Kiernan v Naismith Truck Movers Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 55 min read

FEDERAL CIRCUIT AND FAMILY COURT OF AUSTRALIA

(DIVISION 2)

Kiernan v Naismith Truck Movers Pty Ltd [2024] FedCFamC2G 618

File number: SYG 666 of 2022
Judgment of: JUDGE SYMONS
Date of judgment: 19 July 2024
Catchwords: INDUSTRIAL LAW – application for pecuniary penalties – agreed contraventions - breach of National Minimum Wage Orders and Road Transport and Distribution Award 2010 – significant underpayment – no evidence of contrition or measures to prevent recurrence of offending practices - grouping of contraventions – significance of an earlier related proceeding – no declaratory relief granted – significant penalties imposed
Legislation:

 Evidence Act 1995 (Cth), ss 128, 140.

Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth), ss 12, 45, 293, 538, 539, 546, 557, 557A, 550.

National Minimum Wage Order 2015.

National Minimum Wage Order 2016.

National Minimum Wage Order 2017.

Road Transport and Distribution Award 2010 Cll, 12.5, 15.2, 16.2(f), 16.4(e), 19, 22.1, 26.3, 27.1, 27.3, 28.1, 28.2.

Road Transport (Long Distance Operations) Award 2010.     

Cases cited:

Australian Building and Construction Commission v Pattinson (2022) 274 CLR 450; [2022] HCA 13.

Construction, Forestry, Maritime, Mining and Energy Union v Australian Building and Construction Commissioner (The Non-Indemnification Personal Payment Case) (2018) 264 FCR 155; [2018] FCAFC 97.

Cooper v Naismith Truck Movers Pty Ltd [2021] FedCFamC2G 221.

Fair Work Ombudsman v Australian Sales & Promotions Pty Ltd & Anor [2016] FCCA 2804.

Fair Work Ombudsman v Australian Wild Tuna Pty Ltd & Anor (2016) 313 FLR 126; [2016] FCCA 2626.

Fair Work Ombudsman v Lohr (2018) 356 ALR 424; [2018] FCA 5.

Fair Work Ombudsman v NSH North Pty Ltd trading as New Shanghai Charlestown [2017] FCA 1301

Fair Work Ombudsman v PTES [2023] FCA 934

Impiombato v BHP Group Limited (No 5) [2024] FCA 591.

Morley v Australian Securities and Investments Commission (2010) 274 ALR 205; [2010] NSWCA 331.

Rocky Holdings Pty Ltd v Fair Work Ombudsman (2014) 221 FCR 153; [2014] FCAFC 62.

Trade Practices Commission v CSR Ltd [1990] FCA 521

Division: Division 2 General Federal Law
Number of paragraphs: 182
Date of last submissions: 16 November 2023
Date of hearing: 16 November 2023
Place: Melbourne
Solicitor for the Applicant: Mr J Mattson of Bartier Perry
Counsel for the Respondents: Mr M Garozzo
Solicitor for the Respondents:  Kennedys Law

ORDERS

SYG 666 of 2022

FEDERAL CIRCUIT AND FAMILY COURT OF AUSTRALIA (DIVISION 2)

BETWEEN:

STEVEN THOMAS KIERNAN
Applicant

AND:

GLOBAL TRUCKING PTY LTD (FORMERLY KNOWN AS NAISMITH TRUCK MOVERS PTY LTD)
First Respondent

DARYL JAMES NAISMITH
Second Respondent

ORDER MADE BY:

JUDGE SYMONS

DATE OF ORDER:

19 JULY 2024

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The name of the first respondent be amended to “Global Trucking Pty Ltd (formerly known as Naismith Truck Movers Pty Ltd)”.

2.The first respondent pay pecuniary penalties totalling $153,090.

3.The second respondent pay pecuniary penalties totalling $14,742.

4.The penalties referred to in orders 2 and 3 be paid to the applicant within 28 days.

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Kiernan v Naismith Truck Movers Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] FedCFamC2G 618
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In Kiernan v Naismith Truck Movers Pty Ltd, the applicant, Mr Kiernan, sought penalties against Global Trucking Pty Ltd, formerly Naismith Truck Movers Pty Ltd, and Mr Naismith, its director, for breaches of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth). The breaches included underpayment of wages and superannuation in violation of the National Minimum Wage Orders and the Road Transport and Distribution Award 2010. Mr Kiernan was employed as a casual truck driver by Global Trucking from May 2016 to March 2019. The court had to determine the appropriate penalties for the employer's failure to pay the minimum wage, casual loading, Saturday and Sunday loading, public holiday loading, overtime rates, travelling allowance, and meal allowance, as stipulated by the Award.

