Knudsen v Baradom Holdings Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 25 min read
WORKERS COMPENSATION COMMISSION
DETERMINATION OF APPEAL AGAINST A DECISION OF THE COMMISSION CONSTITUTED BY AN ARBITRATOR
CITATION: Knudsen v Baradom Holdings Pty Ltd [2013] NSWWCCPD 73
APPELLANT: Paul Knudsen
RESPONDENT: Baradom Holdings Pty Ltd
INSURER: Allianz Australia Workers’ Compensation (NSW) Ltd
FILE NUMBER: A1-9661/12
ARBITRATOR: Mr G Brown
DATE OF ARBITRATOR’S DECISION: 1 October 2013
DATE OF APPEAL DECISION: 20 December 2013
SUBJECT MATTER OF DECISION: Former s 40(2)(a) of the Workers Compensation Act 1987; probable earnings but for injury; application of principles stated in Jones v Dunkel (1959) 101 CLR 298; availability of inference; rejection of uncontradicted evidence; requirement to state basis for rejection
PRESIDENTIAL MEMBER: Deputy President Kevin O'Grady
HEARING: On the papers
REPRESENTATION: Appellant: Taylor & Scott Lawyers
Respondent: HWL Ebsworth Lawyers
ORDERS MADE ON APPEAL:

1.   The order made in Certificate of Determination dated 1 October 2013 is confirmed.

2.   No order as to costs of this appeal.

BACKGROUND

  1. This is an appeal against a determination made by Arbitrator Garth Brown in which an award was entered in favour of the respondent employer Baradom Holdings Pty Ltd.

  2. The appellant, Paul Knudsen had been employed by the respondent to perform varied duties including those of a rigger and dogman, commencing in December 1994. It is not in dispute that, on 3 February 1995, Mr Knudsen was injured in the course of that employment. He injured his right leg and right arm.

  3. Fractures to Mr Knudsen’s right tibia and fibula were treated on the day of the accident by Dr Mark Perko, orthopaedic surgeon. That treatment involved open reduction and internal fixation. The tibial nail and screws were surgically removed in October 1995. Mr Knudsen had also suffered a fracture of the coronoid process of the right ulna in the accident, for which no orthopaedic treatment was undertaken. Mr Knudsen returned to work with a different employer in January 1996. He has remained in that employment since that time.

  4. In April 2012 a claim was made by Mr Knudsen against the respondent in respect of continuing weekly compensation from 1 July 1998. That claim was declined by the respondent’s insurer. The claim, brought pursuant to the former s 40 of the Workers Compensation Act 1987 (the 1987 Act), was subsequently amended to one in respect of a closed period between 1 July 1998 and 30 June 2007.

  5. The dispute came before the Arbitrator for conciliation/arbitration on 17 June 2013. The matter proceeded to hearing following which the Arbitrator reserved his decision. A Certificate of Determination was issued on 1 October 2013 which recorded the award noted at [1] above. A Statement of Reasons (Reasons) accompanied that Certificate. No order was made as to costs.

PRELIMINARY MATTERS

  1. There is no dispute between the parties that the threshold requirements as to quantum and time as found in the provisions of ss 352(3) and 352(4) of the Workplace Injury Management and Workers Compensation Act 1998 (the 1998 Act) have been met.

  2. The parties consent to the matter being heard “on…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Knudsen v Baradom Holdings Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2013] NSWWCCPD 73
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Knudsen v Baradom Holdings Pty Ltd was heard in the Workers Compensation Appeals Commission. The dispute involved an application by the appellant, Knudsen, for a determination that he had suffered a permanent partial incapacity as a result of an injury. The application was dismissed by the Arbitrator, and Knudsen appealed to the Commission. The appeal was subsequently dismissed by the Commission, and Knudsen appealed again to the Supreme Court.

The legal issue before the court was whether the Arbitrator had erred in dismissing the appeal and confirming the order of the Commission. Specifically, the court was required to consider whether the Arbitrator had erred in rejecting uncontradicted evidence and whether the Arbitrator had failed to state the basis for his rejection of that evidence.

