Koninklijke Douwe Egberts B.V. v Nestec S.A

Link copied
Case Copied 74 min read

IP AUSTRALIA

AUSTRALIAN PATENT OFFICE

Koninklijke Douwe Egberts B.V. v Nestec S.A. [2018] APO 29

Patent Application:                2010326818

Title:Beverage preparation machine supporting a remote service functionality

Patent Applicant:                   Nestec S.A.

Opponent:  Koninklijke Douwe Egberts B.V.

Delegate:  Greg Powell

Decision Date:  4 May 2018

Hearing Date:  18 December 2017, in Sydney

Catchwords:  PATENTS – section 59 – opposition to the grant of a patent – novelty – claims found to lack novelty – inventive step – are documents “ascertained” when they are given to the person skilled in the art by a third party? – lack of inventive step not established – manner of manufacture – “threshold of inventiveness” – lack of manner of manufacture not established – opposition successful – opportunity to propose amendments – costs awarded against the applicant

Representation:  Counsel for the Applicant: Katrina Crooks

Patent Attorneys for the Applicant: Paul Harrison and Matthew Ford, Shelston IP

Counsel for the Opponent: Clare Cunliffe

Patent Attorney for the Opponent: Richard Brown, Davies Collison Cave

IP AUSTRALIA

AUSTRALIAN PATENT OFFICE

Patent Application:                2010326818

Title:Beverage preparation machine supporting a remote service functionality

Patent Applicant:                   Nestec S.A.

Date of Decision:                   4 May 2018

DECISION

The opposition is successful.  Claims 1–3, 6, 8–15, 17–20 are not novel.  No other grounds of opposition advanced by the opponent were successful.

I award costs according to Schedule 8 of the Patents Regulations 1991 against the applicant.

REASONS FOR DECISION

  1. Patent application 2010326818 (“the opposed application”) was filed on 30 November 2010, as international application PCT/EP2010/068480 in the name of Nestec S.A. (“the applicant”).  The application entered the national phase in Australia on 22 May 2012.  The opposed application claims a priority date of 2 December 2009.

  2. The opposed application was advertised as accepted on 31 March 2016.  A notice of opposition was originally filed by Steven Borovec on 30 June 2016.  A statement of grounds and particulars (the “SGP”) was filed on 29 September 2016.

  3. Evidence in support was filed on 23 December 2016.  This comprised:

    ·    a statutory declaration dated 23 December 2016 by Tristan Matthew Downs with supporting exhibits TD-1 to TD-10 (“Downs1”); and

    ·     a statutory declaration dated 22 December 2016 by Brendan Andrew Jones with supporting exhibits BAJ-1 to BAJ-3.

  4. Evidence in answer was filed on 6 April 2017.  This comprised:

    ·    a statutory declaration dated 6 April 2017 by Graeme Edward Neil MacDonald with supporting exhibits GM-1 to GM-15.

  5. Evidence in reply was filed on 13 June 2017.  This comprised:

    ·    a second statutory declaration dated 13 June 2017 by Tristan Matthew Downs with supporting exhibits TD-11 to TD-13 (“Downs2”).

  6. The name of the opponent was subsequently amended on 5 December 2017 to Koninklijke Douwe Egberts B.V. (“the opponent”).

    5.23 request

  7. On 4 December 2017 the opponent filed a request under regulation 5.23 for the Commissioner to consult:

    (i)a copy of the Wikipedia page for the Coca-Cola Freestyle beverage preparation machine; and

    (ii)a copy of the specification of EP09169800.l,…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Koninklijke Douwe Egberts B.V. v Nestec S.A and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2018] APO 29
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Nestec S.A. (“the applicant”) opposed the grant of a patent to Koninklijke Douwe Egberts B.V. (“the opponent”) in relation to a patent application for a beverage preparation machine supporting a remote service functionality. The Commissioner found that the patent was not novel or involved an inventive step. The Commissioner also found that the patent was not a manner of manufacture. The Commissioner awarded costs to the opponent. The applicant has two months from the date of this decision to file suitable amendments to overcome the findings of the Commissioner.

Background

Background to the litigation

Patent application 2010326818, filed by Nestec S.A., relates to a beverage preparation machine that supports a remote service functionality. The invention is concerned with a method and system for remotely providing service functionalities to these machines, specifically "capsule machines." The invention involves a machine that senses "machine related parameters," sends these parameters to a remote server, and, when a "service functionality" is required, sends this information to the machine. The invention aims to simplify customer interactions required to maintain the machine in optimum condition, particularly for commercially used machines accessed by multiple users. The invention claims a system that monitors conditions, informs the customer of, or partially undertakes, the need to carry out maintenance, including ordering stock.

The patent application was filed on 30 November 2010 and entered the national phase in Australia on 22 May 2012. The application was advertised as accepted on 31 March 2016, and a notice of opposition was filed by Steven Borovec on 30 June 2016. The statement of grounds and particulars was filed on 29 September 2016. Evidence in support was filed on 23 December 2016, and evidence in answer was filed on 6 April 2017. Evidence in reply was filed on 13 June 2017. The opponent's name was amended to Koninklijke Douwe Egberts B.V. on 5 December 2017. The hearing took place on 18 December 2017 in Sydney.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Is the invention a manner of manufacture as per section 59 of the Patents Act?
2. Do claims 1-3, 6, 8-15, 17-20 lack novelty?
3. Do claims 1-3, 6, 8-15, 17-20 lack an inventive step as per sections 7(2) and 7(3) of the Patents Act?

Held
1. The opposition is successful. Claims 1–3, 6, 8–15, 17–20 of the patent application are not novel.
2. The opposition is unsuccessful on all other grounds.
3. Costs are awarded against the applicant according to Schedule 8 of the Patents Regulations 1991.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The opposition was successful in finding that claims 1–3, 6, 8–15, 17–20 of the opposed application were not novel in light of prior art documents D1, D11, and D13. The Court found that these claims lacked novelty because they were anticipated by the cited documents, which disclosed all the essential features of the claims. The Court rejected the applicant's arguments that certain features were not present in the prior art, and found that the opponent had established novelty for these claims.

The Court found that the claims lacked an inventive step in light of the common general knowledge (CGK) alone, as well as in light of the prior art documents combined with the CGK. The opponent argued that the claims would have been obvious to a person skilled in the art in light of the CGK and the cited documents. However, the Court found that the opponent had not established that the cited documents could reasonably have been ascertained, understood, and regarded as relevant by a person skilled in the art. The Court also found that the opponent had not established certain elements of the CGK that it relied on to show that the claims lacked an inventive step.

The Court concluded that the opposition was successful in finding that claims 1–3, 6, 8–15, 17–20 of the opposed application were not novel, and that no other grounds of opposition were successful. The Court awarded costs against the applicant in accordance with Schedule 8 of the Patents Regulations 1991.