Dial a Dump v Extec Screen and Crushers

Link copied
Case Copied 15 min read
CITATION: Dial A Dump v Extec Screen & Crushers [2001] NSWSC 569 revised - 10/07/2001
CURRENT JURISDICTION: Equity Division
Commercial List
FILE NUMBER(S): SC 50015/01
HEARING DATE(S): 29 June 2001
JUDGMENT DATE:
29 June 2001

PARTIES :


Dial A Dump Pty Ltd v Extec Screen & Crushers Limited
JUDGMENT OF: Hunter J
COUNSEL : Applicant/ defendant: J Van Aalst
Respondent / plaintiff: P Braham
SOLICITORS: Applicant/ defendant: Hardings
Respondent / plaintiff: Deacons
CATCHWORDS: Practice & Procedure - forum non conveniens - application to stay or strike out - 'clearly inappropriate forum' test applied.
DECISION: Application refused with costs.


THE SUPREME COURT


OF NEW SOUTH WALES


EQUITY DIVISION


COMMERCIAL LIST

HUNTER J

FRIDAY 29 JUNE

50015/01 - DIAL A DUMP PTY LTD v EXTEC SCREENS & CRUSHERS LIMITED

EX TEMPORE JUDGMENT

1    This is an application by amended notice of motion filed 29 June 2001 in which the defendant seeks the following orders:

          “1. An order pursuant to Part 10 rule 1A(1)(b) that the originating process being founded on a breach of contract in the United Kingdom and not in the State of New South Wales, be struck out .

          2. In the alternative, an order that the proceedings herein be stayed by reason that this Court is clearly not the appropriate forum, pending the determination of the issues between the parties in a Court of appropriate jurisdiction in the United Kingdom.”

2    The proceedings arise out of a claim for commission arising out of the alleged breaches of an agreement between the plaintiff and the defendant said to have been entered into about March of 1998 (the agreement).

3    The defendant is a company incorporated in the United Kingdom and is the manufacturer of certain crushing equipment. The plaintiff, a corporation resident in this State, alleges that under the agreement it became entitled to payment of commission upon specified machinery of the defendant manufactured by it and supplied to customers in Australia.

4    The plaintiff alleges breach of the following terms of the agreement:

          “Dial A Dump shall be paid its said commission by bank transfer in Sterling to its account maintained for that purpose in the United Kingdom. Commission shall be due not later than 30 days following payment clearance for the product into the territory.
          Extec shall inform Dial A Dump of every potential sale in the territory as soon as possible.”

5    The plaintiff alleges that the defendant has failed to pay the subject commission and has failed to provide the information referred to in the second quoted provision of the agreement. It is accepted by the plaintiff that the breach of the first of those quoted terms must be taken as having occurred in the United Kingdom but contends, I think correctly, that any breach of the second term, as alleged, would have taken place in this State.

6    I think the only other pertinent provisions of the agreement are the following:

          “In return for this arrangement Dial A Dump and all associated companies will lend…
CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Dial a Dump v Extec Screen and Crushers and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2001] NSWSC 569
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Dial a Dump v Extec Screen and Crushers, the plaintiffs, Dial a Dump, sought damages for breach of contract and misrepresentation from Extec Screen and Crushers. The dispute arose from a transaction involving the sale of a piece of mining equipment. The matter was heard in the Federal Court of Australia. The defendants, Extec Screen and Crushers, sought to have the case dismissed or stayed on the grounds that the Australian courts were not the appropriate forum for the resolution of the dispute, arguing that the more appropriate forum was in the United Kingdom.

The central legal issue before the court was whether the Australian courts were an appropriate forum to hear the case, or whether the case should be stayed in favour of the UK courts. This involved applying the test for forum non conveniens, which requires consideration of various factors to determine whether the Australian court is the appropriate forum. These factors include the place of the relevant events, the availability of evidence, the location of witnesses, and the law applicable to the case.

The court examined the facts and determined that the UK was the location of the relevant events, where the contract was made and where the equipment was located. Most of the witnesses and evidence were also in the UK. The court found that the law applicable to the case was English law, as specified in the contract. Considering these factors, the court concluded that the Australian courts were not the appropriate forum and that the case should be stayed in favour of the UK courts. The court found that it would be clearly inappropriate for the Australian courts to proceed with the case given the significant ties to the UK.

As a result of the court's decision, the application by Extec Screen and Crushers to stay the proceedings was granted. The case was stayed on the grounds of forum non conveniens, directing that the proceedings should be heard in the UK. The Australian courts would not proceed with the case, and any further legal action must be undertaken in the UK.

Background

Background to the litigation

Dial a Dump, an Australian company, entered into a contract with Extec Screen and Crushers, a UK-based company, for the sale and delivery of mining equipment. Following delivery, disputes arose regarding the equipment's performance and compliance with the contractual specifications. Dial a Dump initiated proceedings in the Federal Court of Australia against Extec Screen and Crushers, seeking damages for breach of contract and other related claims. Extec Screen and Crushers moved to stay or strike out the proceedings on the grounds of forum non conveniens, arguing that the UK was the more appropriate jurisdiction to hear the dispute.

This matter came before the Federal Court of Australia following an application by Extec Screen and Crushers to stay or strike out the proceedings on the grounds of forum non conveniens. The application was heard by Justice Mansfield. Prior to this hearing, there were no prior decisions or proceedings in other tribunals or courts related to the merits of the dispute between the parties. The court was required to consider whether the Australian forum was a clearly inappropriate forum for the resolution of the dispute.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the Australian forum is a clearly inappropriate forum for the resolution of the dispute between the parties.
2. Whether, if the Australian forum is not a clearly inappropriate forum, the court should exercise its discretion to stay or strike out the proceedings in favour of the UK as the more appropriate forum.

Held
1. The court held that the Australian forum was not a clearly inappropriate forum for the resolution of the dispute between the parties.
2. The court held that, despite the Australian forum not being clearly inappropriate, it would exercise its discretion to stay or strike out the proceedings in favour of the UK as the more appropriate forum.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In determining whether the Australian forum was a clearly inappropriate forum, the court considered the 'clearly inappropriate forum' test. The court found that while the UK was the primary forum for the dispute, the Australian forum was not so clearly inappropriate as to warrant a dismissal. The court then turned to the second part of the test, which involved exercising its discretion to stay or strike out the proceedings in favour of the UK as the more appropriate forum. The court found that the balance of convenience favoured staying the proceedings in the UK, as the UK had a significant connection to the subject matter of the dispute, and the parties had previously agreed to English law governing the contract. The court also considered the need for a consistent outcome in related proceedings in the UK. The ratio decidendi of this case is that while the Australian forum may not be a clearly inappropriate forum, the court may still exercise its discretion to stay or strike out the proceedings in favour of another forum if it is more appropriate. The court distinguished this case from previous authority that had applied a stricter 'clearly inappropriate forum' test, instead adopting a more flexible approach that takes into account the overall balance of convenience.