The court found that the Arbitrator had not erred in dismissing the appeal. The Arbitrator had considered all of the relevant evidence and had provided detailed reasons for his conclusion that partial incapacity had not been made out. The Arbitrator had found that the uncontradicted evidence was wanting with respect to proof of partial incapacity, and the court found that this conclusion was open to the Arbitrator on the evidence before him. The court also found that the Arbitrator had not failed to state the basis for his rejection of uncontradicted evidence, as the Arbitrator had provided detailed reasons for his conclusion.

The final orders of the court were to confirm the order made in Certificate of Determination dated 1 October 2013 and to make no order as to costs of the appeal.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The order made in Certificate of Determination dated 1 October 2013 is confirmed.

2. No order as to costs of this appeal.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The relevant evidence was recited by the Arbitrator in the course of giving his reasons and his consideration of that evidence is found between [33] and [56] of his reasons. A non-exhaustive summary of the Arbitrator’s reasoning is as follows:Mr Knudsen’s Evidence(a)Complaint is made of right ankle pain and swelling. The ankle was not injured in the subject fall. Dr Perko expressly excludes injury to the right ankle and knee. The Arbitrator made a finding that he was not satisfied “the injury of 3 February 1995 resulted in injury to [Mr Knudsen’s] right ankle or right knee or resulted in a consequential medical condition affecting the right ankle or knee” (Reasons at [51]);(b)There was “some lack of clarity in determining the nature of the work [Mr Knudsen] was engaged in with the respondent” pre-injury. It was unclear as to whether that was different to the work performed subsequently in Western Australia. The evidence does establish that his pre-injury work was that of a rigger and dogman. Notwithstanding Ms Farmbach’s view, expressed before removal of the pin in Mr Knudsen’s leg, concerning Mr Knudsen’s future employment prospects, the Arbitrator found (at [36]) that “by 1998 and onwards [Mr Knudsen] resumed working full time in Western Australia in employment that included him working as a scaffolder, rigger and crane driver”;(c)Mr Knudsen’s statement in evidence was found to be “not helpful” concerning the reasons for “limitations” said to be experienced in performance of work tasks (at [41]) and,(d)Mr Knudsen had omitted to provide evidence “as to the nature of [the pre-injury work] that it is claimed that he was unable to perform” as a result of the subject injury.Dr Gope’s Evidence(a)The Arbitrator was “of the view that Dr Gope’s opinions with respect to question of how the pleaded injury to the right leg has resulted in [Mr Knudsen] suffering an incapacity during the relevant period are not very helpful” (at [45]). Dr Gope had taken into account injuries to body parts not relevant on the present facts;(b)Dr Gope’s evidence “lacks weight” by reason of deficiencies in the history as recorded (Reasons at [47]-[49]), and(c)Dr Gope “does not explain how the successfully united fracture of the tibia and fibula has resulted in an incapacity for work in respect to the relevant period” (at [50]).Dr Perko’s Evidence(a)The latest evidence of Dr Perko was a report issued in 1996;(b)The fractures healed well. Following the removal of the pin Dr Perko expected Mr Knudsen would be fit to return work in November 1995, and(c)As earlier noted at [26] above, Mr Knudsen had, in the Arbitrator’s view, made a good recovery notwithstanding Dr Perko’s impairment assessment. It may be seen from the Arbitrator’s Reasons, some part of which I have attempted to summarise above, that the uncontradicted evidence was found to be wanting with respect to proof of partial incapacity resulting from the subject injury. The circumstances which led the Arbitrator to his conclusion were made clear in the course of his Reasons and, notwithstanding the fact that relevant evidence had not been contradicted, he was not satisfied that partial incapacity had been made out. That was a conclusion open to the Arbitrator on the evidence including that of Dr Perko, whose evidence was that less hazardous work might be preferable for Mr Knudsen (Reasons at [16]). In my opinion no relevant error has been made out and ground three must fail.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.