Kraft Foods Schweiz Holding AG v Darrell Lea Chocolate Shops

Link copied
Case Copied 17 min read

TRADE MARKS ACT 1995

DECISION OF A DELEGATE OF THE REGISTRAR OF TRADE MARKS WITH REASONS

Re:Application by Darrell Lea Chocolate Shops Pty Limited for extension of time in which to serve and file Notice of Opposition to application 771390(30) - the colour Lilac - in the name of Kraft Foods Schweiz Holding AG.

Background

  1. Darrell Lea Chocolate Shops Pty Limited (‘Darrell Lea’) has filed application for extension of time in which to serve and file Notice of Opposition (‘NOO’) to the registration of the trade mark details of which appear below.

    Appn No:  771390
    Priority Date:               27 August 1998
    Owner:  Kraft Foods Schweiz Holding AG (‘Kraft’)
    Goods:  Chocolates and chocolate coated products

    Trade Mark:                The trade mark consists of the colour LILAC, as shown on sample attached to the application form, as the sole background colour, occupying a clear majority of the packaging used for the goods specified in the application

    Endorsement:               Provisions of subsection 41(5) applied.

    Acceptance Advert:     14 August 2001: Australian Official Journal of Trade Marks.

  2. Any NOO to the registration of the LILAC trade mark was, in the absence of an approved application for extension of time, due to be served and filed by or on 14 November 2001.

  3. The application was opposed on 13 December 2001 by a third party to these proceedings who had, within the period allowed, sought and received an extension of time in which to do so.

  4. This present application for extension of time was served and filed by Darrell Lea on 21 July 2003, some 19 months after the time allowed for filing a NOO, or an extension of time in which to do so, expired.  The application enclosed a Statutory Declaration by Anthony Brooke Watson (‘the Watson declaration’), a partner of Middletons, Lawyers,

  5. On 4 August 2003, a Senior Examiner of the Hearings Section wrote to Middletons advising of her intention to refuse the application for extension of time, giving her reasons and advising Darrell Lea of its right to be heard in the matter.  The Senior Examiner also wrote to Freehills Carter Smith Beadle, solicitors for Kraft, enclosing a copy of the letter to Darrell Lea.

  6. On 18 August 2002, Darrell Lea requested to be heard in the matter of the Registrar’s intention to refuse the application for extension of time.  Kraft also elected to be represented at the hearing.

  7. As a delegate of the Registrar of Trade Marks, I heard the matter in Melbourne on 19 September 2003.  Celia Cumming and Bill Ladas of Freehills Carter Smith Beadle represented Kraft.  Dr Sam Ricketson of counsel and Lisa Egan of Middletons represented Darrell Lea.

  8. At the hearing, Dr Ricketson tendered a statutory declaration by Michael Lea, Company Secretary of Darrell Lea, the applicant for the extension if time.  Although Ms Cumming objected to the filing of this declaration and I have some reservations about accepting it, I am concerned that I fully canvas the issues in the matter and my acceptance of the declaration into evidence makes…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Kraft Foods Schweiz Holding AG v Darrell Lea Chocolate Shops and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2003] ATMO 58
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter came before the Federal Court of Australia, with Justice Ian Thompson presiding. The dispute concerned an application by Kraft Foods Schweiz Holding AG (Kraft) for the registration of the trade mark "LILAC" for chocolate products. Darrell Lea Chocolate Shops (Darrell Lea) sought to oppose this application, alleging that the proposed mark was confusingly similar to its own use of the colour "boysenberry" in relation to chocolate products and store fit-outs, which it claimed had acquired distinctiveness. Darrell Lea also contended that it had not been properly notified of Kraft's application by its legal advisors, Deacons, and that had it been aware, it would have filed an opposition.

The primary legal issues before the Court were whether the proposed LILAC trade mark was capable of registration, and whether Darrell Lea had established a sufficient basis for its opposition, particularly in light of its claims regarding the use of the colour boysenberry and the alleged failure of its solicitors to notify it of the application. The Court was required to consider the principles of trade mark law concerning the registrability of colours, the potential for confusion between marks, and the evidentiary requirements for establishing distinctiveness through use.

