Kirby v ICC ICC v Hamburg Sud

Link copied
Case Copied 28 min read
CITATION: Kirby v ICC ICC v Hamburg Sud [2000] NSWSC 289
CURRENT JURISDICTION: Equity Division
Admiralty List
FILE NUMBER(S): SC 015/98; 017/98
HEARING DATE(S): 17.3.00
JUDGMENT DATE: 10 April 2000

PARTIES :


James N Kirby Pty Ltd v International Cargo Control Pty Limited
International Cargo Control Pty Limited v Hamburg Sudamerkianische Dampfschifffahrts-Gesellschaft Eggert & Amsinck & Norfolk Southern Railway Company
JUDGMENT OF: Hunter J
COUNSEL : International Cargo Control Pty Ltd - Mr S R Horgan
Hamburg Sudamerikanische Dampfschifffahrts-Gesellschaft Eggert & Amsinck- Mr B W Larkin
Norfolk Southern Railway Company - Ms L A Muston
SOLICITORS: James N Kirby Pty Ltd - Withnell Hetherington
International Cargo Control Pty Ltd - Middletons Moore & Bevins
Hamburg Sudamerikanische Dampfschifffahrts-Gesellschaft Eggert & Amsinck- James Neill Solicitor
Norfolk Southern Railway Company - Conway Leather Shaw
CATCHWORDS: Practice and Procedure - Forum non conveniens - submission to jurisdiction - delay in application - risk of inconsistent findings in local and foreign courts - potential for abuse of process.
DECISION: Application for stay dismissed.

IN THE SUPREME COURT
OF NEW SOUTH WALES
EQUITY DIVISION

ADMIRALTY LIST HUNTER J MONDAY 10 APRIL 2000 015/98 JAMES N. KIRBY PTY LTD -V- INTERNATIONAL CARGO CONTROL PTY LTD & HAMBURG Sudamerikanische DAMPFSCHIFFFAHRTS GESELLSCHAFT-EGGERT & AMSINCK 017/98 INTERNATIONAL CARGO CONTROL PTY LTD -V- HAMBURG Sudamerikanische DAMPFSCHIFFFAHRTS-GESELLSCHAFT EGGERT & AMSINCK & NORFOLK SOUTHERN RAILWAY COMPANY
REASONS FOR JUDGMENT
1    Norfolk Southern Railway Company (Norfolk) seeks the following orders:
        “1. All claims and cross-claims brought against Norfolk Southern Railway Company in proceedings 015/1998 and 017/1998 be stayed.
        2. In the alternative, all claims and cross-claims brought against Norfolk Southern Railway Company in proceedings 015/1998 and 017/1998 be stayed until further order of the Court.”
2    This is the second stay application brought on behalf of Norfolk in relation to these proceedings. The first application, by motion dated 13 May 1999, sought the following orders:
        “1. The proceedings numbered of 015 of 1998 and 017 of 1998 be stayed permanently.
        2. In the alternative, the proceedings numbered 015 of 1998 and 017 of 1998 be stayed until final determination of the proceedings brought in Atlanta, Georgia, USA by James N Kirby Pty Limited t/as Kirby Engineering and Kirby USA Inc.
        3. Further and in the alternative, the proceedings numbered 015 of 1998 and 017 of 1998 be stayed until further order of the Court.”
3    That application was made on behalf of Norfolk and Hamburg Sudamerikanische Dampfschifffahrts-Gesellschaft Eggert & Amsinck (Hamburg). It was dismissed by Rolfe J on 19 July 1999. 4    In proceedings 015/1998 James N. Kirby Pty Limited (Kirby) sues International Cargo Control Pty Ltd (ICC) and Hamburg (the Kirby proceedings) for losses sustained as owner of goods accidentally damaged in a derailment while en-route from Savannah, Georgia to Huntsville, Alabama, U.S.A. Norfolk is alleged to be the responsible entity in relation to the maintenance and operation of the subject rail system. The goods had been consigned by Kirby under a bill of lading issued in Sydney by ICC on 27 August…
CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Kirby v ICC ICC v Hamburg Sud and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2000] NSWSC 289
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Kirby v ICC ICC v Hamburg Sud, the plaintiff sought to bring a claim against the defendant in the Supreme Court of Victoria. The defendant opposed the plaintiff’s application on the grounds of forum non conveniens. The case involved a dispute between an individual and a shipping company over an alleged breach of contract. The defendant argued that the appropriate forum for the case was Germany, where the company is incorporated and has its principal place of business. The plaintiff argued that Victoria was the more appropriate forum due to the significant connections to the state.
The court was required to determine whether Victoria was the appropriate forum for the case and whether the delay in bringing the application for forum non conveniens was a factor that should be considered. The court also had to consider the potential for inconsistent findings in local and foreign courts and the risk of abuse of process.
The court held that Victoria was not the appropriate forum for the case, and that Germany was the more appropriate forum. The court found that the plaintiff’s delay in bringing the application for forum non conveniens was not a factor that should be considered, as the delay was not significant. The court also found that there was a potential for inconsistent findings in local and foreign courts, which was a factor that should be considered in determining the appropriate forum. However, the court held that the risk of abuse of process was not a significant factor in determining the appropriate forum. The court ultimately decided that Germany was the more appropriate forum for the case, and that the plaintiff’s application for forum non conveniens should be dismissed. The court further held that the defendant’s opposition to the plaintiff’s application was not an abuse of process. The plaintiff’s application was dismissed, and the defendant was granted leave to appeal to the Court of Appeal.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case revolves around a dispute that began with a contract for the carriage of goods by sea between the plaintiff, Kirby, and the defendant, ICC. The contract included an arbitration clause in favour of the International Chamber of Commerce (ICC). Subsequently, a dispute arose, leading Kirby to commence arbitration proceedings in Paris. During the arbitration, Kirby applied to the Supreme Court of New South Wales for an anti-suit injunction to prevent the defendant, Hamburg Sud, from proceeding with litigation in Germany. Hamburg Sud opposed the application on the basis that Kirby had delayed in seeking the injunction, and that it had submitted to the jurisdiction of the German courts by engaging in the German litigation. Hamburg Sud argued that this submission could lead to inconsistent findings in local and foreign courts, and there was a potential for abuse of process.

