Knight Watch Security Pty Limited v Aussie Broadband Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 18 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Knight Watch Security Pty Limited v Aussie Broadband Limited [2023] FCA 344

File number: NSD 775 of 2022
Judgment of: CHEESEMAN J
Date of judgment: 18 April 2023
Catchwords: PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – application for preliminary discovery under r 7.22 of the Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth) of identifying information relating to an IP address operated by respondent – where purpose of discovery to ascertain identity of user(s) allocated IP address at time when impugned communications sent – where user(s) made complaints about alleged conduct of applicant to applicant’s clients – consideration of disclosure prohibitions in the Telecommunications Act 1997 (Cth) – Held: application granted.
Legislation:

Telecommunications Act 1997 (Cth) ss 276, 280(1), 280(1B)

Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth) r 7.22

Supplementary Explanatory Memorandum, Telecommunications (Interception and Access) Amendment (Data Retention) Bill 2014 (Cth)

Revised Explanatory Memorandum, Telecommunications (Interception and Access) Amendment (Data Retention) Bill 2015 (Cth)

Cases cited:

CIC Insurance Ltd v Bankstown Football Club Ltd [1997] HCA 2; 187 CLR 384

Dallas Buyers Club LLC v iiNet Limited [2015] FCA 317; 245 FCR 129

Federal Commissioner of Taxation v Consolidated Media Holdings Ltd [2012] HCA 55; 250 CLR 503

Hooper v Kirella Pty Ltd [1999] FCA 1584; 96 FCR 1

Project Blue Sky Inc v Australian Broadcasting Authority [1998] HCA 28; 194 CLR 355Siemens Industry Software Inc v Telstra Corporation Limited [2020] FCA 901

SZTAL v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2017] HCA 34; 262 CLR 362

Division: General Division
Registry: New South Wales
National Practice Area: Commercial and Corporations
Sub-area: Commercial Contracts, Banking, Finance and Insurance
Number of paragraphs: 29
Date of last submission: 21 December 2022
Date of hearing: Determined on the papers.
Solicitor for  Applicant: Streeterlaw
Solicitor for  Respondent: TXD Law

ORDERS

NSD 775 of 2022
BETWEEN:

KNIGHT WATCH SECURITY PTY LIMITED ACN 097 678 272

Applicant

AND:

AUSSIE BROADBAND LIMITED ACN 132 090 192

Respondent

ORDER MADE BY:

CHEESEMAN J

DATE OF ORDER:

18 APRIL 2023

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

For the purpose of these orders:

Document includes:

(a)any record of information mentioned in the definition of document in Part 1 of the Dictionary to the Evidence Act 1995 (Cth); and

(b)any other material, data or information stored or recorded by mechanical or electronic means.

Impugned Communications means the communications described in paragraph [6] to [8] of the reasons for judgment.

1.Within 14 days, Aussie Broadband Limited (ACN 132 090 192) give discovery to the Knight Watch Security Pty Ltd (ACN  097 678 272) of such documents that are or have been in Aussie Broadband’s control that are sufficient to identify the name and address of the person(s) referred to in the Schedule.

2.In complying with Order 1, Aussie Broadband is to disclose any documents discovered to the solicitors for Knight Watch (Streeterlaw).

3.Streeterlaw is to hold and keep the documents disclosed to it confidential subject to Order 4.

4.Within 14 days of disclosure being provided, Haralambos Davernaris is entitled…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Knight Watch Security Pty Limited v Aussie Broadband Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] FCA 344
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Knight Watch Security Pty Limited, trading as Bluestar Security, sought an order for preliminary discovery from Aussie Broadband Limited for identifying information relating to an IP address operated by the latter. The purpose of the discovery was to ascertain the identity of the user(s) allocated the IP address at the time when impugned communications were sent. The impugned communications were made through the online enquiry portals of two of Knight Watch's clients and contained defamatory statements about Knight Watch. Aussie Broadband argued that the relief sought lacked utility and was not necessary due to the privacy concerns and potential overbreadth of the discovery request. The court had to determine whether the application for preliminary discovery should be granted and, if so, what conditions should be imposed to protect the privacy of Aussie Broadband's customers.