The primary legal issue was the extent of the penalties to be imposed on Global Trucking and Mr Naismith for the agreed contraventions of workplace laws. The court considered factors such as the seriousness of the breaches, the culpability of the respondents, the absence of contrition, and the need for deterrence. Mr Naismith, who had day-to-day management and control of Global Trucking, did not provide evidence of contrition or take corrective action until after the proceedings had begun. The court also noted the significant financial impact on Mr Kiernan due to the underpayments. The respondents argued that the penalties should not be excessively high given the small business nature of Global Trucking and the previous penalty imposed in a related matter.

The court found that the breaches were serious and involved significant underpayments. There was no evidence of contrition or early corrective action by the respondents. The court held that the penalties should reflect the need for specific deterrence, particularly given Mr Naismith's role and ongoing control of Global Trucking. The court imposed substantial penalties, considering the gravity of the contraventions and the lack of mitigating factors. The court did not grant declaratory relief but focused on the imposition of penalties to ensure compliance with workplace laws in the future.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

During these proceedings, the first respondent (previously known as “Naismith Truck Movers Pty Ltd”), changed its name to Global Trucking Pty Ltd which explains my reference in this judgment to “Global Trucking”.AGREED FACTS The parties agree that:(a)Mr Kiernan was engaged by Global Trucking as a casual employee from 23 May 2016 to 18 March 2019.[1](b)Global Trucking operated and operates a business distributing or relocating by road new or used vehicles required to be driven from one location to another.[2] This work is referred to as “vehicle relocation”.(c)The business of Global Trucking also includes other operations, including the transportation of single and double road train combinations (both stacked and unstacked) and freight.[3](d)The applicant was engaged by Global Trucking to perform vehicle relocation work. [4](e)Mr Naismith was, at all relevant times, the sole director, secretary, and shareholder of Global Trucking and was its controlling mind. Mr Naismith had (and has) day to day management and control of Global Trucking.[5](f)Prior to 1 July 2018, Mr Kiernan was an award/agreement free employee within the meaning of s 12 of the FW Act.[6] (g)Prior to 1 July 2018, Global Trucking was required to comply with the National Minimum Wage Order (NMWO) by paying Mr Kiernan the national minimum wage for each hour of work as well as the casual loading as applied to the national minimum wage. [7](h)From 1 July 2018, the Road Transport and Distribution Award 2010 (Award) applied to Mr Kiernan’s employment and the business of Global Trucking insofar as it involved vehicle relocation.[8][1] SOAF, [1],[8].[2] SOAF, [4]. [3] SOAF, [5].[4] SOAF, [7].[5] SOAF, [6].[6] SOAF, [9].[7] SOAF, [10].[8] SOAF, [11]. During his employment, Global Trucking remunerated Mr Kiernan by the payment of fixed trip rates which were applied without regard to the hours that Mr Kiernan in fact worked. Each of the contraventions arose out of this same incorrect method of payment.[9]THE UNDERPAYMENTS [9] SOAF, [31].The contravention of s 293 Section 293 of the FW Act provides that “an employer must not contravene a term of a national minimum wage order”. It is agreed that Global Trucking did not pay Mr Kiernan the applicable national minimum wage and casual loading for each hour worked by him during the following periods, each of which was subject to a different NMWO corresponding with the relevant financial year:·3 May 2016 to 30 June 2016;·1 July 2016 to 30 June 2017; and·1 July 2017 to 30 June 2018. This resulted in an underpayment of $26,226.46.[10][10] SOAF, [16]. Global Trucking did not pay superannuation on the amount of $26,226.46. The total amount of the unpaid superannuation was $2,491.52.[11][11] SOAF, [17]. The contravention of s 45 Section 45 of the FW Act provides that “a person must not contravene a term of a modern award”. It is agreed that Global Trucking did not pay Mr Kiernan for the period 1 July 2018 to 18 March 2019 (being the period that the Award applied to Mr Kiernan’s employment) the following Award entitlements:[12] (1)the minimum hourly rate and casual loading for each hour worked (clauses 15.2 and 19 and 12.5 of the Award);(2)the applicable Saturday and Sunday loading for each hour worked on Saturdays and Sundays (clause 28.1 of the Award);(3)the applicable public holiday loading for each hour worked on a public holiday (clause 28.2 of the Award);(4)the overtime rates for each hour of overtime worked (clauses 12.5, 22.1, 27.1 and 27.3 of the Award); (5)a travelling allowance for each occasion Mr Kiernan was working and unable to return home at night (clause 16.2(f) of the Award); and (6)a meal allowance for each occasion when Mr Kiernan was required to work overtime for two continuous hours or more (clauses 26.3 and 16.4(e) of the Award).[12] SOAF, [18].