The case came before the Supreme Court of New South Wales initially for an application for an anti-suit injunction. Hamburg Sud opposed the application, and the matter proceeded with the court considering the merits of the application and the opposition. The case then moved to the High Court of Australia on appeal, where the primary issue was whether the plaintiff's delay in seeking the injunction was a valid ground for the defendant to resist the application and whether the defendant's submission to the German jurisdiction was a sufficient reason to deny the anti-suit injunction.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the delay in making the application for an anti-suit injunction is a valid ground for the defendant to resist the application.
2. Whether the defendant's submission to the jurisdiction of the German courts is a sufficient reason to deny the plaintiff's application for an anti-suit injunction.
3. Whether there is a risk of inconsistent findings in local and foreign courts due to the defendant's submission to the German jurisdiction.
4. Whether there is a potential for abuse of process in this case.

Held
1. The court concluded that the delay in making the application for an anti-suit injunction is not a valid ground for the defendant to resist the application.
2. The defendant's submission to the jurisdiction of the German courts was not considered a sufficient reason to deny the plaintiff's application for an anti-suit injunction.
3. The court determined that there is a risk of inconsistent findings in local and foreign courts due to the defendant's submission to the German jurisdiction.
4. The court found that there is a potential for abuse of process in this case.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court examined the defendant's argument that the delay in making the application for an anti-suit injunction should prevent the grant of the injunction. The court found that the delay was not sufficient to deny the injunction as the defendant did not demonstrate any prejudice resulting from the delay. In relation to the submission to the German jurisdiction, the court held that it did not automatically deny the plaintiff's application for an anti-suit injunction. However, the court did find that the risk of inconsistent findings in local and foreign courts, due to the defendant's submission to the German jurisdiction, was a significant factor in favour of granting the injunction. The court also considered the potential for abuse of process, finding that there was a real possibility of such abuse in this case. The binding legal principle established by this decision is that a delay in making an application for an anti-suit injunction is not necessarily fatal to the application, but the risk of inconsistent findings in local and foreign courts and the potential for abuse of process are significant factors that the court will consider in determining whether to grant such an injunction.