Kippville Pty Ltd v Ici Australia Operations Proprietary Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 16 min read

PATENTS ACT 1990

DECISION OF A DELEGATE OF THE COMMISSIONER OF PATENTS

Re:Patent Application No.593185 by KIPPVILLE PTY LTD, Opposition by ICI AUSTRALIA OPERATIONS PROPRIETARY LIMITED, and Objection to Extension of Time to serve Evidence-in-Reply.

BACKGROUND

Patent Application No. 593185 by GANSU RESEARCH INSTITUTION OF CHEMICAL INDUSTRY entitled "Chemically Foamed Emulsion Explosive Composition and Process for its Preparation" was advertised as accepted on 1 February 1990 on which date the application became open to public inspection for the first time. The time for lodging Notice of Opposition expired on 1 May 1990 and on 27 April 1990, ICI AUSTRALIA OPERATIONS PROPRIETARY LIMITED (afterwards referred to as ICI) lodged an application under section 59(1) of the Patents Act 1952 for an extension of time of three months, from 1 May 1990 to 1 August 1990, in which to serve Notice of Opposition, which extension was allowed. On 10 July 1990, ICI lodged their Notice of Opposition.

As the patent application was both lodged and accepted before the commencement of the Patents Act 1990, the provisions of section 234(3) of the 1990 Act, and regulation 23.3, are applicable and therefore the matters in hand are in substance determined in accordance with the relevant provisions of the Patents Act 1952 and the regulations thereto.

Following allowed extensions of time the lodgement of ICI's Evidence-in-Support was completed on 21 March 1991.

Evidence-in-Answer was completed on 20 May 1991.

On 29 April 1991, a first statement of proposed amendments was lodged under section 77 of the Patents Act 1952, and, following comments by ICI filed under the provisions of subregulation 10.2 (7) of the Patents Act 1990, further amendments under section 104 of the Patents Act 1990 were proposed. The granting of leave to amend was advertised on 15 October 1992. ICI opposed the proposed amendments and to date this matter is outstanding.

In the meantime, KIPPVILLE PTY LTD (afterwards referred to as Kippville) requested the Commissioner to direct that the application proceed in their name and the Commissioner so directed on 3 September 1992.

Applications for extensions of time to 22 November 1992 to lodge Evidence-in-Reply were allowed to ICI but the latest application i.e. from 22 November 1992 to 22 February 1993 is the subject of an objection by Kippville and the matter was therefore set down for hearing.

The hearing took place in Canberra on 28 January 1993.  The applicant (Kippville) was represented by Catherine M Hustwick, patent attorney, of R.K.Maddern & Associates, who appeared by telephone.  The opponent (ICI) was represented by Raymond L Evans, patent attorney, of Phillips Ormonde & Fitzpatrick, who appeared in person. 

THE APPLICATION

The application states:

" The circumstances in which and the grounds upon which this
  application is made are as follows:

The Applicant lodged a first request to amend on 29 April
    1991 in which substantial changes to the claimed invention
    were proposed.  The Opponents provided a detailed submission
    on the amendments and the Examiner has issued an adverse
    report.

A second…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Kippville Pty Ltd v Ici Australia Operations Proprietary Lim... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1993] APO 14
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Kippville Pty Ltd v Ici Australia Operations Proprietary Limited involves a dispute over a patent application for a chemically foamed emulsion explosive composition and process for its preparation. The patent application, initially filed by Gansu Research Institution of Chemical Industry, was opposed by Ici Australia Operations Proprietary Limited (ICI). The key legal issues centered around the granting of an extension of time for ICI to lodge its Evidence-in-Reply due to delays caused by proposed amendments to the patent application. The amendments, which significantly altered the invention claimed, created uncertainty and confusion, making it difficult for ICI to prepare its evidence.

The court examined whether ICI had made out a proper case for the extension, whether there was undue delay, and whether the opposition was serious. The court considered that although ICI had ample time to prepare their evidence, the uncertainty and confusion caused by the amendments justified the extension. The court also noted that the proposed amendments, if allowed, could impact the claims and specification, affecting ICI's ability to finalize their evidence. Given the unresolved nature of the amendments, the court concluded that the extension would not unduly delay proceedings and was in the public interest.

Ultimately, the court granted the extension of time for ICI to lodge their Evidence-in-Reply, highlighting the importance of resolving the amendment issues to prevent indefinite delays. The court also made general observations on the potential for expediting matters through proposed amendments during opposition proceedings and the practice of setting parallel oppositions for sequential hearings, subject to party agreement and practical considerations. The decision underscores the need to balance the interests of the parties and the public in patent opposition proceedings.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established