the appropriate "lifestyle rating" to be applied to Mr Forrest's accepted and non-accepted medical conditions, specifically the contribution of war-caused lumbar spondylosis and non-compensable peripheral neuropathy to his overall functional capacity. The case was heard by Miss E A Shanahan, Member, of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal.

The Tribunal was required to determine the correct lifestyle rating for Mr Forrest, considering the impact of his various accepted and non-accepted medical conditions on his daily life. This assessment was to be made in accordance with the *Guide to the Assessment of Rates of Veterans’ Pension (No 2) 2016*, which is binding on the Tribunal. The key issue was to ascertain which of Mr Forrest's conditions, and to what extent, contributed to his claimed incapacity, particularly in relation to mobility, recreation, and domestic activities.

The Tribunal's reasoning focused on the provisions of the *Guide*, which stipulate that assessments of lifestyle effects should primarily consider the clinical features of war-caused or defence-caused injuries and diseases. Mr Forrest's accepted conditions significantly impacting his lifestyle were Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder (PTSD) and lumbar spondylosis, the latter of which he attributed to chronic pain, lack of mobility, and sleep disturbances dating back to his military service. While Mr Forrest also suffered from numerous non-service related conditions, including anxiety disorder, diabetes, and peripheral neuropathy, the *Guide* directs that the assessment should be based on accepted conditions. The Tribunal noted that Mr Forrest was totally incapacitated for work and received a 100 per cent disability pension, but his claim for an increased pension rate was time-barred.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