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The parties’ submissions addressed, with different emphasis, the considerations referred to above. To best understand how the arguments were put, it is convenient to first set out the evidence upon which the parties’ relied, noting that none of it was challenged and is liable therefore to be treated, subject to it being inherently incredible or contradicted by facts otherwise established on the evidence[25] as accurate and credible.[25] Impiombato v BHP Group Limited (No 5) [2024] FCA 591 at [143].The affidavit evidence of Mr Kiernan Mr Kiernan was (as of November 2022) 67 years old and described himself as a “career truck driver”. He gave evidence that during his employment with Global Trucking he regularly dealt with and received instructions from Mr Naismith, and it was Mr Naismith who interviewed him for the role of casual truck driver. During that interview, Mr Naismith told Mr Kiernan that “drivers are paid trip rates” and that “our [Global Trucking’s] rates are the best in the industry, and everyone is happy with them”. Mr Kiernan deposed that during his employment, Mr Naismith performed the following tasks associated with his role: ·allocation of trips;·organisation of and payment for trip accommodation;·organisation of and payment for travel to and from customer depots, home, or any other trip location, including by taxi or airplane;·organisation with customers for vehicle pick-up and delivery locations and times;·contacting Mr Kiernan to inform him about upcoming trips and trip details;·setting trip rates and overnight allowance;·arranging for the reimbursement of any work-related expenses that Mr Kiernan incurred during trips;·emailing Mr Kiernan payslips. Mr Kiernan recalled raising issues regarding his pay with Mr Naismith on approximately six occasions across 2018 and 2019. When he told Mr Naismith that he believed he had been underpaid for certain trips, Mr Naismith said to him words to the effect of “Belinda works all that out, talk to Belinda” and “Belinda does the pay stuff”. Mr Kiernan understood that “Belinda” worked in the payroll department of Global Trucking. Mr Kiernan recalled that on another occasion, Mr Naismith had bragged to him that “I paid someone $400 for a $1200 trip”. Mr Kiernan gave the following evidence about events that occurred on the afternoon of 10 August 2022. This date was said to be significant because it was the day before the mediation in the proceeding took place. Mr Kiernan recalled (and produced evidence of) having received two calls from a private number to his mobile phone at 4.29 pm and 4.32 pm. After Mr Kiernan answered the first call, a male voice that Mr Kiernan recognised as belonging to Mr Naismith, started talking and asked him words to the effect of “did you pick up the mail?”. The caller continued with words to the effect of “I dropped a tape recorder into your letter box. The tape recorder has lots of incriminating evidence against you. If this case goes to Court I will use the tape recording against you. I want to settle for $20,000 at the mediation tomorrow. You and I both stand to lose a lot of money”.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The respondents submitted that the Court should be circumspect about recognising this consideration as an aggravating factor in circumstances where the first respondent is a small business and structured, in effect, as a “one-man show”. Viewed in this light, the involvement of Mr Naismith was not surprising and should not greatly aggravate the culpability of the respondents. Contrition, corrective action, and cooperation Mr Kiernan submitted that there was no evidence of contrition, which ought to weigh heavily in the determination of penalties. In oral submissions, counsel for the respondents accepted there was an absence of evidence on this point. However, he submitted that the failure of Mr Naismith to give evidence (of contrition, or more broadly, at all) in this case, was justified (or explained) in circumstances where there was an allegation of what was essentially criminal conduct made against him. It was submitted that to the extent that the decision not to give evidence impacted the Court’s ability to award a discount, it should not otherwise operate as a substantial aggravating factor against the respondents. Mr Kiernan acknowledged that there was cooperation and corrective action on the part of the respondents but submitted that this had occurred late and in circumstances where these proceedings had been already initiated and substantial evidence on liability had been filed by the applicant. The respondents challenged this submission and invited the Court to find instead that admissions had been made at an early stage in the proceeding and would likely have been made earlier had it not been for the deficiencies in the applicant’s first statement of claim.Deterrence Addressing the topic of deterrence, Mr Kiernan submitted that there was a need to send a message to employers generally in the vehicle relocation industry that contraventions of workplace laws is a matter that warrants censure. Mr Kiernan submitted that in the case of Mr Naismith the following considerations meant that there was a need for specific deterrence. First, he was, at relevant times, the sole director, secretary, and operator of Global Trucking. Second, he continues to be the owner and operator of Global Trucking. Third, he has responsibility for paying employees. Fourth, he has demonstrated a lack of contrition in these proceedings which was borne out by the fact that Mr Kiernan had been required to commence and then maintain these proceedings, even after he had received a call from Mr Naismith telling him that he would settle the proceeding at mediation. The respondents, on the other hand, submitted that there was only a moderate need to generally, or specifically, deter future like contraventions of the FW Act. The respondents invited the Court to proceed on the basis that they had already been punished by the penalty imposed in the Cooper judgment in which case the presiding judge (Judge Cameron) had expressly considered that a penalty of $20,000 was appropriate to deter future contraventions of the FW Act, “whether by the respondents or by others”.[40][40] Cooper at [23].