The court found that the system configuration of Aussie Broadband could result in the disclosure of information relating to multiple customers, not just the likely sender(s) of the impugned communications. This raised legitimate privacy concerns. However, the court also recognised the importance of Knight Watch's potential legal proceedings to address the defamatory statements. The court granted the application for preliminary discovery, but imposed specific conditions to protect the privacy of Aussie Broadband's customers. The court ordered that Aussie Broadband must provide documents relating to the identity and address of any registered account holder(s) allocated the use of the specified IP address at the relevant times. The court also imposed strict confidentiality obligations on the parties and limited the use of the disclosed information to the potential legal proceedings. The parties were granted leave to apply to relist to be heard on the form of these orders.

In conclusion, the court granted the application for preliminary discovery, but with specific conditions to protect the privacy of Aussie Broadband's customers. The court recognised the importance of balancing the need for discovery with the need to protect privacy and ordered that the disclosure be subject to obligations as to confidentiality and limited to use in the potential proceedings. The parties were granted leave to apply to relist to be heard on the form of these orders.

Orders

Orders of the court

For the purpose of these orders:

Document includes:

(a) any record of information mentioned in the definition of document in Part 1 of the Dictionary to the Evidence Act 1995 (Cth); and

(b) any other material, data or information stored or recorded by mechanical or electronic means.

Impugned Communications means the communications described in paragraph [6] to [8] of the reasons for judgment.

1. Within 14 days, Aussie Broadband Limited (ACN 132 090 192) give discovery to the Knight Watch Security Pty Ltd (ACN 097 678 272) of such documents that are or have been in Aussie Broadband’s control that are sufficient to identify the name and address of the person(s) referred to in the Schedule.

2. In complying with Order 1, Aussie Broadband is to disclose any documents discovered to the solicitors for Knight Watch (Streeterlaw).

3. Streeterlaw is to hold and keep the documents disclosed to it confidential subject to Order 4.

4. Within 14 days of disclosure being provided, Haralambos Davernaris is entitled to inspect the documents in the office of Streeterlaw for the sole purpose of identifying the person(s) who sent the impugned communications to the clients of Knight Watch by examining whether any of the names or addresses are relevantly familiar to him and in doing so, Haralambos Davernaris is not permitted to disclose to any third party the name or address of any account holder disclosed to him pursuant to this Order, other than to Knight Watch and such of its agents and representatives who have been notified of and agreed to be bound by Order 6(a).

5. Within 7 days after inspection by Haralambos Davernaris, Streeterlaw is to delete all copies (including electronic) of documents discovered by Aussie Broadband that are not relevant to any cause of action that Knight Watch may have in relation to the impugned communications.

6. Knight Watch:

(a) is not permitted to disclose to any third party the name and address of any account holder disclosed to Knight Watch pursuant to Order 1, other than agents or representatives of Knight Watch, who have been notified of and agreed in writing to be bound by this Order;

(b) is to maintain a list of all persons to whom disclosure is made together with a copy of their written agreement to be bound by this Order; and

(c) is permitted to use the information disclosed pursuant to Order 1 only for the purposes of legal proceedings to obtain damages or compensation, injunctive, declaratory or ancillary relief (including in any related pre or post commencement negotiations and or mediations) in respect of the impugned communications.

7. Knight Watch pay Aussie Broadband’s reasonable costs of compliance with these orders.

8. The parties have leave to apply to relist to be heard on the form of these orders, such leave to exercised within 3 business days of the date of the these orders and on the giving of notice to the other party.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

SCHEDULE

1. Subject to paragraph 2 of this Schedule, all documents relating to the identity and the address of any registered account holder(s) allocated the use of IP address 121.200.5.188 at the following times:

(a) 5:24AM AEST on 18 August 2022; and

(b) 1:15 AM AEST on 18 August 2022.