It is agreed by the parties and the Tribunal that the only issue to be determined relates to the applicant’s lifestyle rating and the contribution to this of the accepted and non‑accepted medical conditions, in particular, the lumbar spondylosis which has been accepted as war-caused and the non-compensable non accepted peripheral neuropathy, both of which impact on function of the lower limbs and in the case of the peripheral neuropathy on the upper limbs also. BACKGROUND TO THE APPLICATION Mr Forrest joined the Royal Australian Army (army) on 13 April 1965 at the age of 17 years and 3 months. In the army he served in the infantry and predominantly in an administrative capacity until 21 December 1981. He then transferred to an administrative role in the Royal Australian Airforce (Airforce) where he remained until 24 July 1989 at which time he became a member of the Reserve service and worked for the Department of Defence, again in administrative duties. He was required to work for a minimum of 100 days per year. Throughout his reserve employment he was based mainly at the Amberley Base in Queensland. He would work for three weeks at Amberley and then have one week at home. From 2005 he and his wife lived in Ballarat in Victoria. He ceased work on 9 August 2009, although his contract ran until 2012. His cessation of work was due to him being unable to pass the required medical fitness examination. He was aged 61 at the time he ceased work. Mr Forrest has the accepted service related disabilities of:·bilateral sensorineural hearing loss;·lumbar spondylosis; ·tinea;·acquired cataracts in both eyes; and·post-traumatic stress disorder. He has numerous non-service related disabilities. These include:·anxiety disorder;·migraine;·hypertension;·hyperlipidaemia;·bilateral presbyopia;·rosacea;·gastro-oesophageal reflux disease;·cervical spondylosis;·osteoarthrosis of the right acromioclavicular joint;·astigmatism in the left eye;·astigmatism in the right eye;·seborrheic dermatitis;·left kidney stones;·diabetes;·peripheral neuropathy, and·right carpal tunnel syndrome.According to his general practitioner’s clinical notes Mr Forrest in 2015 was taking some 14 different medications. Mainly, these were for his hypertension, diabetes, gastro oesophageal reflux, antidepressants for his post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD) and analgesics in the form of opioids in particular Jurnista (a hypomorphone). To the Tribunal’s knowledge, many of these medications interact with each other (online data from Therapeutic Goods Administration (TGA) Product Information of above medications). The Tribunal has not been provided with Mr Forrest’s medical and service history which was provided to VRB. This is not a substantive issue but may have assisted in the determination of the sequence of events. Neither Mr Forrest or Mrs Forrest’s statements nor their evidence provided on transcript address these questions. The Tribunal has relied on the entries in the general practitioner’s records which indicate that Mr Forrest’s chronic back pain has been present since 2002, his lumbar spondylosis since 1970, cataracts were diagnosed in 1986, gastro-oesophageal reflux disease in 1998, sensorineural hearing impairment in 2006, peripheral neuropathy in 2005, PTSD in 2010 and diabetes in 2012. In 2011 Mr Forrest underwent the insertion of a spinal cord stimulator in an effort to control his back pain. Just prior to this he had been diagnosed with arachnoiditis on MRI (magnetic resonance imaging). This diagnosis has since been negated.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Dr Kemp first saw Mr Forrest in 2010 in relation to the peripheral neuropathy and a pre‑diabetic glucose tolerance test. While it is not stated in the letter, the Tribunal assumes this referral was made as the most common cause of peripheral neuropathy is diabetes. Mr Forrest’s diabetes became florid in 2012. Dr Kemp’s reports will be considered separately in conjunction with his oral evidence before the Tribunal. EVIDENCE BEFORE THE TRIBUNALDr Kemp Dr Kemp gave evidence by telephone on both occasions. He provided two reports, the first dated 30 November 2015 (Exhibit A2) and the second 31 March 2016 (Exhibit A3). The clinical records of the treating general practitioner Dr Livingston contain numerous reports relating to Mr Forest and authored by Dr Kemp. Dr Kemp is a consultant physician specialising in general medicine and endocrinology and has been in practice as a consultant physician for 17 years. Dr Kemp stated that he had first seen Mr Forest in 2010 and initially saw him four to five times a year. For the past two to three years Mr Forrest’s attendance has reduced to three times a year. Dr Kemp had prescribed Allegron, a tricyclic anti-depressant, for the control of pain arising from the peripheral neuritis, Jurnista, an opioid, for the pain arising from his spondylosis and added Neurofen, Panamax and Panadeine Forte as adjuncts to the Jurnista. Sifrol has been given for restless leg syndrome. Dr Kemp did not find any evidence of neuritis when he first saw Mr Forrest in 2010. He first detected signs of this condition in 2011. When first seen by Dr Kemp, Mr Forrest had described symptoms of pain and weakness in his thighs and upper part of his legs rather than in his feet. Dr Kemp attributed Mr Forrest’s frequent falls to proximal muscle weakness linked to the spondylosis. When Mr Forrest did develop signs of peripheral neuritis, these were said to be confined to below the mid-foot level. Dr Kemp did acknowledge that Mr Forrest had lost the proprioception senses in his toes but was of the opinion that proprioception was retained in the ankles and thus the neuritis would be unlikely to contribute to any falls. Dr Kemp was unable to quantitate the contribution of the peripheral neuritis to Mr Forrest’s current level of incapacity but suspected that it was minor. He considered secondary deconditioning of the proximal muscles of the legs and thighs, tiring readily and the back pain with problems of core balance were the major factors. He considered that the area he believed was relevant and important was from the bellybutton down to the knees. Dr Kemp was questioned in relation to the diagnosis of arachnoiditis. He was of the opinion that this had been totally excluded by Dr Schnier’s later reassessment of the MRI. Dr Kemp having described what he considered the major area of pain and poor muscle function added that this was entirely non-anatomical in that it did not follow any nerve distribution or dermatomes. He therefore could not attribute it to lumbar spondylosis and postulated that it may be due to a chronic pain syndrome.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In response Ms Spencer submitted that it was the back pain arising from the spondylosis which had most probably given rise to the central pain sensitisation. She rejected Professor Chambers’ opinion that this was merely a hypothesis not a proven relationship. She submitted that the mobility rating should be 6 as both the spondylosis, the back pain and the PTSD contributed to his inability to drive. Similarly, in terms of recreation both the back pain and PTSD alone impacted on his incapacity to engage in previous sports and activities. Ms Spencer agreed that the domestic figure was 5 or possibly 6. TRIBUNAL’S DELIBERATIONS AND DECISION It is not contested that Mr Forrest is totally incapacitated for any form of work. He has multiple documented medical conditions, the majority of which are not accepted as being war-caused. He receives a disability pension at 100 per cent of the general rate. As he ceased work at the age of 61 and did not lodge his application for the extreme disablement allowance or any other appropriate increase in pension until he was 66 he does not qualify for the special or intermediate rate. It is also agreed that the only issue before the Tribunal is the appropriate lifestyle rating. Mr Forrest contends that he meets an average lifestyle rating of 6 and therefore satisfies the requirement of s 22 of the Act. The Commission in their submissions estimated the average lifestyle rating at 4, Dr Hayman for the Commission at 5 and the VRB also at 5. The determination is reliant primarily on the medical evidence before the Tribunal. In assessing the medical evidence the Tribunal is required to reach its determination in accordance with the Guide to the Assessment of Rates of Veterans’ Pension (No 2) 2016 (the Guide) this being the Guide in force at the time the decision is made (Re Anderson and Repatriation Commission (1998)). In the introduction the Guide states that:Its provisions are binding on the Repatriation Commission, the Veterans’ Review Board and the Administrative Appeals Tribunal. (Page 1 of Introduction)The instructions to the Guide state:In making an assessment the clinical features of war-caused or defence‑caused injuries or diseases are to be taken into account. Throughout the Guide and in relation to the lifestyle effects assessment the Guide repeatedly refers to these assessments in terms of the accepted conditions only. The accepted conditions that significantly impact on Mr Forrest’s lifestyle are his diagnosed PTSD and, as he claims, his lumbar spondylosis. His non-service related disabilities that have the greatest impact are the anxiety disorder (separate from the PTSD), diabetes and the peripheral neuropathy. Mr Forrest attributes his chronic pain, lack of mobility and sleep problems to his lumbar spondylosis. He first complained of back pain in 1970 while serving in the Australian Army. He was treated in a South Australian hospital with spinal traction for a period of three weeks. The history given is one of continuing back pain for four decades. The term spondylosis is an alternative term for osteoarthrosis of the spine. In the case of the lumbar spine it is a degenerative condition affecting the joints of the spine, the cartilages and the discs that undergo desiccation and loss of height.