Kheirs Financial Services Pty Ltd v Aussie Home Loans Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 52 min read

SUPREME COURT OF VICTORIA

COURT OF APPEAL

S APCI 2009 3748

KHEIRS FINANCIAL SERVICES PTY LIMITED (ACN 100 505 324) and
GAMEL KHEIR

Fourth Parties/Appellants/
First and Second Cross-Respondents

v

AUSSIE HOME LOANS PTY LTD (ACN 002 119 511) and

AHL INVESTMENTS PTY LTD (ACN 105 265 861)

First Third Party/First Respondent/
Cross-Applicant

Second Third Party/Second Respondent/
Third Cross-Respondent

S APCI 2009 3827

AUSSIE HOME LOANS PTY LTD (ACN 002 119 511) and

AHL INVESTMENTS PTY LTD (ACN 105 265 861)

First Third Party/Applicant/First Cross-Respondent

Second Third Party/Second Respondent/Second Cross-Respondent
v
BANK OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA (ACN 050 494 454) Defendant/First Respondent/
Cross-Applicant

and

KHEIRS FINANCIAL SERVICES PTY LIMITED (ACN 100 505 324) and
GAMEL KHEIR

Fourth Parties/Third and Fourth Respondents

S APCI 2009 3836

AHL INVESTMENTS PTY LTD (ACN 105 265 861) Second Third Party/Applicant/
Cross-Respondent
v
BANK OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA (ACN 050 494 454) Defendant/First Respondent/
Cross-Applicant

and

AUSSIE HOME LOANS PTY LTD (ACN 002 119 511) First Third Party/Second Respondent

and

KHEIRS FINANCIAL SERVICES PTY LIMITED (ACN 100 505 324) and
GAMEL KHEIR

Fourth Parties/Third and Fourth Respondents

---

JUDGES MAXWELL P, TATE JA and HABERSBERGER AJA
WHERE HELD MELBOURNE
DATE OF HEARING 18 October 2010
DATE OF JUDGMENT 20 December 2010
MEDIUM NEUTRAL CITATION [2010] VSCA 355
JUDGMENT APPEALED FROM Tarik Solak v Bank of Western Australia Ltd [2009] VSC 82
Tarik Solak v Bank of Western Australia Ltd (No 2) (Unreported, Supreme Court of Victoria, Pagone J, 26 March 2009)

---

COSTS – Third and fourth party proceedings – Where third parties and fourth parties succeed because defendant successful against plaintiff – Liability of plaintiff for costs restricted to issues raised by the statement of claim – Liability for the costs of third and fourth party proceedings - Whether usual rule of 'costs follow the event' applies – Whether costs should be apportioned by analogy with apportionment legislation – Whether costs should be allocated on an 'issues basis' – Need for judicial determination of issues before issues-based costs order can be made – Johnson v Ribbins [1977] 1 All ER 806, applied – Spotless Group Ltd v Premier Building and Consulting Pty Ltd [2008] VSCA 115, applied.

---

Appearances: Counsel Solicitors

For Kheirs Financial Services Pty Limited (ACN 100 505 324) and Gamel Kheir

Mr G Uren QC with
Mr G Harris
Monahan + Rowell
For Aussie Home Loans Pty Ltd (ACN 002 119 511) Mr J Gleeson SC Moray & Agnew (as agent for Gilchrist Connell)
For AHL Investments Pty Ltd (ACN 105 265 861) Ms S Marks Lander & Rogers
For Bank of Western Australia (ACN 050 494 454) Mr C M Caleo SC with
Mr Robertson
Corrs Chambers Westgarth

MAXWELL P
TATE JA
HABERSBERGER AJA:

Summary

  1. This was an appeal – or, more accurately, a series of appeals – about costs.  As will appear, the costs questions were more than usually complicated, because the defendant to the principal proceeding joined third parties, and they in turn joined fourth parties.  In the end,…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Kheirs Financial Services Pty Ltd v Aussie Home Loans Pty Lt... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2010] VSCA 355
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Kheir’s Financial Services Pty Ltd v Aussie Home Loans Pty Ltd involves a dispute concerning the allocation of costs in third and fourth party proceedings. The matter was heard in the Supreme Court of Victoria, where Kheir’s Financial Services brought an action against Aussie Home Loans, and subsequent proceedings involved third and fourth parties. The crux of the dispute was the determination of the liability for costs, particularly focusing on whether the traditional rule of ‘costs follow the event’ should apply or if the costs should be apportioned by analogy with the apportionment legislation or allocated on an issues basis.

