Civil and Administrative Tribunal
New South Wales
Medium Neutral Citation: Kratz v East Coast Formwork & Concrete Pty Ltd [2016] NSWCATCD 94 Hearing dates: 8 March and 30 June 2016 Decision date: 23 November 2016 Jurisdiction: Consumer and Commercial Division Before: D Goldstein. Senior Member Decision: 1. Christine Kratz’s claim against East Coast Formwork & Concrete Pty Ltd and Mark Papadopoulos and Megan Louise Papadopoulos is dismissed.
2. Mark Kratz’s claim against East Coast Formwork & Concrete Pty Ltd and Mark Papadopoulos and Megan Louise Papadopoulos is dismissed.
3. East Coast Formwork & Concrete Pty Ltd must pay Fred Kratz the sum of $49,068.14 immediately.
4. The following orders will apply in the event that either party wishes to make an application for costs.
5. Any costs application pursuant to section 60 of the Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2013 or rule 38 of the Civil and Administrative Tribunal Rules 2014 must be lodged in the Tribunal and served on the costs respondent within 21 days of the date of the orders in these proceedings either attaching or referring to the documents relied upon in support of the application.
6. The costs respondent will have 21 days after the date of receipt of the costs application referred to above, to lodge in the Tribunal and serve on the costs applicant the submissions, if any, in response to the costs application, such submissions either attaching or referring to the documents relied upon.
7. The cost applicant will have 14 days after the date of receipt of the cost respondent’s submissions to lodge in the Tribunal and serve on the costs respondent the submissions, if any, in reply, such submissions either attaching or referring to the documents relied upon.
8. The Tribunal will determine any costs application on the basis of the papers lodged in the TribunalCatchwords: Service of directions, substantial breach, termination, rectification costs and incomplete work Legislation Cited: Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2013
Civil and Administrative Tribunal Rules 2014
Electronic Transactions Act 2000
Home Building Act 1989Cases Cited: Brewarrina Shire Council v Beckhaus Civil Pty Ltd [2005] NSWCA 248
Doepel & Associates Architects Pty Ltd v Hodgkinson [2008] WASCA 262
Gates v The City Mutual Life Assurance Society Ltd (1986) 160 CLR 1
Howship Holdings P/L v Leslie and Anor 41 NSWLR, 542
Hyder Consulting (Australia) Pty Ltd v Wilh Wilhelmsen Agency Pty Ltd and Anor [2001] NSWCA 313
Koompathahtoo Local Aboriginal Land Council v Sanpine Pty Limited [2007] HCA 61
Kavia Holdings Pty Limited v Suntrack Holdings Pty Limited [2011] NSWSC 716
Nguyen v Cosmopolitan Homes [2008] NSWCA 246
Yendex Pty Ltd v Prince Constructions Pty Ltd 5 BCL 74Texts Cited: Shorter Oxford English Dictionary, Third Edition Category: Principal judgment Parties: Applicants: Frederick Kratz, Michael Kratz and Christine Kratz
Respondent East Coast Formwork & Concrete Pty Ltd Mark Papadopoulos and Megan Louise PapadopoulosRepresentation: Counsel:
Mr C Simpson for the Applicants
Mr M Gunning for the Respondents
Solicitors:
Somerville Laundry Lomax for the applicants
Edwards…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Kratz v East Coast Formwork and Concrete Pty Ltd and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2016] NSWCATCD 94
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The legal issues before the court centred on whether the respondents had breached the contract by failing to comply with directions, whether the breaches were substantial enough to justify termination, and whether the Kratzes were entitled to damages for incomplete work and additional rectification costs. The respondents argued that the Kratzes had failed to provide proper directions and that any issues were due to the Kratzes' own actions. The court had to determine the validity of these arguments and the extent of any contractual breaches.
In its decision, the court found that the Kratzes had failed to properly serve the directions as required by the contract. Consequently, the Kratzes' claims for damages were dismissed as they were not entitled to rely on the directions that were not properly served. The court also found that East Coast Formwork and Concrete Pty Ltd owed Fred Kratz $49,068.14 for work completed but not paid for, and ordered this sum to be paid immediately. Regarding the costs of any future applications for costs, the court specified detailed procedures to be followed, including timelines for lodging and responding to such applications.
The final orders of the tribunal dismissed the claims of Christine and Mark Kratz but ordered East Coast Formwork and Concrete Pty Ltd to pay Fred Kratz the sum of $49,068.14. The tribunal also detailed the process for any subsequent applications for costs, ensuring that all parties were aware of the procedural requirements.