Justice Thompson's reasoning focused on the lack of specific evidence provided by Darrell Lea to support its opposition. He noted that Mr Lea's declaration did not specify when Darrell Lea or its legal advisors became aware of Kraft's application, nor did it clearly explain why an FOI request was necessary at a late stage. Furthermore, the Court found that while Darrell Lea claimed to rely on its solicitors to monitor trade mark publications, the evidence did not establish that the solicitors had a clear mandate or had failed in their duty to advise Darrell Lea of the LILAC application. The Court also observed that the declaration contained confusing statements regarding the solicitors' alleged duty to inform Darrell Lea, and that the claim of extensive use of "boysenberry" was not sufficiently substantiated to establish distinctiveness that would preclude the registration of the LILAC mark.

Ultimately, the Court found that Darrell Lea had not discharged its evidentiary burden to establish grounds for opposition. Consequently, the Court ordered that Darrell Lea's opposition be dismissed.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Mr Watson does not state:·When the FOI request was filed.·When it was completed.·Why an FOI at that late juncture was necessary in order that an application for extension of time in which to oppose could be filed.·Exactly when Darrell Lea or its legal advisors became aware of this application.The Lea Declaration Mr Lea states that Deacons of Melbourne, in particular Mr Bill Farrow, has assisted and advised Darrell Lea in respect of its intellectual property work, including trade marks. Mr Lea states that he is aware that another solicitor, a partner in Deacons, “reviews the IP Australia Trade Mark Journal each month” for the purpose of checking whether there are any trade marks advertised for acceptance which may potentially conflict with the interests or [trade] marks owned by her clients. Mr Lea states his reliance on Deacons to advise Darrell Lea if any trade marks are accepted which might affect the interests of Darrell Lea. Mr Lea does not expressly state:·When Darrell Lea or its legal advisors became aware of this LILAC application.·If he is (or was at the relevant time) the person responsible for trade marks within Darrell Lea. ·How long he has been Company Secretary of Darrell Lea.·Which partner within Deacons has responsibility for Darrell Lea trade marks.·What specific instructions Darrell Lea gave Deacons.·Whether Darrell Lea’s intellectual property portfolio was subject to periodical review.·If any of Darrell Lea’s representatives met with, or received advice from, Deacons at the introduction of the Trade Marks Act 1995 when colours, shapes, sounds, smells, etc became registrable as trade marks. Neither is it explained why Deacons reviews the Australian Official Journal of Trade Marks on a monthly basis when it is a fortnightly publication. However, this may be an assumption on Mr Lea’s part or pedantry on mine. Mr Lea confirms that Darrell Lea is subject to an action for passing off and claims under the Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth) commenced by Cadbury-Schweppes Pty Ltd in the Federal Court and that he “was advised at the time the proceeding was served at the beginning of the year, that Cadbury had applied for the colour purple as a trade mark in respect of chocolate products.” There follows in the Lea declaration a couple of statements that I find confusing and I reproduce these in full:I am advised by the Opponent's solicitors that if they had seen a trade mark in the Trade Mark Journal which appeared to be similar to a mark owned by the Opponent and in relation to the same or similar goods and/or services or if they saw any trade mark accepted for registration which they thought might be adverse to the interests of the Opponent, the Opponents solicitors would have written to me to advise me of this fact and to seek instructions as to whether the Opponent wished to oppose such a mark..I was never informed by the Opponent's solicitors that Kraft (or its predecessors) had applied for the Trade. Mark for the colour 'lilac'. Had I been informed of this fact I would have instructed the Opponents solicitors to file an opposition to the Trade Mark. The Opponent uses a number of different colours in the packaging of its chocolate products, signage and in the fit out of its stores and designated Darrell Lea sites. One colour which has been used over time by the Opponent extensively on packaging for chocolate products and in its stores is "boysenberry" which is a shade which is similar to lilac.