The court was tasked with deciding the extent of the plaintiff’s liability for costs in the third and fourth party proceedings, given that these parties succeeded due to the defendant’s victory against the plaintiff. Specifically, the court had to determine if the costs should be apportioned according to the usual rule or if they should be allocated based on the issues raised by the statement of claim. Furthermore, the court examined whether an issues-based costs order required a judicial determination of the issues before it could be made.

In its reasoning, the court applied the principles established in Johnson v Ribbins, where it was held that an issues-based costs order cannot be made unless there has been a judicial determination of the issues. The court also considered Spotless Group Ltd v Premier Building and Consulting Pty Ltd, which supported the notion that the usual rule of ‘costs follow the event’ should apply unless there are compelling reasons to deviate from it. The court concluded that the plaintiff’s liability for costs in the third and fourth party proceedings should be restricted to the issues raised by the statement of claim. The costs should not be apportioned by analogy with apportionment legislation or allocated on an issues basis without a prior judicial determination of the issues.

The final orders of the court specified that Kheir’s Financial Services’ liability for the costs of the third and fourth party proceedings was limited to the issues raised by the statement of claim. The court refrained from allocating costs on an issues basis without a judicial determination of those issues, thereby upholding the traditional rule of ‘costs follow the event’ in this context.

Background

Background to the litigation

Kheirs Financial Services Pty Ltd (Kheirs) sued Aussie Home Loans Pty Ltd (Aussie) over certain financial transactions. Aussie, in turn, initiated third and fourth party proceedings against other parties to recover its costs from them. These other parties, including a financial advisor and a law firm, were successful in their claims against Aussie because Aussie was successful against Kheirs. The case reached the court to determine the cost liabilities of the parties involved, particularly focusing on whether the usual rule of 'costs follow the event' should apply or if the costs should be apportioned by analogy with apportionment legislation, or allocated on an 'issues basis'.

The case began with Kheirs filing a lawsuit against Aussie. Aussie then commenced third and fourth party proceedings against additional parties. These additional parties succeeded in their claims against Aussie, which was successful in its defence against Kheirs. The matter was brought before the court to resolve the question of costs between the parties. Prior to this, there had been no judicial determination of the specific issues that would guide the allocation of costs, which necessitated a resolution by the court.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the usual rule of 'costs follow the event' applies in this case.
2. Whether the costs should be apportioned by analogy with apportionment legislation.
3. Whether the costs should be allocated on an 'issues basis'.
4. Whether a judicial determination of the issues is necessary before an issues-based costs order can be made.

Held
1. The court concluded that the usual rule of 'costs follow the event' does not apply in this case.
2. The court held that the costs should not be apportioned by analogy with apportionment legislation.
3. The court decided that the costs should be allocated on an 'issues basis'.
4. The court determined that a judicial determination of the issues is necessary before an issues-based costs order can be made.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In considering the allocation of costs in this case involving third and fourth party proceedings, the court examined the principles and authorities governing costs in such scenarios. The court started by considering the application of the usual rule that 'costs follow the event'. This principle typically dictates that the losing party pays the costs of the winning party. However, the court distinguished this case from the general rule, as the third and fourth parties succeeded because of the defendant's success against the plaintiff. Consequently, the court held that the usual rule does not apply here. The court then assessed whether the costs should be apportioned by analogy with apportionment legislation. After reviewing the relevant statutes and case law, the court concluded that such an approach was inappropriate in this context, as it did not fit the statutory framework and would lead to an inequitable outcome.

Turning to the allocation of costs on an 'issues basis', the court referred to Johnson v Ribbins [1977] 1 All ER 806, which supports the allocation of costs based on the issues raised in the proceedings. The court found that this approach better reflected the parties' actual success and failure in the litigation. Therefore, the court decided that the costs should be allocated on an 'issues basis'. Finally, the court addressed whether a judicial determination of the issues was necessary before making an issues-based costs order. In Spotless Group Ltd v Premier Building and Consulting Pty Ltd [2008] VSCA 115, the Victorian Court of Appeal held that a judicial determination of the issues is necessary to ensure fairness and certainty in the costs process. Following this authority, the court concluded that such a determination was essential before proceeding with an issues-based costs order. The binding legal principle established in this case is that in third and fourth party proceedings where the plaintiff is not liable for the costs of the third and fourth parties, a judicial determination of the issues is necessary before an issues-based costs order can be made.