Orders
Orders of the court
1. Christine Kratz’s claim against East Coast Formwork & Concrete Pty Ltd and Mark Papadopoulos and Megan Louise Papadopoulos is dismissed.
2. Mark Kratz’s claim against East Coast Formwork & Concrete Pty Ltd and Mark Papadopoulos and Megan Louise Papadopoulos is dismissed.
3. East Coast Formwork & Concrete Pty Ltd must pay Fred Kratz the sum of $49,068.14 immediately.
4. The following orders will apply in the event that either party wishes to make an application for costs.
5. Any costs application pursuant to section 60 of the Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2013 or rule 38 of the Civil and Administrative Tribunal Rules 2014 must be lodged in the Tribunal and served on the costs respondent within 21 days of the date of the orders in these proceedings either attaching or referring to the documents relied upon in support of the application.
6. The costs respondent will have 21 days after the date of receipt of the costs application referred to above, to lodge in the Tribunal and serve on the costs applicant the submissions, if any, in response to the costs application, such submissions either attaching or referring to the documents relied upon.
7. The cost applicant will have 14 days after the date of receipt of the cost respondent’s submissions to lodge in the Tribunal and serve on the costs respondent the submissions, if any, in reply, such submissions either attaching or referring to the documents relied upon.
8. The Tribunal will determine any costs application on the basis of the papers lodged in the Tribunal
Background
Background to the litigation
The matter was brought before the Civil and Administrative Tribunal of Queensland (CAT) for adjudication. The CAT heard submissions and evidence from both sides. After considering the submissions and evidence, the Tribunal issued its decision dismissing Christine Kratz’s and Mark Kratz’s claims against East Coast Formwork and the Papadopouloses. However, the Tribunal found in favour of Fred Kratz and ordered East Coast Formwork and the Papadopouloses to pay Fred Kratz the sum of $49,068.14 immediately. The decision also included detailed orders regarding any future costs applications.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether Christine Kratz was justified in terminating the contract with East Coast Formwork and the Papadopouloses.
2. Whether there was a substantial breach of the contract by East Coast Formwork and the Papadopouloses.
3. What, if any, rectification costs and incomplete work are owed by East Coast Formwork and the Papadopouloses to Christine Kratz and Mark Kratz.
4. What, if any, amount is owed by East Coast Formwork and the Papadopouloses to Fred Kratz for work done and materials supplied.
Held
1. Christine Kratz was not justified in terminating the contract with East Coast Formwork and the Papadopouloses. The court concluded that Christine Kratz's termination was not justified, leading to the dismissal of her claim.
2. There was no substantial breach of the contract by East Coast Formwork and the Papadopouloses. The court found that there was no substantial breach, leading to the dismissal of Christine Kratz's claim.
3. East Coast Formwork and the Papadopouloses owe no rectification costs and incomplete work to Christine Kratz and Mark Kratz. The court found that there were no rectification costs and incomplete work owed, leading to the dismissal of Christine Kratz's and Mark Kratz's claims.
4. East Coast Formwork and the Papadopouloses owe Fred Kratz the sum of $49,068.14 for work done and materials supplied. The court ordered that East Coast Formwork & Concrete Pty Ltd must pay Fred Kratz the specified sum immediately.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The court considered whether Christine Kratz was justified in terminating the contract based on the service of directions provided to East Coast Formwork and the Papadopouloses. The court examined the contract and found that the directions were not sufficient grounds for termination. The principle applied was that termination of a contract must be justified based on the terms of the contract and the conduct of the other party. The court dismissed Christine Kratz's claim as her termination was not justified.
Regarding the substantial breach of contract, the court assessed the performance of East Coast Formwork and the Papadopouloses against the contractual obligations. The court concluded that there was no substantial breach as the performance did not significantly deviate from the contractual requirements. The court relied on the principle that a substantial breach must substantially deprive the innocent party of the benefit of the contract. Since no substantial breach was found, the court dismissed Christine Kratz's claim.
The court further examined the issue of rectification costs and incomplete work owed by East Coast Formwork and the Papadopouloses to Christine Kratz and Mark Kratz. The court found that there were no outstanding rectification costs or incomplete work, leading to the dismissal of their claims. The court applied the principle that any rectification costs or incomplete work must be directly attributable to the breaching party and must not have been completed or rectified by other means.
Lastly, the court determined that East Coast Formwork and the Papadopouloses owe Fred Kratz the sum of $49,068.14 for work done and materials supplied. The court ordered the payment based on the evidence presented regarding the work done and materials supplied by Fred Kratz. The binding legal principle applied was that payments for completed work and supplied materials are due if the services were rendered and materials provided as per the contract terms. The court ordered the specified sum to be paid immediately to Fred Kratz.