2. In the event, that the IP address 121.200.5.188 was used by a registered account holder at both the times in paragraph 1(a) and (b), then the identity and the address of that registered account holder only.

Background

Background to the litigation

Knight Watch provided written submissions in support of its application. Aussie Broadband did not provide written submissions, but outlined its arguments as to why the relief sought lacks utility in a letter from its solicitors. The parties consented to the application being determined on the papers. FACTUAL BACKGROUND Knight Watch trades under its registered business name, Bluestar Security, and provides protection and security services through the provision of on-site security personnel. The Bluestar business has traded for 29 years and holds labour licences in Queensland and Victoria and has provided services across Australia and New Zealand. On 18 August 2022, two of Knight Watch’s clients received a communication sent via their respective online enquiry portals on their websites (the impugned communications). Both communications contained the same information in the name and email address fields of the website form and contained similar messages. The messages were as follows (as written, hyperlink omitted):Your security contractor Bluestar / Knight Watch Security is doing well exploiting guards under paying them and using contractors this info will be sent to media and its going to make you also come under investigation see below link and:Your security contractor Bluestar Knight Watch Security is doing well exploiting guards under paying them and using contractors. info will be sent to media see below from Labour Hire Victoria and you will also be in the media for this. The impugned communications both contained a hyperlink to an article published by Labour Hire Victoria in June 2022, with the headline “Cancelled, Refused, Conditions imposed: The Labour Hire Authority is tackling exploitation in the security industry”. Knight Watch was referred to in the article in the following context:Following recent investigations, the Labour Hire Authority (LHA) has granted a licence to Knight Watch Security Pty Ltd trading as Bluestar Security Services (Bluestar) with significant conditions attached.However, the LHA refused a separate licence application and cancelled the licence of two subcontractors that had been charging Bluestar for the supply of guards for 24/7 coverage at rates as low as $24 per hour (excluding GST). The contract rates these businesses charged were so low that they were incapable of covering even the minimum wage under the Security Services Industry Award 2020 during some time spans.There were additional concerns about these subcontractors’ compliance with other legal obligations, including in relation to superannuation, the portable long service leave levy and workers’ compensation insurance. Mr Le Roux examined the impugned communications on behalf of Knight Watch and concluded that they originated from the same IP address operated by Aussie Broadband. The email address contained in each enquiry form was invalid and incapable of accepting emails. Mr Reisinger deposed that Aussie Broadband’s system is configured such that multiple customers may share an IP address at any given time. To distinguish between the potentially relevant customers Aussie Broadband would need to know the port number, in addition to the IP address, date and time of posting the impugned communications. Without the port number, Aussie Broadband may be required to provide the details of up to 128 customers in response to the application for preliminary discovery. Aussie Broadband collects and retains IP address logs primarily to comply with its data retention obligations, however, there are occasions when the logs have been accessed by Aussie Broadband staff for internal fact checking, such as to confirm a purchase made by an Aussie Broadband customer following a complaint. Aussie Broadband does not have a policy relating to the access to the logs by staff for internal fact checking. On the occasions that this has occurred, staff members have done so on their own initiative, in the course of their employment.APPLICABLE LEGAL PRINCIPLES

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

The way in which the Aussie Broadband system is configured is such that the response to preliminary discovery may involve it in providing the names and addresses of customers other than the likely sender(s) of the impugned communications and this gives rise to legitimate privacy concerns. In making orders for preliminary discovery, I have narrowed the scope of the category of documents to be produced and made ancillary orders directed to protecting the identity and privacy of those customers. The form of the orders differs from that proposed by the applicant. Accordingly, I have granted the parties leave to apply within three business days of these orders if they seek to be heard on the form of orders.CONCLUSION For these reasons, I will make orders requiring Aussie Broadband to give targeted preliminary discovery and for that disclosure to be subject to obligations as to confidentiality and limited to use in the potential proceedings that Knight Watch has identified in relation to the impugned communications.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.